If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Standard Truther thread. Churn round and round.
Keep the thread going on the same point at all costs.

You are dealing with someone who admits he has no expertise and denies all of physics and engineering in favour of his own model of the universe.

This is what passes for victory.
You are all wasting your time, you will be arguing exactly the same points at Christmas.

I'm denying the laws of physics by citing Newton's laws of motion? Aren't those laws of physics? Are you claiming that Newton didn't understand physics? Are you claiming that his laws of motion are wrong? You claim that I have my own model of the universe. Please explain what physical laws are present in my universe that aren't present in yours.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove breaches of rule 0 and rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I would gladly perform your experiment, but I don't need to.

The fence will still exert an equal and opposite force on the truck. That does not mean the truck will be demolished. It simply means the fence, according to Newton's third law, must exert an equal and opposite force on the truck during a collision.

Watch this. It's not a fence, but it's still an example of a smaller object colliding with a larger object. The fence might not do as much damage as a deer, but it will certainly exert a force on the truck. It has to.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejb0GyW6tkQ You can skip to about 1:40 to see the damage.

I didn't expect that the truck would be demolished, in either experiment. The question is what happens to the fence in the scaled experiment vs what happens in the full scale event.

As you say the fence applies an equal force back on the truck. so why doesn't the big truck bounce off the fence just like the Matchbox version does off the Popsicle stick fence?
 
I didn't expect that the truck would be demolished, in either experiment. The question is what happens to the fence in the scaled experiment vs what happens in the full scale event.

As you say the fence applies an equal force back on the truck. so why doesn't the big truck bounce off the fence just like the Matchbox version does off the Popsicle stick fence?

That's because the mass of the smaller objects are more similar, and the force exerted by the fence is enough to cause a greater deceleration in the toy truck.

The larger truck still decelerates when it impacts the larger fence. A change in the direction of motion of the larger object is not necessary to prove that deceleration occurred.

If an 80,000 pound truck traveling at 70mph impacts a 3,000 pound stationary car not permanently attached to anything, the truck is not going to change direction. The truck will decelerate, but it won't change direction (this example does not take vectors into account for simplicity).
 
Last edited:
That's because the mass of the smaller objects are more similar, and the force exerted by the fence is enough to cause a greater deceleration in the toy truck.

The larger truck still decelerates when it impacts the larger fence. A change in the direction of motion of the larger object is not necessary to prove that deceleration occurred.

If an 80,000 pound truck traveling at 70mph impacts a 3,000 pound stationary car not permanently attached to anything, the truck is not going to change direction. The truck will decelerate, but it won't change direction (this example does not take vectors into account for simplicity).

Does that mean that scale matters??
 
Does that mean that scale matters??

Not the way you want it to. Nice try.

The smaller objects exert equal and opposite forces on each other during a collision. The larger objects exert equal and opposite forces on each other during a collision. You could put the toy truck in front of the large truck and have the large truck run over it at 100mph. At the moment of impact, the toy truck is still going to exert an equal and opposite force on the large truck, and the truck will decelerate, even if the magnitude is extremely small.

Put the larger truck on a completely flat, frictionless surface with no air resistance. Apply a one time force to accelerate the truck. In front of the path of the larger truck place an infinite number of toy trucks spaced an inch apart. Even if you remove friction and air resistance, the truck will eventually come to a stop because each toy truck will decelerate the larger truck with each collision, even if the deceleration is extremely minor. The deceleration will not be constant, because the trucks are not applying constant force in the opposite direction of travel. Each impact would cause an impulse deceleration.
 
Last edited:
Wrong. Constant downward acceleration can been seen right here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjSd9wB55zk and here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJf7pWVyvIw

What conditions are necessary for this to happen?

I have already said it repeatedly, so I'm not going to do it again.

Did you miss the bit where Chandler said "approximately constant", i.e not constant, in that there are small deviations where the resistance varies as you might expect in a building collapse.

You're not a clunkety clunk truther are you?
 
Did you miss the bit where Chandler said "approximately constant", i.e not constant, in that there are small deviations where the resistance varies as you might expect in a building collapse.

You're not a clunkety clunk truther are you?

I have no idea what a clunkety clunk truther is.

I also know that the small deviations are not caused by impacts from floors below. The deviations are much smaller than one would expect in a collapse of a steel-framed high rise.
 
Not the way you want it to. Nice try.

The smaller objects exert equal and opposite forces on each other during a collision. The larger objects exert equal and opposite forces on each other during a collision. You could put the toy truck in front of the large truck and have the large truck run over it at 100mph. At the moment of impact, the toy truck is still going to exert an equal and opposite force on the large truck, and the truck will decelerate, even if the magnitude is extremely small.

Put the larger truck on a completely flat, frictionless surface with no air resistance. Apply a one time force to accelerate the truck. In front of the path of the larger truck place an infinite number of toy trucks spaced an inch apart. Even if you remove friction and air resistance, the truck will eventually come to a stop because each toy truck will decelerate the larger truck with each collision, even if the deceleration is extremely minor. The deceleration will not be constant, because the trucks are not applying constant force in the opposite direction of travel. Each impact would cause an impulse deceleration.
Thanks for showing you are ignoring what Phantwolf was trying to tell you.

And also thanks for using a whole lot of words denying the importance of scale, while actually acknowledging that scale does matter.
 
That's because the mass of the smaller objects are more similar, and the force exerted by the fence is enough to cause a greater deceleration in the toy truck.

Actually it has nothing to do with the mass, for instance I can put a block of lead in the truck trailer and still get the same result with it bouncing off the "fence". The difference is that the Popsicle sticks have a higher tensile strength for their size than the full size fence, so they can proportionally absorb and reflect more of the energy in the collision that the full scale versions can in theirs. It's a scaling issue not a mass one. The same reason I can take the matchbox truck up to the second story of a building and drop it with very little damage being the result, but if I tried taking the full scale version to the same height and dropped it, the damage would be considerable.

The larger truck still decelerates when it impacts the larger fence. A change in the direction of motion of the larger object is not necessary to prove that deceleration occurred.

If an 80,000 pound truck traveling at 70mph impacts a 3,000 pound stationary car not permanently attached to anything, the truck is not going to change direction. The truck will decelerate, but it won't change direction (this example does not take vectors into account for simplicity).

No, a truck going through a fence with the accelerator to the floor will continue to accelerate the entire time, it may however not accelerate as much as a truck with the pedal to the floor that misses the fence.

The fence will apply a force back onto the truck until the forces on the fence are too much for it and it breaks, at which point it no longer applies a force on the truck.

Likewise with the car. If the truck is still accelerating when it hits the car, it will only decelerate (have a negative acceleration) if the force from the car is applied to the truck long enough to overcome the force being provided by the wheels of the truck from its engine.

The negative acceleration from the car has to be added to the positive acceleration from the engine, and unless these cancel then there is still a positive acceleration. To create a negative acceleration you have to apply a negative acceleration greater than the acceleration being applied by the engine.
 
I have no idea what a clunkety clunk truther is.

I also know that the small deviations are not caused by impacts from floors below. The deviations are much smaller than one would expect in a collapse of a steel-framed high rise.

The WTC wasn't a steel framed High-rise, it was a steel inner-outer tube structure.
 
The fact that a video was posted on YouTube has no effect on its credibility.

I didn't say it did. I said they were discredited 'quite early on' [in the thread].

I'll try something else here: Can you explain why scale is immaterial?
 
Wrong. Constant downward acceleration can been seen right here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjSd9wB55zk and here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJf7pWVyvIw

What conditions are necessary for this to happen?

I have already said it repeatedly, so I'm not going to do it again.

Then why does Chandler's own graph show an acceleration, then a deceleration, then a constant fall at the speed offered by the buildings resistance at 36 percent?
You debunked yourself.:D
 
To actually see a deceleration then the Force of the Impact (Fi) > Force applied by Gravity (Fg)

Fi = 2m(s - vit)/ t2
where vi is the velocity of the impactor, s is the distance the impacted object is displaced before it fails, and t is the time required for the impacted object to travel that distance.

Fg = mg

rearranging all of this we have that as long as...

2(s - vit)/t2 < g

there will be no negative acceleration during the collision.
 
YouTube link, I did the experiments that lead to the incite used in that paper that allowed the resistance of the towers to be caculated Banzant had it wrong.
It is all recorded on the old physorg forum, I was able to figure out how the connections failed, and the maxwell equation for a pinned beam provided the math.

Cole and FF, don't have to debunk Banzant, they have to debunk me, and they can't because it is experimentally proven repeatedly as well as mathmatically.

Inorite?
 
If you are asking about average acceleration you have completely failed to understand my argument, or you are making a weak attempt to distract me. You have failed. Try again, sweetie.

See? Look what you wriote, right there! It's so cute!

You are still acting as if the primary mass of debris fell en bloc; you are still ignoring the fact that you, yourself, have said that the mass fell at an acceleration less than g.

I suppose you think the mass should have fallen like a todler stomping downstairs: "thud (pause) thud (pause) thud (pause)".

Unless you are going to identify a specific bit of debris, and trace the forces acting just upon it, all you can speak of is the average acceleration (and average velocity) of the mass. The fact that reality is, to your "argument", a "distraction" should give you a certain...pause.

A mass fell. The time it took it to fall demonstrates that it did not fall at or near g. What, in your personal opinion, slowed it down?
 
I guess I'm going to need to start handing out pacifiers. Your post is the equivalent of a temper tantrum. You're frustrated that Newton keeps proving you're posts are wrong, and you can't deal with it.

Take a deep breath and try to comprehend the basic concepts that Newton teaches us instead of attacking me.

You know none of this proves anything other than Aircraft impact + fire did it, right?
 
If you want to know what I think, watch the video.

I see. I asked for your own, personal opinion; you send me clickbait. You decline to state your own, personal opinion.

OTH, I know what it was that impeded the fall of the main mass of debris, resulting in an average acceleration less than g.

I also know that none of the falling debris fell at an acceleration higher than g.
 
Why? Instead of stating that it is sad, please give examples of how the paper is wrong.

None of this matters. I have already conceded that you can have fantasy steel and a fantasy building. With fantasy steel in a fantasy building none of the above matters.

Explain the reason two steel-framed buildings collapsed at a constant acceleration. Here, let me do it for you. They collapsed at a constant acceleration because there were no intermittent, or implulse, forces in the opposite direction. This can only happen if the floors were removed by an external force as the upper floors collapsed. Period. Deny it all you want, but you're wrong. Bazant is wrong. Deal with it. It does not matter if I say he's wrong, Newton says he's wrong, and that is what matters.

And here dear, is one of the places you do err. You seem to expect the mass of debris to have fallen as a siongle, cohesive object; it demonstrably did not.

What caused the mass to fall at an average acceleration significantly less than g?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom