FalseFlag,
This will be short. Just a demo.
You’re scorching case of Dunning-Kruger has earned you “don’t bother” status.
Your challenge is meaningless.
Newton’s Laws are not broken by anything that NIST analyzed or concluded.
Your understanding of Newton’s laws, on the other hand, is virtually non-existent.
The fundamental question here is “Is scaling a crucial concern in structural modeling?”
The correct application of Newton’s laws is, in fact, crucial to that discussion.
Unfortunately, your lack of understanding of “How to apply Newton’s laws” prevents you from seeing how that comes to pass.
So I’ll have to simply give you a “demonstration by example”.
Here is your textbook:
Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques, Second Edition
By Harry G. Harris
http://tinyurl.com/gra8ejf
You can read the 1st chapter with Google’s “Look Inside” feature.
In order to even be in this conversation, you need to understand:
1.2.1 Model classification (The collapse model is FAR MORE difficult than the hardest model listed here: The Dynamic Model. Dynamic models are rarely pushed to failure, and the results after failure are never cited as reliable.)
1.3 Historical Perspective (optional, but valuable)
1.6 Choice of Geometric Scale
1.7 The Modeling Process. Especially the 9 step study plan.
1.8 Advantages and Limitations of Model Analysis
1.9 Accuracy of Structural models
Then you should just peruse
1.10 Case studies To see the size of the effort that real engineers put into creating real engineering models.
Once you’ve read the above ...
Here is the Lecture Notes for a Laboratory in “Modeling in Structures” class
http://civil.eng.buffalo.edu/cie616...nd Scaling/Slides 2 Modeling and Scaling.pdf
Read pages 1 thru 21.
No, Seriously. Read them.
The math will be beyond you. Don’t worry about that.
Here are the salient points.
1. This is exactly the sort of analysis that must be done in order for your model to mean anything.
Under Remarks (pg 21)
1. "Elastic behavior" means small deflections, where there is no residual deformation after the loads are removed. This analysis is (comparatively) easy, once you know all the engineering listed above.
2. “Plastic behavior” means the stresses get higher, and permanent deformations to some components happen. This analysis is “non-linear” and is much, much harder than the linear elastic one.
We aren’t CLOSE to the difficulty of a collapse model yet.
3. Note this comment carefully:
"Design of models and their construction requires extreme care. Small variations can be critical for interpretation of results."
Pay attention to the words “extreme care” & “Small variations”.
4. "Non-linear structures can be studied using analytical models that are validated by scaled models.”
In other words, in a Non-Linear Dynamics model, do NOT plan on having your scaled model be GLOBALLY accurate. Break the problem down into small pieces, and IF you model the small pieces CAREFULLY & RIGOROUSLY, you may be able to use these results to inform small limited aspect of your mathematical (i.e., “analytical”) model.
The Collapse Model, that Cole claims to be producing, is far more complex than the most complex dynamics model described here.
Next step: Walk thru the Example starting on page 22.
A Prototype Bridge.
An incredibly SIMPLE structure.
An incredibly SIMPLE model.
A scale factor of 1:2.
Once again, read thru the text, and try to appreciate the various math required to get meaningful results.
In the text, “λ” means “scaling factor”.
λl = linear scaling factor = 2
λA = area scaling factor = 4
λI = moment of inertia s.f. = 16
λw = force s.f. = 4
The math for the 1:2 scale model of a simply supported bridge is complicated. Nothing that an engineering student can’t handle, but complex.
The care, the rigor, the math for a non-linear, dynamic model that is going to be “pushed to failure” is orders of magnitude more complex. And the results are orders of magnitude less reliable.
__
The scale factor for Cole’s collapse model was about 1:120
That means:
λl = linear scaling factor = 120
λA = area scaling factor = 14,400
λI = moment of inertia s.f. = 207,000,000
λw = force s.f. = 14,400
Meanwhile, he paid zero attention to ANY of the concepts described above.
His model is a joke.
Your understanding of structural models is the same.
__
Now, the saving grace of any effort to model the collapse of the towers is that “it doesn’t have to be accurate”.
Nobody is going to die if the analysis is wrong.
No building or bridge is going to collapse.
But the other side of that coin is that you are not going to get a model that accurately replicates the collapse of any real skyscraper.
And this is true whether you do it with a physical model, or with an analytic (math) model. Or even if you attempt to build a full sized mode (say of WTC7), try to emulate every single thing that happened, and watch to see if it fails in the same way.
The chances a fully rebuilt WTC7, with all the equipment & furnishings inside, damaged as accurately as possible, set on fire as accurately as possible, collapses are very high.
The chances that it collapses exactly the same manner are in distinguishable from 0.
Do you know what the really annoying thing about this whole fiasco is, FF?
That, after putting in 8 years getting your BS, MS & PhD, after spending decades more honing your skills on building models, performing this type of analysis, studying buildings that did & did not collapse …
… which is exactly what they NIST structural engineers did …
… when you get done with a first-rate analysis, done to the highest professional standards …
… you get to look forward to a bunch of know-nothing clueless amateurs critiquing your work, suggesting that you falsified your data, suggesting that you’re part of some giant conspiracy to hide treason & mass murder, out of evil intent, politics or cowardice …
… because your simulation “had a twist to it that the actual building did not.”
LMAO.