If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
If anybody is ignoring anything it's not Cole who's doing it.

I am sorry to kkep saying this, but Cole ostentatiously ignores the problems of scaling.

No, not because "The Three Laws" "work differently" at different scales, but because his comparison of his scale toy to an actual, full-sized building is inherently false.
 
OK. I accept your argument regarding average velocity. I will get back to you regarding "average acceleration".

Thank you for confirming that Chandler's graph is a measurement of the average velocity in the time interval between two frames. I don't know if you intended to do that or not, but I will use it in a later post.

Dave, I and others have ALL said, repeatedly, that the plots were AVERAGE velocity points. Odd that you seem to have missed that until just now.
 
Then you're not looking. Links are there.

Where? So far it seems you just don't understand physics.

If you want to prove I'm wrong, then do it. Simply saying I'm wrong is not enough.

But you're wrong, full stop.

I have NEVER said that scale does not matter when it comes to scale models.

Huh. Really?

You should tell this guy:

In this case, scale is irrelevant.
 
Here's where the disconnect is. All of the materials you mention will behave exactly according to Newton's laws of motion. As I have said in a previous post, the magnitude of their resistance to forces, and the magnitude of their masses, do not, in any way, have any effect on how they will behave according to Newton's laws of motion.

You're missing that scale here is related to molecular bonds....not rules of motion which pretty much are unchangeable regardless of scale.
 
Where does it say the video is at 30fps? Can you provide a link to the video used, so that we can determine the frame rate? It makes no sense that the software would ignore frames. You can see Chandler step through the collapse frame by frame. The software tells you what frame number you are seeing, and it increments by one frame each with each click of the "step >" button.

Its a professional, CBS TV network video from 2001. THEREFORE it IS 29.97 fps (30 fps is an old standard from B&W TV days). If its not 29.97 fps then its not the original video. That would mean that its even of lesser quality than CBS's original.

You said a position measurement was every frame. The graph shows 13 frames over that 2.25 second period. That corresponds to 5.78 frames per second. A 5.78 fps video would be extremely choppy. The video in question isn't choppy, therefore it isn't 5.78 fps.

So either the graph isn't plotting every velocity point, or velocity points were not taken at every frame. The acceleration slope is garnered from the graph which is then either not using every calculated average velocity, or only using those that were calculated, every 8th frame.
 
Last edited:
There is constant acceleration during the collapse of WTC1 and WTC7. To make things simple, I am just going to focus on NIST's statements and WTC7.

No, what you claim is "constant acceleration" is calculated the same way that the average acceleration of the rest of the time period of collapse was. By best fit of a linear slope to the time period in question, this 2.25 second interval. It is therefore by definition also an average over that time period. A closer look by online poster femr2 demonstrated that far from constant, the acceleration during this time period actually exceeded g, and fell below g.

The mere fact that it exceeded g at any point demonstrates that some other mechanism was in play other than strict Newtonian, point mass, physics. Indeed in all things in reality, point mass Newtonian physics is idealistic. Reality is much messier than ideal masses and forces.

There are videos that demonstrate situations in which falling objects exceed g. Two come to mind, the first is the pivoting rod with a mass on the outer end. The rod is allowed to pivot and it reaches the table before the mass that had been resting on the end of the rod.
The second is a 'chain and rod ladder' where the rods form the steps and are connected at an angle to the two chains. there are two that are released at the same time, one falls past a table the other onto the table. The one falling onto the table demonstrably ends up falling faster than the free falling one. Its a transfer of energy of the tilted 'steps' that pulls the chains down, adding force to the still falling portion of the structure.

WTC 7 had had all columns fail below the 8th floor, buckled, tilted, connections sheared, makes little difference its probably a combination of all of them. The upper structure perimeter frame however was still connected but askew, with all floors tilted down towards the 'kink'. That portion of all floors(along the line of the 'kink') would be the first to hit ground. That's not unlike the falling faster than g ladder. In similar fashion, the E-W line of the center of the building also fell sooner than the perimeter and would see the surviving girders between perimeter and core columns, tilted inwards. Their ends hit first.
 
I have life. Fighting the ignorance of others is not my full time job.

Fighting ignorance?

You mean like thinking a post was directed towards you when it was clearly addressing someone else?

I can see why you thought it was meant for you though, you exhibit the exact same behaviour.
 
Really? You want to go on record saying this?

The only way the chance of collapse is high is if they hired the same CD team. I don't think that's possible because I'm pretty sure most of them are dead.

Dead men tell no tales.

Citation, please. Oh, wait, I'll bold them.

What's that you say? Unsupported assertions? Mindless kneejerk recitation of dogma? Statements based on opinions not facts? Citing yourself as the authority on the subjects of CD and Top Secret ops?

Why yes, your post DOES actually contain all of those. Very impressive fallacy-stacking.
 
Dave Rogers said:
<snip>

and progress to the one that shows the full measure of your incomprehension:

Are you implying that the measured points have to all line up perfectly on the computer generated slope in order to undeniably indicate constant acceleration?

Yes, that is exactly what I'm saying, and anyone competent would agree. The extent to which the measured points deviate from the line is a combination of measurement error and real deviations from constant acceleration, and in the absence of values for one it is not possible to assign a minimum value to the other.

You really need to read an introductory text on experimental physics. You're missing a great many of the most basic concepts if you can even ask questions like the ones above.

Dave

:confused: :jaw-dropp :boggled:
I can't believe FF seriously asked that.
 
I'll try again, perhaps AClark sees this now.
That's all very well and mathy, but it makes some very glaring omissions. Primarily the trigonometry of the situation. If you are going to have pieces toppling, then you are going to need pivot points, and enough geometry for your javelin.
You are Moving the Goal Posts.

You had declared:
The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large...
So I asked:
Can you quantify this "very large" energy required?

There are basically two theories on the table that would explain the source of that energy:
  • Gravity (GPE - Gravitational Potential Energy)
  • Explosives (ChE - Chemical Energy)
I quantified the requirement for the first theory - that GPE is the energy source: Drop height of 10 to 40 floors - easily available for collapses starting 78+ floors above ground.

Remember: You made a claim about the quantity of energy.

Now you:
How much explosives (equivalent to chemical energy, ChE) does it take, per mass unit of steel to propel a steel section to 60 mph?
That calculation is much less straightforward.
I have done it.
Have you?
Can you guess?[/QUOTE]
 
This is wrong. I have clearly corrected my mistakes when they have happened. No one else appears to be doing the same, and I can assure you that I am not the only one who has made mistakes in this thread.

Not true. Many posters have also been correcting your mistakes when they have happened. You just don't seem to learn from these corrections.
 
Speaking of correcting your mistakes, FF, please correct this one:

The floors should have exerted an opposite and equal force on the falling mass.


This is false.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

The force of the gravitational attraction between the earth and the falling mass acts upon the falling mass, pulling it downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the earth, pulling it upward. (The earth, being rather large, does not move very much as a result of that pull. F = ma means a = F/m.)

Simultaneously, the force of the impact between the falling mass and a floor acts upon the floor, breaking it and accelerating the floor material downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the falling mass. That force might decelerate the falling mass, but only if that force exceeds the force of gravity pulling the falling mass down.

There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater overall, there was no sustained deceleration.
 
Speaking of correcting your mistakes, FF, please correct this one:




This is false.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

The force of the gravitational attraction between the earth and the falling mass acts upon the falling mass, pulling it downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the earth, pulling it upward. (The earth, being rather large, does not move very much as a result of that pull. F = ma means a = F/m.)

Simultaneously, the force of the impact between the falling mass and a floor acts upon the floor, breaking it and accelerating the floor material downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the falling mass. That force might decelerate the falling mass, but only if that force exceeds the force of gravity pulling the falling mass down.

There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater overall, there was no sustained deceleration.
Lets get back to basics. FF is confusing Newton with Statics
When we build something like a building, or bridge, we design such that the sum of all forces =0. The effects of gravity on the artifact and everything on it or in it is in balance everywhere, and it doesn't move. All forces sum to zero, so Force=Reaction
Newton states that "for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction", to put it simply. And this is absolutely true, also.
When the artifact suffers damage, and begins to collapse, the floors being impacted offer reaction to the parts doing the falling. If they are sufficiently strong, they stop the fall.
If the force of the impact exceeds the capability of the floor, the floors break.
Yes, they do impart an equal and opposite reaction to the impacting mass, but only up to their ultimate capability. This slows the fall down (deceleration), but does not stop it: Force > Reaction
 
Can't be bothered, on Cole's previous record. If you want a response, please summarise the claims and you'll get one, otherwise you're just pimping the videos. And I also won't bother doing any experiments to prove the obvious; YouTube is not the gold standard of scientific discussion.

Dave

YouTube isn't even the used paper plate standard of elementary school scientific discussion!!!!!
 
If you understood Newton's first law, you would never use the term scale. You know one has nothing to do with the other. You are only saying this because you want to reserve your "scale" argument to criticize Cole's videos.

How about this? Find a scholarly or credible source that clearly states scale matters in Newton's first law. Make sure that source clearly defines scale, and then that same source explains why scale matters.

What you need to do here is explain Newton's first law will apply a certain way to one mass, and then a different way to a different mass. In other words, if your scale argument were actually correct, Newton's law would go something like "an object with a mass of 1kg will remain at rest unless an (unbalanced) force acts upon it, but an object with a mass of 2kg will do whatever it wants, you know, because of the moon, quicksand, local density, quantum mechanics, electrostatic charge, black holes, Republicans, and gremlins". That is what you are trying to claim with your scale argument. It's pure BS and anyone with a brain can see right through it. But, go ahead, find a scholarly or credible source that proves scale matters when it comes to Newton's first law.

Just to save time, don't even bother trying to explain inertia. I already know what that is. If you claim scale matters because an object with a mass of 2kg will resist an unbalanced force more than an object with a mass of 1kg then you are playing a semantics game. Newton's first law applies equally to both objects. The mass of the objects and the magnitude of the forces involved do NOT change his laws. His laws describe how those objects and forces will interact, regardless of the mass or force. Newton's laws do not change if the variables change. The argument of scale is BS.
.
Excuse me, but we established that you didn't understand inertia when you claimed it was a "different concept" from Newton's first law. That law is the definition of inertia, and Oystein already posted an authoritative source: Sir Isaac Newton. It appears that your confusion is because you are (1) following Cole's misdirection about "direction of force is independent of scale"; and (2) operating under the simplified high-school physics version of the law which leaves out an important aspect: As Newton states, inertia acts as a force that's proportional to mass. And absolutely, that matters when you try to apply your confusion to Cole's bungled modeling, because for a given substance, mass is proportional to the cube of linear dimensions. As a result, Cole's models simply do not possess either static or dynamic similarity to the WTC towers, which means that no valid conclusions whatsoever about the WTC towers can be drawn from them.
 
Last edited:
FalseFlag

How about this? Find a scholarly or credible source that clearly states scale matters in Newton's first law. Make sure that source clearly defines scale, and then that same source explains why scale matters.

And here is your mistake.

The issue is “does scaling of one’s models play a significant impact on the outcomes of structural experiments?”

YOUR mistake is to think that this question can be answered ONLY by considering Newton’s 1st, or 2nd, or 3rd law.

You are wrong about that.
You also need to involve mechanics.

And I have already provided you with TWO credible (not only credible, but 100% correct) engineering sources that affirm, in the strongest terms possible, that scale is absolutely critical in planning, constructing, executing & analyzing experimental data.

I provided Harris’ textbook.
Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques By Harry G. Harris
http://tinyurl.com/gra8ejf
And I provided you with the chapters that discussed scaling of experiments.

And I provided you with the SUNY Buffalo Lecture Notes for an Engineering Laboratory in “Modeling in Structures” class
http://civil.eng.buffalo.edu/cie616...nd Scaling/Slides 2 Modeling and Scaling.pdf
And this entire Lecture Note discusses scaling in experiments.

Both of them state, with zero ambiguity, that "proper attention to scaling is absolutely crucial in performing experiments with scaled models.”

It seems that “providing you with scholarly and credible sources that clearly state what you don’t want to believe” is an exercise that falls on deaf ears.
 
I propose to build a model that's similar to one of Cole's models, but only 1/10th the size. FalseFlag, if scale doesn't matter, do you predict that it will behave like Cole's model?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom