If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
My hammer doesn't bounce not even off a steel nut on a steel pin the nut absorbs the energy as it is flattened out!

The hammer is a one handed 8 pound sledge.

There are only two explanations.

1. The force exerted on the hammer by the nut is too small to be perceptible, even though it's there.

2. Newton's third law is wrong.

What is your conclusion? Is 1 or 2 correct?
 
I defined deceleration as acceleration in the opposite direction. I did not say, "go slower than it would otherwise." If something decelerates, acceleration in the opposite direction is occurring. This acceleration in the opposite direction must be cause by some force. Since there was no acceleration in the opposite direction of travel of the upper floors, there was no opposite force, and, therefore, no deceleration. The lower, undamaged structure, should have provided a force in the opposite direction of acceleration. This did not happen.
So the upper floors accelerated at the rate of gravity to the ground? Anything less would indicate a deceleration.

Your mental gymnastics are entertaining, thanks for that. ;)
 
So the upper floors accelerated at the rate of gravity to the ground? Anything less would indicate a deceleration.

Your mental gymnastics are entertaining, thanks for that. ;)

The correct way to describe the collapse would be "near-freefall" acceleration.
 
Go get a hammer and nail and find out. Make sure you pay attention to how the hammer bounces up after you hit the nail. There is a law that explains this. Can you tell me what it is?

Failure to read the instructions.

Start a 4d nail in a block of hardwood. Whan it is stable, strike it with a 4# sledge swung through a 90º arc.

Please identify the moment the sledge "bounces up" after hitting the nail.

Report back,
 
I hope this answers your question. The summary is that you would decelerate at the instant you hit the bird, but the deceleration would not be enough to change your direction of travel.

I think I understand. But you don't see this happening when the towers fell? I mean, if they fall slower than free fall, there must have been some deceleration. Doesn't that meet all your objections about Newton?

It sounds like you are describing exactly what happened, which is why I'm puzzled.
 
Ooooo...you got...so...close.

When you apply the brakes of your car, does the car decelerate?

Yes, it does. What is the correct way to explain this deceleration?

Here, I will help you.

If you apply the brakes momentarily you will slow down. This is because the applied force is in the opposite direction of travel and the force is only momentary.

If you apply the brakes continuously you will eventually stop. This is because the applied force is in the opposite direction of travel and the force is continuous.

You really should spend some time here: www.physicsclassroom.com/
 
I think I understand. But you don't see this happening when the towers fell? I mean, if they fall slower than free fall, there must have been some deceleration. Doesn't that meet all your objections about Newton?

It sounds like you are describing exactly what happened, which is why I'm puzzled.

No, because there was no deceleration. The upper floors should have been stopped by the lower structure, or, at the very least, the time of collapse should have been much longer.
 
There are only two explanations.

1. The force exerted on the hammer by the nut is too small to be perceptible, even though it's there.

2. Newton's third law is wrong.

What is your conclusion? Is 1 or 2 correct?

The force exerted by the Hammer is greater than the resistance of the 3/4 nut so the energy of the blow goes into realign the crystal lattice of the steel allowing the but to absorb the energy as deformation.

Similar to how the towers absorbed the energy as disunification, of structure though connection failures.
 
Yes, it does. What is the correct way to explain this deceleration?

Here, I will help you.

If you apply the brakes momentarily you will slow down. This is because the applied force is in the opposite direction of travel and the force is only momentary.

If you apply the brakes continuously you will eventually stop. This is because the applied force is in the opposite direction of travel and the force is continuous.

You really should spend some time here: www.physicsclassroom.com/

So FalseFlag...how many college level physics classes have you taken?
 
No, because there was no deceleration. The upper floors should have been stopped by the lower structure, or, at the very least, the time of collapse should have been much longer.
Please present your numbers to show by how much. Let me guess, you have no idea, it's just your belief?

You already admitted there was a deceleration.. Post 644.
 
Last edited:
There are only two explanations.

1. The force exerted on the hammer by the nut is too small to be perceptible, even though it's there.

2. Newton's third law is wrong.

What is your conclusion? Is 1 or 2 correct?

Would the negative-vector acceleration of the hammer be too small to detect?

Would the path of the hammer be impeded, even though its direction did not change at all?
 
Yes, it does. What is the correct way to explain this deceleration?

Here, I will help you.

If you apply the brakes momentarily you will slow down. This is because the applied force is in the opposite direction of travel and the force is only momentary.

If you apply the brakes continuously you will eventually stop. This is because the applied force is in the opposite direction of travel and the force is continuous.

You really should spend some time here: www.physicsclassroom.com/

No the force is not in the opposite direction, that would be going forward and suddenly shifting into reverse, doing that can snap the engine crank shaft if the clutch drive shaft, and transmission hold.
Applying the breaks merely stops the wheels from rotating, it does not reverse the wheels motion. Friction resistance is the stopping force.
 
No, because there was no deceleration. The upper floors should have been stopped by the lower structure, or, at the very least, the time of collapse should have been much longer.

OK, I think I got it now. It isn't that the lower part didn't offer resistance and slow down the upper (to less than free fall), but that it didn't slow the collapse down enough.

This is where my lack knowledge on how buildings are built and how they collapse will cut me out of the discussion. I don't think Newton gets violated though, in either case. (Which is good for Newton.)
 
Once again, one does not need to be an engineer to understand Newton's laws of motion. Anyone can duplicate his experiments, given the resources. The issue is what conclusions should be made based on Newton's laws of motion and what was observed during the collapse of the WTC buildings.

Then why do you keep bringing up his credentials and those of others?

So no peer reviewed papers then? You'd think if someone was so interested in the truth they'd publish a paper in a relevant journal. You do know that's how things work in the technical field don't you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom