If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Open Office Space
and
Runaway Open Office Space Destruction (or similar)

I suppose it's handy to pin the main mechanism to floor collapse rather than column-driven collapse.

Accumulated mass causing Rapid individual connection failures, is a better description of all the collapses.
Also it has been mathmaticly proven simple ROOSD fails because mathematics proves that
we should see more core survival.
 
Don't you read my posts?

Look at this thread in a years time, it will be the same or there will be another identical thread.

Truthers just want to keep the argument going, that is their victory, they know what they post is fantasy, no right minded person could have such a wrong idea of physics and the events of 9/11.

Myriad is playing the role of Sisyphus, doomed to roll facts up against the hill of Truther Woo.


I absolutely do and agree.

:thumbsup:
 
I remember once hearing a mathematician talking about science articles in newspapers and why many people believe them despite their conclusions being false. He outlined what I believe is a very common thinking pattern in laypeople when presented with technical subjects. He said, 'It's got numbers in it so it must be scientific, I don't understand it so it must be true.' I'm ashamed to say I fall for this technique quite often.

I think the same sort of thing is the reason people might be convinced by these videos; Cole talks about the value of 'experiments' but ignores the fact that experiments must be well designed to yield meaningful results.

But as soon as one mentions the word 'experiment', that is all that is required to convince many untrained people that what you are presenting must be a well designed one because they simply aren't aware that such a thing as a poorly designed experiment exists.

This pattern of behavior is FAR more common than you might think. And not just with non-technical people.

It took me until my mid to late 20s to really catch onto this.

I'd read an article in the papers, or hear one on the news, which pertained to some field that I knew. There would inevitably be the "Oh, c'mon. Who the hell told you that?!" moment.

So I became extremely jaded about believing them, when they'd talk about things I knew.

But I found myself reflexively believing them when they talked about things that I didn't know. Suddenly, around the age of 27 or so, the light went on for me.

The press is amazingly incompetent at getting simple things correct. I do believe that is part incompetence & part sensationalism. They want to have that "Wow!" moment in each story. In real life, it's just not there that often. So they indulge in a little "artistic license".

This is why I give far, far more credence to read stories that are written by the expert themselves, and not "interpreted" by journalists.

As for the origins of this "blind trust", I believe that it was a result of my first intro to magazines like Time & Newsweek when I went to college. My thought was "Wow, there are all these guys out there who know so much more than I do."

I firmly believe that the standards of journalism have plummeted to abysmal levels from the late '80s. The "Geraldo Effect". Sensational outsells boringly accurate 100 to 1.

It took a long time for that shine to tarnish. And to gather enough of my own life experience to realize that they just make up a ton of stuff.

I know that I sound really jaded on the media. It's true. But I do think that they've earned my distrust.

And I believe that, for a bunch of people today, YouTube & the internet has become their news & info source.

While being a poor, poor imitation of the journalism the '60s & '70s.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps he is not aiming for scientific exactness, maybe he is just going for a simplified visual representation for the majority of his audience, who will be laymen.

His experiments, his conclusions, are lying to people who don't possess the technical knowledge to understand where his nonsense falls apart.

That is abuse of his degree.

It is the absolute, 100% responsibility of technically knowledgeable people to NOT do this. To act as a defender for our audience, and to protect them from exactly this type of deception.

We all know that schools tell lies, and over simplify things to introduce topics, and then offer deeper and deeper levels of understanding at later dates. We know that pie charts and line graphs are used in marketing or management to try and visually represent, in an easily understood way the numbers behind things.

Absolutely false, when it comes to engineering education.
"Simplify"? Yes.
"tell lies"? Absolutely not.

Perhaps statistics for marketing & management.
NOT engineering. Not science.

What you are suggesting is "... easily MISunderstood numbers."

The blacksmith presented a visual display that wasn't very scientific, he responded with like for like.

Wrong.

The Blacksmith was attempting to demonstrate an intrinsic properties of steel.
He got that exactly correct.

Cole was attempting to demonstrate global, extrinsic properties of the WTC towers
He got that 100% wrong

Not close. Not an approximation. Not a simplification.
100% wrong.

There is NO comparison between the two.

Too many assumptions about his motives and reasons, too much dismissal of his integrity and credentials, when one could simply ask him... just a thought.

You will note that, with both Chandler & Cole, they disable comments in their YouTubes & other on-line presentations.

That is NOT an accident.
That is precisely to quash all the knowledgeable people from writing what clueless pieces of nonsense their "analyses" are.

Honest, competent people welcome critical review of their work.
Charlatans try to quash it.
 
Why? Instead of stating that it is sad, please give examples of how the paper is wrong.

LOL, and then you immediately quote the section of my post where I did just that. I have to assume that you didn't understand what I said any more than you understood what Ross was claiming. Or Cole, for that matter. Or Newton. But that doesn't stop you from "debating" this stuff anyway, huh.

None of this matters. Explain the reason two steel-framed buildings collapsed at a constant acceleration.

First, you need to either prove there was "constant" acceleration or explain why things that didn't happen need to be explained.

Here, let me do it for you. They collapsed at a constant acceleration because there were no intermittent, or implulse, forces in the opposite direction. This can only happen if the floors were removed by an external force as the upper floors collapsed.

That would produce a constant acceleration of g. You've been asked to explain how any collapse mechanism could produce a constant 0.64g, since blowing out columns most certainly wouldn't do that.

Period. Deny it all you want, but you're wrong. Bazant is wrong. Deal with it. It does not matter if I say he's wrong, Newton says he's wrong, and that is what matters.

Newton who?
 
Don't you read my posts?

Look at this thread in a years time, it will be the same or there will be another identical thread.

Truthers just want to keep the argument going, that is their victory, they know what they post is fantasy, no right minded person could have such a wrong idea of physics and the events of 9/11.

Myriad is playing the role of Sisyphus, doomed to roll facts up against the hill of Truther Woo.
Hmmm.

"Hope. The quintessential human emotion."
 
Somebody threw another temper tantrum and got some of my posts removed. I'm not surprised, because that's a skeptic's modus operandi of last resort. A skeptic doesn't like an argument so they throw at it whatever nonsensical BS they can, but once they run out of BS they resort to personal attacks. When the personal attacks don't work they run to their mommy, erm, moderator.

What you don't realize is that each one of the skeptics' failures to accept the most fundamental laws of physics absolutely destroys their credibility. No one with the ability to reason can look through this thread and ignore the blatant hypocrisy demonstrated by skeptics, and their extraordinary, almost unbelievable, denial of Newton's laws of motion. Some of the skeptic's arguments are absolutely laughable, and they demonstrate how severely rooted many of them are in delusion, denial, and possibly dementia.

My point wasn't just to post Cole's videos. It was to demonstrate, beyond any reasonable doubt, just how far a skeptic will go to deny even the most basic laws of physics if it goes against their delusions about 9/11. I submit to truthers (and everyone else), in a thread of almost 900 posts, many well-founded arguments based in science getting absolutely rejected by hundreds of the most ridiculous, nonsensical arguments possible. Thank you, skeptics, for doing such a great job proving my point. This is ironclad, and it's available for all of the internet to see.

Flounce complete. It's obvious why this site has so few truthers. It's only possible to endure so much nonsense.

Continue discussing your delusions on your own, but you will do so without me.
 
Last edited:
Here, let me do it for you. They collapsed at a constant acceleration because there were no intermittent, or implulse, forces in the opposite direction. This can only happen if the floors were removed by an external force as the upper floors collapsed.
That would produce a constant acceleration of g. You've been asked to explain how any collapse mechanism could produce a constant 0.64g, since blowing out columns most certainly wouldn't do that.

Actually, blowing out columns in sequence as the collapse front reaches them would produce jolts, ie. changes in acceleration.
Take two objects, drop top one onto next lower one but release that lower one from restraint at the very moment of contact. Since the first, upper, object has been falling and the second only then begins to accelerate due to gravity, the upper one catches the lower one. As the two merge, conservation of momentum requires that the now combined mass be AT THAT MOMENT, moving a velocity lower than the velocity of the upper mass at the moment of contact.

That be Newtonian physics. Odd how Cole forgets this!

THE ONLY WAY to produce a constant acceleration would be to blow out all columns on ALL floors simultaneously. Then the entire building would fall AT g.
 
Last edited:
I wonder what would happen if a group of 1000 elementary school children watched Mr. Cole's experiments with all 9/11 references removed. Then, without adding politics or any external bias, I wonder how they would explain the collapse of the towers. I would be willing to bet that every student who understood the laws of physics, as they pertain to downward motion, would agree that the lower floors had to be removed in order for the collapses to happen the way they did. I'm certain of it.

Every kid who has slept peacefully in bed while lying on it but had it collapse when jumping up and down on it will understand how the impact of the upper section on the lower destroyed the floor connections and caused it collapse one floor at a time. :rolleyes:
 
See, this sort of argument doesn't really make sense to me, so perhaps you could walk me through your thinking and logic.

An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?

It is trivially easy.

The theoretical failing of the Twoofer movement was established by Steven Jones, in this early debate with Leslie Robertson on a Denver radio station.

NOTE: Pay attention to the (idiotic) comments by Gregg Roberts.
He hasn’t the slightest idea what he is babbling about.
But his pompous attitude & vapid arguments are perfectly representative of Truther cluelessness.

Jones hasn’t a clue what he is talking about either.
He’s a particle physicist, with zero knowledge of mechanical or structural engineering. He is used to being the smartest guy in the room. In this discussion, he is the stupidest … by a wide, wide margin.

If the topic were “muon mediated cold fusion or particle physics, he would be smart. But the topic is structural engineering. Jones is an equal parts clueless and arrogant. A deadly mix.

Jones v. Robertson debate, 10/26/06 KGNU Radio, Denver
Radio broadcast: http://tinyurl.com/jssw6bh
Transcript: http://tinyurl.com/kz3zao5

Journal of 911 studies, April 2007

Page 23

Denver Radio Debate said:
ROBERTSON: OK, then, if we accept that to be the case, then I still don’t understand that some kind of controlled demolition could then have hastened the fall. *We’re not—are we really saying every floor, every other, every third floor would have had to have had some kind of explosives in it?* That’s absolute nonsense.

JONES: *That would be required, to move the mass out of the way, yes, in order for the upper floors to proceed so rapidly to the ground.*

ROBERTSON: So the premise that you’re putting forward on the table here I gather, Steven, is that, many, many floors of the building had in them explosives designed to bring down the building. Now ...

JONES: Completely and rapidly.

ROBERTSON: In order to bring them down at that pace, I’m sorry, you’re right, because the building’s gonna collapse, there’s no question about that.
Now what would be the motive, or even how would you achieve it? How would you physically go about it? I’m working in an office building; I’m sitting right now on the 47th floor of an office building. I don’t know how it would be possible to go in and put in a demolition [sic].

Now, in order to put [sic] controlled demolition on every floor, every second floor, every third floor, whatever you think it would take to create that speed of demolition, that would require an absolutely monumental effort. Monumental effort, which would have to get by security police and office workers— You can't just walk into someone's office and put explosives on the columns, I mean forget it. Before or after 9/11, we all controlled our own space. So, it's not practical , to consider [that] demolition explosives could have been put into many, many floors of the building, in order to increase the speed of fall. And why would anyone do it for that matter? I mean, once it's going to fall, it's going to fall. What's the point of trying to speed it, its departure? I don't understand that at all.

JONES: Could I provide some answers then, some enlightenment here, because you’ve asked some questions? We address this – there’s several, but in a short time – I point out the molten metal below both towers and Building 7 after their collapses. This indicates a very large source of chemical energy, and consistent with the use of large quantities of explosives. However, extrapolating from, for instance, the Landmark Tower controlled demolition, it would only require approximately a thousand pounds of high-energy explosives in each Tower to bring them down in that way. So we're not talking about an enormous amount of explosives. But the presence of this molten metal, which I discuss in my paper – again it's at …
(heap o’nonsense)

ROBERTSON: First of all, with respect to the amount of explosives required to bring down a given building, clearly it does not take tons of explosives to do that. But to do it in a kind of floor-by-floor basis, which is your premise in terms of the speed of fall, ah, you would have to have that same amount of explosives—and by the way the World Trade Center was a substantially larger building than the one you’re discussing—you’d have to have that on many floors of the building. Not—and the perimeter of the building, and the core of the building, so it would be a monumental undertaking, it would be outside the realm of reality of what’s permitted, in terms of strangers appearing in office spaces.

JONES: [inaudible] molten metal. I don’t agree with that—

ROBERTSON: You don’t agree with what?

JONES: Well, that it couldn’t be accomplished, because—

ROBERTSON: OK, well, you can accomplish anything if you have the resources to do it—

JONES: —Right—

ROBERTSON: —but I defy you to go into an office building and, and, with your rucksack and your thermite explosives, and stick it on a column and expect it to stay there. That's preposterous

First HUGE lesson: I have fought this battle dozens of times in my professional career. Even tho it is 100% brain-dead stupid: _”In the perception of the clueless, any answer, no matter how stupid or moronic, beats an honest “I don’t know” every time.”_

Lesson 2: Jones is wrong, simply wrong, about *every single one of his statements* in this excerpt. Every one.

Lesson 3: Robertson is also, at that point in time, pretty clueless about the DETAILS of collapse mechanisms, the acceleration of the upper block, etc.

With the exception a very tiny niche, structural engineers don’t give a rat’s ass about, & don’t study, “collapse dynamics”. Nobody gets “attaboys” because “my building collapsed at only 0.2G, while theirs collapsed at 0.8G.”

Note: Progressive Collapse (“whether & why small failures turn into large collapses" is a valid study. Not “the way the building falls to the ground.”)

The fact that Robertson is pretty ignorant about how the building fell to the ground is a manifestation of his knowledge & professionalism. Professionals ignore irrelevant trivia.

The fact that Jones is consumed with, dwell upon how the building fell is a manifestation of his ignorance & amateurism. Amateurs dwell on irrelevant trivia.
__

The parts that Jones didn’t get are: 1) The towers did NOT collapse in free fall, and 2) he has no clue about Load Path: that if the weight is not borne ONLY on the columns, as the towers were built, (instead of on the concrete floor, as during the collapse), then the collapse happens with very little resistance.

The point is that, the collapse timing that we saw is exactly what one who understands “Load path” would expect.

Once you understand Load Path, then you immediately realize that the towers were NOT “stronger near the bottom.” You understand that they were exactly the same strength from he top to the bottom. (Even including the Mechanical floors.)
__

Now, proof that it could NOT have been done by thermite:

1. You can NOT cut vertical columns the size of the columns, and NOT leave a huge amount of physical evidence in the debris. FBI agents, who know what to look for in arson cases, examined all the sifted debris from GZ, down to 1/4” in size. There is no way that the idiotic “thermite slit tubes & clamps”, or any other mechanism to hold the thermite against vertical columns, could have escaped detection.

2. You can NOT set off 1000s of thermite charges without illuminating the towers as though there were 100 spot lights inside. This didn’t happen.

3. The progression of the tilting & bowing that led to collapse happened slowly, over 1 & 2 hours time. Thermite does NOT go off gradually.

4. Thermite would have cut the columns in the middle of the beam. Even if someone were to TRY to set their devices exactly at the junction between one column & the next (above or below), the melting would have progressed several inches into the column. At the very minimum, a couple hundred of the columns would have had “melted ends”. In Jones’ delusions (thermite charges every couple of floors), tens of thousands of column ends would have been “melted”.

I invite you to go to the NIST “9/11 disaster study website”. You will find many hundreds of photos of Ground Zero, showing tens of thousands of columns in the debris pile. There are also hundreds of pictures of the columns, stacked like cordwood, at Fresh Kills.

LOOK at them for yourself. Do not skip this step.!

NOT ONE of them shows a “thermite melted end”, or a “explosive charge cut” end.

Not. ONE.

Each one of these observations, alone, prove that neither thermite, nor explosives, could possibly have been used.

The overlap between “heat could do it but thermite can’t” is minimal.
The “it could not possibly have been thermite” argument stands on its own.
The “it could absolutely have been done by damage, massively increased stress & low levels of heat” stands on its own, too.

Any question?
 
Last edited:
Somebody threw another temper tantrum and got some of my posts removed. I'm not surprised, because that's a skeptic's modus operandi of last resort. A skeptic doesn't like an argument so they throw at it whatever nonsensical BS they can, but once they run out of BS they resort to personal attacks. When the personal attacks don't work they run to their mommy, erm, moderator.

What you don't realize is that each one of the skeptics' failures to accept the most fundamental laws of physics absolutely destroys their credibility. No one with the ability to reason can look through this thread and ignore the blatant hypocrisy demonstrated by skeptics, and their extraordinary, almost unbelievable, denial of Newton's laws of motion. Some of the skeptic's arguments are absolutely laughable, and they demonstrate how severely rooted many of them are in delusion, denial, and possibly dementia.

My point wasn't just to post Cole's videos. It was to demonstrate, beyond any reasonable doubt, just how far a skeptic will go to deny even the most basic laws of physics if it goes against their delusions about 9/11. I submit to truthers (and everyone else), in a thread of almost 900 posts, many well-founded arguments based in science getting absolutely rejected by hundreds of the most ridiculous, nonsensical arguments possible. Thank you, skeptics, for doing such a great job proving my point. This is ironclad, and it's available for all of the internet to see.

Flounce complete. It's obvious why this site has so few truthers. It's only possible to endure so much nonsense.

Continue discussing your delusions on your own, but you will do so without me.

You have already posted Chandler's graph that debunks your claims, there are three separate
Accelerations on it as well as 3 declarations and chandler himself stated the towers provided
The expected 36% resistance to the fall of the mass!

That's the exact resistance the connections should have provided given the equation I showed you!

Your a self debunking truther, we have seen many others similar here thanks for playing you lost as does Cole.
 
....(snip)

Put the larger truck on a completely flat, frictionless surface with no air resistance. Apply a one time force to accelerate the truck. In front of the path of the larger truck place an infinite number of toy trucks spaced an inch apart. Even if you remove friction and air resistance, the truck will eventually come to a stop because each toy truck will decelerate the larger truck with each collision, even if the deceleration is extremely minor. The deceleration will not be constant, because the trucks are not applying constant force in the opposite direction of travel. Each impact would cause an impulse deceleration.

I've highlighted the key component on why you are wrong. If you are unable to understand then I doubt you ever will and further discussion will not be productive.


Now that you've had your expected rant perhaps you can address this.

Edit:
Continue discussing your delusions on your own, but you will do so without me.

My bad. I didn't see this part. No worries. I didn't see this conversation progressing further anyway.
 
Last edited:
The air resistance was real, and it's one of the reasons the towers did not fall at exactly freefall.

Your argument is irrelevant, though. Air resistance, which was close to a static value, would not overcome the force of acceleration due to gravity, unless the object was at its terminal velocity. The towers were nowhere near this.
No. Air resistance was minimal. Do you see those perimeter columns plummeting to earth ahead of the collapse front. They were actually tumbling as they fell (not good for minimizing air resistance). They fell ahead of the inner part of the Twin Towers because they didn't have to plow through the floor-column connections.

BTW, air resistance is not static. It increases with increasing speed. That's why some objects have a terminal velocity when they fall to earth.
 
OK. How about this. We can use my car if you pay for the container, the crane, and a high speed camera capable of recording at extremely high speeds...

Just out of curiosity...

Let's take 680 cars like yours & park them in a 200' x 200' array (~10' long x 6' wide / car would be a 20 x 34 array of parked cars.) 680 cars ... per floor.

How well do you think that this array would serve as "office space"?
How well do you think that you could stack 110 of these arrays on top of each other?

Do you really think that your model is valid for elucidating "collapse mechanisms in the WTC towers"?

Once everything is in place, record the container dropping on my car. Make sure you get the acceleration of the container as it falls. Make sure you carry the value out to enough decimal places. Then, as the container impacts the car, tell me what the acceleration is before and after the impact.

Your car, whether just one or an array of them, is on the ground.
Was the 95th floor of WTC1 or the 76th story of WTC2 "on the ground"?
Do you think that might change things a bit?

You COULD suspend your car on a structure & have it represent a floor.
Why don't you try to think about how you would do that, such that it was an ACCURATE model of one floor of the towers.

Why do I believe that you won't give this enlightening exercise the slightest bit of effort...

I will bet you $1000 the acceleration will decrease, even though the magnitude will be extremely small. The acceleration of the container will NOT be constant once it hits the car and crashes to the ground.

That is true in both examples.
But a "decreased acceleration" is NOT a "deceleration".

I explained this to you a couple of days ago.
You ignored it completely.
Not particularly polite on your part...

My guess is that the deceleration would be visibly noticeable for tens of thousands of frames, if the record rate was a trillion frames per second.

Newton proved this long ago. Why do you refuse to accept it?

You do NOT speak for Newton.
You haven't the slightest clue what Isaac really said.
Sorry to be blunt, but it is completely true.
 
Last edited:
Accumulated mass causing Rapid individual connection failures, is a better description of all the collapses.
Also it has been mathmaticly proven simple ROOSD fails because mathematics proves that
we should see more core survival.

Well yes and no... the falling mass ALSO shattered and in most cased punched through the floor slabs.

To pin the collapse on truss to truss seat connection failures sounds like the entire floor plate was so over loaded that the connections to the seats failed. This was hardly what the floor collapse looked like if you were close enough to see it happening.

Indeed the first "collisions" created some large sections of slabs... but in a NY moment the collapse was a pile of broken up debris... from the floor plates.

Sure there were sections adjacent to the connections which sheared... ripped out bolts... bent over and so failing the connection.

The collapse was not a series of solid plates collapsing breaking hundreds of connections at once at each level.
 
Building a campfire? :D

What it looks like to me, probably green brush though, not very hot,
Here is one of mine for comparison purposes.
http://i271.photobucket.com/albums/jj132/chainsawprof/20141009_181117_zpsfxn6xram.jpg

A 21 inch positive preasure ventilation fan, inside some 55 gallion steel drums and thermite really warm you up on a cold morning and the high velocity fan inside the steel drums makes a giant leaf blower for easy lawn work as well.
Kinda my own cheap home made air curtain.
 
Well yes and no... the falling mass ALSO shattered and in most cased punched through the floor slabs.

To pin the collapse on truss to truss seat connection failures sounds like the entire floor plate was so over loaded that the connections to the seats failed. This was hardly what the floor collapse looked like if you were close enough to see it happening.

Indeed the first "collisions" created some large sections of slabs... but in a NY moment the collapse was a pile of broken up debris... from the floor plates.

Sure there were sections adjacent to the connections which sheared... ripped out bolts... bent over and so failing the connection.

The collapse was not a series of solid plates collapsing breaking hundreds of connections at once at each level.

I understand all that JSO, but would vibrations in the collapse have worked the columns inducing weaknesses in the column welds as the columns vibrated from the off center impacts?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom