If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK. How about this. We can use my car if you pay for the container, the crane, and a high speed camera capable of recording at extremely high speeds. Here, how about this one that records a trillion frames per second. It's so fast it can record light waves. http://www.wired.com/2011/12/trillion-fps-camera-captures-advancing-light-waves

Once everything is in place, record the container dropping on my car. Make sure you get the acceleration of the container as it falls. Make sure you carry the value out to enough decimal places. Then, as the container impacts the car, tell me what the acceleration is before and after the impact. I will bet you $1000 the acceleration will decrease, even though the magnitude will be extremely small. The acceleration of the container will NOT be constant once it hits the car and crashes to the ground.

My guess is that the deceleration would be visibly noticeable for tens of thousands of frames, if the record rate was a trillion frames per second.

Newton proved this long ago. Why do you refuse to accept it?

You really do think the primary mass of the debris fell as a single, solid entity, don't you? That's cute.

Have you forgotten that the average acceleration of the mass was, demonstrably, significantly less than g?
 
What? Did you really just post that? The example was a collision in which an obviously larger object impacts a smaller object. An attempt was made to claim that there would be no deceleration because of the size of the objects.

You don't need a high speed camera to see the constant acceleration of the upper floors of the WTC buildings. Additionally, the upper floors were the smaller mass, not the larger.

So very much fail.

The main mass of debris was, in fact, subject to acceleration with a negative vector, as evidenced by the fact that it fell at an average acceleration significantly less than g.

Please link to the post on this thread where anyone said there was "no deceleration".

The primary debris mass had momentum, and thus more kinetic energy than each of the floors upon which it fell sequentially, could support. They failed, sequentially, impeding the fall of the primary debris mass; which resulted in an average acceleration less than g.
 
Maybe we don't need a high speed camera.

Watch the video and tell me what happens to the bottom of the container.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oTBdoeZKmo8

Do you mean, a container that fell as a solid, cohesive unit?

Do explain why you think a solid block is a good model for the inchoate mass of debris seen on the videos of the collapse...
 
FalseFag,

Here's an experiment for you to try at home. Get a box of these and make one of these. Stand it up between a pair of paving stones and run one of these into it.

Once you have some results, please return and explain why it doesn't predict what would happen when I take one of these and run it into this.

Because this will be the later result

If you can understand the different between these things, you might start to understand the issue with Cole's video experiments.

Dat ol' debbil scaling,...
 
Here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjSd9wB55zk

I need to make this clear, so I will do it here.

It can be stated clearly that 1 constant acceleration was observed during the collapse of the north tower. It can also be stated clearly that 2 freefall acceleration (constant acceleration at 9.8m/s/s) was observed for at least 2 seconds during the collapse of WTC 7. Because of the nature of the collapse of the south tower, there is no definitive proof it collapsed with a constant acceleration. One can apply logic and reason to conclude that 3 if constant acceleration was observed in the collapse of the north tower, and the collapse of the south tower looks very similar and it occurred in roughly the same amount of time, that there was also constant acceleration in the south tower. However, since I can not find definitive proof of this, I will only use WTC 7 and the north tower as examples. If you want to claim that the south tower collapsed via a different mechanism, go right ahead. I will not argue against your claims.

1 . You are still pretending that the falling mass can be treated as a solid block. The fact is that the mass fell at an average acceleration significantly less than g. You are looking at the results of acceleration in a negative vector, and pretending it is something else.

2 . This is an equivocation. The only parts of the debris that fell at g were outside the main column, unimpeded by the lower floors. Further, none of the debris fell at an acceleration greater than g.

3 . see 1 , above.
 
It doesn't matter how they were constructed. The question is, once the building was constructed, did floor 50 (as an example) support floors 51 through 110? The answer is yes.

The correct answer is no. The floors supported nothing except what was on the floors.

It really does matter how they were constructed.

Newton disagrees. You really should understand his laws before you post.

You should also review my definition of floor, which is in this thread.

Your definitions are irrelevant if they have no basis in reality.

The answer is still no.
 
So very much fail.

The main mass of debris was, in fact, subject to acceleration with a negative vector, as evidenced by the fact that it fell at an average acceleration significantly less than g.

Please link to the post on this thread where anyone said there was "no deceleration".

The primary debris mass had momentum, and thus more kinetic energy than each of the floors upon which it fell sequentially, could support. They failed, sequentially, impeding the fall of the primary debris mass; which resulted in an average acceleration less than g.

A good video that might help False Flag, understand what your saying.Forces and Motion REVISION PODCAST (Edexcel IGCSE…: http://youtu.be/6GYx9c_NQTU

It might also show him how to correctly read Chandlers self debunking graphic.
 
If the collapse bypassed the columns, why aren't the outer columns and inner columns still standing? The inner columns were a defacto building unto itself. It could have easily remained standing, if, as you claim, the collapse bypassed the columns.

No, the core could not have stood on its own even if the rest of the structure magically went "poof". Of course the rest of the structure did not magically disappear, the collapsing building broke apart and rained down on the lower structure tearing at connections, including those in the core.
the perimeter, stand alone? Ridiculous to even suggest that it could.
 
Not the way you want it to. Nice try.

The smaller objects exert equal and opposite forces on each other during a collision. The larger objects exert equal and opposite forces on each other during a collision. You could put the toy truck in front of the large truck and have the large truck run over it at 100mph. At the moment of impact, the toy truck is still going to exert an equal and opposite force on the large truck, and the truck will decelerate, even if the magnitude is extremely small.

Put the larger truck on a completely flat, frictionless surface with no air resistance. Apply a one time force to accelerate the truck. In front of the path of the larger truck place an infinite number of toy trucks spaced an inch apart. Even if you remove friction and air resistance, the truck will eventually come to a stop because each toy truck will decelerate the larger truck with each collision, even if the deceleration is extremely minor. The deceleration will not be constant, because the trucks are not applying constant force in the opposite direction of travel. Each impact would cause an impulse deceleration.


I've highlighted the key component on why you are wrong. If you are unable to understand then I doubt you ever will and further discussion will not be productive.
 
Wrong. Constant downward acceleration can been seen right here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjSd9wB55zk and here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJf7pWVyvIw

What conditions are necessary for this to happen?

I have already said it repeatedly, so I'm not going to do it again.

this acceleration was ONLY for the first few tens of feet... AE is being deceptive. Let's see their trace of the acceleration from floor 72 to floor 42.

You won't because there was none....
 
No, the core could not have stood on its own even if the rest of the structure magically went "poof". Of course the rest of the structure did not magically disappear, the collapsing building broke apart and rained down on the lower structure tearing at connections, including those in the core.
the perimeter, stand alone? Ridiculous to even suggest that it could.


The OOS collapse bypassed the core... but the floors within the core destroyed the bracing inside the core and left the remaining columns too unstable to stand without it. They broke at their joints and collapse of toppled over...

Your understanding and observations are way off. You are a science denier... much like Gage et al.
 
The OOS collapse bypassed the core... but the floors within the core destroyed the bracing inside the core and left the remaining columns too unstable to stand without it. They broke at their joints and collapse of toppled over...

Your understanding and observations are way off. You are a science denier... much like Gage et al.

How so, I said the same thing you just did:confused:
 
When the WTC towers collapsed, they continued to fall at or near freefall speeds. The only way this could have happened is if an external force removed the lower floor before the falling part above hit it. Controlled demolition is the ONLY way the WTC towers could have collapsed the way they did. The laws of physics support this, and Mr. Cole's experiments demonstrate this as well.

I'm quoting this from page 3 of the thread. Many pages later FalseFlag has accepted that the collapse time was greater, and the average acceleration less, than he claimed at first. Yet the erroneous observation that leads to the CD conclusion has led to no change in the CD claim.

I wonder if there's some cognitive dissonance bubbling away in the background. I have noticed a slight change of tone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom