If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't follow this topic closely, and was interested in your logic. It seems to me that part of the problem is how some posters are using "decelerate" differently than others. I think you mean it as a synonym for "go slower than it would otherwise" while the others say it still counts as acceleration if there is an average increase in velocity, even if the rate of increase slows.

I defined deceleration as acceleration in the opposite direction. I did not say, "go slower than it would otherwise." If something decelerates, acceleration in the opposite direction is occurring. This acceleration in the opposite direction must be cause by some force. Since there was no acceleration in the opposite direction of travel of the upper floors, there was no opposite force, and, therefore, no deceleration. The lower, undamaged structure, should have provided a force in the opposite direction of acceleration. This did not happen.
 
Last edited:
OK.

Let's simplify this. The steel in the towers does exactly what the skeptics want it to, at all times. It weakens, melts, or whatever you want. None of this matters, though. It doesn't matter one single bit.

As I said before, you can magically remove 20 or 30 floors by whatever means you wish, and then drop the remaining floors on the rest of the building. At the moment of impact, there will be a deceleration. The deceleration will continue until the movement stops, or the top reaches the ground. The only way the top will continue to accelerate is if the lower floors are removed prior to the impact of the upper floors. Go ahead and deny this, but you are denying the most fundamental laws of motion.

In summary, go ahead, pretend the steel can do whatever you want it to. It changes nothing. Newton's third law applies, is valid, and doesn't change with scale.

...what happens when you drive a small nail with a large hammer?
 
I think you need to review the definition of acceleration. You're close, but spend a little more time on it. You also seem to have the beginning of an understanding of Newton's third law, but you could also spend a little more time trying to understand that as well.



OK. Show me. Are you going to use that garbage from NMSR? *Buzzer sound* It's garbage. The floors did not stick to each other as they collapsed.
Go ahead, show me an accurate, peer-reviewed and accepted, mathematical model that shows the upper floors decelerated. You can't, because it didn't happen. If the upper floors decelerated, the collapse would not have progressed to the ground, or, at the very least, it would have taken longer than it did.

No the Maxwell equation for a pinned beam gives the total strength of the connections in the buildings, using that the total resistance to collapse can be c
The towers actually would have fallen faster if the structure was colder, cold steel fractures while heated steel goes though ductile deformations bending.
A one foot off center eccentric strike of an object weighing, 2600lbs dropped twelve feet, will exert a force of 1,000,000 foot pounds per square inch on any structure it impacts, that's enough to sheer the core columns themselves in the towers.
Since it is physically impossible for the core columns to re align there is no possible way for a noticeable jolt to be observed, or for a noticeable pause to occur in the collapses.

The Maxwell equation is the core equation in the Banzant, Greening, Benson, computer model,
Maybe you heard of that I did the experiments that show that was the correct modeling of the resistance of the lower portion of the towers to the falling mass!
 
I defined deceleration as acceleration in the opposite direction. I did not say, "go slower than it would otherwise." If something accelerates in the opposite direction of travel, some force must be causing it. Since there was no acceleration in the opposite direction of travel of the upper floors, there was no opposite force. The lower, undamaged structure, should have provided a force in the opposite direction of acceleration. This did not happen.

The WTC towers collapsed at less than g. Thus there was structure in the way, slowing down the collapse to below G. Thus you are telling lies, or you failed to study the data. Which is, are you spreading lies on purpose, or did you fail to study the collapse? Which is it?

Why do you post lies like this? "This" did happen. You failed to check.
 
As I said before, the entire video is in the context of 9/11. His experiment supports your theories, even though it's not what actually happened during 9/11. Since you agree with his conclusion, you have no problem with what he is doing.

None of this matters, though. You can claim the steel can do whatever you want, other than defy Newton's laws of motion.

See post #575.

...what happens when you drive a small golf ball with a large, fast-moving driver?

...what happens when you hit a fastball with a large, fast-moving bat?
 
Last edited:
I defined deceleration as acceleration in the opposite direction. I did not say, "go slower than it would otherwise." If something decelerates, acceleration in the opposite direction is occurring. This acceleration in the opposite direction must be cause by some force. Since there was no acceleration in the opposite direction of travel of the upper floors, there was no opposite force, and, therefore, no deceleration. The lower, undamaged structure, should have provided a force in the opposite direction of acceleration. This did not happen.

But it's additive, isn't it? I mean, if I am falling from an airplane I have a downward force. Then I hit a bird flying upward. I combine the upward force from the bird with my downward force and if the net result is still downward, I go down, not up.

Isn't that how it works, a combination of forces?
 
...what happens when you drive a small nail with a large hammer?

Go get a hammer and nail and find out. Make sure you pay attention to how the hammer bounces up after you hit the nail. There is a law that explains this. Can you tell me what it is?
 
Scale is irrelevant in regards to Newton's laws of motion.

-1 for your credibility. Thanks for playing, though.

You lack the capacity to judge credibility, given your continued demonstration of utter and pervasive failure of any understanding of physics that might rise to the level of my 9th-grade students.

What happens when you hit a small bug with the bumper of a big truck?

(BTW, putting your fingers in your ears and singing "Dixie" does not change the fact that Cole's demo is deficient precisely because of the problem of scaling.)

Do you ever intend to substantiate your claim that the mass of the falling towers was not subject to any acceleration with a negative vector? (Hint: What happens to a mass when it falls in a gravity well and is not subject to acceleration in a negative vector?)
 
Again, -1 for your credibility. You can't keep playing with a negative score.

To "keep score" intelligibly, you would have to understand the procedure you think you are judging.

Your adjudication of my "score" is as risible as your contention that "scale doesn't matter".

What happens when you swat a fly out of the air with your open hand?
 
I defined deceleration as acceleration in the opposite direction. I did not say, "go slower than it would otherwise." If something decelerates, acceleration in the opposite direction is occurring. This acceleration in the opposite direction must be cause by some force. Since there was no acceleration in the opposite direction of travel of the upper floors, there was no opposite force, and, therefore, no deceleration. The lower, undamaged structure, should have provided a force in the opposite direction of acceleration. This did not happen.

So your saying that Captain kirk applies tractor beams to the lower structure and it flies up though the upper descending mass?

Please state where this opposite outside force is coming from, is it from the Death star, Romulan, Klingon, or did a microscopic black hole suddenly form above the building and dissipated after the collapses stopped?:jaw-dropp
 
But it's additive, isn't it? I mean, if I am falling from an airplane I have a downward force. Then I hit a bird flying upward. I combine the upward force from the bird with my downward force and if the net result is still downward, I go down, not up.

Isn't that how it works, a combination of forces?


If you jump out of a plane you experience the downward force due to gravity, mainly upwards forces due to air resistance, various forces due to wind velocity, and an upwards force due to buoyancy. There might be more, but those are the main ones. Eventually, the downwards and upwards forces will balance, and this is called reaching terminal velocity. You could still be accelerating or decelerating laterally, but you won't continue to decelerate or accelerate vertically until you open your parachute, or you hit the ground.

If you happen to hit a bird during your descent, you will decelerate if certain conditions are met. If the bird flies straight up at you then the acceleration will be in the opposite direction of travel. What happens when you apply a force in the opposite direction of travel? You will decelerate. Deceleration does not mean you will immediately change direction. You will keep going downwards if you hit the bird. You will just slow down, or decelerate, for an instant. Unless you were at terminal velocity, you will speed up again because of acceleration due to gravity.

If the bird impacted you laterally there would be two options. If you were not accelerating laterally, the impact would accelerate you. If you were accelerating laterally, and the bird hit you in the opposite direction of your travel, you would decelerate.


I hope this answers your question. The summary is that you would decelerate at the instant you hit the bird, but the deceleration would not be enough to change your direction of travel.
 
Go get a hammer and nail and find out. Make sure you pay attention to how the hammer bounces up after you hit the nail. There is a law that explains this. Can you tell me what it is?

My hammer doesn't bounce not even off a steel nut on a steel pin the nut absorbs the energy as it is flattened out!

The hammer is a one handed 8 pound sledge.
 
And your argument and conclusion is wrong. Scale does not matter when it comes to the laws of motion.

You should also be embarrassed for citing wikipedia as a source.

...you should be grateful I offered you something you could apprehend. It is a shame you did not read it. Would you care to point out in what way the Wikipedia article is deficient or incorrect? That might be fun, too...

It is not at the point of your misunderstandings of the "laws of motion" that the inability to deal with scale trips you up and makes a mockery of Cole's "demonstration".

I fully believe you are capable of understanding the issue, if you try.
 
I defined deceleration as acceleration in the opposite direction. I did not say, "go slower than it would otherwise." If something decelerates, acceleration in the opposite direction is occurring. This acceleration in the opposite direction must be cause by some force. Since there was no acceleration in the opposite direction of travel of the upper floors, there was no opposite force, and, therefore, no deceleration. The lower, undamaged structure, should have provided a force in the opposite direction of acceleration. This did not happen.

Ooooo...you got...so...close.

When you apply the brakes of your car, does the car decelerate?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom