If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
You know Truthers live for this. In 12 months from now the thread will not have progressed at all, they will have achieved their aim of keeping the thread jogging along and their crazy ideas going.
 
(Wow, I post late on a Saturday night, get up very early Sunday morning and there are three new pages on this thread. Do all Truthers keep Russian time now?)

Further clarification? Cole says, on the video (starting 20 seconds in), "There's plenty of evidence of temperatures high enough to melt steel, including molten spheres of iron..."

Yet no molten spheres have been found, only solid ones.

Molten spheres are evidence that temperatures high enough to melt steel are present. Solid ones are not.

The actual evidence is not molten spheres as Cole claims, it's solid spheres that one might assume (and might be mistaken in so assuming) were molten at the time of the collapse.

Why does that matter? Because it takes an assumption (that temperatures were high enough at the time of collapse that the solid spheres that were found afterward were molten at that time) and pretends that that's evidence for the assumption itself. It's circular reasoning.

It's as though you were accused of embezzling and in court, the prosecutor holds up 67 dollars in cash that was seized from your wallet at your arrest, and tells the jury, "This embezzled money in the accused's possession proves that he is guilty of embezzling." By calling it "embezzled money" he's assuming what he's claiming to show as evidence, that you embezzled the money rather than rightfully owned it.

How does he know it's embezzled money? Because it was in your possession and you're an embezzler. How does he know you're an embezzler? Because you were in possession of embezzled money. That's how circular reasoning works.

Off to prison with you! (Well, maybe in Russia. In the U.S. any competent defense lawyer could object to that statement in court as unsupported, assuming the conclusion, or prejudicial, and the judge would disallow the testimony.)

How does Cole know the spheres were molten at the time of the collapse? Because temperatures were high enough to melt steel! How does he know there were temperatures high enough to melt steel? Because there were molten spheres of iron! That's how circular reasoning works.

His other "evidence" for the "temperatures high enough to melt steel" all works the same way. Assuming the conclusion, again and again: "melted steel full of holes," "melted handguns in the museum" and so forth.

This is not a matter of particular engineering or other expertise; it's a basic error in reasoning. Cole didn't get some engineering wrong, he got elementary logic wrong. He got thinking wrong.

And that's his very first claim in the video. No need to watch any farther to find what he got wrong.


OK. I concede that there were no molten spheres. I will concede that there was no thermite, either.

Now we both agree, solely for the sake of this argument in this thread, that there was no thermite and no spheres. How then do you account for the upper floors falling completely to the ground at or near freefall, using Newton's laws of motion to explain it?
 
You know Truthers live for this. In 12 months from now the thread will not have progressed at all, they will have achieved their aim of keeping the thread jogging along and their crazy ideas going.

Translation: You got nothing; therefore, one skeptic defeated. Thanks for playing.
 
So in you expert opinion the construction and dynamics of a collapse are "irrelevant".

Good to know. Do you really wonder why your movement has only progressed from one obscure website to another? :rolleyes:


Your post is undeniable proof you refuse to read all of the posts in this thread. I have clearly stated I am not an expert.

If you refuse to read the posts in this thread, why should anyone give any credibility to any of your posts?
 
This is nothing more than a personal attack.

Again, see post #575.

Truth is never a personal attack, truth hurts sometimes doesn't it.

The speed of acceleration of the top mass will vary based on the resistance provided by the material it falls into.

The upper mass of the twin towers, was slowed by the lower portion, and that has been mathematically proven to have occured.

Get over it Daffy Duck's, Wile E. Coyote's, and Elmer Fud's physics weren't real, Cole's physics needs a good flush.

The buildings will never agree with Cole's physics because nothing about Cole's physics is correct!

work= gravitational potential, - resistance. 2600 dropped twelve feet, = 100,000 psi per square inch. 2600 pounds plus 2600 pounds = 5200 pounds dropped twelve feet= 200,000 pounds per square feet. 5200 pounds +2600 pounds = 7800pounds dropped twelve feet, = 300,000 pounds per square feet.
Each time a floor is added the energy to break the next floor increases, decreasing the resistance the building can offer, to slow the falling mass!
 
Wow...this from someone that clearly doesn't understand physics and or structural engineering.

I don't need to be an engineer to understand Newton's laws of motion. That's why they are taught to children in elementary school. Even they have the capacity to understand them, and apply them to what they see.
 
...
You should also be embarrassed for citing wikipedia as a source.

lol, wiki beats 911 truth, and your claims by orders of magnitude. 911 truth, no valid claims for 14 years.

Scale does matter. Cole's idiotic experiments failed. There is no valid scaling in Cole's delusional experiments.

911 truth has no clue what physics is - Cole's experiments are proof 911 truth followers are dumber than dirt.

I don't need to be an engineer to understand Newton's laws of motion. That's why they are taught to children in elementary school. Even they have the capacity to understand them, and apply them to what they see.
You don't understand them, or you would understand Cole's experiments are nonsense.
 
Your post is undeniable proof you refuse to read all of the posts in this thread. I have clearly stated I am not an expert.

If you refuse to read the posts in this thread, why should anyone give any credibility to any of your posts?
Do you conceded then your argument that the laws of physics were violated by the official story is a belief that you can not support?


You clearly have no understanding of structures.
 
The speed of acceleration of the top mass will vary based on the resistance provided by the material it falls into.
I think you need to review the definition of acceleration. You're close, but spend a little more time on it. You also seem to have the beginning of an understanding of Newton's third law, but you could also spend a little more time trying to understand that as well.

The upper mass of the twin towers, was slowed by the lower portion, and that has been mathematically proven to have occured.

OK. Show me. Are you going to use that garbage from NMSR? *Buzzer sound* It's garbage. The floors did not stick to each other as they collapsed.
Go ahead, show me an accurate, peer-reviewed and accepted, mathematical model that shows the upper floors decelerated. You can't, because it didn't happen. If the upper floors decelerated, the collapse would not have progressed to the ground, or, at the very least, it would have taken longer than it did.
 
I don't need to be an engineer to understand Newton's laws of motion. That's why they are taught to children in elementary school. Even they have the capacity to understand them, and apply them to what they see.

What would be the resistance if the top mass fell though the lower mass, into the black hole in the center of the Milky Way?

Newtons Laws apply equally to that question as too the earth and the building, why would it there fore be impossible for the top block to even fall though the lower block into the black hole?
 
Do you conceded then your argument that the laws of physics were violated by the official story is a belief that you can not support?


You clearly have no understanding of structures.

The laws of physics were not violated. The laws of physics can not be violated, under any circumstances. The laws of physics are self-enforcing; they don't care what we think, or if we understand them or not. However, if we do understand them we can see what really happened on 9/11.
 
Last edited:
What would be the resistance if the top mass fell though the lower mass, into the black hole in the center of the Milky Way?

Newtons Laws apply equally to that question as too the earth and the building, why would it there fore be impossible for the top block to even fall though the lower block into the black hole?

What?

Your post is the epitome of "grasping". I'm not playing.
 
The laws of physics were not violated. The laws of physics can not be violated, under any circumstances. The laws of physics are self-enforcing; they don't care what we think, or if we understand them or not. However, if we do understand them we can see what really happened on 9/11.
So there is nothing wrong with the explanation given in the "official story". Unless of course you can explain where it was wrong.

Thanks for clearing that up.
 
The laws of physics were not violated. The laws of physics can not be violated, under any circumstances. The laws of physics are self-enforcin; they don't care what we think, or if we understand them or not. However, if we do understand them we can see what really happened on 9/11.

Understanding the laws of physics may help inform your observations. You can see a plane of a bird fly but that does not let you understand the physics of flight.

Everything we saw of the buildings going from stable, static to unstable and a collapsed pile of rubble can be explained without resorting to energy inputs grossly called "CD". There was more than enough stored PE in a high rise for it to "destroy" itself once a threshold amount of the integrity is breached and mass is freed.
 
As a skeptic, shouldn't you know this? I mean, it's in the 9/11 CR.

I don't follow this topic closely, and was interested in your logic. It seems to me that part of the problem is how some posters are using "decelerate" differently than others. I think you mean it as a synonym for "go slower than it would otherwise" while the others say it still counts as acceleration if there is an average increase in velocity, even if the rate of increase slows.

So, to me, as a not-expert, it seems very relevant how near to free fall the towers fell. Anything less than free fall would represent a difference from an unimpeded acceleration. If both sides agree on how fast the towers fell, then the difference from free fall should represent an answer to the questions about deceleration.
 
Last edited:
So there is nothing wrong with the explanation given in the "official story". Unless of course you can explain where it was wrong.

Thanks for clearing that up.

There are problems with the official story.

In regards to WTC 7, NIST's explanation for the collapse does not match what happened. Why won't they release the data they used in their computer model? If you could collapse a building by removing one column, why don't they do that when they need to demolish buildings?

In regards to WTC 1 and 2, where in the official report is there an investigation into the actual collapse? They go up until the "collapse was inevitable", but where is their investigation into what happened after? What is their explanation of the speed at which WTC 1 and 2 fell, after "collapse was inevitable"?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom