Then why didn't they [say “approximately freefall"? Why would they admit freefall, when they didn't need to? Are you really going to say they were "sloppy"? If so, I do agree with you, but for different reasons.
Well, the first time, when they were discussing the details of the analysis, they DID say “approximately freefall” and they did attribute this to “the line on the graph”, not to the building.
Later, they got sloppy & imprecise in their language.
As I said before, I attribute it to being rushed & giving the project to a junior engineer at the 11th hour.
I believe that a junior engineer got the job because a senior engineers would likely refuse to waste his time on irrelevant nonsense.
This also begs a major question. Why are you so critical, and I mean extremely critical, when it comes to how they measured acceleration during the collapse?
I am not “extremely critical” of their acceleration method.
they did a fair, if rushed, job.
They left out the adjective, “approximately” or “near”.
I am more critical of the person who attributes 5 significant digits to slope of the velocity curve.
I am more critical of the person who failed to provide an error estimate for these numbers.
This is the only section in the entire report that suffers from these technical annoyances.
If you are so critical of them here,
I am not.
You’re making this up because you think it gives you an opportunity to win a dating point.
… then why do you accept their conclusions regarding progressive collapse, which is a laughable explanation?
Oh really.
Where did you get YOUR PhD in structural engineering?
How many decades have YOU demonstrated outstanding accomplishments in that field.
Please explain what is the basis for your calling it a “laughable explanation”.
Why do you accept their computer model when it clearly doesn't match what can be observed - by anyone?
Because I have experience with computer models, & I know what level of detail to NOT expect out of a massively complex, massively chaotic process such as the collapse of a skyscraper.
Why are you not critical of them refusing to release the data they used to create their computer model?
Because the engineers at NIST are not the people that classified it.
Some National Security bureaucrat did.
And then, the whole issue was reviewed by a judge, who looked at both sides. And who DID see the data, and the reason why that bureaucrat decided to classify that data.
And the judge agreed with the National Security puke.
There are times that reasonable people have to let other people do their job & trust them. Especially with things exactly like this.
I really could go on at the glaring failures of NIST to do a proper investigation, but I will just stop here, for now.
You’ve listed NOT ONE thing that indicates any “failure” whatsoever, much less a “glaring failure” on the part of NIST’s analysis.
You don’t have the knowledge or experience to make that judgment.
The people who DO have the knowledge & experience to make that judgment, the entire mechanical & structural engineering community (including, yes, me) have come to the opposite conclusions. We have accepted NIST’s assumptions, analyses & conclusions as “substantially correct”.
You disagree?
Again, where is your Structural Engineering degree?
Where have you presented your disagreement to the engineering community in the traditional way: a peer reviewed paper in a respected engineering journal.
Where have ANY of the SEs or MEs at AE911T done that?
No place.
Your disdain is rendered irrelevant by virtue of your incompetence.
I know the answer to all these questions, but will you admit it?
Oh, please.
Share your answer with us.
I don't mean this as a personal attack, but I really need to address this issue.
I’d strongly suggest that, if you need answers to this or any technical issue, you not act like such a petulant child & consummate dick to the people who have the ability to give you those answers.
Your assertions can only be interpreted that you claim to know physics and engineering better than anyone at NIST.
That’s the “only interpretation” that you can come up with, is it??
LoL.
Remember the “consummate dick” part of the above response…?
Even David Chandler admits the people at NIST are brilliant engineers.
Yup, Chandler’s right about that.
And Chandler knows zippo about structural engineering.
That’s why I strongly suggested, when he first got into this, that he take his trash to an unbiased, experienced Structural Engineer. He refused.
His colossal mistake. He's been humiliating himself in public ever since.
But don't he impress the clueless chillun ...!
His conclusion is that they were tasked with covering up what really happened.
Yup, that’s correct.
The other consummate dick in this conversation, Chandler, states in public that the engineers at NIST are “brilliant”, but are also traitors, cowards & abettors after the fact to mass murder.
All because of his own searing delusion that a degree in physics makes you a knowledgeable about very specialized, complex topics in structural engineering. Chandler doesn't know JACK about these topics.
And his delusion that he is one of the few honorable people on the planet…
Chandler is despicable.
He is also a coward, who will allow no comments on any of his videos.
I invited him to come to this forum (when it was at JREF). I told him that the moderators would filter out all the snark, and it would just be me & the people with engineering experience that would debate the issues with him.
He ran away.
Real engineers, real scientists, and people who are interested in the truth INVITE criticism from competent reviewers. NIST hosted several programs at their facilities, inviting engineers from all pertinent walks, to come & critique their work. They were open & transparent about their methods, their assumptions, etc.
Contrast that approach to Chandler's avoidance of anyone except other Truthers.