If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
NIST says acceleration was a constant 9.8m/s/s for approximately 2.25 seconds during the collapse of WTC7.
NIST is using average acceleration. They didn't measure the acceleration to enough precision to allow them to examine the overall progress. It did exceed g.

Point is, you're basing your claim of constant acceleration on a lousy measurement of a video.
 
The total energy in the building, whatever that value was, should not have increased at any time during the collapse. If you claim that an object accelerated faster than 9.8m/s/s, you are also claiming that additional energy was added by some method. In a supposed gravity driven collapse, additional energy is not expected. Additional energy is not favorable to the official story.

You don't want to go down this road.

The inside of the building started collapsing 6 seconds before the exterior. How could it possibly not transfer momentum to the exterior or the building ?

How about that real world example of an object in uniform motion ?
 
Yeah, neither of them measures it to enough precision. And the graph I posted and you quoted is from WTC1, not WTC7.

[Edit: And both use methods that average out the acceleration, so claiming that the acceleration was constant was based on the premise of assuming that their methods are more accurate than they are.]

You can learn about the method used to get the necessary precision here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=182833

It's called feature tracking.

OK. I agree that the measurements could be more precise, but does it really matter? Are the videos so degraded that reliable, accurate measurements can't be achieved? I don't think so, and the reason I don't think so has to do with NIST. If NIST thought that precision was an issue, don't you think they would have made it a bigger one?

My opinion is that NIST would want to avoid admitting freefall. In fact, they did try to avoid the topic until they were forced to admit it. Freefall is not seen in their computer models, and their computer models don't match what anyone can see in videos of the actual collapse. If the precision of the video was really an issue, I think they would have made this a much bigger deal. I think they would claim that accurate measurements can't be achieved because of this.

NIST did not make this claim. They could have, but they didn't. If NIST didn't seize this as an excuse to deny the freefall of WTC7, I don't think anyone else should either. Anyone can certainly say it's an issue, but if it is, it's a minor one that doesn't affect the outcome of the measurements enough to make them unreliable.
 
NIST is using average acceleration. They didn't measure the acceleration to enough precision to allow them to examine the overall progress. It did exceed g.

Point is, you're basing your claim of constant acceleration on a lousy measurement of a video.

In fact if you look at the graph they made, you can clearly see the period where the curtain wall of WTC7 did exceed G for about the same duration as the more accurate graph of FEMR2.
 
Apart from when you got the WTC1 collapse time wrong and had to recalculate its acceleration? A change from ~G to substantially less? A change that entirely ruined your original claim that ~G proved CD yet didn't lead to any change in the CD theory?

What a joke :)
Where did I get the collapse time wrong?
 
The total energy in the building, whatever that value was, should not have increased at any time during the collapse. If you claim that an object accelerated faster than 9.8m/s/s, you are also claiming that additional energy was added by some method. In a supposed gravity driven collapse, additional energy is not expected. Additional energy is not favorable to the official story.

You don't want to go down this road.

The energy that drove the collapse was stored PE (gravity) released / converted to kinetic energy. The release was initiated by a complex combination of mechanical damage and distortion and weakening of the structural members/elements/materials by heat from fires (fire are kinetic energy from "stored" potential chemical energy - combustion.

The structure remained static and stable which is what structures do... "resist" the conversion of gravity PE into gravity KE. There was more than enough PE / converted to KE to destroy the materials and nodes of the structure... turning its integrity and stability, into a chaotic dis assembly and conversion of the materials into heat, motion and fractured, deformed materials.
 
You can obviously post in this forum, so why don't you point out where Newton is wrong, or point out where I don't understand Newton's first law of motion.
Newton isn't wrong, you just fundamentally don't understand how to apply the first law.

When you sit at your PC are you at rest or in motion?
 
Wrong. It's quite possible for parts of a system to accelerate faster than gravity, as long as the center of mass doesn't.

The core was already collapsing when the façade started to fall.

What provides the energy in a gravity driven collapse to accelerate something faster than the acceleration due to gravity?
 
Newton isn't wrong, you just fundamentally don't understand how to apply the first law.

When you sit at your PC are you at rest or in motion?

Don't say I'm wrong, and then ask me a meaningless question. This is garbage.
If you claim I'm wrong, use a reliable source to prove I'm wrong. You claim I don't understand how to apply Newton's first law of motion. First, using just Newton's first law of motion, prove I don't understand it. Then, using just Newton's first law of motion prove I don't understand how to apply it.

Your words will be meaningless. Use a credible source that just uses Newton's first law of motion to prove I'm wrong.
 
You are all wasting your time.
All you will get in reply to anything you post is 'Newtons third law'
FalseFlag has his USP as all truthers do.
He will stick on this and ignore anything else.
It doesn’t matter how many of you have degrees, diplomas, accreditation or any kind of qualification or engineering license.
You could force him to read all the engineering and physics books you want. Even send him to College.
You will not get beyond what you have now.
He doesn't care. He has an ideological and political position he is pushing. 9/11 is just the peg it is hung on.
 
The energy that drove the collapse was stored PE (gravity) released / converted to kinetic energy. The release was initiated by a complex combination of mechanical damage and distortion and weakening of the structural members/elements/materials by heat from fires (fire are kinetic energy from "stored" potential chemical energy - combustion.

The structure remained static and stable which is what structures do... "resist" the conversion of gravity PE into gravity KE. There was more than enough PE / converted to KE to destroy the materials and nodes of the structure... turning its integrity and stability, into a chaotic dis assembly and conversion of the materials into heat, motion and fractured, deformed materials.

You didn't answer my question. If you want to claim there was enough PE in the entire building to cause it to collapse to the ground then go ahead. I won't argue against this point.

Again, my question was, if the collapse is gravity driven, where did the energy come from to accelerate the building faster than 9.8m/s/s? I'm trying to help you by letting you know that you don't want to go down this road.
 
You are all wasting your time.
All you will get in reply to anything you post is 'Newtons third law'
FalseFlag has his USP as all truthers do.
He will stick on this and ignore anything else.
It doesn’t matter how many of you have degrees, diplomas, accreditation or any kind of qualification or engineering license.
You could force him to read all the engineering and physics books you want. Even send him to College.
You will not get beyond what you have now.
He doesn't care. He has an ideological and political position he is pushing. 9/11 is just the peg it is hung on.

My posts in this thread all disagree with your conclusions. It's a shame you don't see this.
 
What provides the energy in a gravity driven collapse to accelerate something faster than the acceleration due to gravity?

The mass inside the building that started falling 6 seconds before the exterior provides the energy.

This is conservation of momentum stuff, your'e a Truther you should know this stuff, and have a an appropriate counter response ready.

How about an real world example of an object in uniform motion. Ya got one?
 
Where do you suppose the noted acceleration of more than 9,8 m/s/s in WT7 would come from?

My suspicions are beyond the scope of this thread. I have not taken any time whatsoever to review the work of femr and whoever else is involved.

What does femr attribute the acceleration to? Perhaps you should ask him.
 
Don't say I'm wrong, and then ask me a meaningless question. This is garbage.
If you claim I'm wrong, use a reliable source to prove I'm wrong. You claim I don't understand how to apply Newton's first law of motion. First, using just Newton's first law of motion, prove I don't understand it. Then, using just Newton's first law of motion prove I don't understand how to apply it.

Your words will be meaningless. Use a credible source that just uses Newton's first law of motion to prove I'm wrong.
The very fact that you cannot answer such a simple question shows that you don't understand and are therefore wrong.

You have been asked a number of times to give real world examples to back your claims.

When you sit at your PC are you at rest or in motion?

What part of Newton's first law does your own body come under?
 
Thank you for posting this. I will use your post as the first example where I can conclusively, and undeniably prove you are 100 percent wrong.

On Monday I posted three definitions of Newton's first law of motion. I then gave my own example of Newton's first law. I then set forth three challenges. The first was to prove Newton wrong. The second was to prove that my example was wrong. The third was to prove that scale matters in regards to Newton's first law of motion.

More than 24 hours later no one has successfully completed even one challenge. There have been countless attempts, but they have all failed. In fact, each attempt to complete any of the challenges should actually be viewed as a clear, undeniable sign that the person attempting the challenge has no understanding of Newton's first law. Anyone attempting to prove Newton wrong is clearly clueless. Anyone attempting to prove my example was wrong is also clueless. The example was so simple, and clearly correct, that anyone who even made the attempt to prove me wrong should have their actions questioned. Their motivation for even attempting to prove me wrong should be highly suspect. Third, not one person posted any conclusive proof that scale is relevant to Newton's first law of motion.

The fact that no one successfully completed my challenges is proof that I do understand Newton's first law of motion. My next challenges will involve Newton's second law of motion, where I once again will conclusively prove that I do understand Newton's second law of motion.

I say this all the time, but I will say it again. The fact that you don't like what I am posting does not mean I'm wrong.


Anyone else see a problem here?
 
The very fact that you cannot answer such a simple question shows that you don't understand and are therefore wrong.

You have been asked a number of times to give real world examples to back your claims.

When you sit at your PC are you at rest or in motion?

What part of Newton's first law does your own body come under?

I am not going to answer your questions. If your attempt is to prove I'm wrong, then it is you who must do the work.
 
I am not going to answer your questions. If your attempt is to prove I'm wrong, then it is you who must do the work.
Your body is in motion. You sit on the earth and the earth is orbiting the sun. (Relative to the earth you are at rest)

Now is the sun at rest or in motion?
 
I am not going to answer your questions. If your attempt is to prove I'm wrong, then it is you who must do the work.

The first law of motion does not, strictly, apply to any object in the universe. Everything that exists is constantly acted on by at least one external force at all times (gravity) and so nothing is capable of "uniform motion." Also, nothing is at rest. Everything is moving, non-uniformly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom