If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nonsense. Your post is proof you don't understand the concept of acceleration. Speed is not the issue. The issue is that the towers fell at an acceleration that was constant. Prove to me you understand the meaning of this.

Did the mass and energy accumulate, can you answer that one simple question?
 
LOL...Bazant is probably the most brilliant structural engineer on the planet. By the way, how can you say it is garbage when you lack the education to understand it?

Again, not a personal attack...you are the one who said you are not an expert.

The Bazant paper does not model what is observed. You don't need to be an expert to understand it's garbage.
 
The floors should have exerted an opposite and equal force on the falling mass. This means that the deceleration could not be constant, since the resistance was temporary and only felt with each floor impact. Since acceleration was constant, this means there were no impacts with lower floors. This means the floors were removed. The only conclusion from this is obvious.

How do you know that part? From what I've seen, all we can tell is some average acceleration. There could very well be variation we just can't spot in a video. Wasn't it falling at something like 10 floors a second? It would be pretty hard to distinguish a 1/10th of a second variation through a cloud of dust and debris - but I'm game to hear how it was done.

But I'm thinking the scenario you present might very well have happened to some degree and we simply can't spot it.
 
The Bazant paper does not model what is observed. You don't need to be an expert to understand it's garbage.

It was never ment to, it models a limited case, theoretical collapse with the most resistance to collapse the buildings can provide.
You did understand that according to the Banzant paper the towers would have alined perfectly after buckling each 36 foot section, and still the towers collapse.
Banzant show that given the maximum upward force the lower block can provide the towers still collapse.
 
How do you know that part? From what I've seen, all we can tell is some average acceleration. There could very well be variation we just can't spot in a video. Wasn't it falling at something like 10 floors a second? It would be pretty hard to distinguish a 1/10th of a second variation through a cloud of dust and debris - but I'm game to hear how it was done.

But I'm thinking the scenario you present might very well have happened to some degree and we simply can't spot it.


See post #764.
 
A youtube link... lovely. Nevermind then. :rolleyes:

Good tactic. Discredit YouTube, because you know mainstream media will never cover this.

Well done, but your answer is in the video.

It's also worth noting that the blacksmith video was posted on YouTube. Not one skeptic had a problem with where it was posted.

It's also worth nothing that NMSR posts on YouTube. You skeptics have no problem posting those videos. You also have no problem posting verinage videos posted on YouTube. It's very simple. If it supports your views, YouTube is OK. If it questions your views, or outright proves you're full of BS, YouTube is not credible.

The hypocrisy is extreme.
 
Last edited:
Good tactic. Discredit YouTube, because you know mainstream media will never cover this.

Well done, but your answer is in the video.

It's also worth noting that the blacksmith video was posted on YouTube. Not one skeptic had a problem with where it was posted.

If you can't answer a question with a writeup but must rely on a youtube video then I'm not particularly interested in discussing issues with you. Hence the "nevermind" part of my post. Unless you'd like to actually describe the basis for your claim then maybe you could get on with that?

On Edit: It's all well and good to use video to support your claims. But when you can't write a description for what the video purports to show then it's obvious you don't have a real basis for your claim.
 
Last edited:
If you can't answer a question with a writeup but must rely on a youtube video then I'm not particularly interested in discussing issues with you. Hence the "nevermind" part of my post. Unless you'd like to actually describe the basis for your claim then maybe you could get on with that?

It would be nice if he had a valid claim, to start with.
 
If you can't answer a question with a writeup but must rely on a youtube video then I'm not particularly interested in discussing issues with you. Hence the "nevermind" part of my post. Unless you'd like to actually describe the basis for your claim then maybe you could get on with that?

No, because I learned a long time ago that nothing a truther posts here is accepted. I'm not going to type something that can be explained in a video. It's a waste of time. Watch the video, or your question will remain unanswered.
 
No, because I learned a long time ago that nothing a truther posts here is accepted. I'm not going to type something that can be explained in a video. It's a waste of time. Watch the video, or your question will remain unanswered.

So you can't assemble a description? All right then. Guess your claim goes in the dustbin.
 
Originally Posted by FalseFlag
OK.

Let's simplify this. The steel in the towers does exactly what the skeptics want it to, at all times. It weakens, melts, or whatever you want. None of this matters, though. It doesn't matter one single bit.

As I said before, you can magically remove 20 or 30 floors by whatever means you wish, and then drop the remaining floors on the rest of the building. At the moment of impact, there will be a deceleration. The deceleration will continue until the movement stops, or the top reaches the ground. The only way the top will continue to accelerate is if the lower floors are removed prior to the impact of the upper floors. Go ahead and deny this, but you are denying the most fundamental laws of motion.

In summary, go ahead, pretend the steel can do whatever you want it to. It changes nothing. Newton's third law applies, is valid, and doesn't change with scale.

Next thing ya know, FF will be saying that even a moon sized pile of rubble would decelerate.

Poor FF won't get the reference. This was all thoroughly discussed and dismissed long ago, in the Age of Heiwa and of Gordon Ross. (Where are they now? Ross at least had a legit engineering license, but it seems he's long gone from Trutherism. FF would do well to review these threads from long ago.) :rolleyes:
 
I answered your questions, even though I knew you would ignore the answers.

No, sweetie, you "answered" the question you wish I had asked.

Here, again, is a question you have not answered:

What do you, personally, think caused the average acceleration of the main mass of debris to be significantly less than the acceleration due to gravity?
 
Last edited:
Poor FF won't get the reference. This was all thoroughly discussed and dismissed long ago, in the Age of Heiwa and of Gordon Ross. (Where are they now? Ross at least had a legit engineering license, but it seems he's long gone from Trutherism. FF would do well to review these threads from long ago.) :rolleyes:

Oh boy - Heiwa! I'd forgotten that particular branch of trutherism.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom