If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
The rest of your post is nothing more than a red-herring with the purpose of making this discussion more complex than necessary, and about concepts beyond Newton's three laws of motion.

You got that backwards, kid.

The question that started this little fiasco is, "Does Jon Cole's ignorance of scaling render his 'collapse model' experiments meaningless?"

All the information in my post is precisely spot on in providing the answer: "Yup, Cole's model is meaningless."

Look at the title of the reference book:
Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques, Second Edition
By Harry G. Harris
http://tinyurl.com/gra8ejf

Do you REALLY intend to argue that it is a Red Herring to the original topic that started this?
Really?
__

The Red Herring here is your silly & ignorant of the concept "Newton challenge".

You didn't look at any of the stuff I dug up for you, did you.
It is a mighty Fortress Of Ignorance that you've built around yourself.
 
Last edited:
JSanderO, You may want to encourage Mick West at Metabunk to read my post #1269. It pertains to his attempt at a model, too.
 
Last edited:
Yeh. Chandler made that mistake. I had a discussion with a truther once about it. According to him an chandler if you blow the 10th floor of a building of 12 stories, only the top 2 floors, and the 2 floors beneath it will collapse.

That's because Chandler made a classic mistake, when two gravitational bodies are close or under the influence of a larger gravitational body, you have too use general relativity not Newton, to determine precise gravitational effect.

Though I could be wrong that's what I was doing, I understood gravity
Perfectly I was just trying to understand chandler, now I need some romulan Ale to get the garbage equations of his out of my head.:)
 
JSanderO, You may want to encourage Mick West at Metabunk to read my post #1269. It pertains to his attempt at a model, too.

I read it. I know that you can't accurately replicate the collapses. It's just intended to illustrate a subset of the type of things that are going on. In particular the progressive failure of the floor sections at their seated connections, and the subsequent failure of the outer walls. Obviously the scale requires a lot of compromises. The "floors" and "columns" are insanely strong (to scale). The focus is on the seated connections failing when a sudden load is applied.

Hopefully I'll have an 8 foot high model up and running later today. Progress can be followed here:
https://www.metabunk.org/towards-a-...ive-collapse-of-the-wtc-towers-on-9-11.t7396/

Here's the current state of the "seated connections". Note the scale discrepancies between the "seat" essentially a flimsy bit of bent laminated paper, and the "floor" (0.75 inch thick wood, about a thousand times stronger than the connection). The "core" is a 4x4.
20160316-090218-y615l-jpg.18085
 
Last edited:
William you have made a mistake, Gravity is not an action, Gravitational acceleration is an action, For every action of a force there is an opposite reaction, under newton
That's what I have been trying to tell you. That is where the problem lies.
It is quite possible for constant acceleration of less than G to occur.
So long as the value of structural resistance is lower than the value
Of gravitational acceleration.
It's not Newton's laws that are being interpreted incorrectly it is gravity.

You're unnecessarily confusing the issues. We're talking Newtonian physics here, where gravity is adequately described as a force rather than a geometry, because there are no measurable relativistic effects. That is definitely not where the problem lies in the specific issue FF is dodging here. That problem is from trying to equate two different forces: the "force" of gravity and the contact force of collisions. Nor is it the problem with the fallacies in Chandler's arguments. A constant acceleration less than g would require a constant resistance, like falling through water, and there is simply no way a collapsing structure can provide constant resistance, whether or not the collapse was initiated with explosives.
 
Last edited:
You're unnecessarily confusing the issues. We're talking Newtonian physics here, where gravity is adequately described as a force rather than a geometry, because there are no measurable relativistic effects. That is definitely not where the problem lies in the specific issue FF is dodging here. That problem is from trying to equate two different forces: the "force" of gravity and the contact force of collisions. Nor is it the problem with the fallacies in Chandler's arguments. A constant acceleration less than g would require a constant resistance, like falling through water, and there is simply no way a collapsing structure can provide constant resistance, whether or not the collapse was initiated with explosives.

I was simply stating that gravity does not exert a repulsive force to it's self an oppisite reaction. And no the buildings can not provide a consistent resistance only a maximum resistance, a minimum resistance, and an average of the two.

Chandler's and False Flags Fallacy is that they believe the action of the floor will exert an upward force against Gravity do to the weight of the top block in earth's gravitational field,
That's the whole basis of Chandler's arguments and of False Flags arguments based on Chandler's unique physics.
 
Again, you refuse to listen to my posts.

Your words are meaningless. Post a credible outside source that deals just with Newton's first law of motion. Using that source, prove Newton is wrong, or that I don't understand his first law.
.
Okay, here's the unequivocal proof that you don't understand Newton's First Law:

You are talking about inertia. Inertia is often discussed along with Newton's first law of motion, but they are different concepts. Mass (what is being confused with scale and size) does affect inertia, but it has no effect on Newton's first law of motion.
 
Last edited:
.
Okay, here's the unequivocal proof that you don't understand Newton's First Law:
You are talking about inertia. Inertia is often discussed along with Newton's first law of motion, but they are different concepts. Mass (what is being confused with scale and size) does affect inertia, but it has no effect on Newton's first law of motion.

Absolutely!
Let's turn to Sir Isaac Newton himself, and the Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica, in which he formulated the laws.

Here is a link to the English translation by Andrew Motte (1729; Philosophiæ was written in Latin):
https://archive.org/stream/newtonspmathema00newtrich/newtonspmathema00newtrich_djvu.txt

The first book (you have to scroll past the introduction; or search for "DEFINITION I") starts with definitions of mass and momentum, and then already comes the First Law:
Sir Isaac Newton said:
DEFINITION III.

The vis insita, or innate force of matter, is a power of resisting, by
which every body, as much as in it lies, endeavours to persevere in its
present stale, whether it be of rest, or of moving uniformly forward
in a right line.
This force is ever proportional to the body whose force it is ; and differs
nothing from the inactivity of the mass, but in our manner of conceiving
it. A body, from the inactivity of matter, is not without difficulty put out
of its state of rest or motion. Upon which account, this vis insita, may,
by a most significant name, be called vis inertia
, or force of inactivity.
But a body exerts this force only, when another force, impressed upon it,
endeavours to change its condition ; and the exercise of this force may bo
considered both as resistance and impulse ; it is resistance, in so far as the
body, for maintaining its present state, withstands the force impressed; it
is impulse, in so far as the body, by not easily giving way to the impressed
force of another, endeavours to change the state of that other. Resistance
is usually ascribed to bodies at rest, and impulse to those in motion;
but motion and rest, as commonly conceived, are only relatively distin
guished ; nor are those bodies always truly at rest, which commonly are
taken to be so.
I quote that definition in full. Bolding and highlight are mine.

Newton himself points out that the First Law is about inertia!
 
Isn't this fun? Irrational thinking ripped to bits by rational arguments.......using ammunition handed out by the irrational thinker. It's a great spectator sport.
 
Absolutely!
Let's turn to Sir Isaac Newton himself, and the Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica, in which he formulated the laws.

Here is a link to the English translation by Andrew Motte (1729; Philosophiæ was written in Latin):
https://archive.org/stream/newtonspmathema00newtrich/newtonspmathema00newtrich_djvu.txt

The first book (you have to scroll past the introduction; or search for "DEFINITION I") starts with definitions of mass and momentum, and then already comes the First Law:

I quote that definition in full. Bolding and highlight are mine.

Newton himself points out that the First Law is about inertia!

Newton didn't understand the first law
 
I have posted this repeatedly. I have posted proof that constant acceleration was observed during the collapse of WTC 1, and I have posted proof that constant acceleration was observed during the collapse of WTC 7. NIST has also confirmed a constant acceleration of 9.8m/s/s for approximately 2.25 seconds during the collapse of WTC 7.

The fact that constant acceleration occurred is not open for debate; It happened.

Sorry, in what post number did you quote NIST declaring a constant at g acceleration in any collapse?
 
Here's a velocity trace for WTC1 (black thick line):
[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/6/2/214138321.jpg?1458121527[/qimg]
The deceleration is clearly visible when the velocity ramps up rather than down, at about frame 85. The jerks at frames ~116 and ~139 are quite prominent too.

Well, that's interesting, isn't it. Why does FalseFlag not have a graph like this?

Do you have a link to a description of how the data was collected and processed? I would have expected more noise in the individual data points, so I am wondering if a filter had been applied? ...maybe a 5-point moving average?
 
Thank you for posting this. I will use your post as the first example where I can conclusively, and undeniably prove you are 100 percent wrong.

On Monday I posted three definitions of Newton's first law of motion. I then gave my own example of Newton's first law. I then set forth three challenges. The first was to prove Newton wrong. The second was to prove that my example was wrong. The third was to prove that scale matters in regards to Newton's first law of motion.

More than 24 hours later no one has successfully completed even one challenge. There have been countless attempts, but they have all failed. In fact, each attempt to complete any of the challenges should actually be viewed as a clear, undeniable sign that the person attempting the challenge has no understanding of Newton's first law. Anyone attempting to prove Newton wrong is clearly clueless. Anyone attempting to prove my example was wrong is also clueless. The example was so simple, and clearly correct, that anyone who even made the attempt to prove me wrong should have their actions questioned. Their motivation for even attempting to prove me wrong should be highly suspect. Third, not one person posted any conclusive proof that scale is relevant to Newton's first law of motion.

The fact that no one successfully completed my challenges is proof that I do understand Newton's first law of motion. My next challenges will involve Newton's second law of motion, where I once again will conclusively prove that I do understand Newton's second law of motion.

I say this all the time, but I will say it again. The fact that you don't like what I am posting does not mean I'm wrong.

No. I will not waste any more time performing your pointless tasks.

Humm...
 
:thumbsup:
You are all wasting your time.
All you will get in reply to anything you post is 'Newtons third law'
FalseFlag has his USP as all truthers do.
He will stick on this and ignore anything else.
It doesn’t matter how many of you have degrees, diplomas, accreditation or any kind of qualification or engineering license.
You could force him to read all the engineering and physics books you want. Even send him to College.
You will not get beyond what you have now.
He doesn't care. He has an ideological and political position he is pushing. 9/11 is just the peg it is hung on.
:thumbsup:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom