If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
How was I "schooled"? Back up your statement with examples instead of posting a meaningless hit-and-run attack.

I edited my post as you were posting. Myriad explained it, you acknowledged reading it.
 
In the starting situation it was at rest, yes. As per your post.
It just wouldn't stay at rest because of scale.

No, if an object is at rest it will stay at rest unless an (unbalanced) external force acts upon it. If an object is at rest, by the very definition of "rest", the forces are balanced and equal zero.

Maybe the moon and earth could never touch each other and remain at rest. That discussion or concept has absolutely nothing to do with Newton's first law of motion. Period.

Each time you bring up this ridiculous example you demonstrate an extreme misunderstanding of one of the easiest concepts in physics to understand. Each time you refuse to accept my explanation as to why you are not correct, you demonstrate an unwillingness to learn anything that does not conform to your preconceived notions.
 
No, if an object is at rest it will stay at rest unless an (unbalanced) external force acts upon it. If an object is at rest, by the very definition of "rest", the forces are balanced and equal zero.

Maybe the moon and earth could never touch each other and remain at rest. That discussion or concept has absolutely nothing to do with Newton's first law of motion. Period.

Each time you bring up this ridiculous example you demonstrate an extreme misunderstanding of one of the easiest concepts in physics to understand. Each time you refuse to accept my explanation as to why you are not correct, you demonstrate an unwillingness to learn anything that does not conform to your preconceived notions.
If you know that. Than why did you give the example in which you said they would stay at rest?
Don't look at the singlest detail, while ignoring all the rest of the real world. Not if you want to describe the actions of something that really happened.
 
If you know that. Than why did you give the example in which you said they would stay at rest?
Don't look at the singlest detail, while ignoring all the rest of the real world. Not if you want to describe the actions of something that really happened.

Are you kidding me? I was accepting a hypothetical possibility in order to prove a point. If you, for even one second, think that I am the one who brought up the absurd moon/earth analogy you are beyond help. Don't blame me for the earth/moon nonsense. I only conceded a hypothetical scenario to prove a point.
 
Again, back up your statement with proof. Point to the posts you are referring to.

OK -


This is false.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.
<snipped for brevity>

I appreciate your response. Perhaps you might want to save this response for level 1, challenge 3 of my game.

You're welcome.
 
Here is the definition of scale, according to the Cambridge dictionary:
the ​relationship of the ​size of a ​map, ​drawing, or ​model of something to the ​size of the ​actual thing.
Source: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/scale

Some of you keep using the earth and moon as examples of scale. What you are really trying to say is that the size of the object affects Newton's first law of motion. You are wrong. Neither scale nor size affects Newton's first law of motion.
 
........I absolutely can not believe the level of misunderstanding that exists........

The irony of a statement like this coming from a person who thinks that each floor of a multi-storey building structurally supports all the floors above it is just hilarious. Frankly, from that point on it wasn't worth anyone's while dealing with you. That's the "give up and go home" moment of this thread, and you glibly breeze along as if nothing had happened, still expecting people to take you seriously. That's before we even start on the scaling up of models, silly claims about heated steel only being weak in one direction, and fraudulent claims about "freefall" rates of building collapse. Count yourself lucky that you've anyone left to talk to in here, but don't for a minute kid yourself that anyone takes your guff seriously.
 
Last edited:
"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

This is a gross misunderstanding of Newton's third law. Equal and opposite forces are experienced by any two objects that collide.

The following is from: http://www.physicsclassroom.com/class/newtlaws/Lesson-4/Newton-s-Third-Law

Definition of Newton's third law: For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.

Example: While driving down the road, a firefly strikes the windshield of a bus and makes a quite obvious mess in front of the face of the driver. This is a clear case of Newton's third law of motion. The firefly hit the bus and the bus hits the firefly. Which of the two forces is greater: the force on the firefly or the force on the bus?

Trick Question! Each force is the same size. For every action, there is an equal ... (equal!). The fact that the firefly splatters only means that with its smaller mass, it is less able to withstand the larger acceleration resulting from the interaction. Besides, fireflies have guts and bug guts have a tendency to be splatterable. Windshields don't have guts. There you have it.
 
Last edited:
Did anyone bother to read any one of the three credible statements of Newton's first law of motion? It is becoming apparent no one did.

I this universe we have a thing called Gravity. You like Newton, maybe you should read Newton's law of universal gravitation, which states that: any two bodies in the universe attract each other with a force that is directly proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them.

This is why when you throw a ball it does it does not follow a strait line and keep a constant speed as Newtons 1st law says it should. Gravity is an outside force.

If you read the part of Newton's law of universal gravitation that states:


"a force that is directly proportional to the product of their masses"



This is Newton telling you that scale matters.
 
The irony of a statement like this coming from a person who thinks that each floor of a multi-storey building structurally supports all the floors above it is just hilarious. Frankly, from that point on it wasn't worth anyone's while dealing with you. That's the "give up and go home" moment of this thread, and you glibly breeze along as if nothing had happened, still expecting people to take you seriously. That's before we even start on the scaling up of models, silly claims about heated steel only being weak in one direction, and fraudulent claims about "freefall" rates of building collapse. Count yourself lucky that you've anyone left to talk to in here, but don't for a minute kid yourself that anyone takes your guff seriously.

If I can stop posting, so can you. If you don't want to post, then don't.
 
Count yourself lucky that you've anyone left to talk to in here

Is that why you come here, so that you can talk to people? If you want to talk to people, aren't there other forums in which you could do this? No, I'm not saying you can't post in here, but please understand the difference between wanting to talk to someone and posting a cogent argument.

I completely understand the desire to want to talk to people, but that is not why I'm here.
 
What does this have to do with Newton's first law of motion? Nothing.


Well silly. We are trying to get you to understand how Newtons first law applies to the real world, A WORLD WITH GRAVITY.

Lets move on from an object at rest to an object in motion.

If you throw a ball, why doesn't follow a strait line like Newtons first law says it should ?

You should know this. It's a simple one word answer. Starts with a G.
 
Well silly. We are trying to get you to understand how Newtons first law applies to the real world, A WORLD WITH GRAVITY.

Lets move on from an object at rest to an object in motion.

If you throw a ball, why doesn't follow a strait line like Newtons first law says it should ?

You should know this. It's a simple one word answer. Starts with a G.

At any time in your example is the ball at rest or in uniform motion? No, it's not. If the object is not at rest or in uniform motion, Newton's first law of motion does not apply.

Newton's first law of motion does apply to the real world. It applies to real-world objects at rest, and real-world objects in uniform motion.
 
At any time in your example is the ball at rest or in uniform motion?


Yes, the instant it leaves my hand it is in uniform motion.

The next instant it starts deviating from it's course as gravity starts accelerating the ball towards the centre of the Earth at 9.8 M/S ^2.

Gravity is an outside force. It affects Newtons 1st law.
 
Last edited:
If the object is not at rest or in uniform motion, Newton's first law of motion does not apply.

So is there a third state that Newton neglected to mention.

Not at rest, not in motion, but in a state of _____ ?

What do you call it? What are the laws of motion that apply to it ?
 
What does this have to do with Newton's first law of motion? Nothing.

If you could connect Newton's first law of motion with your theories on WTC collapses then perhaps we can get back on topic?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom