If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
In regards to Newton's first law of motion, does it talk about the forces exerted before the object came to rest? Nope. It says that an object at rest will stay at rest. Your argument is invalid. The two objects can crush each other as much as you want. Once they come to rest, regardless of size, they will stay at rest.

Is this really the best you can do?

Oh, and let me bring up this post, number 937. Who said, and I quote exactly, "Newton's First Law of Motion is not 'wrong,'" and "An object that is not subject to any unbalanced forces will not experience acceleration. If it is not moving, it will not begin moving; if it is moving, its motion will not change," and " Newton's First Law of Motion applies at any scale, nor has anyone here said it does not?" That last part is my favorite. Who said all that? Hmm. Who?

An object at rest in space will stay at rest without resistance, but an object on a structure that is damaged to the point that the gravitational PE can not be balanced will be pulled downward by the force of gravity.
It will accelerate overcoming the resistance of the structure below!
 
You have claimed the acceleration was constant, yet you have not provided data sufficient to justify that claim.
Yes, I have. I have posted it numerous times. Go find it on your own, it's there, over and over and over, right here in this thread.

Thank you for correcting me in regards to the term "velocity" vs. "acceleration". You are exactly correct, and that is the word I should have typed. I was thinking it; I have no idea why my fingers typed something else.

I agree that a camera from 2001 would record interlaced frames. I still don't think it would matter. If I'm wrong, submit proof. I would like to see it.
 
In regards to Newton's first law of motion, does it talk about the forces exerted before the object came to rest? Nope. It says that an object at rest will stay at rest. Your argument is invalid. The two objects can crush each other as much as you want. Once they come to rest, regardless of size, they will stay at rest.

Is this really the best you can do?

Oh, and let me bring up this post, number 937. Who said, and I quote exactly, "Newton's First Law of Motion is not 'wrong,'" and "An object that is not subject to any unbalanced forces will not experience acceleration. If it is not moving, it will not begin moving; if it is moving, its motion will not change," and " Newton's First Law of Motion applies at any scale, nor has anyone here said it does not?" That last part is my favorite. Who said all that? Hmm. Who?

Read again.

If you were able to magically bring the Earth and the Moon into contact, at rest, and then release them, they would be subject to...unbalanced forces; that is, the attractions of the centers of the masses to each other would be greater than the modulus of cohesion of the nearly spheroidal masses. The masses would move toward each other under the influence of those unbalanced forces (remember Newton's First Law of Motion) until the forces were balanced again (after all the crushing and collapsing and melting and flowing and combining and all).

At that point the two masses would be at rest with respect to each other. Did you really think you could balance the Moon on Denali, and have it just sit there?

ETA: some brandy and I are taking this URI to bed. I'll check in and resume correcting your egregious errors in the morning.
 
Last edited:
Where did I ever say gravity was a one time force? Are you talking about my large truck / toy truck example? Where did I say that example was a comparison to the WTC collapses?

Here's a small part of the skeptics' problems. They think everything has to do with 9/11. It doesn't. If they would take the time to learn physics outside of 9/11, they might actually understand it. Then, once they understood real physics, they might apply that knowledge and understand and finally see what happened.

Standard truther trick. Ignore all posts exposing their failing arguments then fein indignation when pointed out and dismissing them entirely.

Seen it before. Very transparent.

Nice try FF. You leave little to the imagination.
 
Yes, I have. I have posted it numerous times. Go find it on your own, it's there, over and over and over, right here in this thread.

Thank you for correcting me in regards to the term "velocity" vs. "acceleration". You are exactly correct, and that is the word I should have typed. I was thinking it; I have no idea why my fingers typed something else.

I agree that a camera from 2001 would record interlaced frames. I still don't think it would matter. If I'm wrong, submit proof. I would like to see it.
Why can't you post the constant acceleration data? Is it lost? Another lie?


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJNzaMRsN00 The idiotic comments keep coming for the idiots who can't do physics and believe Cole's BS.
collapse because of a weakened structure, not the entire building collapsed into its own footprint.
Do you agree with the 911 truth failed followers, and use the silly claim, "its own footprint".

So, we have 911 truth followers Playing games by spreading lies.
 
Last edited:
Wrong. No impact is required.

Do you think a sphere of rock over 2,000 miles in diameter can support its own weight in earth's gravitational field?

Even if the point of contact between the two were spread out over 1000 square kilometers (that is, someone prepares a nice smooth "socket" for the moon on the earth's surface, the size of Indiana), the rock at the contact area (in both bodies) will still be under pressure on the order of 50 billion PSI. What happens to rock under that kind of pressure?

Are your arguments related to Newton's first law? No, they aren't. If the object never comes to rest, or is never in constant motion, Newton's first law won't apply.

Here's an example for you regarding scale. Imagine you have a neutrino and you accelerate it towards the surface of the earth. Neutrinos are so small they can pass through the entire earth without being affected. Does this violate Newton's first law? Nope. If a neutrino stays in motion without an external force acting on it then it will stay in motion forever. If a neutrino actually came to rest somewhere, it would stay at rest until another (unbalanced) force acted on it. In this example you have the earth, and a particle so small it can pass through the earth. Does scale matter? No. Not when it comes to Newton's first law of motion.

Why can't we get past this? Why are you giving absurd examples to try to disprove something that has never been disproved in human history? Don't you think this says something about your arguments regarding what happened on 9/11? If you continue to argue against such widely accepted laws of physics, and come up with absurd examples that clearly show you lack even a basic understanding of them, how can you reasonably expect anyone to take you seriously when you argue in favor of the official 9/11 story?
 
Yes, I have. I have posted it numerous times. Go find it on your own, it's there, over and over and over, right here in this thread.

No, you have not. You provided a graphic of a plot, but not the raw data. Thirty data points for each second, please. It will also be important to note if the reference points being tracked appear in more than one scan line.
 
At that point the two masses would be at rest with respect to each other. Did you really think you could balance the Moon on Denali, and have it just sit there?

Does it matter in regards to Newton's first law of motion? No, it doesn't, so why are you bringing it up? Newton's first law of motion only applies to objects already at rest, or already in constant motion. You know this, so why are you bringing up this garbage? Do you honestly think I'm not going to call you out on this?
 
Last edited:
Are your arguments related to Newton's first law? No, they aren't. If the object never comes to rest, or is never in constant motion, Newton's first law won't apply.

Here's an example for you regarding scale. Imagine you have a neutrino and you accelerate it towards the surface of the earth. Neutrinos are so small they can pass through the entire earth without being affected. Does this violate Newton's first law? Nope. If a neutrino stays in motion without an external force acting on it then it will stay in motion forever. If a neutrino actually came to rest somewhere, it would stay at rest until another (unbalanced) force acted on it. In this example you have the earth, and a particle so small it can pass through the earth. Does scale matter? No. Not when it comes to Newton's first law of motion.

Why can't we get past this? Why are you giving absurd examples to try to disprove something that has never been disproved in human history? Don't you think this says something about your arguments regarding what happened on 9/11? If you continue to argue against such widely accepted laws of physics, and come up with absurd examples that clearly show you lack even a basic understanding of them, how can you reasonably expect anyone to take you seriously when you argue in favor of the official 9/11 story?
Fallacy detected, it is not the size of neutrinos that allows them to go though almost all matter, it is that they have a neutral charge, photons are smaller than neutrinos but they carry charge.
 
FF's post remind me very much of Heiwa who stated that, IIRC, the upper mass of WTC 1 could be dropped from 2 miles up and it wouldn't collapse the lower mass.

Again, amazing stuff.
 
Does it matter in regards to Newton's first law of motion? No, it doesn't, so why are you bringing it up? Newton's first law of motion only applies to objects already at rest, or already in constant motion. You know this, so why are you bringing up this garbage? Do you honestly think I'm not going to call you out on this?

Do you honestly think newtons laws don't apply to everything?

The moon and earth are in constant motion all the time.
 
Fallacy detected, it is not the size of neutrinos that allows them to go though almost all matter, it is that they have a neutral charge, photons are smaller than neutrinos but they carry charge.
Seriously? Where did I mention a photon?

Is a neutrino vastly smaller than the earth? Yes. There is no problem with my example.
 
Last edited:
Does it matter in regards to Newton's first law of motion? No, it doesn't, so why are you bringing it up? Newton's first law of motion only applies to objects already at rest, or already in constant motion. You know this, so why are you bringing up this garbage? Do you honestly think I'm not going to call you out on this?

Oh, my.

I am, in fact, glad I decided to give this a quick read after walking the dogs.

Tyr this: Fill two large water balloons. Hold them, one above the other, and bring them into close contact, stationary with respect to one another. Now let go of the top one...

Newton's First Law in action.

Good night.
 
Are your arguments related to Newton's first law? No, they aren't. If the object never comes to rest, or is never in constant motion, Newton's first law won't apply.

Here's an example for you regarding scale. Imagine you have a neutrino and you accelerate it towards the surface of the earth. Neutrinos are so small they can pass through the entire earth without being affected. Does this violate Newton's first law? Nope. If a neutrino stays in motion without an external force acting on it then it will stay in motion forever. If a neutrino actually came to rest somewhere, it would stay at rest until another (unbalanced) force acted on it. In this example you have the earth, and a particle so small it can pass through the earth. Does scale matter? No. Not when it comes to Newton's first law of motion.

Why can't we get past this? Why are you giving absurd examples to try to disprove something that has never been disproved in human history? Don't you think this says something about your arguments regarding what happened on 9/11? If you continue to argue against such widely accepted laws of physics, and come up with absurd examples that clearly show you lack even a basic understanding of them, how can you reasonably expect anyone to take you seriously when you argue in favor of the official 9/11 story?
The official story you can't debunk? What is your official story? You can't say for what reason?

No one believes the CD claim, you can't explain how it worked.

More proof, 911 truth followers don't have a clue what physics is, or why they failed.

The WTC towers collapsed, and physics prove it was possible as seen. You are the one with delusional examples, starting with Cole, then the moon,...
 
You either don't understand what a straw man argument is, or you haven't read all of the posts in this thread. Just remember, when my argument is complete, I'm going to point out each and every time you are wrong.

Be careful when you accuse me of committing a logical fallacy.

Get over yourself and stop projecting.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom