If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
What about Newton? What did he do to you? Oh, I'm sorry. I know the answer. He shatters your fantasy and delusions of the official 9/11 story.

Newton...I love Newton, his work clearly shows how the natural progressive collapse took place. Read some of Prof. Bazant papers, and how Newtonian physics work. BTW...Bazant is considered one of the most brilliant structural engineers on the planet.
 
Fascinating. Like a horrid train wreck from which one simply cannot avert one's eyes...

What do you, personally, think caused the average acceleration of the main mass of debris to be significantly less that the acceleration due to gravity?

He doesn't realize it is him and Cole who are making Newton spin in his grave, any speed less than G is evidence of structure below the collapse providing resistance to collapse.
 
He doesn't realize it is him and Cole who are making Newton spin in his grave, any speed less than G is evidence of structure below the collapse providing resistance to collapse.

I know that...

YOU know that...

I can explain that to a roomful of hormone-crazed ESL 9th-graders to the point that THEY know that...

The rest is, as they say, an exercise for the student.
 
What possible value would such have? Do you really think that if somebody dies ramming their car into a tree a forensic investigation should ensue into exactly how the car crumpled? Do you think that's a "thing"?

Yes, it's a thing. It's a thing that http://www.nhtsa.gov/ is devoted to.

1. They set standards. They do not forensically examine every crash.

2. America is not the levant in the first century AD.

3. Whatever standard they apply do not so apply to the other 95% of the world.

Need I continue?
 
I know that...

YOU know that...

I can explain that to a roomful of hormone-crazed ESL 9th-graders to the point that THEY know that...

The rest is, as they say, an exercise for the student.

I explained to a six year old, using drawings to help of course, and she got it instantly, some people though it goes from ear to ear, and hits nothing in between.:jaw-dropp
 
This is what we call the Unevaluated Inequality Fallacy. There are two primary forces acting upon the falling mass: the attraction of earth's gravity, a downward force, and the resistance presented by the resisting members of the lower structure (which were the floors), an upward force. Call the former Fdown and the latter Fup.

Agreed.

By claiming that the falling mass should have decelerated, you are claiming that the Fdown should have been less than Fup. Because of course if Fdown were greater than Fup the mass would continue accelerating downward as was observed.

This is a misunderstanding of acceleration and velocity. I am also not claiming that the downward force is less than the upwards force (even though it actually was as it constantly accelerated, but this is a different concept).

Based on your first paragraph, we both agree that the lower floors would have and should have exerted an upward force on the falling mass. We are in 100 percent agreement on this.

Here's where the issue is. As the falling mass impacted the lower floors, the lower floors would provide resistance to the fall during each impact. It does not matter how great the resistance is, and it doesn't matter which object exerted the greater force. What matters is that whatever the magnitude of this resistance was, it was in the opposite direction of the force exerted by the falling upper floors. Newton's third law says this.

The force exerted by each floor during each impact would not be constant. The force would be temporary, and since it was in the opposite direction, it would cause the floors to decelerate. The magnitude of the deceleration is insignificant. What matters is that any temporary force in the opposite direction of the falling floors is going to change the acceleration of the floors. If there are any temporary changes in acceleration, the acceleration, by definition, can not be constant.

The floors should have exerted an opposite and equal force on the falling mass. This means that the deceleration could not be constant, since the resistance was temporary and only felt with each floor impact. Since acceleration was constant, this means there were no impacts with lower floors. This means the floors were removed. The only conclusion from this is obvious.
 
1. They set standards. They do not forensically examine every crash.

2. America is not the levant in the first century AD.

3. Whatever standard they apply do not so apply to the other 95% of the world.

Need I continue?

You asked if it was a thing. The answer is yes, regardless of how often it's done.
 
Fascinating. Like a horrid train wreck from which one simply cannot avert one's eyes...

What do you, personally, think caused the average acceleration of the main mass of debris to be significantly less that the acceleration due to gravity?

I answered your questions, even though I knew you would ignore the answers.
 
He doesn't realize it is him and Cole who are making Newton spin in his grave, any speed less than G is evidence of structure below the collapse providing resistance to collapse.

Nonsense. Your post is proof you don't understand the concept of acceleration. Speed is not the issue. The issue is that the towers fell at an acceleration that was constant. Prove to me you understand the meaning of this.
 
754 posts in this thread, and so much denial. So. Much. Denial. Why? What do you get from denying the obvious?
 
The Bazant paper is garbage. It's proof that credentials are meaningless when it comes to 9/11.

LOL...Bazant is probably the most brilliant structural engineer on the planet. By the way, how can you say it is garbage when you lack the education to understand it?

Again, not a personal attack...you are the one who said you are not an expert.
 
For more argumentum ad YouTube? That's so sweet.

Your argument is that the media outlet makes the content not credible?

So the videos from these accounts are not credible because they are on YouTube?

https://www.youtube.com/user/NASAtelevision

https://www.youtube.com/user/fbi/videos

https://www.youtube.com/user/whitehouse

https://www.youtube.com/user/NationalGeographic

Oh, wait, these guys are also on YouTube:

https://www.youtube.com/user/usnistgov

They certainly have no credibility, so you just might be right.
 
Last edited:
Agreed.



This is a misunderstanding of acceleration and velocity. I am also not claiming that the downward force is less than the upwards force (even though it actually was as it constantly accelerated, but this is a different concept).

Based on your first paragraph, we both agree that the lower floors would have and should have exerted an upward force on the falling mass. We are in 100 percent agreement on this.

Here's where the issue is. As the falling mass impacted the lower floors, the lower floors would provide resistance to the fall during each impact. It does not matter how great the resistance is, and it doesn't matter which object exerted the greater force. What matters is that whatever the magnitude of this resistance was, it was in the opposite direction of the force exerted by the falling upper floors. Newton's third law says this.

The force exerted by each floor during each impact would not be constant. The force would be temporary, and since it was in the opposite direction, it would cause the floors to decelerate. The magnitude of the deceleration is insignificant. What matters is that any temporary force in the opposite direction of the falling floors is going to change the acceleration of the floors. If there are any temporary changes in acceleration, the acceleration, by definition, can not be constant.

The floors should have exerted an opposite and equal force on the falling mass. This means that the deceleration could not be constant, since the resistance was temporary and only felt with each floor impact. Since acceleration was constant, this means there were no impacts with lower floors. This means the floors were removed. The only conclusion from this is obvious.

And false as the floor to floor impacts created sound and seismic waves, a proof the floors were impacted and provided a micro second, slowing of the collapses acceleration, which decreased over time as the mass accumulated and the gravitational energy built.
 
Nonsense. Your post is proof you don't understand the concept of acceleration. Speed is not the issue. The issue is that the towers fell at an acceleration that was constant. Prove to me you understand the meaning of this.

Who is claiming that the towers fell at at constant rate of acceleration and what is that claim based on? They weren't rigid bodies as they fell, and there are a number of threads here that get into the details of the difficulty of measuring the movement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom