If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
You didn't answer my question. If you want to claim there was enough PE in the entire building to cause it to collapse to the ground then go ahead. I won't argue against this point.

Again, my question was, if the collapse is gravity driven, where did the energy come from to accelerate the building faster than 9.8m/s/s? I'm trying to help you by letting you know that you don't want to go down this road.

There is no evidence that the top of the building AND the collapse from was accelerating except in the change of state from static to dynamic If something... such as the roof line and structure associated with it starts to move it HAS to be accelerating. It's acceleration was the result of the supports for a column length - 36 or so becoming axially misaligned with the ones above hence no resistance... gravity acceleration for at least 36' But then the falling columns hit the structure, the beams, the slabs and this began to slow the descent, the colliding parts started to shatter and fall free inside the structure until they encountered some resistance and in less than 4 seconds there was an avalanche of debris from the top 12 or so floors pouring down on the largely intact upper floors... This descending debris was more than enough to beging a progressive collapse which from about floor 95 and this too ramped up from 0 - static to what would quickly become a terminal velocity of 100 feet per second. If data points were available the velocity would show some acceleration between floor impacts. But what we have is the floor by floor material ejections through the facade which WAS timed at 100ft per second descent... 1100 or so feet at 100 or so feet per second returns the collapse time from floor 95 or so of 11 seconds added to the approximately 4 seconds for the top 15 stories to drop gives a collapse time of 14 - 15 seconds for the entire 1365 feet. If you take start and end... 1365 feet apart and 15 seconds you COULD fit this to a single constant acceleration which would be LESS than G. But it would be a very GROSS simplification.

If you drive 250 miles from NYC to Boston with stops along the way in 5 hrs your average speed was 50mph.... but this is an gross description (and inaccurate) of the motion... stops, constant speed on the I95 for hrs... slow down for traffic etc.

The whole discussion about constant acceleration or G or almost G is simply a waste of time.
 
Last edited:
Wrong. It's quite possible for parts of a system to accelerate faster than gravity, as long as the center of mass doesn't.

The core was already collapsing when the façade started to fall.

I agree that an object constantly accelerating at 9.8m/s/s could impact another object and accelerate it faster than 9.8m/s/s. I want to make this clear.

What I don't understand is what object accelerated faster than 9.8m/s/s. Are you claiming that the outside of the building accelerated faster, or the roof line, or an object inside the building? I don't understand exactly what accelerated faster than 9.8m/s/s in femr's example. What exactly is he measuring?
 
Your body is in motion. You sit on the earth and the earth is orbiting the sun. (Relative to the earth you are at rest)

Now is the sun at rest or in motion?

Again, you refuse to listen to my posts.

Your words are meaningless. Post a credible outside source that deals just with Newton's first law of motion. Using that source, prove Newton is wrong, or that I don't understand his first law.
 
The whole discussion about constant acceleration or G or almost G is simple a waste of time.

This is wrong. Constant acceleration at G is only possible if there is no opposing force.

Remember that. It's the key to everything, and I will get back to this in my conclusion in a few days.

Yes, I can tell you are all looking forward to this.
 
Last edited:
The first law of motion does not, strictly, apply to any object in the universe. Everything that exists is constantly acted on by at least one external force at all times (gravity) and so nothing is capable of "uniform motion." Also, nothing is at rest. Everything is moving, non-uniformly.

Source?

Also, for the purpose of a basic physics discussion about objects on earth, are you really saying Newton's first law is wrong? If so, as I said before, you should let the media and your local university know about your findings.
 
FalseFlag,

This will be short. Just a demo.
You’re scorching case of Dunning-Kruger has earned you “don’t bother” status.

Your challenge is meaningless.
Newton’s Laws are not broken by anything that NIST analyzed or concluded.

Your understanding of Newton’s laws, on the other hand, is virtually non-existent.

The fundamental question here is “Is scaling a crucial concern in structural modeling?”

The correct application of Newton’s laws is, in fact, crucial to that discussion.
Unfortunately, your lack of understanding of “How to apply Newton’s laws” prevents you from seeing how that comes to pass.

So I’ll have to simply give you a “demonstration by example”.

Here is your textbook:
Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques, Second Edition
By Harry G. Harris
http://tinyurl.com/gra8ejf

You can read the 1st chapter with Google’s “Look Inside” feature.
In order to even be in this conversation, you need to understand:
1.2.1 Model classification (The collapse model is FAR MORE difficult than the hardest model listed here: The Dynamic Model. Dynamic models are rarely pushed to failure, and the results after failure are never cited as reliable.)
1.3 Historical Perspective (optional, but valuable)
1.6 Choice of Geometric Scale
1.7 The Modeling Process. Especially the 9 step study plan.
1.8 Advantages and Limitations of Model Analysis
1.9 Accuracy of Structural models

Then you should just peruse
1.10 Case studies To see the size of the effort that real engineers put into creating real engineering models.

Once you’ve read the above ...

Here is the Lecture Notes for a Laboratory in “Modeling in Structures” class
http://civil.eng.buffalo.edu/cie616...nd Scaling/Slides 2 Modeling and Scaling.pdf

Read pages 1 thru 21.
No, Seriously. Read them.

The math will be beyond you. Don’t worry about that.

Here are the salient points.
1. This is exactly the sort of analysis that must be done in order for your model to mean anything.

Under Remarks (pg 21)
1. "Elastic behavior" means small deflections, where there is no residual deformation after the loads are removed. This analysis is (comparatively) easy, once you know all the engineering listed above.

2. “Plastic behavior” means the stresses get higher, and permanent deformations to some components happen. This analysis is “non-linear” and is much, much harder than the linear elastic one.

We aren’t CLOSE to the difficulty of a collapse model yet.

3. Note this comment carefully:
"Design of models and their construction requires extreme care. Small variations can be critical for interpretation of results."
Pay attention to the words “extreme care” & “Small variations”.

4. "Non-linear structures can be studied using analytical models that are validated by scaled models.”

In other words, in a Non-Linear Dynamics model, do NOT plan on having your scaled model be GLOBALLY accurate. Break the problem down into small pieces, and IF you model the small pieces CAREFULLY & RIGOROUSLY, you may be able to use these results to inform small limited aspect of your mathematical (i.e., “analytical”) model.

The Collapse Model, that Cole claims to be producing, is far more complex than the most complex dynamics model described here.

Next step: Walk thru the Example starting on page 22.

A Prototype Bridge.

An incredibly SIMPLE structure.
An incredibly SIMPLE model.
A scale factor of 1:2.

Once again, read thru the text, and try to appreciate the various math required to get meaningful results.

In the text, “λ” means “scaling factor”.

λl = linear scaling factor = 2
λA = area scaling factor = 4
λI = moment of inertia s.f. = 16
λw = force s.f. = 4

The math for the 1:2 scale model of a simply supported bridge is complicated. Nothing that an engineering student can’t handle, but complex.

The care, the rigor, the math for a non-linear, dynamic model that is going to be “pushed to failure” is orders of magnitude more complex. And the results are orders of magnitude less reliable.
__

The scale factor for Cole’s collapse model was about 1:120

That means:
λl = linear scaling factor = 120
λA = area scaling factor = 14,400
λI = moment of inertia s.f. = 207,000,000
λw = force s.f. = 14,400

Meanwhile, he paid zero attention to ANY of the concepts described above.

His model is a joke.

Your understanding of structural models is the same.
__

Now, the saving grace of any effort to model the collapse of the towers is that “it doesn’t have to be accurate”.

Nobody is going to die if the analysis is wrong.
No building or bridge is going to collapse.

But the other side of that coin is that you are not going to get a model that accurately replicates the collapse of any real skyscraper.

And this is true whether you do it with a physical model, or with an analytic (math) model. Or even if you attempt to build a full sized mode (say of WTC7), try to emulate every single thing that happened, and watch to see if it fails in the same way.

The chances a fully rebuilt WTC7, with all the equipment & furnishings inside, damaged as accurately as possible, set on fire as accurately as possible, collapses are very high.

The chances that it collapses exactly the same manner are in distinguishable from 0.

Do you know what the really annoying thing about this whole fiasco is, FF?

That, after putting in 8 years getting your BS, MS & PhD, after spending decades more honing your skills on building models, performing this type of analysis, studying buildings that did & did not collapse …

… which is exactly what they NIST structural engineers did …

… when you get done with a first-rate analysis, done to the highest professional standards …

… you get to look forward to a bunch of know-nothing clueless amateurs critiquing your work, suggesting that you falsified your data, suggesting that you’re part of some giant conspiracy to hide treason & mass murder, out of evil intent, politics or cowardice …

… because your simulation “had a twist to it that the actual building did not.”

LMAO.

Beautifully done!

Now it can only be hoped that it will be read, and understood (or at least apprehended) by its addressee...

ETA: I see my hopes were not brought to fruition. Ah, well.
 
Last edited:
This is wrong. Constant acceleration at G is only possible if there is no opposing force.

Remember that. It's the key to everything, and I will get back to this in my conclusion in a few days.

Yes, I can tell you are all looking forward to this.

I explained where there was acceleration... at the outset... all the other movement was not G, close to G, a fraction of G.. it was an average velocity... of 100ft/sec... the motion was a "saw tooth" but smoothed out it was a constant.
 
If you claim I'm wrong, use a reliable source to prove I'm wrong.

I'll use Monty python as my reliable source:

" The sun and you and me and all the stars that we can see
Are moving at a million miles a day
In an outer spiral arm, at forty thousand miles an hour
Of the galaxy we call the 'milky way' "

The object you placed placed in a vacuum and set at rest more than 24 hours ago. If it was truly at rest shouldn't it be more than a million miles behind us, you now, on a galactic scale, Or is it being drug, along with every thing else on this planet by Earths gravitational field.
 
We are not discussing Newton's third law.

Save your argument for then. It will be clear that I do understand Newton's third law.

It is, not to put it too bluntly, simply precious that you seem to think that each of Newton' Laws of Motion only acts in isolation.

As demonstrated by the many examples offered you (and by real-world events) that is, simply, not how it works.
 
I have posted this repeatedly. I have posted proof that constant acceleration was observed during the collapse of WTC 1, and I have posted proof that constant acceleration was observed during the collapse of WTC 7. NIST has also confirmed a constant acceleration of 9.8m/s/s for approximately 2.25 seconds during the collapse of WTC 7.

The fact that constant acceleration occurred is not open for debate; It happened.

Was the constant acceration below G, and did the buildings provide 36% resistance?

Also could you please post Newton's laws as directly stated by Newton's principia?

I. Every object in a state of uniform motion tends to remain in that state of motion unless an external force is applied to it.
http://csep10.phys.utk.edu/astr161/lect/history/newton3laws.html
 
...
On Monday I posted three definitions of Newton's first law of motion. I then gave my own example of Newton's first law. I then set forth three challenges. The first was to prove Newton wrong. The second was to prove that my example was wrong. The third was to prove that scale matters in regards to Newton's first law of motion.

......

The fact that no one successfully completed my challenges is proof that I do understand Newton's first law of motion. My next challenges will involve Newton's second law of motion, where I once again will conclusively prove that I do understand Newton's second law of motion.

I say this all the time, but I will say it again. The fact that you don't like what I am posting does not mean I'm wrong.

If I post something about about general relativity and challenge people to prove that general relativity is wrong and nobody manages to prove Einstein wrong, does that mean that I understand general relativity?
 
If there was a problem then you would have also posted the proof that either Newton is wrong about his first law, or that my example of Newton's first law is wrong. I don't see this in your post.


There's no 'if' about it. I enjoy pointing out logic errors when I find them, and that post of yours was a dense thicket of wrongness.

I won't be engaging with your daft Newton challenge, I'm happy for others to attempt to lead you to the light on that one :)
 
Source?

Also, for the purpose of a basic physics discussion about objects on earth, are you really saying Newton's first law is wrong? If so, as I said before, you should let the media and your local university know about your findings.

Are you asking me for a source on gravity and its infinite range?

I'm not saying Newton's Laws are wrong, I'm saying they apply to an ideal physical representation that works for math but doesn't actually exist. Spherical cows and all that.
 
Lol. Are you guys still trying to explain Newtons laws to him? What's the use? Hè will never understand it, or aknowledge hè is wrong. So why bother?
 
Source?

Also, for the purpose of a basic physics discussion about objects on earth, are you really saying Newton's first law is wrong? If so, as I said before, you should let the media and your local university know about your findings.

Zero point field, the universe itself is an energy field being expanded by dark energy acting upon all mass similar but opposite to gravity, as long as mass exists in an energy field,
There can be no truly uniform motion.
Acceleration is irrelevant as long as a source of energy is known for and accounts for said Acceleration.
 
I don't have enough information to make any remarks about the graph.

Well, I'll make one. The graph shows that at no point in the collapse was the acceleration constant; it varied throughout, due to the retardation being a series of micro-jolts rather than a constant force. And one might ask, if you can't comment on the observed data on acceleration, where you got the idea that the acceleration was constant? To paraphrase the thread title: If it doesn't agree with measured data, it's wrong.

Dave
 
Well, I'll make one. The graph shows that at no point in the collapse was the acceleration constant; it varied throughout, due to the retardation being a series of micro-jolts rather than a constant force. And one might ask, if you can't comment on the observed data on acceleration, where you got the idea that the acceleration was constant? To paraphrase the thread title: If it doesn't agree with measured data, it's wrong.

Dave

Exactly, observations the key to science.
 
I agree that an object constantly accelerating at 9.8m/s/s could impact another object and accelerate it faster than 9.8m/s/s. I want to make this clear.

It's also possible, if an object is rotating about a pivot, for parts of that object to accelerate at greater than the acceleration of the centre of mass. Has anyone got that film of the ball coming out of the cup on the end of a pivoted bar that was posted here some while back? WTC7 has all the necessary characteristics for that; the point measured was not at the centre of mass, and it was clearly rotating southwards during the collapse. In such circumstances an acceleration of one point on the structure greater than 1G is quite possible.

Dave
 
This is wrong. Constant acceleration at G is only possible if there is no opposing force.

Remember that. It's the key to everything, and I will get back to this in my conclusion in a few days.

Yes, I can tell you are all looking forward to this.
K
Sky diver problem say I have a sky diver jump from A plane on opposite sides of the earth,
Will the acceleration, be at G, or will the acceleration, be slightly over G?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom