If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ok I'm out. If FF won't even acknowledge that gravity is more than a "one time force", in relation to the collapse of the Towers it's obvious he/she is not here for honest discussion.
 
You have, at this point, only two honest options open to you.

1. Demonstrate the post on this thread where anyone actually claimed that Maxwell was Newton (do you believe in "reincarnation", along with all your other misconceptions?).

2. Admit that no one has done so, and that you were indulging in rhetorical hyperbole; correct your error, and move on.

Anything else will simply reinforce your apparent dishonesty.

Wow. Is this post to make me do "busy work"? Read the last two pages again. You will know who brought up Maxwell. It wasn't me, and there was absolutely no reason to bring him up. Maxwell has nothing to do with Newton.
 
You either don't understand what a straw man argument is, or you haven't read all of the posts in this thread. Just remember, when my argument is complete, I'm going to point out each and every time you are wrong.

Be careful when you accuse me of committing a logical fallacy.

Oh, sweetie, what do you, personally, think a "straw person" argument is?

What are you doing when you accuse people of claiming that Maxwell was, in fact, Newton, other than raising up a person of straw, to more easily defeat it rather than face the actual issue, which is your complete failure to understand why Cole's "demonstration" is deficient (hint: it rhymes with "ailing", and starts with an :"s")?

BTW, feel free to point out the specific post where you believe the claim was made...
 
Ok I'm out. If FF won't even acknowledge that gravity is more than a "one time force", in relation to the collapse of the Towers it's obvious he/she is not here for honest discussion.

Where did I ever say gravity was a one time force? Are you talking about my large truck / toy truck example? Where did I say that example was a comparison to the WTC collapses?

Here's a small part of the skeptics' problems. They think everything has to do with 9/11. It doesn't. If they would take the time to learn physics outside of 9/11, they might actually understand it. Then, once they understood real physics, they might apply that knowledge and understand and finally see what happened.
 
Ok I'm out. If FF won't even acknowledge that gravity is more than a "one time force", in relation to the collapse of the Towers it's obvious he/she is not here for honest discussion.

Stop think about this past a grade school understanding. Remember the target audience. ;)
 
Oh, sweetie, what do you, personally, think a "straw person" argument is?

What are you doing when you accuse people of claiming that Maxwell was, in fact, Newton, other than raising up a person of straw, to more easily defeat it rather than face the actual issue, which is your complete failure to understand why Cole's "demonstration" is deficient (hint: it rhymes with "ailing", and starts with an :"s")?

BTW, feel free to point out the specific post where you believe the claim was made...

Seriously, give me a break. If you want to continue any further discussion, then take some effort to understand how Maxwell became a part of this argument. He should never should have been a part of this thread.
 
You either don't understand what a straw man argument is, or you haven't read all of the posts in this thread. Just remember, when my argument is complete, I'm going to point out each and every time you are wrong.

Be careful when you accuse me of committing a logical fallacy.

You have committed a logical fallacy, you neglected that to resist gravity an object has to exert a force against gravity, like a plane or a rocket, or it has to be resting on a structure or material capable of providing equal or greater resistance to gravity.

Why are volcano's larger on mars a smaller planet?
 
Last edited:
...How would anyone on the planet know what the collapse of a steel-framed high rise is supposed to look like? ...
The person who designed the structure. 911 truth has no clue, and zero capability to do physics, engineering, and more.

You keep making up BS, mocking the murder of thousands by spreading lies for Cole.

ROBERTSON: But the collapse mechanism of the Trade Center is as we had anticipated it would be when we first designed it. It was not – please don't misunderstand me – it was not designed to collapse. But any prudent engineer looking at the future has to think about, what are the mechanisms that cause collapse, and how to go about strengthening the building so as to minimize that circumstance. So sure, we spent time looking at that kind of event, and that which was observable from the photographs and so forth is reasonably consistent with that which we thought would be the case.
HOST: Why did it fall so straight down?
ROBERTSON: Well, that's kind of the nature of that kind of failure.
Robertson would agree, Cole's experiments are BS.
How many engineers agree with you, as a percentage of all engineers?

You ask questions, and fail to learn; is this common with you? Why do you have zero useful knowledge of physics?
 
I appreciate your response, but this is not correct.

If the moon smashed into the earth then you might be right, but if the moon was placed on the earth's surface, and the moon was at rest, it would stay at rest unless another force acted on it. It does not matter how big the object is. If the object is at rest, it will stay at rest unless an (unbalanced) external force acts upon it.

Ummm...no. (But not for the reaon you seem to be saying.

The masses of the Moon and the earth would come to rest at the point at which the forces acting upon them were balanced. That point would not be the point where the two near-spheroids came in contact at only one point. Once the crushing and collapsing and rupturing were done 9and the metaphorical smoke cleared, do to speak), then the two masses would be at rest, at least with respect to one another.

Or do you actually think that the Earth and the Moon would stay whole, like two bowling balls? You truly ought to work to understand scaling problems.
 
I just want to know your definition of local density. I'm not trying to advance a point, I just want to know why you used that term.

Since you do not understand a basic concept, I wil lbe glad to teach it to you.

So: of what do you think "quicksand" is composed? Put another way, what is it that makes sand, "quicksand"?
 
Post 922 is where Maxwell was first mentioned. It wasn't by me, and Maxwell is completely irrelevant to the discussion.

Post 923 is where quicksand was mentioned. It wasn't by me, and it's completely irrelevant to the challenge and the example I gave.

Enough of this nonsense. I get it, you're playing a game. How about playing the game in my post, instead? That would further a logical discussion, but you don't seem to want that to happen.
 
Wow. Is this post to make me do "busy work"? Read the last two pages again. You will know who brought up Maxwell. It wasn't me, and there was absolutely no reason to bring him up. Maxwell has nothing to do with Newton.

In other words, it was you, and only you, that claimed that someone else said that Maxwell was Newton.

You misstated a position, in order to be able to dismiss it more easily.

You may not be aware, but that is the textbook construction of a "straw person" argument.

You have yet to take one of the only two honest courses open to yoou.
 
Seriously, give me a break. If you want to continue any further discussion, then take some effort to understand how Maxwell became a part of this argument. He should never should have been a part of this thread.

If you don't think Maxwell shouldn't be part of this argument then you don't understand Newton since Maxwell is a refinement of Newtonian physics.
Are you thus willing too admit you don't understand Newton by admitting you can't understand the simple refinement of Newtonian physics maxwell makes?
 
Ummm...no. (But not for the reaon you seem to be saying.

The masses of the Moon and the earth would come to rest at the point at which the forces acting upon them were balanced. That point would not be the point where the two near-spheroids came in contact at only one point. Once the crushing and collapsing and rupturing were done 9and the metaphorical smoke cleared, do to speak), then the two masses would be at rest, at least with respect to one another.

Or do you actually think that the Earth and the Moon would stay whole, like two bowling balls? You truly ought to work to understand scaling problems.

In regards to Newton's first law of motion, does it talk about the forces exerted before the object came to rest? Nope. It says that an object at rest will stay at rest. Your argument is invalid. The two objects can crush each other as much as you want. Once they come to rest, regardless of size, they will stay at rest.

Is this really the best you can do?

Oh, and let me bring up this post, number 937. Who said, and I quote exactly, "Newton's First Law of Motion is not 'wrong,'" and "An object that is not subject to any unbalanced forces will not experience acceleration. If it is not moving, it will not begin moving; if it is moving, its motion will not change," and " Newton's First Law of Motion applies at any scale, nor has anyone here said it does not?" That last part is my favorite. Who said all that? Hmm. Who?
 
Post 922 is where Maxwell was first mentioned. It wasn't by me, and Maxwell is completely irrelevant to the discussion.

Post 923 is where quicksand was mentioned. It wasn't by me, and it's completely irrelevant to the challenge and the example I gave.

Enough of this nonsense. I get it, you're playing a game. How about playing the game in my post, instead? That would further a logical discussion, but you don't seem to want that to happen.

You just admitted openly you don't understand Newtonian physics, you admitted it openly in your own words.

Thanks for playing the game you lost!:D

Maxwell denotes how newtons forces act on materials, the forces can not act in isolation they have to act upon something!
 
Seriously, give me a break. If you want to continue any further discussion, then take some effort to understand how Maxwell became a part of this argument. He should never should have been a part of this thread.

I know how Maxwell became a proper part of this explanation.

I also know who was the first, and only, poster to pretend that another poster claimed that Maxwell was "Newton reincarnated"; and who raised up that person of straw.

Maxwell's work is a proper part of this thread. An explanation of the behaviour of "quicksand" according to the concept of viscoelasticity is richer, and more technically accurate, than the simplified explanation I am discussing with you. However, remember the Physicist and the cow barn--in this case the simplification is useful for the point being made.
 
You didn't answer my question.

Interlacing is one method of scanning. Progressive scanning is the other method.

Progressive scanning would be non-interlaced.

Scanning has nothing to do with uncompressed frames.

Seriously? Whether that frame is composed of two interlaced fields or one continuous field has nothing to do with uncompressed frames? Moreover, progress/non-interlaced scans are typically at twice the frame rate of interlaced frames. Nothing to do with uncompressed frames?

When a device records video it can record interlaced uncompressed frames, progressive uncompressed frames, interlaced compressed frames or progressive compressed frames.

Really? Any video recording device can do that? Even one from, say, 2001?

You could get compression artifacts regardless of whether the scanning was interlaced or progressive.

Sure do. Not exactly the same artifacts, though.

To answer your question, the answer is no, it wouldn't matter significantly. When you use software to measure velocity, you set scale using the video you are testing. Interlaced frames are not going noticeably affect your results.

Interesting conclusion you have there. Let's set it aside for a moment since my question was about the raw data. Where's the raw data?

(By the way, I mentioned 30 data points per second because NTSC video would be a reasonable assumption for the time. If it is non-interlaced, great!, because then we'll have 60 per second. I'd be extremely surprised were it non-interlaced.)

If I'm wrong, then prove I'm wrong. You could very easily get a ladder, a ball, and a video camera. Stand on top of the ladder and drop the ball four times. Film the first drop using interlaced uncompressed frames, the second drop using progressive uncompressed frames, the third drop using interlaced compressed frames, and the fourth drop using progressive compressed frames. Since you are going to set the scale on each video, I seriously doubt the measured velocity is going to be different between each video.

Like I said, prove I'm wrong. I'm would like to see the results.

It would be acceleration that we would want to determine, not velocity. And the question would not be whether the methods produced similar overall results, but what were the appropriate error bars on each individual data point.

You have claimed the acceleration was constant, yet you have not provided data sufficient to justify that claim.
 
I appreciate your response, but this is not correct.

If the moon smashed into the earth then you might be right, but if the moon was placed on the earth's surface, and the moon was at rest, it would stay at rest unless another force acted on it. It does not matter how big the object is. If the object is at rest, it will stay at rest unless an (unbalanced) external force acts upon it.


Wrong. No impact is required.

Do you think a sphere of rock over 2,000 miles in diameter can support its own weight in earth's gravitational field?

Even if the point of contact between the two were spread out over 1000 square kilometers (that is, someone prepares a nice smooth "socket" for the moon on the earth's surface, the size of Indiana), the rock at the contact area (in both bodies) will still be under pressure on the order of 50 billion PSI. What happens to rock under that kind of pressure?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom