If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have life. Fighting the ignorance of others is not my full time job.

I'm retired now, so I have more time for that sort of thing, so:

Do you understand Newton's first law now? If so, do you now understand how scale affects the inertial force of an object?

Do you understand Myriad's point about improperly equating gravitational force with impact contact force?
 
Do you understand Newton's first law now? If so, do you now understand how scale affects the inertial force of an object?

If you understood Newton's first law, you would never use the term scale. You know one has nothing to do with the other. You are only saying this because you want to reserve your "scale" argument to criticize Cole's videos.

How about this? Find a scholarly or credible source that clearly states scale matters in Newton's first law. Make sure that source clearly defines scale, and then that same source explains why scale matters.

What you need to do here is explain Newton's first law will apply a certain way to one mass, and then a different way to a different mass. In other words, if your scale argument were actually correct, Newton's law would go something like "an object with a mass of 1kg will remain at rest unless an (unbalanced) force acts upon it, but an object with a mass of 2kg will do whatever it wants, you know, because of the moon, quicksand, local density, quantum mechanics, electrostatic charge, black holes, Republicans, and gremlins". That is what you are trying to claim with your scale argument. It's pure BS and anyone with a brain can see right through it. But, go ahead, find a scholarly or credible source that proves scale matters when it comes to Newton's first law.

Just to save time, don't even bother trying to explain inertia. I already know what that is. If you claim scale matters because an object with a mass of 2kg will resist an unbalanced force more than an object with a mass of 1kg then you are playing a semantics game. Newton's first law applies equally to both objects. The mass of the objects and the magnitude of the forces involved do NOT change his laws. His laws describe how those objects and forces will interact, regardless of the mass or force. Newton's laws do not change if the variables change. The argument of scale is BS.
 
Last edited:
Fighting the ignorance of others is not my full time job.

That's a shame. Over thirty years as a professional physicist have left me completely ignorant of how a straight line fit to a series of average velocities over fixed measurement intervals can measure anything other than an average acceleration, and I was hoping not to have to wait too much longer to find out.

Dave
 
Thanks for making it clear you have no clue as to what velocity or acceleration is, or how they can be measured. Every point on Chandler's graph is a measurement of the average velocity in the time interval between two frames, and cannot possibly be anything else, and a "straight line that is the best fit of all the points between the two times" is by definition the average acceleration over that time interval. Your inability to grasp this is quite obvious to everyone here but you.

Dave

OK. I accept your argument regarding average velocity. I will get back to you regarding "average acceleration".

Thank you for confirming that Chandler's graph is a measurement of the average velocity in the time interval between two frames. I don't know if you intended to do that or not, but I will use it in a later post.
 
If you understood Newton's first law, you would never use the term scale. You know one has nothing to do with the other. You are only saying this because you want to reserve your "scale" argument to criticize Cole's videos.

How about this? Find a scholarly or credible source that clearly states scale matters in Newton's first law. Make sure that source clearly defines scale, and then that same source explains why scale matters.

What you need to do here is explain Newton's first law will apply a certain way to one mass, and then a different way to a different mass. In other words, if your scale argument were actually correct, Newton's law would go something like "an object with a mass of 1kg will remain at rest unless an (unbalanced) force acts upon it, but an object with a mass of 2kg will do whatever it wants, you know, because of the moon, quicksand, local density, quantum mechanics, electrostatic charge, black holes, Republicans, and gremlins". That is what you are trying to claim with your scale argument. It's pure BS and anyone with a brain can see right through it. But, go ahead, find a scholarly or credible source that proves scale matters when it comes to Newton's first law.

Just to save time, don't even bother trying to explain inertia. I already know what that is. If you claim scale matters because an object with a mass of 2kg will resist an unbalanced force more than an object with a mass of 1kg then you are playing a semantics game. Newton's first law applies equally to both objects. The mass of the objects and the magnitude of the forces involved do NOT change his laws. His laws describe how those objects and forces will interact, regardless of the mass or force. Newton's laws do not change if the variables change. The argument of scale is BS.

Could we have more of these kind of arguments please?
I learn a lot from the people who actually know these things, but we need arguments like this to keep the knowledge flow going.
 

You claim my statement is wrong:

No, the computer program David Chandler used tracks the vertical (and horizontal) position of the reference point (the top corner of WTC7) over time. Each frame (not every 8 frames as was incorrectly claimed by another poster) generates a new reference point.

Just to keep this as easy to understand as possible, here is your statement:

Both Chandler & NIST took the position vs. time data and calculated APPROXIMATE velocity versus time. NIST used a central difference approximation. (See NCSTAR1-9 v2, pg. 602). I’m not sure what Chandler used (back biased, central or forward biased). But in both cases, they took a data point approximately every 8th frame.

I am the one who added the emphasis on the last sentence.

Here is the video Chandler posted on YouTube, just so everyone can see exactly what I'm talking about. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rVCDpL4Ax7I

Please explain your claim, and provide proof that your statement is correct.
 
Last edited:
"straight line that is the best fit of all the points between the two times" is by definition the average acceleration over that time interval. Your inability to grasp this is quite obvious to everyone here but you.

Dave

I understand your definition, and, at this time, I can't see any issues with it. I completely understand it. I have always understood the concept, but the term constant acceleration is "muddying the waters" for me.

I need to go back a day or two and find my post where I claim that "average acceleration is a meaningless quantity", or something to that effect. I do understand why that statement would be a red flag for you to pounce on, and I completely understand why you would think I don't understand what is going on. I do, but my posts do not make that clear. I thought I was being careful enough, but that is not the case.

What I was referring to was something David Chandler said in his video. He said, "average acceleration is a meaningless quantity." What he was referring to was an older NIST report that lists the average acceleration between the time of the initial collapse of the penthouse and the time the building disappears from view. That definitely is a meaningless quantity.

What matters is the constant average acceleration of 9.8m/s/s for a period of approximately 2.25 seconds as the building began to fall. I believe this statement proves I do understand the concepts involved.

If you want to ignore Chandler's results, then fine. What can't be ignored is that NIST does admit constant average acceleration at 9.8m/s/s for approximately 2.25 seconds. The implications of this are substantial.
 
The fundamental question here is “Is scaling a crucial concern in structural modeling?”
Your post is an attempt to deflect my original argument. Nice try, but you have failed.

I have NEVER said that scale does not matter when it comes to scale models. What I have said, and continue to say, is that scale does not matter when it comes to Newton's three laws of motion.

Again, nice try, but, no.
 
The chances a fully rebuilt WTC7, with all the equipment & furnishings inside, damaged as accurately as possible, set on fire as accurately as possible, collapses are very high.

Really? You want to go on record saying this?

The only way the chance of collapse is high is if they hired the same CD team. I don't think that's possible because I'm pretty sure most of them are dead.

Dead men tell no tales.
 
If I post something about about general relativity and challenge people to prove that general relativity is wrong and nobody manages to prove Einstein wrong, does that mean that I understand general relativity?
If you post an example in your own words that no one can prove is wrong, then you must understand general relativity.

Can you prove my example regarding Newton's first law is wrong, without taking your argument to absurd levels? Can you use a source that solely discusses Newton's first law to prove I don't understand it?
 
I count 13 data points on the free fall portion of his graph.

At 30 frames per second for 2.5 seconds that should be 75 data points.

Where are the other 62 data points ?

Where does it say the video is at 30fps? Can you provide a link to the video used, so that we can determine the frame rate? It makes no sense that the software would ignore frames. You can see Chandler step through the collapse frame by frame. The software tells you what frame number you are seeing, and it increments by one frame each with each click of the "step >" button.
 
If you understood Newton's first law, you would never use the term scale. You know one has nothing to do with the other. You are only saying this because you want to reserve your "scale" argument to criticize Cole's videos.

How about this? Find a scholarly or credible source that clearly states scale matters in Newton's first law. Make sure that source clearly defines scale, and then that same source explains why scale matters.

What you need to do here is explain Newton's first law will apply a certain way to one mass, and then a different way to a different mass. In other words, if your scale argument were actually correct, Newton's law would go something like "an object with a mass of 1kg will remain at rest unless an (unbalanced) force acts upon it, but an object with a mass of 2kg will do whatever it wants, you know, because of the moon, quicksand, local density, quantum mechanics, electrostatic charge, black holes, Republicans, and gremlins". That is what you are trying to claim with your scale argument. It's pure BS and anyone with a brain can see right through it. But, go ahead, find a scholarly or credible source that proves scale matters when it comes to Newton's first law.

Just to save time, don't even bother trying to explain inertia. I already know what that is. If you claim scale matters because an object with a mass of 2kg will resist an unbalanced force more than an object with a mass of 1kg then you are playing a semantics game. Newton's first law applies equally to both objects. The mass of the objects and the magnitude of the forces involved do NOT change his laws. His laws describe how those objects and forces will interact, regardless of the mass or force. Newton's laws do not change if the variables change. The argument of scale is BS.


The issue of scale is really about the inherent strength and relative strength of materials. Ant and elephants are made from the same biological material yet and ant can lift perhaps hundreds of times its own body weight and an elephant on a small fraction.

You cannot scale strength of materials... and you certainly can scale gravity or time. Any scale model will be limited by this.

Injecting Newton into this when it about the structural propertics of materials which ultimately is determined by chemical bonds and structure on the molecular level is simply an apples and oranges mistake.

tfk has show you all the materials and reference about the engineering. You are acting like a science denier... because it suits your politics.

There is nor will there be a proof other than the settled engineering which describes the behavior of the materials of the composite structure.... called "a building" and this settle science/engineering is used to design structure that withstand normal conditions. And the conditions which those structures were subjected to on 9/11 were not normal... ie outside the design envelope including the margin of safety typically used.
 
That's a shame. Over thirty years as a professional physicist have left me completely ignorant of how a straight line fit to a series of average velocities over fixed measurement intervals can measure anything other than an average acceleration, and I was hoping not to have to wait too much longer to find out.

Dave

I can't ask the question I want to because of one of the forum rules. Bummer, because I would really like to know the answer.
 
If you post an example in your own words that no one can prove is wrong, then you must understand general relativity.

Can you prove my example regarding Newton's first law is wrong, without taking your argument to absurd levels? Can you use a source that solely discusses Newton's first law to prove I don't understand it?

Can you take your discussion outside this universe because as long as your in this energy field you will never understand Newton's laws!
 
Injecting Newton into this when it about the structural propertics of materials which ultimately is determined by chemical bonds and structure on the molecular level is simply an apples and oranges mistake.

You really have gotten to the root of the issue. No skeptic wants to admit scale isn't relevant when it comes to Newton's laws of motion because they know the implications. You insist of bringing scale up because you want to focus on materials and everything else. It's not relevant.

The truth is simple. To see it you don't need to get caught up in the complexities of the issue. You just need to understand the basics.

I'm getting to my conclusion, I just keep getting distracted.

I am actually learning quite a bit. Some of you think you are "schooling" me. Maybe so, but you're making my final conclusion just that much more bulletproof.
 
No it's not, because of what it implies.

What does it imply?

Anything falling which can't be plotted in a perfectly linear slope has noise, inaccuracy of measurements or some form of resistance or additional impulse...

So what?


Free fall does not imply CD.... It tells us that what was measure falling at that acceleration was meeting no measurable resistance. In the case of 1 wtc.. this was only for a column length or so because of the misalignment of axial supports at one connection... hence the 36 feet ff acceleration.

In the case of 7wtc the perimeter moment frame lost support at the 8th floor... which... if you bothered to look at how it was supported makes perfect sense if the east and west braced truss frames were "pulled in" by an internal structural collapse below floor 8.... the majority of the north side moment frame was supported on cantilever ends at the 8th floor and the shorter south side has unbraced columns standing 5 stories to the level of the mech floors.
 
Where does it say the video is at 30fps? Can you provide a link to the video used, so that we can determine the frame rate? It makes no sense that the software would ignore frames. You can see Chandler step through the collapse frame by frame. The software tells you what frame number you are seeing, and it increments by one frame each with each click of the "step >" button.

Are you saying that the video was recorded at 5.2 frames per second and Chandler didn't leave any frames out ?

Prove that the video was recorded at 5.2 FPS.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom