If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, my.

I am, in fact, glad I decided to give this a quick read after walking the dogs.

Tyr this: Fill two large water balloons. Hold them, one above the other, and bring them into close contact, stationary with respect to one another. Now let go of the top one...

Newton's First Law in action.

Good night.

What are you trying to prove? This isn't wrong, but it's certainly not the best example.
 
Seriously? Where did I mention a photon?

Is a neutrino vastly smaller than the earth? Yes. There is no problem with my example.

It is not the size of the particle that allows them to travel though the earth but the balanced forces, that keep the neutrinos from interacting with matter.
 
Are your arguments related to Newton's first law? No, they aren't. If the object never comes to rest, or is never in constant motion, Newton's first law won't apply.


The moon resting on the earth, and starting out motionless relative to the earth's surface, exactly meets every detail of the description in your "challenge." Just as the small moon rock resting on the earth's surface does. The only difference is... you guessed it... scale.

And yes, Newton's first law applies in both cases. The force the one-pound moon rock exerts on the earth's surface is equal and opposite to the force the surface exerts on the rock. The force the moon exerts on the earth's surface is equal and opposite to the force the surface exerts on the moon.

The difference is what happens next. One of the systems (the smaller scale one) remains static, and the other does not. That's because the magnitude of the forces, relative to the strengths of the materials, is different. That's an effect of the difference in scale between a moon rock and the moon.

Why can't we get past this?


Because you're still as wrong as the last time you posted.

I showed exactly why you are wrong about expecting the falling mass of the towers on 9/11 to decelerate at every floor impacted. You attempted to apply the law of equal and opposite reaction but got confused between two different forces, the force of gravity pulling the falling mass downward the the force of impact acting against that fall. As a result of that mistake, you got the wrong answer.

Your moronic challenges, which it's becoming very clear you will also be repeatedly and laughably wrong about, won't change that.
 
Last edited:
I appreciate your response. Perhaps you might want to save this response for level 1, challenge 3 of my game.

Did you understand his response? The answer seems to be no.

You keep seeming to think that that in a chaotic system that all the forces involved must be countered by one single opposing force. This isn't true.

It's not that Newton was wrong, it that you are misapplying Newton's Laws.

If I take a rocket and fire it, then it works due to Newton's laws. By "throwing" the propellant out the back, the main body of the rocket moves forwards because the propellant is applying an equal and opposite force to the rocket's motor as the rocket's motor does to the propellant.

You with me so far?

Let's (for simple math) say that our rocket weights 150 kg and our rocket engine can produce a thrust of 3000 Newtons.

We know that F = ma so this means that F/m = a

3,000N / 150kg = 20ms2
So we have a pair of matched forces and an acceleration of 20m2
Still with me and all happy?

Now I'm going to cheat just a little. In a real experiment, because we are burning fuel, our rocket gets lighter so we have to lower the amount of fuel we're burning, and thus our thrust, to keep our acceleration constant, but since this is a thought experiment I'm going to introduce a magical fuel that regenerates thus keeping a constant fuel mass on board the rocket to keep the rocket's mass and the thrust required the same and therefore the math easy. Hopefully this doesn't throw you, I just bring it up to explain the assumption of using a constant mass rocket for the experiment.

Okay we now take two identical rockets and fire them along a course in space that is 500m in length.

We know that they both have a constant acceleration of 20ms2, right?

Because our starting velocity is 0 and our acceleration is constant, we can rearrange a few formulas to discover that our final Velocity is √(2as) and since v = at, then √(2as)/a is the time it takes to cover the 500m for both our identical rockets.

Plugging in our distance and acceleration we get a final velocity of 141.4 m/s and a time to cover the course of 7.07 seconds.

Hopefully you are still with me.

Now things are going to get rather complicated

Let's run the course a second time, but this time, every 50m we are going to add a wall to the path of rocket #2. These walls will be able to take a loading of 200kg and be able to move 0.2m before it gives way. This means that if it was on the Earth and we sat our rocket on the wall, it would actually hold it up without breaking.

Okay, so we know that our wall can take 2,000N of Force before breaking and we know it can move 0.2 m before breaking, so if our rocket hit the wall with a dynamic load of more then 2,000N or requires more then 0.2m to stop, the wall will break.

Because our rocket has traveled 50 m we know that it's current speed can be determined by √(2as)

with s = 50 and a = 20 we get a final velocity of 44.72m/s

If the wall was to totally stop out rocket, i.e. bring its velocity to 0 moving it's maximum distance before it breaks, it's have to apply negative acceleration to the rocket of -v2/2s

This time s = 0.2m so our acceleration is -5,000m/s2!

since F=ma this means that the dynamic force applied to our wall is 750,000 N, 375 times the amount it can withstand.

This means that our rocket can't be brought to a halt by the wall (and we're not even considering that the rocket engine is still running yet).

So since the rocket can't be stopped, let's instead apply the 2,000N resistance to the rocket. we know this is applied to the 150kg rocket over 0.2m.

F = ma so a = F/m since F is -2,000N and m is 150kg, a then must be -13.333 m/s2
vf2 = vi2 + 2as

so we end up with a Δv of -0.06 m/s

This would mean that were it not for the Rocket motor the rocket would go from 44.72m/s to 44.66m/s, however, remember that there is a rocket engine still firing. This means that while the wall is applying it's 2,000N to the Rocket and accelerating it negatively, the engine is still applying its 3,000N and accelerating it positively.

in the same 0.2m we have a

vf2 = vi2 + 2as

This gives a Δv of 0.09m/s

So the wall is inflicting a Δv of -0.06 m/s while the rocket engine boosts the Δv by 0.09m/s. This means that overall we have a Δv of 0.03m/s

and since a = vf2-vi2/2s we have a total acceleration through the wall of 4.47m/s2 rather than the matched rocket without the wall which is accelerating through the same space as the full 20m/s2
Over the entire 50.2m it would have an average acceleration of 19.95m/s2 again compared to the other rocket having 20m/s2 over the same distance.

We could go on and show that this happens for each and every wall, that the Rocket loses some of its acceleration because of the wall's resistance, but never actually experiences an overall negative acceleration. It's also quite clear that the rocket hitting the walls will finish the 500m course slower then the rocket that doesn't have walls.

Do you understand why this is and how it applies to the WTC?

Do you understand why the wall doesn't apply a force equal to the force of the rocket motor, but rather that the rocket motor and the propellant have equal and opposite forces and the nose cone of the rocket and the wall have equal and opposite forces applied, but that these two sets of forces are quite unequal to each other?

When you understand this, you'll be on your way to understanding the dynamics of the WTC collapse.
 
I appreciate your response, but this is not correct.

If the moon smashed into the earth then you might be right, but if the moon was placed on the earth's surface, and the moon was at rest, it would stay at rest unless another force acted on it. It does not matter how big the object is. If the object is at rest, it will stay at rest unless an (unbalanced) external force acts upon it.

There is a force acting on it, Gravity
 
Did I say there were no forces acting on the object? No.

If there is a force acting on it then Newton's first Law doesn't apply. Newton's 1st law says that a item will stay at rest as long as no force is acting on it, but since gravity is a force and is acting on it, then the First Law no longer applies.

Now yes I am aware that you modified this to "no unequal forces" but this is why people are trying to get you to look deeper.

Lets take the moon example. We place the moon on the surface of the earth. It's not moving, it is at rest, the force applied to the Earth's surface by the moon is the same as the force being applied to the moon's surface by the Earth. We have equal but opposite forces and an object at rest.

By pure Newtonian Physics they should both remain in that position because they are at rest and have no unequal forces acting on them, yet we know that this will not happen, in fact both will crush into the other.

Newtonian Physics doesn't explain this, which is why you need to understand things like Maxwell and Material Physics to understand why.

Your "game" is pointless. No one is disagreeing with Newton. They aren't saying Newton's laws are incorrect, they are pointing out that the way you and Cole are applying the Newtonian Laws is incorrect.

Do you get the difference?
 
Challenge 1b. Explain how scale could make any difference in regards to Newton's first law.

"Every object persists in its state of rest or uniform motion in a straight line unless it is compelled to change that state by forces impressed on it."

"An object at rest stays at rest and an object in motion stays in motion with the same speed and in the same direction unless acted upon by an unbalanced force."

"Newton's First Law states that an object will remain at rest or in uniform motion in a straight line unless acted upon by an external force."


I have hilited the portion of Newtons First Law where scale would make a difference. It was easy to find it was right there at the end of all three versions.
 
If there is a force acting on it then Newton's first Law doesn't apply.

What? That statement is absolutely not correct.

Newton's 1st law says that a item will stay at rest as long as no force is acting on it, but since gravity is a force and is acting on it, then the First Law no longer applies.

Again, what? Yes, gravity is a force, but how does this make Newton's first law no longer apply? This is an incredible misunderstanding of Newton's first law of motion. How do you expect me to take you seriously when you can't, or refuse to understand the first basic law of motion?

You do NOT get to make up the laws of physics to serve your needs.

How about this? Show me anywhere, anywhere in an even remotely respectable publication or video, where your gross misunderstandings of Newton's first law of motion are supported. I am only talking about Newton's first law. Do you understand that? I am only talking about one law, nothing more, and nothing less. The second you talk about any other law, concept, or anything, you are done. Using Newton's first law ONLY, prove your misconceptions are correct.

I absolutely can not believe the level of misunderstanding that exists. Is it even possible for you to answer this? We are talking only about Newton's first law of motion. Can you try to understand this?

This is amazing.
 
I appreciate your response, but this is not correct.

If the moon smashed into the earth then you might be right, but if the moon was placed on the earth's surface, and the moon was at rest, it would stay at rest unless another force acted on it. It does not matter how big the object is. If the object is at rest, it will stay at rest unless an (unbalanced) external force acts upon it.

That is not true.
If somehow the moon was placed on the surface of the Earth it would not stay there motionless.
Earth and Moon would flow into each other and combine into a single round object, slightly bigger than earth is now. Scale does matter.
 
"Every object persists in its state of rest or uniform motion in a straight line unless it is compelled to change that state by forces impressed on it."

"An object at rest stays at rest and an object in motion stays in motion with the same speed and in the same direction unless acted upon by an unbalanced force."

"Newton's First Law states that an object will remain at rest or in uniform motion in a straight line unless acted upon by an external force."


I have hilited the portion of Newtons First Law where scale would make a difference. It was easy to find it was right there at the end of all three versions.

Highlighting only demonstrates your ability to put pretty colors in a post. Try using an external, reliable, authoritative reference that states that scale matters in regards to Newton's first law of motion.
 
That is not true.
If somehow the moon was placed on the surface of the Earth it would not stay there motionless.
Earth and Moon would flow into each other and combine into a single round object, slightly bigger than earth is now. Scale does matter.

Is the object at rest? No? If the object is not at rest, or in continuous motion, then Newton's first law of motion does not apply. If Newton's first law of motion does not apply, then your example involving scale does not apply.

Did anyone bother to read any one of the three credible statements of Newton's first law of motion? It is becoming apparent no one did.
 
Highlighting only demonstrates your ability to put pretty colors in a post. Try using an external, reliable, authoritative reference that states that scale matters in regards to Newton's first law of motion.

When I went to bed last night you'd just been thoroughly schooled on Newton's third law. Rather than concede that your misunderstanding of it had led to incorrect conclusions about building collapse you've switched to an irrelevant discussion of Newton's first law? And I should point out that you acknowledged reading Myriad's very neat explanation of why you were wrong.

I suggest you tidy up that very significant loose end (3rd law) rather than tell people it'll have to wait until we've discussed this subject (1st law), otherwise you'll never reach a conclusion on any element. Or is that your intention?
 
Last edited:
Is the object at rest? No? If the object is not at rest, or in continuous motion, then Newton's first law of motion does not apply. If Newton's first law of motion does not apply, then your example involving scale does not apply.

Did anyone bother to read any one of the three credible statements of Newton's first law of motion? It is becoming apparent no one did.

In the starting situation it was at rest, yes. As per your post.
It just wouldn't stay at rest because of scale.
 
When I went to bed last night you'd just been thoroughly schooled on Newton's third law. Rather than concede that your misunderstanding of it had led to incorrect conclusions about building collapse you've switched to an irrelevant discussion of Newton's first law?

I suggest you tidy up that very significant loose end (3rd law) rather than tell people it'll have to wait until we've discussed this subject (1st law), otherwise you'll never reach a conclusion on any element. Or is that your intention?

How was I "schooled"? Back up your statement with examples instead of posting a meaningless hit-and-run attack.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom