If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
.
Okay, here's the unequivocal proof that you don't understand Newton's First Law:
You are talking about inertia. Inertia is often discussed along with Newton's first law of motion, but they are different concepts. Mass (what is being confused with scale and size) does affect inertia, but it has no effect on Newton's first law of motion.

Just to clarify that this isn't an insignificant "gotcha" detail, FF's misconception about inertia is also the answer to his challenge to explain what scale has to do with Newton's first law. That law defines inertia as a force that is proportional to the mass of an object, so if you double the dimensions of an object, its inertia goes up by a factor of 8.
 
Last edited:
...
I have provided evidence of constant acceleration. You just refuse to accept it by hiding behind insignificant minutia. Defects in the quality of the video are not enough to affect the measurement of acceleration.
Next...

I am not making up my facts. I have made up nothing. I have cited NIST's own data when discussing constant acceleration.

Average acceleration and constant acceleration are two entirely different things. Average acceleration is meaningless. The issue is constant acceleration.

NIST says acceleration was a constant 9.8m/s/s for approximately 2.25 seconds during the collapse of WTC7. Your continued refusal to accept this and the fact that you continue to confuse average acceleration with constant acceleration have serious implications.
You lied?

Physics and NIST, two subject you decided you could lie about.

The closest NIST gets to "constant acceleration", is this...
The slope of the velocity curve is approximately constant between about 1.75 s and 4.0 s, and a good straight line fit to the points in this range (open-circles in Figure 3-15) allowed estimation of a constant downward acceleration during this time interval. This acceleration was 32.2 ft/s2 (9.81 m/s2), equivalent to the acceleration of gravity g. (NIST NCSTAR 1A, WTC Investigation, page 45)

1%201%201%20WTC%207%20velocity%20profile.jpg


Or did you mean to discuss constants?
A function of the form z(t) = A{1 – exp[–(t/λ)k]} was assumed, which satisfies the initial conditions of zero displacement, zero velocity, and zero acceleration. The constants A, λ, and k were determined using least squares fitting. (NIST NCSTAR 1A, WTC Investigation, page 45)

911 truth does not use physics to promote the delusional claims 911 truth makes. 911 truth uses idiotic experiments, like Cole's failed experiments. Cole's experiments intentionally or unintentionally are designed to fool people who have no practical knowledge of physics. Plus you and 911 truth follower, having never studied NIST for comprehension, are left making up BS, and lies about NIST.

Your claims of CD remain fantasy, and you will never offer evidence to support CD.
Did you lie on purpose, or is this another error you can correct? ... all claims of CD are in error.


A lie, you never provided evidence of "constant acceleration".
A lie, NIST never said acceleration was a constant.
 
Oh yeah, one other thing:

Average acceleration and constant acceleration are two entirely different things. Average acceleration is meaningless. The issue is constant acceleration.

If "average acceleration is meaningless," then please explain how it's possible, working from data from a video with a finite frame rate, to calculate anything other than the average acceleration over the interval between a pair of frames. And, once you've realised that it isn't, maybe you'd like to reconsider your insistence that a measurement that cannot measure anything other than the average acceleration over a time interval can be used to determine anything, given that "average acceleration is meaningless". And, of course, you may want to consider the fact that no data can establish whether the acceleration was constant over a shorter timescale than the video frame rate, which means that your insistence on constant acceleration not only is not, but cannot be, supported by the data.

Dave
 
Last edited:
What provides the energy in a gravity driven collapse to accelerate something faster than the acceleration due to gravity?
Gravity. Like in this case:


Substitute tower = core, cable = beams and girders, crane = perimeter. Notice how the tip of the crane experiences a sudden acceleration far greater than gravity (it would have been less sudden if the cable was more elastic).

Or you can imagine this experiment.

You have two balls tied with an elastic rope. You hold them both, each with one hand, with the rope loose, on top of a building. You release one, and before the rope tightens you release the other. What happens now?

One of the balls has started accelerating earlier, therefore the distance between both will increase. Therefore, at a certain point, the rope will tighten. At that point, the ball which was dropped first will be pulled up, and the ball which was dropped last will be pulled down. Since the latter was falling at g, the acceleration resulting from the pull must be > g.
 
OK. I agree that the measurements could be more precise, but does it really matter?
It matters, if you want to claim constant acceleration based on smoothed (=averaged) data coming from a lousy analysis.


Are the videos so degraded that reliable, accurate measurements can't be achieved?
Measurements can certainly be achieved. "Accurate" needs quantification, because each and every possible measurement has errors. "More accurate than NIST's and Chandler's" has been done, and the resulting graphs have been posted. There are several threads discussing the topic. I think I've linked to one recently.


I don't think so, and the reason I don't think so has to do with NIST. If NIST thought that precision was an issue, don't you think they would have made it a bigger one?
For reasons that tfk has explained, NIST didn't give a damn about the collapse progression; they only included that analysis because they were trying to address truthers. I think they erred doing that and should just have ignored collapse progression.
 
Last edited:
Well, that's interesting, isn't it. Why does FalseFlag not have a graph like this?

Do you have a link to a description of how the data was collected and processed? I would have expected more noise in the individual data points, so I am wondering if a filter had been applied? ...maybe a 5-point moving average?
Well, that topic was very large, and it was quite some time ago and I can't remember the details now. I think femr2 explained how he obtained the data in this thread, but maybe I'm wrong:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=182833
 
Also could you please post Newton's laws as directly stated by Newton's principia?

Lex. I.
Corpus omne perseverare in statu suo quiescendi vel movendi uniformiter in
directum, nisi quatenus a viribus impressis cogitur statum illum mutare.

Lex. II.
Mutationem motus proportionalem esse vi motrici impressæ, & fieri secun-
dum lineam rectam qua vis illa imprimitur.

Lex. III.
Actioni contrariam semper & æqualem esse reactionem: sive corporum duo-
rum actiones in se mutuo semper esse æquales & in partes contrarias dirigi.

I could translate them, but it's pointless. The past several hundred posts are proof that skeptics take them to mean whatever they want.
 
Lex. I.
Corpus omne perseverare in statu suo quiescendi vel movendi uniformiter in
directum, nisi quatenus a viribus impressis cogitur statum illum mutare.

Lex. II.
Mutationem motus proportionalem esse vi motrici impressæ, & fieri secun-
dum lineam rectam qua vis illa imprimitur.

Lex. III.
Actioni contrariam semper & æqualem esse reactionem: sive corporum duo-
rum actiones in se mutuo semper esse æquales & in partes contrarias dirigi.

I could translate them, but it's pointless. The past several hundred posts are proof that skeptics take them to mean whatever they want.

You can read latin?
 
indigo girls said:
Galileo's head was on the block
The crime was looking up the truth
And as the bombshells of my daily fears explode
I try to trace them to my youth

And then you had to bring up reincarnation
Over a couple of beers the other night
And now I'm serving time for mistakes
Made by another in another lifetime

How long till my soul gets it right?
Can any human being ever reach that kind of light?
I call on the resting soul of Galileo
King of night vision, King of insight

HehTM
 
That's not a very good poem, and going way off topic

Tastes vary. Have you heard it sung?



It is germane because of the "reincarnation" tag, and because Newton refined & codified Galileo's concept of "inertia", a concept with which a particular poster is struggling.

Shoulders of Giants, and all that...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom