If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
You contradict yourself: Claiming constant acceleration for the WTC towers proves that you don't understand Newton.
Who else is claiming constant acceleration? Hint, it's a government agency with 4 letters. Still need a hint? It's NIST. Are you saying they don't understand Newton?

You also need to stop the nonsense with Ronan Point, and Verinage and whatever else. Was Ronan Point a steel-framed high rise? No. Did Ronan Point collapse at freefall for any period of time? No. Does verinage apply to steel-framed high rises? No? Is constant acceleration observed in verinage? No. End of discussion.
 
I said "in this thread", not "in this forum".


(But don't let me interrupt your workflow)

This is amusing. I get criticized for answering posts, and I get criticized for not answering them, which, ironically, is the post your original comment is on.

Predictable.
 
Clues there in yellow. It took several pages of discussion to get you to admit that the average acceleration was only about 65% of G.

The wrong (10 seconds) collapse time led you to the CD conclusion, where you claimed it showed there was little or nothing resisting collapse as support was being removed as the building fell. When you abandoned the wrong collapse time you retained the CD conclusion it had led you to.

There is constant acceleration during the collapse of WTC1 and WTC7. To make things simple, I am just going to focus on NIST's statements and WTC7.
 
I keep telling them but on they go.
He has no interest in learning or progressing the thread.

Same old.

This is wrong. I have clearly corrected my mistakes when they have happened. No one else appears to be doing the same, and I can assure you that I am not the only one who has made mistakes in this thread.
 
FalseFlag,

Falling faster than G:

Compare the downward acceleration of the ball (in freefall) to the downward acceleration of the tee that was supporting it.

Does the tee fall at lower acceleration, at the same acceleration, or at higher acceleration than the ball? Answer: higher than G

Were there any forces other than gravity at work here? Answer: no

Please explain.
I'm not doing any of your mindless busy work. I have watched the video, I understand what is happening, and I am certain it has nothing to do with the collapse of WTC7.

Now, if the NIST report mentions any of the concepts in the video in their report, please let me know.
 
I knew that getting him to actually read something, put aside his ego & make an attempt to understand it, was a minuscule probability.
This statement is clearly contradicted by numerous posts I have made. If you can't get something as simple as this correct, why should anyone believe anything you have said in your other posts?
 
Really? You want to go on record saying this?

The only way the chance of collapse is high is if they hired the same CD team. I don't think that's possible because I'm pretty sure most of them are dead.

Dead men tell no tales.

You have evidence of a 'CD Team' and their ultimate fate?

Who were they?

How did they do it?

Who killed them?
 
If anybody is ignoring anything it's not Cole who's doing it.

OK, I have 3 steel spheres, one is a steel micro sphere, one is a one inch Diameter. steel sphere, One is a ten foot diameter wreaking ball, I drop each from ten feet, onto a standard
4 inch concrete slab, what would I observe in the experiment?

Why does only the one inch sphere bounce?
 
Where does it say the video is at 30fps? Can you provide a link to the video used, so that we can determine the frame rate?
That would be the well-known "Dan Rather" video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XL3kL0nXZvk

The frame rate is 29.97 fps. [edit: not necessarily of the youtube version]

NIST released a cleaner version which is presumably what Chandler used.
 
Last edited:
There is constant acceleration during the collapse of WTC1 and WTC7. To make things simple, I am just going to focus on NIST's statements and WTC7.
No, there isn't.

The problem is that their (=NIST and Chandler's) measurement error is too big to give anything other than an approximate averaged acceleration. More accurate measurements show that it isn't constant. Another poster and I already noted this to you.
 
Last edited:
This is amusing. I get criticized for answering posts, and I get criticized for not answering them, which, ironically, is the post your original comment is on.

Predictable.


I've tried reading that through several times and in several ways, and it still makes no sense contextually or grammatically.

Could be just me though...
 
Thank you for confirming that Chandler's graph is a measurement of the average velocity in the time interval between two frames. I don't know if you intended to do that or not, but I will use it in a later post.

Will this be in a post in which you retract your recent claim that it was a measurement of the actual, and not the average, velocity, or do you plan to pretend that you never said that?

Dave

ETA: Just as a reminder:

The graph David Chandler shows in his video is not of average velocity. The graph is of actual velocity vs. time.
 
Last edited:
Your post is an attempt to deflect my original argument. Nice try, but you have failed.

I have NEVER said that scale does not matter when it comes to scale models. What I have said, and continue to say, is that scale does not matter when it comes to Newton's three laws of motion.

Again, nice try, but, no.

And this, precisely is where you do err.

No one has said that scaling errors mean Newton's Three Laws of motion "do not apply". Instead, it has been rightly pointed out that Cole's "demonstration" fails to take scaling into consideration.

There may yet be hope for you.

Have you corrected your egregious absurdity about resting the Moon upon the Earth?

Have you corrected your careless idea that the Three Laws of Motion work independently of one another, and (apparently in your world) only one at a time?
 
What matters is the constant average acceleration of 9.8m/s/s for a period of approximately 2.25 seconds as the building began to fall. I believe this statement proves I do understand the concepts involved.

Quite the reverse. The fact that you can even use the phrase "constant average acceleration" demonstrates a staggering level of incomprehension of the basic concepts involved. The average acceleration over a given time interval is by definition constant over that time period. You are, in effect, claiming that a tautology is a suspicious circumstance.

If you want to ignore Chandler's results, then fine. What can't be ignored is that NIST does admit constant average acceleration at 9.8m/s/s for approximately 2.25 seconds. The implications of this are substantial.

And this is comedy gold. The implications of the average acceleration being 9.8ms-2 for 2.25 seconds is that the structure exerted negligible force on the falling section over this period, as would be expected from the initial failure being a multi-storey buckle. The implications of the average acceleration being constant over this period are zero, as it cannot be anything else.

Are you saying the computer programs are wrong?

No, I believe that Chandler and NIST are able to determine an average acceleration over a given period, and that over a specific period of 2.25 seconds that average acceleration is close to 1G. So we can ignore your strawman questions:

How are they wrong? Can you provide any evidence other than your opinion?

and progress to the one that shows the full measure of your incomprehension:

Are you implying that the measured points have to all line up perfectly on the computer generated slope in order to undeniably indicate constant acceleration?

Yes, that is exactly what I'm saying, and anyone competent would agree. The extent to which the measured points deviate from the line is a combination of measurement error and real deviations from constant acceleration, and in the absence of values for one it is not possible to assign a minimum value to the other.

You really need to read an introductory text on experimental physics. You're missing a great many of the most basic concepts if you can even ask questions like the ones above.

Dave
 
If you're trying to prove I'm wrong about something asking me a question isn't the way to do it.


Asking you a question seems to be the only way to find out the limits of your admittedly somewhat skewed understanding.

There is much to be learned from your choice not to be tied to an answer.

You still have not resolved the "falling, unimpeded, at an average acceleration less than g" problem...

Nor have you explained (and I am really interested in this) what you think the collapse of the WTC "should have" looked like, since the reality does not suit you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom