If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe we don't need a high speed camera, once again.

Watch this.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNZvz4mbsJM

Why didn't the car disintegrate? According to the video, the container weighs 40 tons. The car can't weigh more than 3 tons. It looks like the container decelerated, and completely stopped, before reaching the ground. Are cars designed to withstand the forces of 40 tons being dropped on them?

Clearly a much larger mass fell on a much smaller mass not designed to carry such loads, but the car didn't disintegrate.

Hmmm. I wonder why.
 
FalseFag,

Here's an experiment for you to try at home. Get a box of these and make one of these. Stand it up between a pair of paving stones and run one of these into it.

Once you have some results, please return and explain why it doesn't predict what would happen when I take one of these and run it into this.

Because this will be the later result

If you can understand the different between these things, you might start to understand the issue with Cole's video experiments.
 
Here's another video.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zrr_XYU3T8Q

Before the car starts to shatter into pieces, one piece goes straight up. Why? What is causing the car to shatter? Does the car continue to accelerate? Most of the debris from the front of the car travels in one direction. Why? In what general direction(s) does the debris from the back of the car travel? Why?
 
Wrong. I have spent hours giving proof. You just refuse to accept it.

Hours? A few 'you tube' videos by amateurs in the OP, and the odd truther article? All which you failed to notice was discredited quite early on, after that you basically tried to shut down debate.

I'll leave you with it.
 
FalseFag,

Here's an experiment for you to try at home. Get a box of these and make one of these. Stand it up between a pair of paving stones and run one of these into it.

Once you have some results, please return and explain why it doesn't predict what would happen when I take one of these and run it into this.

Because this will be the later result

If you can understand the different between these things, you might start to understand the issue with Cole's video experiments.

I would gladly perform your experiment, but I don't need to.

The fence will still exert an equal and opposite force on the truck. That does not mean the truck will be demolished. It simply means the fence, according to Newton's third law, must exert an equal and opposite force on the truck during a collision.

Watch this. It's not a fence, but it's still an example of a smaller object colliding with a larger object. The fence might not do as much damage as a deer, but it will certainly exert a force on the truck. It has to.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejb0GyW6tkQ You can skip to about 1:40 to see the damage.
 
Last edited:
FalseFag,

Here's an experiment for you to try at home. Get a box of these and make one of these. Stand it up between a pair of paving stones and run one of these into it.

Once you have some results, please return and explain why it doesn't predict what would happen when I take one of these and run it into this.

Because this will be the later result

If you can understand the different between these things, you might start to understand the issue with Cole's video experiments.

A great demonstration of the scale problem. :thumbsup:
 
Hours? A few 'you tube' videos by amateurs in the OP, and the odd truther article? All which you failed to notice was discredited quite early on, after that you basically tried to shut down debate.

The fact that a video was posted on YouTube has no effect on its credibility.
 
Last edited:
A great demonstration of the scale problem. :thumbsup:
No, it isn't. I have posted a written and visual example of why it isn't.

Scale does not affect Newton's laws of motion. Every time someone posts this they are destroying their credibility, not that it seems to matter to any of you.
 
Last edited:
I wonder if someone could help me out. Rather than read through countless pages of tripe, could someone point to FF's sources for his two claims:

-the collapse of the towers happened at the rate of freefall

and its cousin

-there was no deceleration (OK, we know he doesn't know what he's actually claiming here) when the accumulated collapsing mass hit the floor below.

There must be some work or other he is using as his authority.
 
I wonder if someone could help me out. Rather than read through countless pages of tripe, could someone point to FF's sources for his two claims:

-the collapse of the towers happened at the rate of freefall

and its cousin

-there was no deceleration (OK, we know he doesn't know what he's actually claiming here) when the accumulated collapsing mass hit the floor below.

There must be some work or other he is using as his authority.

Here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjSd9wB55zk

I need to make this clear, so I will do it here.

It can be stated clearly that constant acceleration was observed during the collapse of the north tower. It can also be stated clearly that freefall acceleration (constant acceleration at 9.8m/s/s) was observed for at least 2 seconds during the collapse of WTC 7. Because of the nature of the collapse of the south tower, there is no definitive proof it collapsed with a constant acceleration. One can apply logic and reason to conclude that if constant acceleration was observed in the collapse of the north tower, and the collapse of the south tower looks very similar and it occurred in roughly the same amount of time, that there was also constant acceleration in the south tower. However, since I can not find definitive proof of this, I will only use WTC 7 and the north tower as examples. If you want to claim that the south tower collapsed via a different mechanism, go right ahead. I will not argue against your claims.
 
Last edited:
I wonder if someone could help me out. Rather than read through countless pages of tripe, could someone point to FF's sources for his two claims:

-the collapse of the towers happened at the rate of freefall

and its cousin

-there was no deceleration (OK, we know he doesn't know what he's actually claiming here) when the accumulated collapsing mass hit the floor below.

There must be some work or other he is using as his authority.

His mistake here was explained to him some days ago. A report unintentionally misrepresented global collapse time by referring to *first* recorded debris impact, which was debris falling unimpeded outside the footprint. He didn't notice or didn't care and is sticking to the wrong timing for global collapse.
 
His mistake here was explained to him some days ago. A report unintentionally misrepresented global collapse time by referring to *first* recorded debris impact, which was debris falling unimpeded outside the footprint. He didn't notice or didn't care and is sticking to the wrong timing for global collapse.

What? Show the post where this was explained, and show the video where the collapse time is measured this way. I have seen no such post.
 
What? Show the post where this was explained, and show the video where the collapse time is measured this way. I have seen no such post.

Collapse time was estimated from seismic records, not video, as the collapse zone was masked by dust and debris towards the end. Look it up.
 
Collapse time was estimated from seismic records, not video, as the collapse zone was masked by dust and debris towards the end. Look it up.

OK. I have seen this in other places. It does nothing to explain constant acceleration.
 
OK. I have seen this in other places. It does nothing to explain constant acceleration.

That's because you don't understand the meaning of the word. If I accelerate my car across a field of corn stubble my speed, at any given moment, will be less than if I were giving it the same gas on a flat road, but I'm still accelerating. The Towers accelerated downwards, but at less than G because of the resistance encountered.
 
That's because you don't understand the meaning of the word. If I accelerate my car across a field of corn stubble my speed, at any given moment, will be less than if I were giving it the same gas on a flat road, but I'm still accelerating. The Towers accelerated downwards, but at less than G because of the resistance encountered.

First, WTC 7 did accelerate at g (the downward force due to gravity, which is 9.8m/s/s) for at least 2 seconds. NIST admits this, but they refuse to explain it.

Second, the north tower experienced constant acceleration downwards (6.31m/s/s) for approximately 3 seconds. You can observe this for yourself in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjSd9wB55zk

Your claim is that if the towers constantly accelerated at less than g, they encountered resistance. First, the upper floors of WTC 7 could not have encountered any resistance if they fell at 9.8m/s/s for 2 seconds. Second, you are correct that there had to be some constant upwards force acting on the upper floors of the north tower in order to prevent it from accelerating at 9.8m/s/s, since it was only constantly accelerating downwards at 6.31m/s/s. The problem is that the lower floors would NOT provide constant resistance to the falling upper floors. They would provide impulse resistance (a temporary force in the opposite direction) during each impact. This impulse resistance would be in the opposite direction of the fall, and it would prohibit constant acceleration downwards.

I do understand acceleration. I can't say the same for you.
 
Last edited:
Here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjSd9wB55zk

I need to make this clear, so I will do it here.

It can be stated clearly that constant acceleration was observed during the collapse of the north tower. It can also be stated clearly that freefall acceleration (constant acceleration at 9.8m/s/s) was observed for at least 2 seconds during the collapse of WTC 7. Because of the nature of the collapse of the south tower, there is no definitive proof it collapsed with a constant acceleration. One can apply logic and reason to conclude that if constant acceleration was observed in the collapse of the north tower, and the collapse of the south tower looks very similar and it occurred in roughly the same amount of time, that there was also constant acceleration in the south tower. However, since I can not find definitive proof of this, I will only use WTC 7 and the north tower as examples. If you want to claim that the south tower collapsed via a different mechanism, go right ahead. I will not argue against your claims.

Constant acceleration was NOT observed in the collapse of 1wtc. There was only a periofd in the very beginning when the top begins to move downward that a point on the roof line starts at rest and "accerlates" but this acceleration DOES not continue. The collapse reaches a terminal velocity... of about 65mp... and this was measured over several floors based on the descending blasts of debris from the windows. The speed was about 100' / second for 1100 feet or so making that part of the collapse about 11 seconds. The top portion which WAS accelerating took 3.75 secs to collapse about 15 stories or 180'... so the collapse duration was about 14 seconds. This does not consider the downward movement of the antenna and of course the precise end of the collapse cannot be seen because of obscuring dust.

It did not descend at free fall... that would have been 9.2 seconds

it did not descend at a fraction of free fall

read this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terminal_velocity

An object falling from rest reaches a speed of 3.34 mph in .5 seconds
then 7.62 mph after 1 second then 19mph after 2 seconds and finally 40 mph after about 4 seconds.

if you calculate the distance traveled during this few second period of acceleration it will come to a column length or so...
 
Last edited:
Standard Truther thread. Churn round and round.
Keep the thread going on the same point at all costs.

You are dealing with someone who admits he has no expertise and denies all of physics and engineering in favour of his own model of the universe.

This is what passes for victory.
You are all wasting your time, you will be arguing exactly the same points at Christmas.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom