If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, the instant it leaves my hand it is in uniform motion.

The next instant it starts deviating from it's course as gravity starts accelerating the ball towards the centre of the Earth at 9.8 M/S ^2.

Gravity is an outside force. It affects Newtons 1st law.

I am not even amazed anymore that he does not understand this tbh.
 
What? That statement is absolutely not correct.



Again, what? Yes, gravity is a force, but how does this make Newton's first law no longer apply? This is an incredible misunderstanding of Newton's first law of motion. How do you expect me to take you seriously when you can't, or refuse to understand the first basic law of motion?

You do NOT get to make up the laws of physics to serve your needs.

How about this? Show me anywhere, anywhere in an even remotely respectable publication or video, where your gross misunderstandings of Newton's first law of motion are supported. I am only talking about Newton's first law. Do you understand that? I am only talking about one law, nothing more, and nothing less. The second you talk about any other law, concept, or anything, you are done. Using Newton's first law ONLY, prove your misconceptions are correct.

I absolutely can not believe the level of misunderstanding that exists. Is it even possible for you to answer this? We are talking only about Newton's first law of motion. Can you try to understand this?

This is amazing.

Read the first Law again. Every object in a state of uniform motion tends to remain in that state of motion unless an external force is applied to it. It is talking about the motion of an object that has no external forces being applied to it. Objects that have gravity acting on them have an external force being applied to them, thus they are not in a state of uniform motion, and so so the 1st Law does not apply to them. Any object that is under acceleration is not covered by the 1st Law, their motion is covered by the 2nd Law, they will act under F=ma.

If you are going to jump up and down, at least understand how the laws are applied. This is your problem all around, you believe you know when and where they should be applied, and you keep getting it wrong, yet when told this, you refuse to learn but jump on the, "I'm right, you're wrong, I'm not listening" wagon.

The fact is that the 1st Law is a idealized Law for objects that don't exist in the real world. It's impossible to have an object that remains in a uniform state with no external forces acting on it, even if you were to place it in deep space, it'd still have gravity acting on it. We can approximate objects that obey the the 1st law, but we can never have an object that actually is covered by it perfectly, so instead we understand that this is how our ideal objects should act, and we rely on the second law to tell us how they actually do act.

If you can't understand this much, then this conversation is going to be heading nowhere fast.
 
Read the first Law again. Every object in a state of uniform motion tends to remain in that state of motion unless an external force is applied to it. It is talking about the motion of an object that has no external forces being applied to it. Objects that have gravity acting on them have an external force being applied to them, thus they are not in a state of uniform motion, and so so the 1st Law does not apply to them. Any object that is under acceleration is not covered by the 1st Law, their motion is covered by the 2nd Law, they will act under F=ma.

If you are going to jump up and down, at least understand how the laws are applied. This is your problem all around, you believe you know when and where they should be applied, and you keep getting it wrong, yet when told this, you refuse to learn but jump on the, "I'm right, you're wrong, I'm not listening" wagon.

The fact is that the 1st Law is a idealized Law for objects that don't exist in the real world. It's impossible to have an object that remains in a uniform state with no external forces acting on it, even if you were to place it in deep space, it'd still have gravity acting on it. We can approximate objects that obey the the 1st law, but we can never have an object that actually is covered by it perfectly, so instead we understand that this is how our ideal objects should act, and we rely on the second law to tell us how they actually do act.

If you can't understand this much, then this conversation is going to be heading nowhere fast.

No, he knows when he wants the laws to apply and when he does not want the laws to apply,
He is being deliberately deceitfully dishonest.
You cannot turn on and off the laws of physics at will they are constant.
Force or no force apply or does not apply no in between!
 
If there is a force acting on it then Newton's first Law doesn't apply.

What? That statement is absolutely not correct.

Again, what? Yes, gravity is a force, but how does this make Newton's first law no longer apply?

At any time in your example is the ball at rest or in uniform motion? No, it's not. If the object is not at rest or in uniform motion, Newton's first law of motion does not apply.

:rolleyes:

[Newton's first law of motion does apply to the real world. It applies to real-world objects at rest, and real-world objects in uniform motion.

There is no such thing.
 
Yes, the instant it leaves my hand it is in uniform motion.

Not even then because gravity is acting on it before it leaves your hand so even the instant after it does, gravity is acting on it so it follows F=ma rather then the 1st law.
 
I really can't be arsed to follow the next half dozen pages to see whether anyone else has pointed this out; but, FalseFlag, you've answered your own question here, you just can't see it.

Second, you are correct that there had to be some constant upwards force acting on the upper floors of the north tower in order to prevent it from accelerating at 9.8m/s/s, since it was only constantly accelerating downwards at 6.31m/s/s. The problem is that the lower floors would NOT provide constant resistance to the falling upper floors. They would provide impulse resistance (a temporary force in the opposite direction) during each impact. This impulse resistance would be in the opposite direction of the fall, and it would prohibit constant acceleration downwards.

The bit after the last comma is simply wrong, but the rest is in principle OK; every time part of the top section hits part of the bottom section, there is an impulse.

Now, try to imagine a situation where, instead of a flat object falling on a flat object in one single collision, you have two complex shapes with bits sticking out all over, one falling on to the other. Each time a bit sticking out from one shape hits a bit of the other, there's an impulse, but only a relatively small one. A moment later another bit hits, and there's another small impulse, then another, then another. If the shapes are complex enoug and there are enough small impulses, they all smear out together into what looks like a constant force, but with little jolts when a few happen together or there's one bigger impulse. That's what we would expect to see if there are no explosives and no magical disappearance of multiple storeys of steel, but instead there's a complicated series of failures of the structure that leads to a highly chaotic collapse. And that's exactly what we saw in all the WTC collapses, and it's also exactly what the best measurements of all the collapses show; lots of micro-jolts from small impulses when part of the structure collides with another part of the structure.

If you understand acceleration as well as you think you do, you should be able to figure out how that works. If you want to, that is.

Dave
 
No, he knows when he wants the laws to apply and when he does not want the laws to apply,
He is being deliberately deceitfully dishonest.
You cannot turn on and off the laws of physics at will they are constant.
Force or no force apply or does not apply no in between!

I don't think he's being deliberately dishonest, I think he honestly doesn't realize that no object is ever at in a state of uniform motion, even if it's sitting on a table and at rest relative to the centre of the planet.

I don't think he fully grasps the idea that an object that is "stationary" when he looks at it is actually traveling at considerable speed and obeying Newton's 2nd Law with the force of Gravity keeping it in place instead of it following a straight line and flying off into space as there 1st law would demand if there was no force acting on it.

While going on about Newton and Newton's first law, what he's really describing is an approximation of the 1st law using relative uniform motion inside an observational frame found in special relativity.
 
Gravity is not a force,Physics: Laws of Motion - Newton and beyond: http://youtu.be/Ixf9ZyZaE9Q

That's why it has special properties no other force can have.

He's having trouble with Newton, you really think he's ready for the idea that Gravity is actually the result of objects trying to lower their energy states by falling down into a four-dimensional curvature in the space/time continuum?
 
He's having trouble with Newton, you really think he's ready for the idea that Gravity is actually the result of objects trying to lower their energy states by falling down into a four-dimensional curvature in the space/time continuum?

It is part of the key reason he is wrong, gravity is able to overcome electromagnetism, because it isn't a force. There fore it can never truly be at balance, that's why you jump and fall back to earth instead of flying off the planet.
 
This is a gross misunderstanding of Newton's third law. Equal and opposite forces are experienced by any two objects that collide.

You completely missed Myriad's point, which is that there are two different equal-and-opposite force pairs involved and you are mistakenly equating them to each other. When the Earth pulls down on a building, the equal and opposite force is the building pulling up on the Earth, not the Earth pushing up on the building. Where they meet at the foundation, there is a contact force pushing down on the Earth and an equal and opposite reaction force pushing up on the building. IF the building's foundation can support that contact force, then the building is static: the contact force pair is equal to the gravity force pair. What you're missing is that there is a maximum contact force that the foundation can withstand, and the contact reaction force cannot be greater than that force, even if the gravity force is much larger.

If the top of the building is falling and hitting the lower part of the building, then yes, the forces in the collision are equal and opposite, but your mistake is thinking that they are equal to the force of gravity pulling down on the top. No, if the structure yields, the contact force and its reaction are equal to the maximum force that the structure can withstand before yielding. In that case, the downward force of gravity plus the momentum gained in falling are not balanced by the contact reaction force so the top continues moving, and it might decelerate or it might just see reduced acceleration, depending on the condition that Myriad mentioned, which also went right over your head.

QED, as you and Cole demonstrate, knowing Newton's laws and applying them correctly in a given situation are two completely different things.
 
Last edited:
It is part of the key reason he is wrong, gravity is able to overcome electromagnetism, because it isn't a force. There fore it can never truly be at balance, that's why you jump and fall back to earth instead of flying off the planet.

True, but when someone is having trouble grasping the concept of atomic particles, you don't jump right in with Electrons being a negatively charged wave form with mass called a lepton, orbiting the nuclei of the atom within a 3D probability shell rather than it being a particle which orbits in a defined singular orbit like a planet, do you?
 
You completely missed Myriad's point, which is that there are two different equal-and-opposite force pairs involved and you are mistakenly equating them to each other. When the Earth pulls down on a building, the equal and opposite force is the building pulling up on the Earth, not the Earth pushing up on the building. Where they meet at the foundation, there is a contact force pushing down on the Earth and an equal and opposite reaction force pushing up on the building. IF the building's foundation can support that contact force, then the building is static: the contact force pair is equal to the gravity force pair. What you're missing is that there is a maximum contact force that the foundation can withstand, and the contact reaction force cannot be greater than that force, even if the gravity force is much larger.

If the top of the building is falling and hitting the lower part of the building, then yes, the forces in the collision are equal and opposite, but your mistake is thinking that they are equal to the force of gravity pulling down on the top. No, if the structure yields, the contact force and its reaction are equal to the maximum force that the structure can withstand before yielding. In that case, the gravity force and the contact reaction force are unbalanced so the top continues moving, and it might decelerate or it might just see reduced acceleration, depending on the condition that Myriad mentioned, which also went right over your head.

QED, as you and Cole demonstrate, knowing Newton's laws and applying them correctly in a given situation are two completely different things.

Not correct Gravity is pulling all the building down at the same time, the only opisite force is provided by electromagnetism.

So there will be no equal and opisite reaction to a force that does not exist.

Gravity does not obey the laws of Newtonian forces because Gravity is not a force.
 
True, but when someone is having trouble grasping the concept of atomic particles, you don't jump right in with Electrons being a negatively charged wave form with mass called a lepton, orbiting the nuclei of the atom within a 3D probability shell rather than it being a particle which orbits in a defined singular orbit like a planet, do you?

Gravity not being a force does not obey the equal and oppisite reaction law of newton.
that is why Newtonian physics can not predict the change in Mercury's orbit.

Only forces obey Newton's laws.
 
The most breathtaking part of this performance is that his original CD claim was based on an erroneous ~10 seconds collapse time and ~G acceleration. When he finally accepted a ~15 seconds collapse time and more like a ~6.5 m/s/s average acceleration this was still evidence for CD. The only thing that would turn him against CD would be collapse arrest, afaics.
 
Gravity not being a force does not obey the equal and oppisite reaction law of newton.
that is why Newtonian physics can not predict the change in Mercury's orbit.

Only forces obey Newton's laws.

For our purposes here it can be considered a force, I would have thought.
 
The most breathtaking part of this performance is that his original CD claim was based on an erroneous ~10 seconds collapse time and ~G acceleration. When he finally accepted a ~15 seconds collapse time and more like a ~6.5 m/s/s average acceleration this was still evidence for CD. The only thing that would turn him against CD would be collapse arrest, afaics.

His problem is he is viewing the entire universe though Newtonian physics, and Newtonian physics is wrong about Gravity being a force, gravity is the effect of mass distorting space time.
If False Flag is right Einstein is wrong, and black holes can not capture light, and you can theoretically jump off the earth by overcoming gravity which you do with every step.

Forces are not constant once balance is reached they are momentary, and opposing.
 
For our purposes here it can be considered a force, I would have thought.

That is exactly the fallacy that FF is presenting, that's even Chandler's and Tony S's problem,
Applying Newton where Newton can not apply, and Einstein takes over.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom