If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I give you credit for playing a game, it's just not the one you're commenting on.
Making fun of thousands killed with lies about CD, and BS from Cole. Playing a game, spreading lies.

If 911 truth followers had any useful knowledge of physics, and they don't, they could dismiss Cole as a 911 truth nut spreading lies of CD. Why has 911 truth failed for 14 years, spreading lies and thinking they know physics?

...
Continue discussing your delusions on your own, but you will do so without me.
Lies about 911, and lies about doing so without.
Why can't 911 truth followers figure out physics, and do what they say they will do?
 
I really thought I would get banned, but I'm still alive.

OK, while I'm alive, let's play a game. It's pretty clear from the plethora of skeptics' posts that they love to play games, so let's do it.

Level 1.

Here's the text of Newton's first law of motion:
Source: https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/newton1g.html

Here is another explanation of Newton's first law of motion:
Source: http://www.physicsclassroom.com/class/newtlaws/Lesson-1/Newton-s-First-Law

Here is yet one more explanation of Newton's first law of motion:

Source: http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/newt.html

Challenge 1.
Prove Newton's first law is wrong.

The challenge will be open until someone does it, or 24 hours, whichever happens sooner.


Heat lowers the resistance of steel to gravity, by weakening the bonding of the steel crystals.
Gravity then works as an external force to pull the descending mass downward as it accelerated then according to the graph you posted in the Chandler video. It underwent three acceleration events and three deceleration events, as per Chandler's own Graph.
The Collapses occured as per Newton's laws at 36% resistance to the collapse.
Exactly the energy the structure should have provided according to the laws of Newton's and Maxwell's physics.
Maxwells work was in electrion bonding of materials!
You thus get an F in basic physics you fail.
 
I really thought I would get banned, but I'm still alive.

OK, while I'm alive, let's play a game. It's pretty clear from the plethora of skeptics' posts that they love to play games, so let's do it.

Level 1.

Here's the text of Newton's first law of motion:
Source: https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/newton1g.html

Here is another explanation of Newton's first law of motion:
Source: http://www.physicsclassroom.com/class/newtlaws/Lesson-1/Newton-s-First-Law

Here is yet one more explanation of Newton's first law of motion:

Source: http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/newt.html

Challenge 1.

Prove Newton's first law is wrong.

Challenge 1a.

Prove the following example is wrong.

Example: A object rests on the surface of the earth. The object is in a vacuum. Since the object is at rest, there is no motion. There is a downward force acting on the object, which is exerted by gravity. Since the object is at rest, there is an opposite force acting on the object in the opposite direction. This force is called the normal force. Since the object is in a vacuum, there is no force exerted by air. The only forces acting on the object are the force due to gravity and the normal force. The forces are balanced, so the net force is zero. As long as the net force is zero, the object will stay at rest.

Once again, prove any part of my example is wrong. Simply saying that I'm wrong doesn't count. You must clearly prove I'm wrong, with an example citing your sources and reasoning.

Challenge 1b. Explain how scale could make any difference in regards to Newton's first law.

The challenge will be open until someone does it, or 24 hours, whichever happens sooner.

Quick sand, you set the object on quick sand so it sinks toward the center of the earth.
 
I really thought I would get banned, but I'm still alive.

Why would you think you would be banned? Unlike "truther" forums you can have views outside the mainstream. As long as you stick to the members agreement you can have any view you want. Unlike "truther" forums, free speech is allowed here. ;)
 
I understand all that JSO, but would vibrations in the collapse have worked the columns inducing weaknesses in the column welds as the columns vibrated from the off center impacts?

Dunno... I think the swaying would shear the welds... but that's a guess.
 
Heat lowers the resistance of steel to gravity, by weakening the bonding of the steel crystals.
Gravity then works as an external force to pull the descending mass downward as it accelerated then according to the graph you posted in the Chandler video. It underwent three acceleration events and three deceleration events, as per Chandler's own Graph.
The Collapses occured as per Newton's laws at 36% resistance to the collapse.
Exactly the energy the structure should have provided according to the laws of Newton's and Maxwell's physics.
Maxwells work was in electrion bonding of materials!
You thus get an F in basic physics you fail.
Does any of this apply to my example? No.
 
Quick sand, you set the object on quick sand so it sinks toward the center of the earth.
Does this prove Newton's first law of motion is wrong? No.
Does this prove my example is wrong? No.
Does this have anything to do with scale? No.
Does your post go to extreme lengths to argue against a truther's point, even if it makes you look ridiculous? Yes. Absolutely, yes.
 
Last edited:
Quick sand, you set the object on quick sand so it sinks toward the center of the earth.

OK. Here is a chance to prove that YOU understand the laws of motion. Explain why the object might sink in quicksand. Explain the forces involved. Since the game is only at the first level, you only have to discuss this in terms of Newton's first law.
 
Last edited:
OK. Here is a chance to prove that YOU understand the laws of motion. ....
911 truth followers don't understand anything concepts in physics, and then some act as if they are a teacher; a failed teacher who can't figure out Cole's experiments are delusional.

Belief in 911 truth claims proves 911 truth followers missed their chance to prove they understand physics.
 
Last edited:
I wasn't aware Newton's Laws of Motion were in dispute. The applicability of Cole's models, yes; Netwton, not so much.

That being the case, what is the point of this rhetoric, FalseFlag?
 
OK. Here is a chance to prove that YOU understand the laws of motion. Explain why the object might sink in quicksand. Explain the forces involved. Since the game is only at the first level, you only have to discuss this in terms of Newton's first law.

Gravity and the resistance provided by the electrons creating the viscosity of the quicksand.
Per the Maxwell physics model.
 
I wasn't aware Newton's Laws of Motion were in dispute. The applicability of Cole's models, yes; Netwton, not so much.

That being the case, what is the point of this rhetoric, FalseFlag?

We will all find out in three or four days, or maybe earlier if someone successfully completes a challenge.
 
It why you don't understand resistance.Simple Physical Maxwell Model of Viscoelasticity: http://youtu.be/ZVK1qVkXfC4

Isaac Newton was born in 1642 or 1643 (depending on the source), and he died in 1726 or 1727 (also depending on your source).

James Clerk Maxwell was born on 1831 and he died in 1879.

Are you claiming that Maxwell is Newton reincarnated? If not, then how on earth does Maxwell have anything to do with Newton's first law of motion? We are only talking about Newton's first law of motion and nothing else. Why do you refuse to accept this?
 
I really thought I would get banned, but I'm still alive.

The flounce, she is so hard to stick...that didn't last long.

OK, while I'm alive, let's play a game. It's pretty clear from the plethora of skeptics' posts that they love to play games, so let's do it.

Level 1.

Here's the text of Newton's first law of motion:
Source: https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/newton1g.html

Here is another explanation of Newton's first law of motion:
Source: http://www.physicsclassroom.com/class/newtlaws/Lesson-1/Newton-s-First-Law

Here is yet one more explanation of Newton's first law of motion:

Source: http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/newt.html

Challenge 1.

Prove Newton's first law is wrong.

Newton's First Law of Motion is not "wrong" (nor has anyone here made the claim that the Law is "wrong"...perhaps you ought to send your person of straw to stand over there with the others, under that windmill).

An object that is not subject to any unbalanced forces will not experience acceleration. If it is not moving, it will not begin moving; if it is moving, its motion will not change.

Challenge 1a.

Prove the following example is wrong.

Example: A object rests on the surface of the earth. The object is in a vacuum. Since the object is at rest, there is no motion. There is a downward force acting on the object, which is exerted by gravity. Since the object is at rest, there is an opposite force acting on the object in the opposite direction. This force is called the normal force. Since the object is in a vacuum, there is no force exerted by air. The only forces acting on the object are the force due to gravity and the normal force. The forces are balanced, so the net force is zero. As long as the net force is zero, the object will stay at rest.

Once again, prove any part of my example is wrong. Simply saying that I'm wrong doesn't count. You must clearly prove I'm wrong, with an example citing your sources and reasoning.

Other than a few clumsy constructions ("...an opposite force acting in the opposite direction...", for one; a rather simplistic "definition" of the normal force, for another; and so on), and a failure to explain how the object, at the surface of the earth, is "...in a vacuum...", this example is not wrong. By PARCC rubrics, it would get about a 3 out of 4.

Challenge 1b. Explain how scale could make any difference in regards to Newton's first law.

This is, and has been, one of your pervasive sources of error. Newton's First Law of Motion applies at any scale, nor has anyone here said it does not. (You are welcome to demonstrate where someone has made that specific claim; until you do, this person of straw ought to be sent to go stand with the others...)

It is not at the level of the simplistic operation of Newton's First Law of Motion that Cole's "demonstration" falls afoul of scaling (nor has anyone here identified that as the reason Cole's "demonstration" is such a pervasively transparent failure). I am sorry that you do not understand that.

The challenge will be open until someone does it, or 24 hours, whichever happens sooner.

Feel free to reassure yourself that you are setting up an invincible "gotcha". You simply do not understand the inherent deficiencies in Cole's work; nor have you accounted for the fact that the inchoate mass of debris in the towers demonstrably fell at an acceleration significantly less than g.

There. I have jumped through your hoop.

Suppose, in exchange, you explain what you thnk the collapse of the towers ought to have looked like. I would be...fascinated...to hear it.
 
Last edited:
Why do 911 truth followers think they can teach something they can't do? We are being taught delusional physics by a faith based 911 truth follower. This is incredible, now much ignorance it takes to believe Cole.


its really a shame that NIST received many $$$$ for investigating BUT instead you should had get it cause you took the effort. Great job. btw did you sent this video to NIST???
NIST might die from laughing. Idiots think Cole's video has value.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJNzaMRsN00

Lucky so few are dumb enough to believe Cole... How dumbed down do claims have to be from Cole for 911 truth followers to believe.

Funny how that terrible blacksmith debunking video with the tiny steel rod went viral and was featured on almost every news site online, but this video is ignored.
the clue less 911 truth followers have no clue who dirt dumb the video is. Ignorance of their own ignorance rules their ignorance.
 
Newton's First Law of Motion applies at any scale

Thanks for that, but I think it might be more appropriate to say that scale in not relevant when discussing Newton's first law.

Suppose, in exchange, you explain what you thnk the collapse of the towers ought to have looked like. I would be...fascinated...to hear it.

How would anyone on the planet know what the collapse of a steel-framed high rise is supposed to look like? In modern history, there have only been three, and for some odd reason, they all happened within a few hundred yards of each other on the same day, and they all had WTC in their names. If it didn't happened before 9/11, and it hasn't happened since, how am I supposed to tell you what the collapse of a steel-framed high rise is supposed to look like?
 
Last edited:
OK. Here is a chance to prove that YOU understand the laws of motion. Explain why the object might sink in quicksand. Explain the forces involved. Since the game is only at the first level, you only have to discuss this in terms of Newton's first law.

Ignoring for a moment the fact that "quicksand" is a suspension of sand grains in water; and if the "quicksand" were in the vacuum chamber with the object, the water would quickly boil off, doing two things: 1)reducing the "quicksand" to "sand", and, 2)destroying the vacuum; the object would only sink in the "quicksand" if its density were greater than the local density of the "quicksand". The object would sink into the "quicksand" to the point that the mass of the displaced "quicksand" was equal to the mass of the object.

The forces involved are the effect of gravity upon the mass of the object, friction between the "quicksand" and the portion of the object in contact with it, and the buoyant force.

At the point where the forces acting upon the object were balanced, the object's motion would stop changing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom