If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
The OOS collapse bypassed the core... but the floors within the core destroyed the bracing inside the core and left the remaining columns too unstable to stand without it. They broke at their joints and collapse of toppled over...

Your understanding and observations are way off. You are a science denier... much like Gage et al.

JSO, wouldn't some of the core columns and beams fall though the core, sphereing though the floors as they fell?
Wouldn't the breakage of the connections to the core produce vibrations, that work the core columns in leveraged actions compressing the ductile steel against the less ductile weld?

Wouldn't this work age of the welds induce deformations leading to columns fracturing under their own weight?

Simple OOS does not give really an accurate picture of the physics of global collapse because of what it tends to ignore.
 
I'm quoting this from page 3 of the thread. Many pages later FalseFlag has accepted that the collapse time was greater, and the average acceleration less, than he claimed at first. Yet the erroneous observation that leads to the CD conclusion has led to no change in the CD claim.

I wonder if there's some cognitive dissonance bubbling away in the background. I have noticed a slight change of tone.


Probably. I think FF is so limited in his reasoning that "Free Fall!", in his mind, trumps all counter argument.
 
I guess I'm going to need to start handing out pacifiers. Your post is the equivalent of a temper tantrum. You're frustrated that Newton keeps proving you're posts are wrong, and you can't deal with it.

Take a deep breath and try to comprehend the basic concepts that Newton teaches us instead of attacking me.

Here's what you do FF, I assume you live in or near a city large enough to include universities and colleges. Go to the nearest one and find a physicist or engineer then explain your concept of Newtonian mechanics to them (don't mention 9/11, you don't want to scare them off by threatening their jobs and govie funding!).

Now make sure you bring a camera capable of capturing video with you! Explain why you "think" any collision regardless of scale will produce visual evidence of deceleration (or is it acceleration?) then come back here and post the video so these SHILLS finally understand!

I'd do it but I truly don't understand physics the way you do.
 
The floors should have exerted an opposite and equal force on the falling mass.


This is false.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

The force of the gravitational attraction between the earth and the falling mass acts upon the falling mass, pulling it downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the earth, pulling it upward. (The earth, being rather large, does not move very much as a result of that pull. F = ma means a = F/m.)

Simultaneously, the force of the impact between the falling mass and a floor acts upon the floor, breaking it and accelerating the floor material downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the falling mass. That force might decelerate the falling mass, but only if that force exceeds the force of gravity pulling the falling mass down.

There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater, there was no deceleration.
 
Last edited:
This is false.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

The force of the gravitational attraction betweens the earth and the falling mass acts upon the falling mass, pulling it downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the earth, pulling it upward. (The earth, being rather large, does not move very much as a result of that pull. F = ma means a = F/m.)

Simultaneously, the force of the impact between the falling mass and a floor acts upon the floor, breaking it and accelerating the floor material downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the falling mass. That force might decelerate the falling mass, but only if that force exceeds the force of gravity pulling the falling mass down.

There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater, there was no deceleration.

Exactly why I said it had to be Captain Kirk with a tractor beam, but that went right over false flags head.
 
This is false.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

The force of the gravitational attraction between the earth and the falling mass acts upon the falling mass, pulling it downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the earth, pulling it upward. (The earth, being rather large, does not move very much as a result of that pull. F = ma means a = F/m.)

Simultaneously, the force of the impact between the falling mass and a floor acts upon the floor, breaking it and accelerating the floor material downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the falling mass. That force might decelerate the falling mass, but only if that force exceeds the force of gravity pulling the falling mass down.

There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater, there was no deceleration.


Considering this is your 10th year at least on this forum, Myriad, I am left wondering how many times you have had to use that exact explanation over the course of 9/11 discussions.
 
Considering this is your 10th year at least on this forum, Myriad, I am left wondering how many times you have had to use that exact explanation over the course of 9/11 discussions.

It's a good way to explain it as it separates the motive force from the resistive force and explains how they're of different magnitudes. Many have tried in their various ways and I even started a tongue-in-cheek "Newton's Third Law for Truthers" thread some time back.
 
JSO, wouldn't some of the core columns and beams fall though the core, sphereing though the floors as they fell?
Wouldn't the breakage of the connections to the core produce vibrations, that work the core columns in leveraged actions compressing the ductile steel against the less ductile weld?

Wouldn't this work age of the welds induce deformations leading to columns fracturing under their own weight?

Simple OOS does not give really an accurate picture of the physics of global collapse because of what it tends to ignore.

The inside the core destruction was similar to the OOS. You had some very heavy gear such as elevator motors in MOST of the bays which would destroy the floors BELOW the shafts... and likely rip off the bracing steel. As we see in "spire"... remaining core columns... they were too slender and unstable to self support and collapse from their own weight, breaking weak splices... and being jostled by the collapse and even the wind!

The facade pretty much peeled away when the floor plates were gone... broke into sections and panels because the splices didn't hold.

But inside and outside... the column destruction was CAUSED by the floor collapsing. The structure was COMPOSITE... the steel columns could not stand without bracing... the floors WERE the bracing.

I have my doubts that a core of just the columns and the bracing would stand up too long without the concrete slabs preventing twisting and breaking the connections.

Composites get their strength from the elements of the composite working together... and lose it when they don't or are missing.
 
It's a good way to explain it as it separates the motive force from the resistive force and explains how they're of different magnitudes. Many have tried in their various ways and I even started a tongue-in-cheek "Newton's Third Law for Truthers" thread some time back.


Just for clarification, I didn't mean it as any sort of a criticism towards Myriad's post. It was quite precise. I was commenting on the frustrating number of times the post was necessary.

:)
 
Just for clarification, I didn't mean it as any sort of a criticism towards Myriad's post. It was quite precise. I was commenting on the frustrating number of times the post was necessary.

:)

Yeah, I get that and agree. It should be bookmarked :)
 
The inside the core destruction was similar to the OOS. You had some very heavy gear such as elevator motors in MOST of the bays which would destroy the floors BELOW the shafts... and likely rip off the bracing steel. As we see in "spire"... remaining core columns... they were too slender and unstable to self support and collapse from their own weight, breaking weak splices... and being jostled by the collapse and even the wind!

The facade pretty much peeled away when the floor plates were gone... broke into sections and panels because the splices didn't hold.

But inside and outside... the column destruction was CAUSED by the floor collapsing. The structure was COMPOSITE... the steel columns could not stand without bracing... the floors WERE the bracing.

I have my doubts that a core of just the columns and the bracing would stand up too long without the concrete slabs preventing twisting and breaking the connections.

Composites get their strength from the elements of the composite working together... and lose it when they don't or are missing.

Ah and there is my problem with ROOSD I did the calculations, and at one million foot pound per square inch the too slinderness theory only explains the top one third of column failures, not the bottom 2/3rds.

The rain of mass has to be damaging the welds, as well as floor connections otherwise there would have been significantly greater core fragment survival.

Unfortunately everyone thinks ROOSD solves everything with out the math to back it up.:confused:
 
I'm confused by some of the acronyms you guys are using. What are OOS and ROOSD? I've tried googling them but don't get a lot of help there.
 
I'm confused by some of the acronyms you guys are using. What are OOS and ROOSD? I've tried googling them but don't get a lot of help there.

Open Office Space
and
Runaway Open Office Space Destruction (or similar)

I suppose it's handy to pin the main mechanism to floor collapse rather than column-driven collapse.
 
Last edited:
FalseFlag said:
The floors should have exerted an opposite and equal force on the falling mass.
This is false.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

The force of the gravitational attraction between the earth and the falling mass acts upon the falling mass, pulling it downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the earth, pulling it upward. (The earth, being rather large, does not move very much as a result of that pull. F = ma means a = F/m.)

Simultaneously, the force of the impact between the falling mass and a floor acts upon the floor, breaking it and accelerating the floor material downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the falling mass. That force might decelerate the falling mass, but only if that force exceeds the force of gravity pulling the falling mass down.

There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater, there was no deceleration.



Just for clarification, I didn't mean it as any sort of a criticism towards Myriad's post. It was quite precise. I was commenting on the frustrating number of times the post was necessary.

:)
Yeah, I get that and agree. It should be bookmarked :)
This is how I bookmark such posts:

#oysteinbookmark

;)
 
Considering this is your 10th year at least on this forum, Myriad, I am left wondering how many times you have had to use that exact explanation over the course of 9/11 discussions.

Don't you read my posts?

Look at this thread in a years time, it will be the same or there will be another identical thread.

Truthers just want to keep the argument going, that is their victory, they know what they post is fantasy, no right minded person could have such a wrong idea of physics and the events of 9/11.

Myriad is playing the role of Sisyphus, doomed to roll facts up against the hill of Truther Woo.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom