If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Your argument is that the media outlet makes the content not credible?

So the videos from these accounts are not credible because they are on YouTube?

https://www.youtube.com/user/NASAtelevision

https://www.youtube.com/user/fbi/videos

https://www.youtube.com/user/whitehouse

https://www.youtube.com/user/NationalGeographic

Oh, wait, these guys are also on YouTube:

https://www.youtube.com/user/usnistgov

They certainly have no credibility, so you just might be right.

Interesting attempt to pretend I said something I did not. I have explained, elsewhere, my distaste for video "proof".

I notice you did not provide the least bit of citation, or explain what you, personally, think the video to which you link shows. I would be very interested in reading it.

Care to do that?

Ta ever so.
 
Last edited:
Why wasn't this paper printed in a known and respected engineering journal?

I tell you why, because no respected engineering journal would touch it. They have minimum standards.

Not only that the paper I linked was published in 2008, that paper from Gordon Ross was published in 2005.
FF apearently doesn't know the paper I linked proved Ross completely wrong!
 
...maybe if you had a YouTube link...?

YouTube link, I did the experiments that lead to the incite used in that paper that allowed the resistance of the towers to be caculated Banzant had it wrong.
It is all recorded on the old physorg forum, I was able to figure out how the connections failed, and the maxwell equation for a pinned beam provided the math.

Cole and FF, don't have to debunk Banzant, they have to debunk me, and they can't because it is experimentally proven repeatedly as well as mathmatically.
 
And how is this different from the blacksmith heating the rod to 1800 degrees? He clearly says jet fuel burns at 1500 degrees, yet he heats the rod to 1800 degrees. He also claims the rod is structural steel. This implies he is talking about structures. He is talking about 9/11. The WTC towers were made of structural steel. What more do you want? You know he was talking about the WTC buildings. It is implied.

What is your point by your argument? Your argument is absolutely pointless, and it's no longer worth discussing. Continue all you want, but you will do so without me.

This is just another game of semantics. You can continue playing on your own.

So now you are denying that he compares a steel rod to the towers? Typical :)
 
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 12


Maybe he should do the following experiment. He should go to the harbour, and ask a friendly cranedriver to dump a container on his car. Maybe he could make a video, to show us how much the container jumped upwards after it hits his car.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove reference to ignore lists. Discussing who you are putting on ignore is rarely civil and almost never on topic, thus breaching rule 0 and rule 11.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
While you continue to align yourself with idiots, nuts and liars like Richard Gage, David Ray Griffin, Steven Jones, etc. The bottom 1/10 of 1% of the scum of the world.

This post consists of nothing but ad hominem attacks on people you don't agree with, but you fail to state why you don't agree.
 

I hadn't seen that Ross paper; it's pretty sad:

Ross said:
The first error which Dr. Bazant has made is his assumption that all of the available energy would be utilised exclusively in the destruction of the uppermost storey of the lower section. This is physically impossible under any and all circumstances.

Ross is famous for his logic errors, but this one is a doozy: Bazant makes no such "assumption" and in fact what his analysis actually concludes is that no such assumption is necessary: If only 1/8th of the gravitational potential energy was delivered to the impact, that would have been enough to collapse the columns (even if they all buckled, which didn't happen, anyway). I should think that someone who is supposed to be a mechanical engineer would have a better understanding of Bazant's logic, but suffice it to say that anyone who doesn't understand it is in no position to criticize it.

Ross said:
The second error made by Dr. Bazant is his failure to take account of the factor of safety designed into the towers' construction. He makes no mention whatsoever of this crucial design parameter.

And another logic error: Bazant "makes no mention" of a factor of safety, therefore he must have failed to take it into account? The Bazant & Zhou paper was written before any design details were available, so they estimated a weight for the building and then estimated the columns that standard engineering practice would design for that weight. Ross gives no reason whatsoever for claiming that one of the world's foremost structural mechanics theoreticians, one who writes textbooks, would "forget" to include standard safety factors.

Sure looks to me like Ross = garbage.
 
Why wasn't this paper printed in a known and respected engineering journal?

I tell you why, because no respected engineering journal would touch it. They have minimum standards.

No, they don't have minimum standards. The issue is too political for them (engineering journals) to touch it, and they don't want to lose their funding. That is the reality. I already know you will deny it, but that is the answer.

The Bazant paper can be found on Northwestern University servers. Is that because it's credible? No. The paper has been thoroughly proven to be worthless. It's on university servers because they don't want to lose their government funding.

Once again, deny it all you want. That is the reality of the situation.
 
Poor FF won't get the reference. This was all thoroughly discussed and dismissed long ago, in the Age of Heiwa and of Gordon Ross. (Where are they now? Ross at least had a legit engineering license, but it seems he's long gone from Trutherism. FF would do well to review these threads from long ago.) :rolleyes:

Why should I take the time to find the posts and read them? You are making an argument, so you should summarize the posts for me.

What? You can do it, but I can't? Fair is fair.
 
No, sweetie, you "answered" the question you wish I had asked.

Here, again, is a question you have not answered:

What do you, personally, think caused the average acceleration of the main mass of debris to be significantly less than the acceleration due to gravity?

If you are asking about average acceleration you have completely failed to understand my argument, or you are making a weak attempt to distract me. You have failed. Try again, sweetie.
 
Interesting attempt to pretend I said something I did not. I have explained, elsewhere, my distaste for video "proof".

I notice you did not provide the least bit of citation, or explain what you, personally, think the video to which you link shows. I would be very interested in reading it.

Care to do that?

Ta ever so.


If you want to know what I think, watch the video.
 
there is no reasoning with this person.

I just read the entire thread, and the lengths FF goes to in order to avoid the burden of proof are worthy of comment.

Jay Whindley proven right yet again. 9/11 truth certainly know how to frustrate the debate process.
 
Last edited:
I hadn't seen that Ross paper; it's pretty sad:
Why? Instead of stating that it is sad, please give examples of how the paper is wrong.

Ross is famous for his logic errors, but this one is a doozy: Bazant makes no such "assumption" and in fact what his analysis actually concludes is that no such assumption is necessary: If only 1/8th of the gravitational potential energy was delivered to the impact, that would have been enough to collapse the columns (even if they all buckled, which didn't happen, anyway). I should think that someone who is supposed to be a mechanical engineer would have a better understanding of Bazant's logic, but suffice it to say that anyone who doesn't understand it is in no position to criticize it.

And another logic error: Bazant "makes no mention" of a factor of safety, therefore he must have failed to take it into account? The Bazant & Zhou paper was written before any design details were available, so they estimated a weight for the building and then estimated the columns that standard engineering practice would design for that weight. Ross gives no reason whatsoever for claiming that one of the world's foremost structural mechanics theoreticians, one who writes textbooks, would "forget" to include standard safety factors.

Sure looks to me like Ross = garbage.

None of this matters. I have already conceded that you can have fantasy steel and a fantasy building. With fantasy steel in a fantasy building none of the above matters.

Explain the reason two steel-framed buildings collapsed at a constant acceleration. Here, let me do it for you. They collapsed at a constant acceleration because there were no intermittent, or implulse, forces in the opposite direction. This can only happen if the floors were removed by an external force as the upper floors collapsed. Period. Deny it all you want, but you're wrong. Bazant is wrong. Deal with it. It does not matter if I say he's wrong, Newton says he's wrong, and that is what matters.
 
Last edited:
I just read the entire thread, and the lengths FF goes to in order to avoid the burden of proof are worthy of comment.

Jay Whindley proven right yet again. 9/11 truth certainly know how to frustrate the debate process.

*Buzzer sound*

Wrong. I have spent hours giving proof. You just refuse to accept it.

-1 for your credibility. Thanks for playing.
 
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove previously moderated content.


Maybe he should do the following experiment. He should go to the harbour, and ask a friendly cranedriver to dump a container on his car. Maybe he could make a video, to show us how much the container jumped upwards after it hits his car.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove previously moderated content.

OK. How about this. We can use my car if you pay for the container, the crane, and a high speed camera capable of recording at extremely high speeds. Here, how about this one that records a trillion frames per second. It's so fast it can record light waves. http://www.wired.com/2011/12/trillion-fps-camera-captures-advancing-light-waves

Once everything is in place, record the container dropping on my car. Make sure you get the acceleration of the container as it falls. Make sure you carry the value out to enough decimal places. Then, as the container impacts the car, tell me what the acceleration is before and after the impact. I will bet you $1000 the acceleration will decrease, even though the magnitude will be extremely small. The acceleration of the container will NOT be constant once it hits the car and crashes to the ground.

My guess is that the deceleration would be visibly noticeable for tens of thousands of frames, if the record rate was a trillion frames per second.

Newton proved this long ago. Why do you refuse to accept it?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
YouTube link, I did the experiments that lead to the incite used in that paper that allowed the resistance of the towers to be caculated Banzant had it wrong.
It is all recorded on the old physorg forum, I was able to figure out how the connections failed, and the maxwell equation for a pinned beam provided the math.

Cole and FF, don't have to debunk Banzant, they have to debunk me, and they can't because it is experimentally proven repeatedly as well as mathmatically.

Post this magical paper.
 
Because of course we have such footage available from 11th Sept 2001 to compare it with, don't we. :rolleyes:

What? Did you really just post that? The example was a collision in which an obviously larger object impacts a smaller object. An attempt was made to claim that there would be no deceleration because of the size of the objects.

You don't need a high speed camera to see the constant acceleration of the upper floors of the WTC buildings. Additionally, the upper floors were the smaller mass, not the larger.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom