If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
These time motion studies clearly are not very precise... But more importantly there is nothing of particular interest in them.

The buildings were collapsing... driven by gravity... the resistance was variable and consisted of the buildings frame/structure. Boo hoo... The total time from the first visible motion to "end was" less than the time for an object at the roof line to drop through the air to the ground. Boo Hoo. Buildings are about 95% air in the first place.

The speed / time of collapse is much ado about nothing. There is no way to infer a CD from it. Why would a CD be slower or faster?

These discussions are mostly a waste of time... yet they go on and on for years.
 
If your example was truly representative of newtons first law, I should be able to put on a spacesuit, climb inside your vacuum, and give your object a little kick. I'm going to give it an upwards kick like you would a soccer ball. If your example holds true to Newtons first law it should travel in a strait line at a constant speed (uniform motion) forever. Unfortunately you have Earths gravity field in your example, and as soon as I kick it it will start accelerating back towards the surface of the Earth at 9.8m/s/s where it will eventually come to rest.

If your example can't go from rest to uniform motion or vice versa then it is not representative of newtons first law and your application is flawed.

I have clearly proven that you are wrong and here is my source:

Lex I: Corpus omne perseverare in statu suo quiescendi vel movendi uniformiter in directum, nisi quatenus a viribus impressis cogitur statum illum mutare.


I am waiting until he gets from Newton to Maxwell and Einstein.:rolleyes:
 
These time motion studies clearly are not very precise... But more importantly there is nothing of particular interest in them.

The buildings were collapsing... driven by gravity... the resistance was variable and consisted of the buildings frame/structure. Boo hoo... The total time from the first visible motion to "end was" less than the time for an object at the roof line to drop through the air to the ground. Boo Hoo. Buildings are about 95% air in the first place.

The speed / time of collapse is much ado about nothing. There is no way to infer a CD from it. Why would a CD be slower or faster?

These discussions are mostly a waste of time... yet they go on and on for years.

A good site on engineering, that obviously Cole has missed.

https://www.egr.msu.edu/~harichan/classes/ce405/chap4.pdf
 
Its been pointed out to him before that the ONLY thing actually measured is the position of a location on the building and that then the average velocity is calculated between those points, and then an average acceleration is calculated.

No, the computer program David Chandler used tracks the vertical position of the reference point (the top corner of WTC7) over time. Each frame (not every 8 frames as was incorrectly claimed by another poster) generates a new reference point. The graph David Chandler shows in his video is not of average velocity. The graph is of actual velocity vs. time. The user can then enter a start and end time, and the computer will generate a straight line (slope) that is the best fit of all of the points in between the two times. This slope is the acceleration.

The graph shows an acceleration of (approximately) 9.8m/s/s for about 2.25 seconds. This value approximately matches NIST's experiments. Acceleration that has the same value over an interval can be said to have constant acceleration during that interval. Why? Simple. It's because the value of the acceleration does not change. Something that does not change is constant. The interval in this example is about 2.25 seconds. That means, without a doubt, anyone can correctly say there was constant acceleration during the collapse of WTC7 for about 2.25 seconds. The value of that acceleration was 9.8m/s/s, or freefall.

You keep saying I don't understand this. You are wrong, and your personal attacks are getting tiring. It is ludicrous to claim I'm wrong, when I'm the one who is correcting you, and providing clear proof that you are wrong.
Your post simply underlines that you don't understand what the program is doing. The computer takes the measured POSITION of a location on the facade at set time intervals. It then calculates the AVERAGE velocity between those each pair of measured points. It PLOTS those AVERAGE velocity values and then employs a smoothing technique, "Best fit" to arrive at a LINEAR , as tfk put it, "Average of averages" slope, which translates to acceleration.Its possible that computer programs are a mystery to you and that a computer is simply a magical black box. I know this because it does exactly what I said was being done.
You obviously do not understand "best fit" linearity, nor, possibly, the concept of linearity itself.
You are being corrected by several people but stubbornly stick to a very ball's up view of the physics involved.

The graph OBVIOUSLY plots points that are above and below the best fit line. Draw in a line from point to point and the slope is different each interval. THAT demonstrates a non-constant acceleration. "Best Fit" is used as a smoothing technique, often used to partially account for margins of error in measurement and calculation on those measurements.

I see that my prediction that you wouldn't understand tfk's excellent explanation was borne out in reality.
 
Last edited:
You post simply underlines that you don't understand what the program is doing. Its possible that computer programs are a mystery to you and that a computer is simply a magical black box. I know this because it does exactly what I said was being done.
You obviously do not understand "best fit" linearity, nor, possibly, the concept of linearity itself.

The graph OBVIOUSLY plots points that are above and below the best fit line. Draw in a line from point to point and the slope is different each interval. THAT demonstrates a non-constant acceleration. "Best Fit" is used as a smoothing technique, often used to partially account for margins of error in measurement and calculation on those measurements.

I see that my prediction that you wouldn't understand tfk's excellent explanation was borne out in reality.

And it has no significance as far as the collapse is concerned.
 
These time motion studies clearly are not very precise... But more importantly there is nothing of particular interest in them.

The buildings were collapsing... driven by gravity... the resistance was variable and consisted of the buildings frame/structure. Boo hoo... The total time from the first visible motion to "end was" less than the time for an object at the roof line to drop through the air to the ground. Boo Hoo. Buildings are about 95% air in the first place.

........

These discussions are mostly a waste of time... yet they go on and on for years.
Even more so, the fascination on the final seven seconds of a collapse that saw the structure falling apart for a total of near 20 seconds, or the utter laser focus on the final three seconds.

The speed / time of collapse is much ado about nothing. There is no way to infer a CD from it. Why would a CD be slower or faster?

A question never answered by Gage or any who baldly declare that only CD can account for the rate of the final 7 seconds of collapse.
 
Fact is this time period is at the end of a collapse sequence of between 17 and 20 seconds (depending largely on when the clock starts). By the time acceleration maxs , a great majority of structural integrity simply does not exist any longer.
I noted earlier that the first part of the facade itself , that began falling, was along the vertical kink on the north face. That movement was also seen on the rooftop , demonstrating that the entire central portion of the building was fully compromised at the time that truthers at best, start the collapse clock.

Focusing on the last 3 seconds of collapse made no sense at all to NIST. It cannot tell anyone anything about the cause of the collapse. Its hardly "sloppy" to spend little effort on a insignificant bit of minutia.

Only AE911T thinks it can and they cannot garner any widespread support for their odd position, from the professional community.

And it has no significance as far as the collapse is concerned.
Pointed out ad nauseum to truthers for a decade and a half
 
Pointed out ad nauseum to truthers for a decade and a half

The other fallacy by Cole is the balanced resistance, of the upper block and the lower block, that can not occur resistance has to be equal to the strength of the upper blocks connections to disunification, which can never match that of the lower structure.
 
FalseFlag,

Provide examples ...
Provide examples ...
Please provide a specific example to prove I don't understand the physics or engineering using a source other than your own words ...
Please provide concrete proof that NIST did a better job ...
Please provide a link to show the materials, data, and computer programs ...
Please explain, using sources other than your own opinion, why …
Please transcribe exactly what David Chandler said about …
Also, please explain the subtle difference …
Then, please let me know what NIST said …
Please make sure to explain why …
Please explain, using a source other than your own opinion, why NIST's method ...
Please provide proof that Chandler's video picks up this rotation …
please provide a source, other than your own opinion, why this matters …
Please post where your data points are from and the formulas used to calculate the values you list …
Also, please provide links to your sources ...

And, my personal favorite in this giant steaming pile of nonsense …

Also, please provide {NIST & Chandler’s] exact method so I can see the exact pixel they used.

I’m certain that you think all this is a clever response.
Just the last in a long, long line of things that you’re wrong about.

In the late 1970s, I taught an evening Engineering Dynamics class at a local college in Southern California, to a class of about 18 sophomore engineering students. We had to shift the class to evenings, because I was designing electronic connectors during the day.

Teaching the class was a lot of work, and it brought me face to face with the old saying, “You never learn anything as well as you do when you’re required to teach it."

Nonetheless, it was a very rewarding experience, because the kids were very anxious to learn.

You are … different.

My usual fees for a short term task like this are $185/hour. But because of your honest desire to learn, and positive attitude, we’ll do it for $250/hr.

So, as soon as you indicate your agreement for a non-cancelable, non-refundable contract for $2,500, I’ll get right on it.
You let me know…

Is this what goes on in a typical classroom today?
The classroom dunce ordering teachers to "prove this …", "show me that …”, “serve this up on a silver platter", while the dunce sits at the back of the room, causing a ruckus??

Sad.

The sadder fact of the matter, FF, is that if you had shown the SLIGHTEST desire to learn anything, then I would have been more than happy to provide you lots of free time in explanations.

But you are not interested.
Therefore, neither am I.

In Chandler's video he clearly states that the computer program determines the best slope based on the data points. How do you know NIST's computer program is better, when they both arrived at the same results?

Another example of your sloppiness. I never said or suggested that they used different algorithms. The algorithm that both used is the exact same “residual minimization” algorithm that’s been used in science & engineering for about the last 100 years.

I said,

tfk said:
NIST did a better job in their analysis.
And a FAR better job in articulating their conclusions.

And I explained exactly why.
You missed it.

Finally, do you have a link to the video NIST uses for their measurements?
It’s colloquially called the “Dan Rather” video, because he’s narrating it.
All of NIST’s raw data is on their website, and free to the public.

Spoon feeding of recalcitrant youngsters inhibits their learning & development.
Find it yourself.
__

Here's a few more questions. NIST doesn't mention freefall in their early drafts. Then, all of a sudden, they do. Who is the person who brought this to NIST's attention?

Chandler.

If this was such a non-issue, why wouldn't NIST just ignore it?

Because they’re in the business of explaining things to the public. Even irrelevant, brain-dead issues brought up by rank amateurs, like high school physics teachers.

If this person wasn't right, wouldn't they say so?

He was approximately correct about an irrelevant detail, so they addressed it honestly.

They addressed it,

Yup, that’s what the did.

Because a bunch of amateurs used the amateur’s amateurish analysis to stir up a clueless ruckus. This sort of nonsense happens all the time at the collision of technology & politics.

And NIST gave it all the attention that it deserved: about 2 brief pages of explanation in a 1000 page report.

Which changed not one single conclusion.
Which deserved to change not one single conclusion.

although they did come up with a lame explanation for it.
[/quote]

“Lame”?

Please explain what you think is lame about their explanation.

Then why didn't they? Why would they admit freefall, when they didn't need to? Are you really going to say they were "sloppy"?

Yes, sloppy.

It was "near freefall", or "approximately freefall". They should have been more careful, because a bunch of amateurs were able to take their "at freefall" statement & turn it into all sorts of mischief.

And this section is a bit sloppy because it was rushed. The whole issue arose at the last moment, with lots of powerful people pushing hard for release of the report, and appears to have been given to some junior engineer.


  • It’s the only section in the entire 10,000 page report in which there is no error bands estimated for their results.
  • 5 significant digits on the acceleration, when the data supports 2 to 2 1/2 digits, at best
  • The inclusion of the first point in the “Stage 2” segment (a clear outlier), because Chandler did the same.
  • The dropping of the term “approximately” as noted earlier.
  • The attribution of the acceleration to the building, instead of to the math model.

All the above screams “junior engineer, with administrators whipping him to finish up”.
 
Then why didn't they [say “approximately freefall"? Why would they admit freefall, when they didn't need to? Are you really going to say they were "sloppy"? If so, I do agree with you, but for different reasons.

Well, the first time, when they were discussing the details of the analysis, they DID say “approximately freefall” and they did attribute this to “the line on the graph”, not to the building.

Later, they got sloppy & imprecise in their language.
As I said before, I attribute it to being rushed & giving the project to a junior engineer at the 11th hour.

I believe that a junior engineer got the job because a senior engineers would likely refuse to waste his time on irrelevant nonsense.

This also begs a major question. Why are you so critical, and I mean extremely critical, when it comes to how they measured acceleration during the collapse?

I am not “extremely critical” of their acceleration method.
they did a fair, if rushed, job.
They left out the adjective, “approximately” or “near”.

I am more critical of the person who attributes 5 significant digits to slope of the velocity curve.
I am more critical of the person who failed to provide an error estimate for these numbers.

This is the only section in the entire report that suffers from these technical annoyances.

If you are so critical of them here,

I am not.
You’re making this up because you think it gives you an opportunity to win a dating point.

… then why do you accept their conclusions regarding progressive collapse, which is a laughable explanation?

Oh really.
Where did you get YOUR PhD in structural engineering?
How many decades have YOU demonstrated outstanding accomplishments in that field.

Please explain what is the basis for your calling it a “laughable explanation”.

Why do you accept their computer model when it clearly doesn't match what can be observed - by anyone?

Because I have experience with computer models, & I know what level of detail to NOT expect out of a massively complex, massively chaotic process such as the collapse of a skyscraper.

Why are you not critical of them refusing to release the data they used to create their computer model?

Because the engineers at NIST are not the people that classified it.
Some National Security bureaucrat did.

And then, the whole issue was reviewed by a judge, who looked at both sides. And who DID see the data, and the reason why that bureaucrat decided to classify that data.

And the judge agreed with the National Security puke.

There are times that reasonable people have to let other people do their job & trust them. Especially with things exactly like this.

I really could go on at the glaring failures of NIST to do a proper investigation, but I will just stop here, for now.

You’ve listed NOT ONE thing that indicates any “failure” whatsoever, much less a “glaring failure” on the part of NIST’s analysis.

You don’t have the knowledge or experience to make that judgment.

The people who DO have the knowledge & experience to make that judgment, the entire mechanical & structural engineering community (including, yes, me) have come to the opposite conclusions. We have accepted NIST’s assumptions, analyses & conclusions as “substantially correct”.

You disagree?
Again, where is your Structural Engineering degree?
Where have you presented your disagreement to the engineering community in the traditional way: a peer reviewed paper in a respected engineering journal.

Where have ANY of the SEs or MEs at AE911T done that?
No place.

Your disdain is rendered irrelevant by virtue of your incompetence.

I know the answer to all these questions, but will you admit it?

Oh, please.
Share your answer with us.

I don't mean this as a personal attack, but I really need to address this issue.

I’d strongly suggest that, if you need answers to this or any technical issue, you not act like such a petulant child & consummate dick to the people who have the ability to give you those answers.

Your assertions can only be interpreted that you claim to know physics and engineering better than anyone at NIST.

That’s the “only interpretation” that you can come up with, is it??
LoL.
Remember the “consummate dick” part of the above response…?

Even David Chandler admits the people at NIST are brilliant engineers.

Yup, Chandler’s right about that.
And Chandler knows zippo about structural engineering.

That’s why I strongly suggested, when he first got into this, that he take his trash to an unbiased, experienced Structural Engineer. He refused.

His colossal mistake. He's been humiliating himself in public ever since.

But don't he impress the clueless chillun ...!

His conclusion is that they were tasked with covering up what really happened.

Yup, that’s correct.
The other consummate dick in this conversation, Chandler, states in public that the engineers at NIST are “brilliant”, but are also traitors, cowards & abettors after the fact to mass murder.

All because of his own searing delusion that a degree in physics makes you a knowledgeable about very specialized, complex topics in structural engineering. Chandler doesn't know JACK about these topics.

And his delusion that he is one of the few honorable people on the planet…
Chandler is despicable.

He is also a coward, who will allow no comments on any of his videos.

I invited him to come to this forum (when it was at JREF). I told him that the moderators would filter out all the snark, and it would just be me & the people with engineering experience that would debate the issues with him.

He ran away.

Real engineers, real scientists, and people who are interested in the truth INVITE criticism from competent reviewers. NIST hosted several programs at their facilities, inviting engineers from all pertinent walks, to come & critique their work. They were open & transparent about their methods, their assumptions, etc.

Contrast that approach to Chandler's avoidance of anyone except other Truthers.
 
I'll try again, perhaps AClark sees this now.
That's all very well and mathy, but it makes some very glaring omissions. Primarily the trigonometry of the situation. If you are going to have pieces toppling, then you are going to need pivot points, and enough geometry for your javelin.
You are Moving the Goal Posts.

You had declared:
AClark said:
The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large...
So I asked:
Can you quantify this "very large" energy required?

There are basically two theories on the table that would explain the source of that energy:
  • Gravity (GPE - Gravitational Potential Energy)
  • Explosives (ChE - Chemical Energy)
I quantified the requirement for the first theory - that GPE is the energy source: Drop height of 10 to 40 floors - easily available for collapses starting 78+ floors above ground.

Remember: You made a claim about the quantity of energy.

Now you:
How much explosives (equivalent to chemical energy, ChE) does it take, per mass unit of steel to propel a steel section to 60 mph?
That calculation is much less straightforward.
I have done it.
Have you?
Can you guess?
 
No, the computer program David Chandler used tracks the vertical position of the reference point (the top corner of WTC7) over time. Each frame (not every 8 frames as was incorrectly claimed by another poster) generates a new reference point.

Wrong.

The graph David Chandler shows in his video is not of average velocity. The graph is of actual velocity vs. time.

Wrong.

The user can then enter a start and end time, and the computer will generate a straight line (slope) that is the best fit of all of the points in between the two times. This slope is the acceleration.

Wrong.

The graph shows an acceleration of (approximately) 9.8m/s/s for about 2.25 seconds. This value approximately matches NIST's experiments. Acceleration that has the same value over an interval can be said to have constant acceleration during that interval. Why? Simple. It's because the value of the acceleration does not change. Something that does not change is constant. The interval in this example is about 2.25 seconds. That means, without a doubt, anyone can correctly say there was constant acceleration during the collapse of WTC7 for about 2.25 seconds. The value of that acceleration was 9.8m/s/s, or freefall.

Wrong.

You keep saying I don't understand this. You are wrong, and your personal attacks are getting tiring. It is ludicrous to claim I'm wrong, when I'm the one who is correcting you, and providing clear proof that you are wrong.

Laughably wrong.
You’ve provided “proof” of anything?? Anywhere??

Point it out.
Your assertions are NOT proof.

Now, in this post, I have provide no proofs either. I've asserted that you are wrong.
The difference between us is that I can go on to the next step.
I CAN provide proof, REAL proof, that you are wrong about every single one of your baseless assertions above.

Let's see you attempt to provide evidence, aka "proof", that you are correct.
The above are YOUR assertions.
It is YOUR job to prove YOUR assertions.

Let's see what you've got.
 
Last edited:
Oystein,

I ran across this useful tidbit & thought you might be interested.

From “Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques, 2nd Edition” pg. 75

Harris said:
Internal Blast Effects - The nature of gaseous explosions in domestic surroundings has been studied extensively after the progressive collapse at Ronan Point (Rashbash, 1969; Stretch, 1969; Alexander and Hambly, 1970; Slack, 1971). The 100-psi theoretical maximum pressure that can be reached in a completely confined explosion in a maximum concentration of most gaseous types is rarely realized (Rashbash, 1969). Most gaseous explosions are less concentrated, and venting of the burning gases drastically reduces the theoretical peace pressures. Most experimentally induced explosions have peak pressures in the range of 1/20 to 1/10 of the theoretical maximum.

I the wide open spaces of the towers, with all the glass windows, I bet the over-pressure from a blast couldn't get any higher than the low end of this range: about 5 psi.

Although they may have been talking about commonly occurring blasts, like natural gas explosions.
I'm not sure where the Hush-A-Booms™ fall in this range.

What does your data say for pressure vs time curves in blasts?
 
Last edited:
.

Lets take the moon example. We place the moon on the surface of the earth. It's not moving, it is at rest, the force applied to the Earth's surface by the moon is the same as the force being applied to the moon's surface by the Earth. We have equal but opposite forces and an object at rest.

By pure Newtonian Physics they should both remain in that position because they are at rest and have no unequal forces acting on them, yet we know that this will not happen, in fact both will crush into the other.

Newtonian Physics doesn't explain this, which is why you need to understand things like Maxwell and Material Physics to understand why.

Your "game" is pointless. No one is disagreeing with Newton. They aren't saying Newton's laws are incorrect, they are pointing out that the way you and Cole are applying the Newtonian Laws is incorrect.

Do you get the difference?

Correct, but with the caution that you are referring to Newtonian Physics as taught in high school. As Newtonian physics is taught in high school, objects are treated as point sources (and therefore have infinite density! :rolleyes:) and have no structure and are often modeled as being tied together by massless rods of infinite strength.

This has value as a heuristic, and in limiting cases, to the real world. But since this doesn't deal with objects that have structure, and are made of real world materials, there are limits to its usability. In the world of high school physics, inelastic collisions never result in ejected material, and no moon orbiting a planet could ever break up from tidal forces, although Edouard Roche calculated the limit for such, almost 170 years ago.

The inability of Truthers to get beyond even high school physics accounts for the "theoretical physics" part of their overall failure, and why it's useless to try to school them in the real world.
 
Oystein,

I ran across this useful tidbit & thought you might be interested.

From “Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques, 2nd Edition” pg. 75



I the wide open spaces of the towers, with all the glass windows, I bet the over-pressure from a blast couldn't get any higher than the low end of this range: about 5 psi.

Although they may have been talking about commonly occurring blasts, like natural gas explosions.
I'm not sure where the Hush-A-Booms™ fall in this range.

What does your data say for pressure vs time curves in blasts?

Thanks for this tidbid, might come in handy some time.
My approach was a rather simple Conservation of Energy + Conservation of Momentum approach. I did not consider forces as such, and hence no pressure. The idea is roughly: Put plastic explosives on the inside of a wall panel (columns and/or spandrels), detach the panel already, and blast. All the explosive material will speed away orthogonally from the panel (inward), and the panel will fly the other way (outward). Given realistic values of energy density of the explosives, how much do you need to create the momentum Truthers fantasize about, considering that the chemical energy goes both into the wall panel and the hot gasses.
I essentially didn't consider the strength of the steel. Or you might say I assumed it to be of unlimited strength. I this ignored the energy loss due to tearing and bending the steel.
I also ignored any rotation stemming from explosives not acting perfectly balanced on the panel's CoG.
This approach gives an absolute minimum of explosives needed to propel, e.g., 1 ton of steel to, e.g., 60 mph.
You would have to apply generous factors (10x or more?) to account for all the losses I ignored.
 
Good luck getting an answer, he's ignored several posts already in hopes we'd all forget after a few days. Now he's gish galloping into a section of the NIST report he doesn't seem to understand.

Typical twoofer behaviour.
I have life. Fighting the ignorance of others is not my full time job.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom