If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
It proves that there is such a thing as progressive collapse. If Cole's bastardisation of Newton's Third Law were correct, then the initial failure of one floor in Ronan Point could at most have caused the collapse of one additional floor below it, after which the destructive force of the first collapsing floor would have been fully absorbed. The fact that the collapse continued to progress is a simple demonstration that Cole's argument is nonsense.

Dave

No, Cole's argument is not nonsense. The above argument is, however. Cole's experiments are not intended to prove that a structure can not collapse. You know this. Cole's experiments are intended to prove that the collapse would not continue to accelerate unless there was nothing below the falling mass.
 
You aren't even trying.
You must know that your idea of physics and how the world works is completely unique and at variance with reality.
I don't think you care though, the message is more important.
 
OK.

Let's simplify this. The steel in the towers does exactly what the skeptics want it to, at all times. It weakens, melts, or whatever you want. None of this matters, though. It doesn't matter one single bit.

As I said before, you can magically remove 20 or 30 floors by whatever means you wish,

Simple question. Do you believe all structural members will line up on failure to transfer their loads perfectly? You are not stupid enough to think the towers were built as blocks, right? :eek:
 
You aren't even trying.
You must know that your idea of physics and how the world works is completely unique and at variance with reality.
I don't think you care though, the message is more important.

Really?

Please keep digging a hole for yourself and your fellow skeptics.

-1 for credibility. As I told another poster, thanks for playing.
 
No, Cole's argument is not nonsense. The above argument is, however. Cole's experiments are not intended to prove that a structure can not collapse. You know this. Cole's experiments are intended to prove that the collapse would not continue to accelerate unless there was nothing below the falling mass.

Wouldn't that require a vacuum? Your argument about deceleration works just as well for air as it does for floors. Does something falling in air decelerate as it hits more and more air molecules on the way down?
 
Simple question. Do you believe all structural members will line up on failure to transfer their loads perfectly? You are not stupid enough to think the towers were built as blocks, right? :eek:

Irrelevant.

I will concede magical steel. It's yours. The steel can do whatever you want, other than defy Newton's laws of motion.

I will also concede the towers were built however you want. Go ahead, make up whatever you want. It doesn't matter how they were constructed. The question is, once the building was constructed, did floor 50 (as an example) support floors 51 through 110? The answer is yes.

So, I will concede magical steel, and that the towers were built in the weakest, most defective way possible. It still does not change the fact that Newton's third law is valid, and the upper floors should not have collapsed at or near freefall. Period.

To make things easy. I will concede anything else you want. You don't want thermite? OK. No thermite. You want 4 planes instead of 2? OK. Take 10 planes crashing into the building. It does not matter. What else do you want? I will give it to you. Make up whatever fantasy you want, but under no circumstances will I deny Newton's laws of motion. They exist, and they prove that the lower floors were removed prior the the impact of the upper floors.
 
Wouldn't that require a vacuum? Your argument about deceleration works just as well for air as it does for floors. Does something falling in air decelerate as it hits more and more air molecules on the way down?

The air resistance was real, and it's one of the reasons the towers did not fall at exactly freefall.

Your argument is irrelevant, though. Air resistance, which was close to a static value, would not overcome the force of acceleration due to gravity, unless the object was at its terminal velocity. The towers were nowhere near this.
 
Irrelevant.

I will concede magical steel. It's yours. The steel can do whatever you want, other than defy Newton's laws of motion.

I will also concede the towers were built however you want. Go ahead, make up whatever you want. It doesn't matter how they were constructed. The question is, once the building was constructed, did floor 50 (as an example) support floors 51 through 110? The answer is yes.

So, I will concede magical steel, and that the towers were built in the weakest, most defective way possible. It still does not change the fact that Newton's third law is valid, and the upper floors should not have collapsed at or near freefall. Period.

To make things easy. I will concede anything else you want. You don't want thermite? OK. No thermite. You want 4 planes instead of 2? OK. Take 10 planes crashing into the building. It does not matter. What else do you want? I will give it to you. Make up whatever fantasy you want, but under no circumstances will I deny Newton's laws of motion. They exist, and they prove that the lower floors were removed prior the the impact of the upper floors.

How near?
 
I am not being paid to be here.

I'm a high school physics teacher, who understands how critical scaling is, and am here of my own volition.

And your argument and conclusion is wrong. Scale does not matter when it comes to the laws of motion.

You should also be embarrassed for citing wikipedia as a source.
 
Make up whatever fantasy you want, but under no circumstances will I deny Newton's laws of motion. They exist, and they prove that the lower floors were removed prior the the impact of the upper floors.

Please explain how you feel the official story defies these laws in your own words.

Please use actual numbers/formulas not YouTube video.

Bet you can't without misrepresenting the "official story".
 
OK.

Let's simplify this. The steel in the towers does exactly what the skeptics want it to, at all times. It weakens, melts, or whatever you want. None of this matters, though. It doesn't matter one single bit.

As I said before, you can magically remove 20 or 30 floors by whatever means you wish, and then drop the remaining floors on the rest of the building. At the moment of impact, there will be a deceleration. The deceleration will continue until the movement stops, or the top reaches the ground. The only way the top will continue to accelerate is if the lower floors are removed prior to the impact of the upper floors. Go ahead and deny this, but you are denying the most fundamental laws of motion.

In summary, go ahead, pretend the steel can do whatever you want it to. It changes nothing. Newton's third law applies, is valid, and doesn't change with scale.

Next thing ya know, FF will be saying that even a moon sized pile of rubble would decelerate.
 
The issue is this:

While you explain your understanding of what you mean by floor - and in that context, are correct - it misses the point entirely.

It misses the point cuz in your view, the falling stuff has its momentum directed onto the columns ONLY, bypassing any inherent weakness/inability of the floor pans to stop the stuff from falling.

But that's not how things work in the real world.

In the real world, stuff falls onto the floor pans first, which have to be able to absorb that momentum and THEN direct that momentum onto the columns. You now realize/admit that couldn't happen.

Therefore, your earlier assertion that the "floors" should survive falling stuff, or however you phrased it, to be wrong.

You should thank those that corrected you. It doesn't hurt your position to do so....

See post #575. Fantasy steel and a fantasy structure is yours. I concede it. I will concede whatever you want, but your fantasy steel and structure must still adhere to Newton's laws of motion.
 
...
I will also concede the towers were built however you want. Go ahead, make up whatever you want. It doesn't matter how they were constructed. The question is, once the building was constructed, did floor 50 (as an example) support floors 51 through 110? The answer is yes...

The correct answer is no. The floors supported nothing except what was on the floors.

It really does matter how they were constructed.
 
Next thing ya know, FF will be saying that even a moon sized pile of rubble would decelerate.

This is hilarious.

-10 for credibility on this one.

First off, I'm not saying it, Newton is. And it has been proven.

NASA engineers often use trajectories that harness the gravitational pull of planets in order to boost the speed of a satellite or probe. If the probe gets a speed boost from the planet, the planet slows down. The amount of the slowdown is extremely minute, but it's there. This is in accordance with Newton's third law. Don't believe me? Google it.
 
Simple question. Do you believe all structural members will line up on failure to transfer their loads perfectly? You are not stupid enough to think the towers were built as blocks, right? :eek:

Irrelevant.

So in you expert opinion the construction and dynamics of a collapse are "irrelevant".

Good to know. Do you really wonder why your movement has only progressed from one obscure website to another? :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom