If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
All of my posts in this thread are working towards the proof you are looking for. Anyone who makes a claim that I'm not referring to real data is clueless. I clearly do post credible links to real data. The fact that you don't agree with this does not prove I'm not using real data.

All of your posts? I've yet to see you post any sort of data at all.

Are you seeing a different thread?
 
The fact that constant acceleration occurred is not open for debate; It happened.

We are not discussing Newton's third law.

Save your argument for then. It will be clear that I do understand Newton's third law.

You contradict yourself: Claiming constant acceleration for the WTC towers proves that you don't understand Newton. In fact, you've painted yourself into a corner with the constant acceleration nonsense. Anyone who understands Newton's laws should be able to understand why there is no conceivable way for the WTC towers to collapse with constant 0.64g acceleration, CD or otherwise, because any collisions whatsoever will exert an upward force on the falling mass in accordance with Newton's 3rd law, and will therefore cause a change in acceleration in accordance with the 2nd law.

Your lack of physics knowledge should be correctable, even despite your obviously limited mechanical aptitude and visualization skills, but your willful ignorance seems to be an insurmountable obstacle.

The sources and example I posted should be enough. I have wasted a substantial amount of time trying to explain basic physics concepts to members who refuse to listen. I will no longer do this.

Again, I posted a source and and example. That is all I am going to do.

Nope, after insulting the board as you have by wasting page after page on idiotic nonsense, I'm not letting you off the hook that easily. I guess you'll have take my word for this, but anyone who actually understands Myriad's point can see that you haven't gotten anywhere near even acknowledging it, much less refuting it. The fact that you think you have simply makes you look even more clueless.

But here's another opportunity, and I'll try to make the point dirt simple: The force of gravity is equal and opposite between the building and the Earth, and the contact forces in collisions are equal and opposite on the colliding masses, but these are two different forces which you are erroneously equating with each other. As long as you persist in doing that, you will never understand a progressive collapse, which means that you will continue to make a fool of yourself whenever Verinage demolitions, Ronan Point, and Skyline Towers are discussed.
 
Where did I get the collapse time wrong?


OK, how long would it take for a bowling ball dropped from the 110th floor to reach the ground?

What are the differences in times between the fall of bowling ball and the fall of the top floor of each tower?

Does it make sense that the top floor of a 110 story steel structure could fall to the ground in nearly the same time it takes an unimpeded bowling ball to fall? No, it doesn't, and Newton tells us why.

Thank you for the clarification. I sometimes get WTC7 mixed up with WTC 1 and 2 when it comes to the value of the constant acceleration. It won't happen again.

Clues there in yellow. It took several pages of discussion to get you to admit that the average acceleration was only about 65% of G.

The wrong (10 seconds) collapse time led you to the CD conclusion, where you claimed it showed there was little or nothing resisting collapse as support was being removed as the building fell. When you abandoned the wrong collapse time you retained the CD conclusion it had led you to.
 
Last edited:
Lol. Are you guys still trying to explain Newtons laws to him? What's the use? Hè will never understand it, or aknowledge hè is wrong. So why bother?

I keep telling them but on they go.
He has no interest in learning or progressing the thread.

Same old.
 
FalseFlag,

Falling faster than G:

Compare the downward acceleration of the ball (in freefall) to the downward acceleration of the tee that was supporting it.

Does the tee fall at lower acceleration, at the same acceleration, or at higher acceleration than the ball? Answer: higher than G

Were there any forces other than gravity at work here? Answer: no

Please explain.
 
You contradict yourself: Claiming constant acceleration for the WTC towers proves that you don't understand Newton. In fact, you've painted yourself into a corner with the constant acceleration nonsense. Anyone who understands Newton's laws should be able to understand why there is no conceivable way for the WTC towers to collapse with constant 0.64g acceleration, CD or otherwise, because any collisions whatsoever will exert an upward force on the falling mass in accordance with Newton's 3rd law, and will therefore cause a change in acceleration in accordance with the 2nd law.

Your lack of physics knowledge should be correctable, even despite your obviously limited mechanical aptitude and visualization skills, but your willful ignorance seems to be an insurmountable obstacle.



Nope, after insulting the board as you have by wasting page after page on idiotic nonsense, I'm not letting you off the hook that easily. I guess you'll have take my word for this, but anyone who actually understands Myriad's point can see that you haven't gotten anywhere near even acknowledging it, much less refuting it. The fact that you think you have simply makes you look even more clueless.

But here's another opportunity, and I'll try to make the point dirt simple: The force of gravity is equal and opposite between the building and the Earth, and the contact forces in collisions are equal and opposite on the colliding masses, but these are two different forces which you are erroneously equating with each other. As long as you persist in doing that, you will never understand a progressive collapse, which means that you will continue to make a fool of yourself whenever Verinage demolitions, Ronan Point, and Skyline Towers are discussed.

William you have made a mistake, Gravity is not an action, Gravitational acceleration is an action, For every action of a force there is an opposite reaction, under newton
That's what I have been trying to tell you. That is where the problem lies.
It is quite possible for constant acceleration of less than G to occur.
So long as the value of structural resistance is lower than the value
Of gravitational acceleration.
It's not Newton's laws that are being interpreted incorrectly it is gravity.
 
Beautifully done!

Now it can only be hoped that it will be read, and understood (or at least apprehended) by its addressee...

ETA: I see my hopes were not brought to fruition. Ah, well.

I knew that getting him to actually read something, put aside his ego & make an attempt to understand it, was a minuscule probability.

Their motto should be:

"Just Asking Questions ...
... Not Interested in Answers."
 
Ooh, FalseFlag, you forgot to answer my Newton's First Law question. According to Newton's First Law, does the cart move or not?

Also, if no one minds, I'm just going to keep posting the following. If FF refuses to address it because it mentions concepts he doesn't feel like acknowledging just now, it will just stand unanswered as refutation of his claims.

The floors should have exerted an opposite and equal force on the falling mass.


This is false.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

The force of the gravitational attraction between the earth and the falling mass acts upon the falling mass, pulling it downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the earth, pulling it upward. (The earth, being rather large, does not move very much as a result of that pull. F = ma means a = F/m.)

Simultaneously, the force of the impact between the falling mass and a floor acts upon the floor, breaking it and accelerating the floor material downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the falling mass. That force might decelerate the falling mass, but only if that force exceeds the force of gravity pulling the falling mass down.

There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater (on average), there was no deceleration (on average).
 
Last edited:
I don't agree.

Disagree all you like, but that, too, is baseless.

The raw data should have 30 data points per second. Your graph has 5 or 6. Without all that missing data, you cannot conclude anything about the acceleration of the fall being constant.

How did NIST determine constant acceleration for WTC7? Well, you don't have to speculate because the answer is here: http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/factsheet/wtc_qa_082108.cfm

The focus was on your claim of constant acceleration for tower collapse. Trying to shift the subject to Building 7 doesn't support your claim. Moreover, and this is important since it is provably contrary to your claim, NIST did not report the collapse of WTC 7 was at constant acceleration. The word, constant, does not even appear at the link you cited.

...
I have provided evidence of constant acceleration. You just refuse to accept it by hiding behind insignificant minutia. Defects in the quality of the video are not enough to affect the measurement of acceleration.

The data you've presented has been reduced, averaged, filtered, and smoothed, and you consider that "insignificant minutia". And where did this strawman about "defects in the quality of the video" come from? Be that as it may, without the actual raw data, you cannot make any valid claim about the acceleration being constant.

You cannot conclude the acceleration was constant, and you cannot rule out a sequence of floor-to-floor collisions, fully consistent with the graph you posted.
 
I'll try again, perhaps AClark sees this now.

That's all very well and mathy, but it makes some very glaring omissions. Primarily the trigonometry of the situation. If you are going to have pieces toppling, then you are going to need pivot points, and enough geometry for your javelin.
You are Moving the Goal Posts.

You had declared:
AClark said:
The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large...
So I asked:
Can you quantify this "very large" energy required?

There are basically two theories on the table that would explain the source of that energy:
  • Gravity (GPE - Gravitational Potential Energy)
  • Explosives (ChE - Chemical Energy)
I quantified the requirement for the first theory - that GPE is the energy source: Drop height of 10 to 40 floors - easily available for collapses starting 78+ floors above ground.

Remember: You made a claim about the quantity of energy.

Now you:
How much explosives (equivalent to chemical energy, ChE) does it take, per mass unit of steel to propel a steel section to 60 mph?
That calculation is much less straightforward.
I have done it.
Have you?
Can you guess?
 
To paraphrase George Bernard Shaw. Never wrestle with Truthers. You both get dirty and the Truther likes it.
 
Lol. Are you guys still trying to explain Newtons laws to him? What's the use? Hè will never understand it, or aknowledge hè is wrong. So why bother?

It's hilarious, I haven't giggled this much reading a thread in quite sometime.

This is pretty much what has happened:

Engineer, Physicist, Teacher, Architect: What is 2+2?

FalseFlag: I'm not answering your questions

Engineer, Physicist, Teacher, Architect: Well the answer is 4

FalseFlag: Your words are meaningless post a credible source
 
It's hilarious, I haven't giggled this much reading a thread in quite sometime.

This is pretty much what has happened:

Engineer, Physicist, Teacher, Architect: What is 2+2?

FalseFlag: I'm not answering your questions

Engineer, Physicist, Teacher, Architect: Well the answer is 4

FalseFlag: Your words are meaningless post a credible source

My favorite part was when he said NIST didn't deal with "free fall," read the link where NIST addressed free fall five years ago and then declared NIST wrong because reasons.
 
It's hilarious, I haven't giggled this much reading a thread in quite sometime.

This is pretty much what has happened:

Engineer, Physicist, Teacher, Architect: What is 2+2?

FalseFlag: I'm not answering your questions

Engineer, Physicist, Teacher, Architect: Well the answer is 4

FalseFlag: Your words are meaningless post a credible source

Almost perfect. :thumbsup:
May I suggest this variant?

FalseFlag: I know how the adding of numbers work, and you don't

Engineer, Physicist, Teacher, Architect: What is 2+2?

FalseFlag: I'm not answering your questions

Engineer, Physicist, Teacher, Architect: Well the answer is 4

FalseFlag: Your words are meaningless post a credible source
 
Ooh, FalseFlag, you forgot to answer my Newton's First Law question. According to Newton's First Law, does the cart move or not?

Also, if no one minds, I'm just going to keep posting the following. If FF refuses to address it because it mentions concepts he doesn't feel like acknowledging just now, it will just stand unanswered as refutation of his claims.




This is false.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

The force of the gravitational attraction between the earth and the falling mass acts upon the falling mass, pulling it downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the earth, pulling it upward. (The earth, being rather large, does not move very much as a result of that pull. F = ma means a = F/m.)

Simultaneously, the force of the impact between the falling mass and a floor acts upon the floor, breaking it and accelerating the floor material downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the falling mass. That force might decelerate the falling mass, but only if that force exceeds the force of gravity pulling the falling mass down.

There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater (on average), there was no deceleration (on average).

Hooray that's the point Chandler seems to be saying the Top mass will exert a gravitational force equal too it's own weight on earth, on the lower portion of the building arresting collapse. not it's mass in zero G.

That where the calculation I did comes in and why the value is so small, that's just Nutty.
 
Hooray that's the point Chandler seems to be saying the Top mass will exert a gravitational force equal too it's own weight on earth, on the lower portion of the building arresting collapse. not it's mass in zero G.

That where the calculation I did comes in and why the value is so small, that's just Nutty.

Yeh. Chandler made that mistake. I had a discussion with a truther once about it. According to him an chandler if you blow the 10th floor of a building of 12 stories, only the top 2 floors, and the 2 floors beneath it will collapse.
 
FalseFlag,

Falling faster than G:

Compare the downward acceleration of the ball (in freefall) to the downward acceleration of the tee that was supporting it.

Does the tee fall at lower acceleration, at the same acceleration, or at higher acceleration than the ball? Answer: higher than G

Were there any forces other than gravity at work here? Answer: no

Please explain.

Thanks, tfk. That was the one I was talking about.

Dave
 
Thanks, tfk. That was the one I was talking about.

Dave

You're welcome.

And another:

I fear it's going to be pointless, tho.
You can't force anyone to learn ... if they already think they know everything.


FalseFlag, The end of the ruler vs the washers?

"Faster than freefall"?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom