If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
The resistance calculation per floor.
Fc(z, z˙) = Fb + Fs + Fa + Fe, Fb = Wd/(1 − λ)h

So you admit that each floor should have provided resistance, regardless of whether or not your formula is correct. That resistance would cause the upper floors to decelerate. Thanks for finally agreeing with Cole and Newton.
 
Personal attack.

You can keep going, but it's just not worth responding.
Your posts prove no practical knowledge of physics.

You keep proving without a doubt you don't understand physics. You call correct information, wrong because you don't understand physics.

Each floor slowed the velocity of the collapse... this is why it did not fall at g. And you keep telling lies about it.
 
You're not answering the question.

Oh really gravity is a constant force, and the connections failed,
Imagine not a chair but a bench composed of three boards, held by steel wood screws,
Now imagine your sitting on the bench and someone breaks the screws.
What happens to your rear?
 
According to David Chandler the buildings fell at 68% of free fall acceleration.

68% is closer to 50% than it is to 100%. So the more correct way to describe the collapse would be:

The buildings collapsed at near 1/2 free-fall.


Thank you for the clarification. I sometimes get WTC7 mixed up with WTC 1 and 2 when it comes to the value of the constant acceleration. It won't happen again.
 
...snip...
Edited by jsfisher: 
Posts announcing whom you will be ignoring are seldom civil and usually not on topic.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
...snip...
Edited by jsfisher: 
Posts announcing whom you will be ignoring are seldom civil and usually not on topic.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That is because FF and Cole seem to believe that the columns were involved in the collapse, post initiation. The collapse bypassed the columns.

Yes, and even for events where columns buckled, they provided their design resistance for only a fraction of an inch. After only a few inches of downward deflection and buckling, their resistance was insufficient to prevent the mass from accelerating again, with rapidly decreasing resistance, so that mass would also get to "near" free fall before the next collision. I always have to laugh at Chandler's weird belief that if you took out enough columns, the remaining ones would provide the "uniform" 0.64g acceleration that he imagines he measured. I'm still waiting for an explanation for how any type of CD could produce that result.
 
Last edited:
...snip...
Edited by jsfisher: 
Posts announcing whom you will be ignoring are seldom civil and usually not on topic.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So you admit that each floor should have provided resistance, regardless of whether or not your formula is correct. That resistance would cause the upper floors to decelerate. Thanks for finally agreeing with Cole and Newton.

Yes but the resistance is so low, you can never balance out the forces, to cause a noticible stop or slowing as the mass accumulated.
To cause noticeable deceleration the forces must near a point of equality, that is what can never happen because the dynamic loading quickly over comes the molecular energy of the electron bonding of the steel, that gives the bolts and welds their strength.
The balance of forces is where you and Cole are embarrassing failures.
 
That is because FF and Cole seem to believe that the columns were involved in the collapse, post initiation. The collapse bypassed the columns.

If the collapse bypassed the columns, why aren't the outer columns and inner columns still standing? The inner columns were a defacto building unto itself. It could have easily remained standing, if, as you claim, the collapse bypassed the columns.
 
Exactly.

What prevents you from accelerating downwards right now? It's probably a chair. The chair is exerting an equal and opposite force in the exact amount that gravity is exerting. That is why your vertical acceleration is zero (if you are sitting in a chair).

Now, take away the chair and the ground and the air. You would immediately accelerate towards the center of the earth at 9.8m/s/s. If there was nothing to stop you, you would continue to accelerate until you reached the center of the earth. Your acceleration would be a constant 9.8m/s/s. Your velocity would increase each second. You would not decelerate unless an opposite force was applied.

The top of the towers did encounter some air resistance. This is one of the reasons you can't claim they accelerated exactly at freefall, but, they did fall at close to that rate, and that rate (acceleration) was constant. How is that possible if there was so much undamaged structure below what initially collapsed? There is only one conclusion. That conclusion is that the lower floors were removed prior to impact. How were the floors removed? That's a good question, but the most likely hypothesis is controlled demolition.

Chandler, a high school physics teacher and truther, says it accelerates at .7 g

Can you agree to that?
 
I can live with that...

Personally, I would like look up to great minds like Einstein, not idiots like Gage, Chandler, Cole and Griffin.

What about Newton? What did he do to you? Oh, I'm sorry. I know the answer. He shatters your fantasy and delusions of the official 9/11 story.
 
If the collapse bypassed the columns, why aren't the outer columns and inner columns still standing? The inner columns were a defacto building unto itself. It could have easily remained standing, if, as you claim, the collapse bypassed the columns.

The column ends did not aline, however the welds on the columns were still violently vibrated
From side to side rapidly, as the floor girders, and beams were stripped from them.
That caused separation of the welded joints in the columns working them to where it was impossible for them to support their own weight.
 
Chandler, a high school physics teacher and truther, says it accelerates at .7 g

Can you agree to that?

Sure, but he's simply reading the result of a commonly-used physics program. So yes, I agree with the results of the computer program.
 
OK.

Let's simplify this. The steel in the towers does exactly what the skeptics want it to, at all times. It weakens, melts, or whatever you want. None of this matters, though. It doesn't matter one single bit.

As I said before, you can magically remove 20 or 30 floors by whatever means you wish, and then drop the remaining floors on the rest of the building. At the moment of impact, there will be a deceleration. The deceleration will continue until the movement stops, or the top reaches the ground. The only way the top will continue to accelerate is if the lower floors are removed prior to the impact of the upper floors. Go ahead and deny this, but you are denying the most fundamental laws of motion.

In summary, go ahead, pretend the steel can do whatever you want it to. It changes nothing. Newton's third law applies, is valid, and doesn't change with scale.


This is what we call the Unevaluated Inequality Fallacy. There are two primary forces acting upon the falling mass: the attraction of earth's gravity, a downward force, and the resistance presented by the resisting members of the lower structure (which were the floors), an upward force. Call the former Fdown and the latter Fup.

By claiming that the falling mass should have decelerated, you are claiming that the Fdown should have been less than Fup. Because of course if Fdown were greater than Fup the mass would continue accelerating downward as was observed.

But you have not quantified either value, so how do you know which is, or should be, greater? You make that part up out of nothing. Your argument amounts to declaring one greater than another (that's the inequality), without quantifying either number (that's the "unevaluated").

It's not particularly easy to quantify either force but when those with the expertise to do so have done so they don't find anything unexpected about the observed behavior of the structures.
 
Wrong.

A constant acceleration less than 9.8m/s/s is not evidence of deceleration.

What is the acceleration due to gravity?

At what average acceleration did the primary mass of the debris fall? (I can help you with the math, if you want...)

As for your second point, see here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvw0_i1rGns

You're welcome.

For more argumentum ad YouTube? That's so sweet.

For someone who arrogates to denigrate Wikipedia, you have...lax...standards. Selectively lax.

Is there a transcript to your "proof" video? Can you at least point out at what point you think the video support whatever claim you have not yet made, yet?

In your own words, what do you think the video to which you link indicates?
 
Last edited:
Wrong.

A constant acceleration less than 9.8m/s/s is not evidence of deceleration.

What is the acceleration due to gravity?

At what average acceleration did the primary mass of the debris fall? (I can help you with the math, if you want...)

What caused the difference?

What makes you call the resultant acceleration "constant"? (You really, really, really need to stop thinking of the falling debris as a solid block.)

As for your second point, see here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvw0_i1rGns

You're welcome.

For more argumentum ad YouTube? That's so sweet.

For someone who arrogates to denigrate Wikipedia, you have...lax...standards. Selectively lax.

Is there a transcript to your "proof" video? Can you at least point out at what point you think the video support whatever claim you have not yet made, yet?

In your own words, what do you think the video to which you link indicates?
 
So you admit that each floor should have provided resistance, regardless of whether or not your formula is correct. That resistance would cause the upper floors to decelerate. Thanks for finally agreeing with Cole and Newton.

Fascinating. Like a horrid train wreck from which one simply cannot avert one's eyes...

What do you, personally, think caused the average acceleration of the main mass of debris to be significantly less that the acceleration due to gravity?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom