If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is, not to put it too bluntly, simply precious that you seem to think that each of Newton' Laws of Motion only acts in isolation.

As demonstrated by the many examples offered you (and by real-world events) that is, simply, not how it works.
You state that this is simply not how it works, but you have already stated that my example was not wrong. Hmmmm. Do you see an issue here?
 
You really have gotten to the root of the issue. No skeptic wants to admit scale isn't relevant when it comes to Newton's laws of motion because they know the implications. You insist of bringing scale up because you want to focus on materials and everything else. It's not relevant.

The truth is simple. To see it you don't need to get caught up in the complexities of the issue. You just need to understand the basics.

I'm getting to my conclusion, I just keep getting distracted.

I am actually learning quite a bit. Some of you think you are "schooling" me. Maybe so, but you're making my final conclusion just that much more bulletproof.

Newton laws of motion are a side track... the issue of scale relates to strength of materials... connections and so forth. PERIOD...FULL STOP.
 
Are you saying that the video was recorded at 5.2 frames per second and Chandler didn't leave any frames out ?
I have no idea what the record rate was. I have no idea how many times it has been edited, compressed, uploaded, modified, or whatever. What I do know, from what I can see and have repeatedly posted, is that the software he uses places a reference point on each frame. It makes no sense for Chandler to leave any frames out. Anybody taking the time to do this experiment would want it to be as accurate as possible. Chandler also says he downloaded the video from the NIST website, so I have no idea what they did to it. I can't find the video on the internet, so I can't find out any information on my own.
 
Newton laws of motion are a side track... the issue of scale relates to strength of materials... connections and so forth. PERIOD...FULL STOP.
Here's where the disconnect is. All of the materials you mention will behave exactly according to Newton's laws of motion. As I have said in a previous post, the magnitude of their resistance to forces, and the magnitude of their masses, do not, in any way, have any effect on how they will behave according to Newton's laws of motion.
 
Are you asking me for a source on gravity and its infinite range?

I'm not saying Newton's Laws are wrong, I'm saying they apply to an ideal physical representation that works for math but doesn't actually exist. Spherical cows and all that.
No, I'm asking you to prove my example of Newton's first law is wrong.

Are you saying the real world doesn't exist? Are you saying Newton lived on another planet? Do you think he made his observations first, and then did the math, or vice-versa?
 
Zero point field, the universe itself is an energy field being expanded by dark energy acting upon all mass similar but opposite to gravity, as long as mass exists in an energy field,
There can be no truly uniform motion.
Acceleration is irrelevant as long as a source of energy is known for and accounts for said Acceleration.

+1 for making stuff up as you go. I bet you would be great at improv. I would like to live in your universe for a day or two; it seems like a fun place.
 
Well, I'll make one. The graph shows that at no point in the collapse was the acceleration constant; it varied throughout, due to the retardation being a series of micro-jolts rather than a constant force. And one might ask, if you can't comment on the observed data on acceleration, where you got the idea that the acceleration was constant? To paraphrase the thread title: If it doesn't agree with measured data, it's wrong.

Dave

OK. I get the idea that acceleration was constant from NIST. I also get it from David Chandler, but I will focus mainly on NIST.

Are you saying the computer programs are wrong? How are they wrong? Can you provide any evidence other than your opinion? Are you implying that the measured points have to all line up perfectly on the computer generated slope in order to undeniably indicate constant acceleration?
 
Once again, you fail to provide an example to support your claim.

You provided your own example of your misunderstanding of Newton, you can't Issolate a force or action from the rest of the universe because the universe exists in space time.
There fore your understanding of Newton's laws is incomplete.
Atoms and atomic structure can not be scaled because of the proportion to mass problems the more mass the more forces effect the atoms in an atomic structure.
Like the recently discovered dark energy, the heavier and farther away two objects are from each other the faster they move away from each other.
The force of Dark energy is proportional to the mass it is applied to, as is the electromagnetic force, that bonds iron to iron molicules, it is precisely that force that gives steel it's strength, fail to understand that, and you fail to understand modeling, and the reason
the Towers and building 7 collapsed.
 
You provided your own example of your misunderstanding of Newton, you can't Issolate a force or action from the rest of the universe because the universe exists in space time.
There fore your understanding of Newton's laws is incomplete.
Atoms and atomic structure can not be scaled because of the proportion to mass problems the more mass the more forces effect the atoms in an atomic structure.
Like the recently discovered dark energy, the heavier and farther away two objects are from each other the faster they move away from each other.
The force of Dark energy is proportional to the mass it is applied to, as is the electromagnetic force, that bonds iron to iron molicules, it is precisely that force that gives steel it's strength, fail to understand that, and you fail to understand modeling, and the reason
the Towers and building 7 collapsed.

I knew Muslims weren't to blame; it was the Klingons and Romulans.
 
I have life. Fighting the ignorance of others is not my full time job.


We all have life.

You, however, are far and away the busiest poster in this thread with 340 posts, 216 more than the next most prolific poster.


This means............something.
 
It's also possible, if an object is rotating about a pivot, for parts of that object to accelerate at greater than the acceleration of the centre of mass. Has anyone got that film of the ball coming out of the cup on the end of a pivoted bar that was posted here some while back? WTC7 has all the necessary characteristics for that; the point measured was not at the centre of mass, and it was clearly rotating southwards during the collapse. In such circumstances an acceleration of one point on the structure greater than 1G is quite possible.

Dave

I agree with the physics concept, but I'm not getting dragged into debating the other claims you make.
 
We all have life.

You, however, are far and away the busiest poster in this thread with 340 posts, 216 more than the next most prolific poster.


This means............something.

Yes, I have been away for two days and now I'm catching up. I also have about 500 posts next to my name. How many thousands of posts do other members have? Whatever you think my posting means, it doesn't. It might mean I have some free time right now, and it might mean I want to answer other member's posts, but I'm not sure you want to admit that's what I'm doing.
 
K
Sky diver problem say I have a sky diver jump from A plane on opposite sides of the earth,
Will the acceleration, be at G, or will the acceleration, be slightly over G?
If you're trying to prove I'm wrong about something asking me a question isn't the way to do it.
 
All of your posts? I've yet to see you post any sort of data at all.
Then you're not looking. Links are there.

If you can't even take the time to see the links I post, it's highly unlikely you will take the time to understand what I'm posting.
 
No, experiments are the key, because if it doesn't agree with experiment it's wrong.

Not correct an experiment can be flawed, observations of experiments, and analysis of the data against known physical constants is what gives valid results.
With out credible observations and good design an experiment will fail you can even design experiments to fail. I fear that seems to be what Cole has done.
He is ignoring the proportional laws of the action of forces, that appears to be by design.
 
Not correct an experiment can be flawed, observations of experiments, and analysis of the data against known physical constants is what gives valid results.
With out credible observations and good design an experiment will fail you can even design experiments to fail. I fear that seems to be what Cole has done.
He is ignoring the proportional laws of the action of forces, that appears to be by design.
If anybody is ignoring anything it's not Cole who's doing it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom