If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I admitted no such thing. Acceleration due to gravity is approximately 9.8m/s squared. An object can constantly accelerate at any value without deceleration being involved.

True.

But right here is where net force comes into play. Any falling object has gravity attempting to accelerate it downwards at all times.

Correct?
 
The laws of physics were not violated. The laws of physics can not be violated, under any circumstances. The laws of physics are self-enforcing; they don't care what we think, or if we understand them or not. However, if we do understand them we can see what really happened on 9/11.

Yes, we can; just as we can also understand Verinage demolitions, Ronan Point, and Skyline Towers. It's Cole, Chandler, and you who can't understand any of those things, because your imaginary physics can't explain them.
 
Wrong.

Absolutely wrong.

The top floors did not decelerate as they fell. The continued to accelerate as they fell.

It has been mathmaticly proven that the towers fell equal to the resistance provided by the buildings structural strength.
 
True.

But right here is where net force comes into play. Any falling object has gravity attempting to accelerate it downwards at all times.

Correct?


Exactly.

What prevents you from accelerating downwards right now? It's probably a chair. The chair is exerting an equal and opposite force in the exact amount that gravity is exerting. That is why your vertical acceleration is zero (if you are sitting in a chair).

Now, take away the chair and the ground and the air. You would immediately accelerate towards the center of the earth at 9.8m/s/s. If there was nothing to stop you, you would continue to accelerate until you reached the center of the earth. Your acceleration would be a constant 9.8m/s/s. Your velocity would increase each second. You would not decelerate unless an opposite force was applied.

The top of the towers did encounter some air resistance. This is one of the reasons you can't claim they accelerated exactly at freefall, but, they did fall at close to that rate, and that rate (acceleration) was constant. How is that possible if there was so much undamaged structure below what initially collapsed? There is only one conclusion. That conclusion is that the lower floors were removed prior to impact. How were the floors removed? That's a good question, but the most likely hypothesis is controlled demolition.
 
Last edited:
It has been mathmaticly proven that the towers fell equal to the resistance provided by the buildings structural strength.

I've seen times for the North Tower ranging from 12-17 seconds, depending on video quality. I can't get anything solid for the South Tower, due to the extra smoke and fires in that building, but I'd imagine it's probably in the lower part of that range (probably about 11-13?)
 
It has been mathmaticly proven that the towers fell equal to the resistance provided by the buildings structural strength.

OK. Show me. Make sure you take the time to explain the formulas you are using.

Also, if this is correct, why didn't NIST or the 9/11 CR put that in their report? Don't you think they would jump on that "evidence"?
 
I've seen times for the North Tower ranging from 12-17 seconds, depending on video quality. I can't get anything solid for the South Tower, due to the extra smoke and fires in that building, but I'd imagine it's probably in the lower part of that range (probably about 11-13?)

OK, how long would it take for a bowling ball dropped from the 110th floor to reach the ground?

What are the differences in times between the fall of bowling ball and the fall of the top floor of each tower?

Does it make sense that the top floor of a 110 story steel structure could fall to the ground in nearly the same time it takes an unimpeded bowling ball to fall? No, it doesn't, and Newton tells us why.
 
Yes, we can; just as we can also understand Verinage demolitions, Ronan Point, and Skyline Towers. It's Cole, Chandler, and you who can't understand any of those things, because your imaginary physics can't explain them.

*Loud buzzer sound*
No, this one deserves two buzzers because it's so wrong.

You do NOT get to cite verinage, Ronan Point, or any other building unless it involves a steel-frame high rise. If I can't do it, you can't either.

Also, buildings demolished using verinage don't collapse at freefall, or near it; they experience deceleration. Second, Ronan Point, as I have stated before, collapsed due to sudden-impact loading. This was made possible because there was no external structure supporting each unit. Additionally, there is no evidence anywhere that states Ronan Point collapsed at freefall.
 
*Loud buzzer sound*
No, this one deserves two buzzers because it's so wrong.

You do NOT get to cite verinage, Ronan Point, or any other building unless it involves a steel-frame high rise. If I can't do it, you can't either.

Also, buildings demolished using verinage don't collapse at freefall, or near it; they experience deceleration. Second, Ronan Point, as I have stated before, collapsed due to sudden-impact loading. This was made possible because there was no external structure supporting each unit. Additionally, there is no evidence anywhere that states Ronan Point collapsed at freefall.

You seem to have no idea at all what Cole claims to be demonstrating. That just might be why you believe it.
 
OK, how long would it take for a bowling ball dropped from the 110th floor to reach the ground?

What are the differences in times between the fall of bowling ball and the fall of the top floor of each tower?

Does it make sense that the top floor of a 110 story steel structure could fall to the ground in nearly the same time it takes an unimpeded bowling ball to fall? No, it doesn't, and Newton tells us why.
You failed to say at what rate the WTC towers collapsed at. Can you say .6g, or something?
Got a number? No, you have BS. The WTC fell slower than G. You failed to say how long a bowling ball takes, and never said how long the towers took. Where is your data?

Big fail. No data, no clue percent of g the towers fell at. Can you present the data?
 
You failed to say at what rate the WTC towers collapsed at. Can you say .6g, or something?
Got a number? No, you have BS. The WTC fell slower than G. You failed to say how long a bowling ball takes, and never said how long the towers took. Where is your data?

Big fail. No data, no clue percent of g the towers fell at. Can you present the data?

Can you present the data? More importantly, can you understand it? I'm not so sure that you can.
 
Did the buildings stand for 30 years? Yes. Was the potential energy of the 110th floor known to the designers? Yes. Was it taken into account when determining safety margins? Maybe. Is any of this relevant? No.

Was there a deceleration? No. Should there have been? Yes. That is what matters.

How long did it take the main mass of debris to fall the distance?

Did pieces of the building outside the main mass fall faster than the main mass?
 
The correct way to describe the collapse would be "near-freefall" acceleration.

According to David Chandler the buildings fell at 68% of free fall acceleration.

68% is closer to 50% than it is to 100%. So the more correct way to describe the collapse would be:

The buildings collapsed at near 1/2 free-fall.
 
Last edited:
How long did it take the main mass of debris to fall the distance?

Did pieces of the building outside the main mass fall faster than the main mass?

Actually, yes. Some parts fell faster.

I will save you some time and tell you why your argument, which is coming next, is going to fail.

First, we already know that the top floors did not fall at freefall; therefore and object outside the main mass that does fall at freefall does NOT prove deceleration of the main mass.

Second, in some cases, objects outside the main mass fell faster than acceleration due to gravity? How is this possible? I know the answer, do you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom