If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
We will all find out in three or four days, or maybe earlier if someone successfully completes a challenge.

For the LOLZ, then. That is a method for discussing evidence of which I was previously unaware.

Wouldn't it be more interesting to explore, oh, perhaps your repeated claim of constant acceleration? Doesn't your claim stem from someone's measurements taken from a video of the upper tower beginning its descent? The raw data would be interesting, no? At 29.97 fps, there should be about 30 measurements for each second of drop.

Hopefully, the original uncompressed video was used, right? I mean, even just interlacing would wreck enough havoc with the error bars, but compression artifacts would really confuse things. I'm sure that sort of rookie mistake wasn't made.

So, whatcha got?
 
Oh, I almost forgot. By posting a video hosted on YouTube, you forever and for all eternity forfeit any and all rights to criticize anyone else for doing the same.

I don't criticize a video for being on You Tube I critizies only for stupid content or out right fraud.
 
Hopefully, the original uncompressed video was used, right? I mean, even just interlacing would wreck enough havoc with the error bars, but compression artifacts would really confuse things.
How are interlacing and uncompressed video related?
 
Isaac Newton was born in 1642 or 1643 (depending on the source), and he died in 1726 or 1727 (also depending on your source).

James Clerk Maxwell was born on 1831 and he died in 1879.

Are you claiming that Maxwell is Newton reincarnated? If not, then how on earth does Maxwell have anything to do with Newton's first law of motion? We are only talking about Newton's first law of motion and nothing else. Why do you refuse to accept this?

Because for an object to be at rest on earth, it has to rest upon something Newton showed this in his famous canon ball model.

Lay the canon ball on the ground the canon ball rests upon the ground.
Shoot the canon ball it travels in an arch equal to the two forces acting upon it.
With enough force newton theorized the canon ball would orbit the earth.

Maxwell was a physicist that worked out how to measure the strength of materials, how much resistance a material could provide against the pull of gravity.

Quicksand provides less resistance than stone so an object will sink into the quick sand.

If the resistance of the towers lower structure is 36%, that is the rate at which the mass will fall though it, reguardless of the shape and condition of the mass.
 
Last edited:
How are interlacing and uncompressed video related?

Seriously?

Raw video can be either interlaced or non-interlaced. If one were tracking image details as it moved from one scan line to the next, the timing between adjacent scan lines would be rather important, no?
 
Isaac Newton was born in 1642 or 1643 (depending on the source), and he died in 1726 or 1727 (also depending on your source).

James Clerk Maxwell was born on 1831 and he died in 1879.

Are you claiming that Maxwell is Newton reincarnated? If not, then how on earth does Maxwell have anything to do with Newton's first law of motion? We are only talking about Newton's first law of motion and nothing else. Why do you refuse to accept this?

You are truly multiplying your people of straw beyond any reason. Yon windmill is getting crowded.

(No one said Maxwell was Newton, and it is silly of you to pretend so. Stay focused.)

Viscoelasticity is the property that lets one run across some "quicksands" without sinking in; whereas one will sink if one stands still. It is a more complex, and more accurate model of the interaction between an amorphous fluid like quicksand and a solid.

For the purposes of your model, the complexities may be considered to be subsumed in the simple fact that the object will sink in your somehow-magically-protected-from-boiling-dry-in-vacuum "quicksand" to the point that the mass of the displaced "quicksand" is equal to the mass of the object.
 
Seriously?

Raw video can be either interlaced or non-interlaced. If one were tracking image details as it moved from one scan line to the next, the timing between adjacent scan lines would be rather important, no?

You didn't answer my question.

Interlacing is one method of scanning. Progressive scanning is the other method. Scanning has nothing to do with uncompressed frames.

When a device records video it can record interlaced uncompressed frames, progressive uncompressed frames, interlaced compressed frames or progressive compressed frames. You could get compression artifacts regardless of whether the scanning was interlaced or progressive.

To answer your question, the answer is no, it wouldn't matter significantly. When you use software to measure velocity, you set scale using the video you are testing. Interlaced frames are not going noticeably affect your results.

If I'm wrong, then prove I'm wrong. You could very easily get a ladder, a ball, and a video camera. Stand on top of the ladder and drop the ball four times. Film the first drop using interlaced uncompressed frames, the second drop using progressive uncompressed frames, the third drop using interlaced compressed frames, and the fourth drop using progressive compressed frames. Since you are going to set the scale on each video, I seriously doubt the measured velocity is going to be different between each video.

Like I said, prove I'm wrong. I'm would like to see the results.
 
Last edited:
You are truly multiplying your people of straw beyond any reason. Yon windmill is getting crowded.

(No one said Maxwell was Newton, and it is silly of you to pretend so. Stay focused.)

Viscoelasticity is the property that lets one run across some "quicksands" without sinking in; whereas one will sink if one stands still. It is a more complex, and more accurate model of the interaction between an amorphous fluid like quicksand and a solid.

For the purposes of your model, the complexities may be considered to be subsumed in the simple fact that the object will sink in your somehow-magically-protected-from-boiling-dry-in-vacuum "quicksand" to the point that the mass of the displaced "quicksand" is equal to the mass of the object.

Funny thing is Maxwell also applies to steel as it is steels viscoelasticity that makes it a ductible metal.

The more your heat it the more Viscoelasticity it has, the cooler it is the less it will deform under stress.
 
(No one said Maxwell was Newton, and it is silly of you to pretend so. Stay focused.)

Neither have I. Are you able to see all of the posts in this forum? Are you reading them? If you can see them, and you did read them, you would obviously know I was addressing a rather ridiculous post by one of your fellow skeptics.
 
Thanks for that, but I think it might be more appropriate to say that scale in not relevant when discussing Newton's first law.

Do not presume to misquote me. Do not presume to alter my words. Your understanding is superficial; your model is simplistic.

Pedagogically, I will engage you at an appropriate level.

Scale is always relevant when applying Newton's First Law of Motion; therefore:

"Newton's First Law of Motion applies at any scale."

Once again: it is not at the level of the Laws of Motion that you do err, but at their inappropriate application to inapt, inept, and inappositive models. That is where your inability to deal with scaling leads you astray.

How would anyone on the planet know what the collapse of a steel-framed high rise is supposed to look like? In modern history, there have only been three, and for some odd reason, they all happened within a few hundred yards of each other on the same day, and they all had WTC in their names. If it didn't happened before 9/11, and it hasn't happened since, how am I supposed to tell you what the collapse of a steel-framed high rise is supposed to look like?

And yet, you claim that the inchoate mass of debris from either tower did not fall "as it should", or words to that effect. What is it you imagine the fall was to be supposed to have looked like?

BTW: "...for some reason..." is disingenuous to the point of dishonesty. You are aware that an airliner full of jet fuel flew into each of the two main Towers, yes? Or are you a "no-planer", in addition to being innocent of actual physics (especially the problems of scaling models)?
 
If the object at rest in a vacuum upon the earth's surface is a one-pound moon rock, it remains motionless.

If the object at rest in a vacuum upon the earth's surface is the moon, it and the earth it's resting on mutually crush, melt, and coalesce.

Same forces, same force law; different magnitudes, different results. Scale.
 
Last edited:
You are truly multiplying your people of straw beyond any reason.
You either don't understand what a straw man argument is, or you haven't read all of the posts in this thread. Just remember, when my argument is complete, I'm going to point out each and every time you are wrong.

Be careful when you accuse me of committing a logical fallacy.
 
You didn't answer my question.

Interlacing is one method of scanning. Progressive scanning is the other method. Scanning has nothing to do with uncompressed frames.

When a device records video it can record interlaced uncompressed frames, progressive uncompressed frames, interlaced compressed frames or progressive compressed frames. You could get compression artifacts regardless of whether the scanning was interlaced or progressive.

To answer your question, the answer is no, it wouldn't matter significantly. When you use software to measure velocity, you set scale using the video you are testing. Interlaced frames are not going noticeably affect your results.

If I'm wrong, then prove I'm wrong. You could very easily get a ladder, a ball, and a video camera. Stand on top of the ladder and drop the ball four times. Film the first drop using interlaced uncompressed frames, the second drop using progressive uncompressed frames, the third drop using interlaced compressed frames, and the fourth drop using progressive compressed frames. Since you are going to set the scale on each video, I seriously doubt the measured velocity is going to be different between each video.

Like I said, prove I'm wrong. I'm would like to see the results.

It is a timing problem compressed video is faster than reality interlaced has a lot of distortions.
That's why the Paper from Dr. Greening used the seismic data for timing collapse to double check. The video records.
 
If the object at rest in a vacuum upon the earth's surface is a one-pound moon rock, it remains motionless.

If the object at rest in a vacuum upon the earth's surface is the moon, it and the earth it's resting on mutually crush, melt, and coalesce.

Same forces, same force law; different magnitudes, different results. Scale.

I appreciate your response, but this is not correct.

If the moon smashed into the earth then you might be right, but if the moon was placed on the earth's surface, and the moon was at rest, it would stay at rest unless another force acted on it. It does not matter how big the object is. If the object is at rest, it will stay at rest unless an (unbalanced) external force acts upon it.
 
Neither have I. Are you able to see all of the posts in this forum? Are you reading them? If you can see them, and you did read them, you would obviously know I was addressing a rather ridiculous post by one of your fellow skeptics.

You have, at this point, only two honest options open to you.

1. Demonstrate the post on this thread where anyone actually claimed that Maxwell was Newton (do you believe in "reincarnation", along with all your other misconceptions?).

2. Admit that no one has done so, and that you were indulging in rhetorical hyperbole; correct your error, and move on.

Anything else will simply reinforce your apparent dishonesty.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom