See, this sort of argument doesn't really make sense to me, so perhaps you could walk me through your thinking and logic.
An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?
It is trivially easy.
The theoretical failing of the Twoofer movement was established by Steven Jones, in this early debate with Leslie Robertson on a Denver radio station.
NOTE: Pay attention to the (idiotic) comments by Gregg Roberts.
He hasn’t the slightest idea what he is babbling about.
But his pompous attitude & vapid arguments are perfectly representative of Truther cluelessness.
Jones hasn’t a clue what he is talking about either.
He’s a particle physicist, with zero knowledge of mechanical or structural engineering. He is used to being the smartest guy in the room. In this discussion, he is the stupidest … by a wide, wide margin.
If the topic were “muon mediated cold fusion or particle physics, he would be smart. But the topic is structural engineering. Jones is an equal parts clueless and arrogant. A deadly mix.
Jones v. Robertson debate, 10/26/06 KGNU Radio, Denver
Radio broadcast:
http://tinyurl.com/jssw6bh
Transcript:
http://tinyurl.com/kz3zao5
Journal of 911 studies, April 2007
Page 23
Denver Radio Debate said:
ROBERTSON: OK, then, if we accept that to be the case, then I still don’t understand that some kind of controlled demolition could then have hastened the fall. *We’re not—are we really saying every floor, every other, every third floor would have had to have had some kind of explosives in it?* That’s absolute nonsense.
JONES: *That would be required, to move the mass out of the way, yes, in order for the upper floors to proceed so rapidly to the ground.*
ROBERTSON: So the premise that you’re putting forward on the table here I gather, Steven, is that, many, many floors of the building had in them explosives designed to bring down the building. Now ...
JONES: Completely and rapidly.
ROBERTSON: In order to bring them down at that pace, I’m sorry, you’re right, because the building’s gonna collapse, there’s no question about that.
Now what would be the motive, or even how would you achieve it? How would you physically go about it? I’m working in an office building; I’m sitting right now on the 47th floor of an office building. I don’t know how it would be possible to go in and put in a demolition [sic].
Now, in order to put [sic] controlled demolition on every floor, every second floor, every third floor, whatever you think it would take to create that speed of demolition, that would require an absolutely monumental effort. Monumental effort, which would have to get by security police and office workers— You can't just walk into someone's office and put explosives on the columns, I mean forget it. Before or after 9/11, we all controlled our own space. So, it's not practical , to consider [that] demolition explosives could have been put into many, many floors of the building, in order to increase the speed of fall. And why would anyone do it for that matter? I mean, once it's going to fall, it's going to fall. What's the point of trying to speed it, its departure? I don't understand that at all.
JONES: Could I provide some answers then, some enlightenment here, because you’ve asked some questions? We address this – there’s several, but in a short time – I point out the molten metal below both towers and Building 7 after their collapses. This indicates a very large source of chemical energy, and consistent with the use of large quantities of explosives. However, extrapolating from, for instance, the Landmark Tower controlled demolition, it would only require approximately a thousand pounds of high-energy explosives in each Tower to bring them down in that way. So we're not talking about an enormous amount of explosives. But the presence of this molten metal, which I discuss in my paper – again it's at …
(heap o’nonsense)
ROBERTSON: First of all, with respect to the amount of explosives required to bring down a given building, clearly it does not take tons of explosives to do that. But to do it in a kind of floor-by-floor basis, which is your premise in terms of the speed of fall, ah, you would have to have that same amount of explosives—and by the way the World Trade Center was a substantially larger building than the one you’re discussing—you’d have to have that on many floors of the building. Not—and the perimeter of the building, and the core of the building, so it would be a monumental undertaking, it would be outside the realm of reality of what’s permitted, in terms of strangers appearing in office spaces.
JONES: [inaudible] molten metal. I don’t agree with that—
ROBERTSON: You don’t agree with what?
JONES: Well, that it couldn’t be accomplished, because—
ROBERTSON: OK, well, you can accomplish anything if you have the resources to do it—
JONES: —Right—
ROBERTSON: —but I defy you to go into an office building and, and, with your rucksack and your thermite explosives, and stick it on a column and expect it to stay there. That's preposterous
First HUGE lesson: I have fought this battle dozens of times in my professional career. Even tho it is 100% brain-dead stupid: _”In the perception of the clueless, any answer, no matter how stupid or moronic, beats an honest “I don’t know” every time.”_
Lesson 2: Jones is wrong, simply wrong, about *every single one of his statements* in this excerpt. Every one.
Lesson 3: Robertson is also, at that point in time, pretty clueless about the DETAILS of collapse mechanisms, the acceleration of the upper block, etc.
With the exception a very tiny niche, structural engineers don’t give a rat’s ass about, & don’t study, “collapse dynamics”. Nobody gets “attaboys” because “my building collapsed at only 0.2G, while theirs collapsed at 0.8G.”
Note: Progressive Collapse (“
whether & why small failures turn into large collapses" is a valid study. Not “
the way the building falls to the ground.”)
The fact that Robertson is pretty ignorant about
how the building fell to the ground is a manifestation of his knowledge & professionalism. Professionals ignore irrelevant trivia.
The fact that Jones is consumed with, dwell upon
how the building fell is a manifestation of his ignorance & amateurism. Amateurs dwell on irrelevant trivia.
__
The parts that Jones didn’t get are: 1) The towers did NOT collapse in free fall, and 2) he has no clue about Load Path: that if the weight is not borne ONLY on the columns, as the towers were built, (instead of on the concrete floor, as during the collapse), then the collapse happens with very little resistance.
The point is that, the collapse timing that we saw is exactly what one who understands “Load path” would expect.
Once you understand Load Path, then you immediately realize that the towers were NOT “stronger near the bottom.” You understand that they were exactly the same strength from he top to the bottom. (Even including the Mechanical floors.)
__
Now, proof that it could NOT have been done by thermite:
1. You can NOT cut vertical columns the size of the columns, and NOT leave a huge amount of physical evidence in the debris. FBI agents, who know what to look for in arson cases, examined all the sifted debris from GZ, down to 1/4” in size. There is no way that the idiotic “thermite slit tubes & clamps”, or any other mechanism to hold the thermite against vertical columns, could have escaped detection.
2. You can NOT set off 1000s of thermite charges without illuminating the towers as though there were 100 spot lights inside. This didn’t happen.
3. The progression of the tilting & bowing that led to collapse happened slowly, over 1 & 2 hours time. Thermite does NOT go off gradually.
4. Thermite would have cut the columns in the middle of the beam. Even if someone were to TRY to set their devices exactly at the junction between one column & the next (above or below), the melting would have progressed several inches into the column. At the very minimum, a couple hundred of the columns would have had “melted ends”. In Jones’ delusions (thermite charges every couple of floors), tens of thousands of column ends would have been “melted”.
I invite you to go to the NIST “9/11 disaster study website”. You will find many hundreds of photos of Ground Zero, showing tens of thousands of columns in the debris pile. There are also hundreds of pictures of the columns, stacked like cordwood, at Fresh Kills.
LOOK at them for yourself.
Do not skip this step.!
NOT ONE of them shows a “thermite melted end”, or a “explosive charge cut” end.
Not. ONE.
Each one of these observations, alone, prove that neither thermite, nor explosives, could possibly have been used.
The overlap between “heat could do it but thermite can’t” is minimal.
The “it could not possibly have been thermite” argument stands on its own.
The “it could absolutely have been done by damage, massively increased stress & low levels of heat” stands on its own, too.
Any question?