If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wrong.

Absolutely wrong.

The top floors did not decelerate as they fell. The continued to accelerate as they fell.

Actually, sweetie, it is you who are wrong.

Try this one: At what rate did the primary mass of the debris of the tower accelerate, and in which direction?

At what rate would an unimpeded mass have accelerated, and in which direction?
 
According to David Chandler the buildings fell at 68% of free fall acceleration.

68% is closer to 50% than it is to 100%. So the more correct way to describe the collapse would be:

The buildings collapsed at near 1/2 free-fall.

OK. Was the acceleration constant? How is this possible?
 
Actually, yes. Some parts fell faster.

I will save you some time and tell you why your argument, which is coming next, is going to fail.

First, we already know that the top floors did not fall at freefall; therefore and object outside the main mass that does fall at freefall does NOT prove deceleration of the main mass.

Second, in some cases, objects outside the main mass fell faster than acceleration due to gravity? How is this possible? I know the answer, do you?
Nothing falling outside of the building exceeded an acceleration of g. Perhaos you'd care to elaborate on how you deduced that
 
OK, how long would it take for a bowling ball dropped from the 110th floor to reach the ground?

t = √2d/g = 9 seconds. You're welcome.

What are the differences in times between the fall of bowling ball and the fall of the top floor of each tower?

3-6 seconds, and 2-4 seconds, respectively. You're welcome.

Does it make sense that the top floor of a 110 story steel structure could fall to the ground in nearly the same time it takes an unimpeded bowling ball to fall? No, it doesn't, and Newton tells us why.

This is another place you do err.

(Hint: it did not do as you claim.) You're welcome.
 
Can you present the data? More importantly, can you understand it? I'm not so sure that you can.
I am an engineer, and you can't say how long a bowling ball, your example, takes to fall. Gee, i know, you don't.

How can you make up lies about 911 like you do, and have zero data, and a total ignorance of the rate the WTC fell at, and the time it takes your bowling ball to fall? you made up the BS, when can't you provide numbers?

You have no clue how much potential energy was released from each tower? Does 130 2,000 pound bombs worth get close for each tower? What number do you have. I graduated from engineering school in 74, and got my masters in engineering in 83; what is your degree in?

I can understand, and understand Cole's experiments are dumber than dirt. You can't back up Cole's work, the made up BS about physics failed.

First, we already know that the top floors did not fall at freefall; therefore and object outside the main mass that does fall at freefall does NOT prove deceleration of the main mass.
Then you expose a hate of physics with this BS. BTW, an object falling faster than the collapse front, does prove the debris field is slowed by the intact building; did you lie, or are you really unable to understand physics?
 
Last edited:
Once again, you got nothing. Game over, but thanks for playing.

What I've got is many "experiments" which, unlike Cole's ridiculous models, involve real buildings. Read the title of the OP again.

I also have an intuitive understanding of why such collapses proceed at "near" free fall: because mostly they ARE free fall, punctuated by brief collisions. Along with your imaginary physics, you seem to have an extremely faulty understanding of what was actually happening in the collapses. Small wonder that you are so confused about it.
 
Actually, yes. Some parts fell faster.

I will save you some time and tell you why your argument, which is coming next, is going to fail.

First, we already know that the top floors did not fall at freefall; therefore and object outside the main mass that does fall at freefall does NOT prove deceleration of the main mass.

Second, in some cases, objects outside the main mass fell faster than acceleration due to gravity? How is this possible? I know the answer, do you?

Two strong fails.

The fact that the top floors fell at slightly more than half of "free fall" shows that they were, in fact, decelerated on the way down.

I encourage you to demonstrate (with actual evidence) anything that fell at an acceleration faster than g at, near, or out of either of the towers. Until you do so, it is silly (and I'm being generous to say you "know" why they did something you cannot demonstrate that they did, in fact, do.
 
What I've got is many "experiments" which, unlike Cole's ridiculous models, involve real buildings. Read the title of the OP again.

I also have an intuitive understanding of why such collapses proceed at "near" free fall: because mostly they ARE free fall, punctuated by brief collisions. Along with your imaginary physics, you seem to have an extremely faulty understanding of what was actually happening in the collapses. Small wonder that you are so confused about it.

That is because FF and Cole seem to believe that the columns were involved in the collapse, post initiation. The collapse bypassed the columns.
 
OK. Show me. Make sure you take the time to explain the formulas you are using.

Also, if this is correct, why didn't NIST or the 9/11 CR put that in their report? Don't you think they would jump on that "evidence"?

The resistance calculation per floor.
Fc(z, z˙) = Fb + Fs + Fa + Fe, Fb = Wd/(1 − λ)h
 
Again, I'm not an expert.

Stop fishing, your bait sucks.

And your knowledge of physics is nonexistent.

So Sweetie, this is your life, believing in the dumbest idea in the history of mankind. No evidence to support you, impossible theory.

Look around you...9/11 truth is made up of the bottom 1/10 of 1% of humanity...idiots, nut cases, liars and con artists. The intellectual scum of the Universe. I think you would want more for yourself...
 
There are problems with the official story.
Are there? Do tell. Mr. Expert Non-Expert.

In regards to WTC 7, NIST's explanation for the collapse does not match what happened. Why won't they release the data they used in their computer model? If you could collapse a building by removing one column, why don't they do that when they need to demolish buildings?
Collapse initiation must perforce happen somewhere, right? Some member of the structure must be the first to give way, right? It matters not a whit whether it is CD or unplanned collapse. Some structural member must be the first one to give way. You do understand that, right?

And as for why such a method would not be used in normal CD? That would be because in normal CD you don't set fire to the whole frakkin building, that's why.



In regards to WTC 1 and 2, where in the official report is there an investigation into the actual collapse? They go up until the "collapse was inevitable", but where is their investigation into what happened after? What is their explanation of the speed at which WTC 1 and 2 fell, after "collapse was inevitable"?
What possible value would such have? Do you really think that if somebody dies ramming their car into a tree a forensic investigation should ensue into exactly how the car crumpled? Do you think that's a "thing"?
 
Two strong fails.

The fact that the top floors fell at slightly more than half of "free fall" shows that they were, in fact, decelerated on the way down.

I encourage you to demonstrate (with actual evidence) anything that fell at an acceleration faster than g at, near, or out of either of the towers. Until you do so, it is silly (and I'm being generous to say you "know" why they did something you cannot demonstrate that they did, in fact, do.


Wrong.

A constant acceleration less than 9.8m/s/s is not evidence of deceleration.

As for your second point, see here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvw0_i1rGns

You're welcome.
 
And your knowledge of physics is nonexistent.

So Sweetie, this is your life, believing in the dumbest idea in the history of mankind. No evidence to support you, impossible theory.

Look around you...9/11 truth is made up of the bottom 1/10 of 1% of humanity...idiots, nut cases, liars and con artists. The intellectual scum of the Universe. I think you would want more for yourself...

Personal attack.

You can keep going, but it's just not worth responding.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom