If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why do you assume that we have to have complete theories on everything?

I don't. A plausible reasoning would be nice.

I don't know what was in building 7, I don't know what was in the twin towers. I don't know if or why they were brought down, or by whom.

But, you bring to the table without evidence that they were "brought down". Why are things just not what was seen and backed by all physical evidence?

You seem to assume that because I disagree with what I have been told, that I have to have a complete theory down to every last detail. I don't.

I'm trying to work through possibilities, rule out what's impossible and evaluate what's left. Most other people don't want to do that.

Have you worked out any impossibilities yet? If so, what and how?

The most complete "official narrative" is NIST, and whether you personally admit it or not, it has been agreed by persons on both sides of the debate that it is not 100% correct. The reasons for this are either benign or malicious, and the significance is also hotly debated.

I wouldn't say it's hotly debated. Who exactly is involved in this hot debate?

Collaborating, agreeing and discussing on parts that are in dispute, and coming to some sort of rational outcome would in an ideal world put the whole thing to bed, but not if the arguers get so carried away in the fight, that they get distracted from the issues.

The problem is application of these supposed issues and how they are actually relevant.

"Free-fall" is a perfect example. The building and engineering community has a very good handle on this. The consensus is, so what.
 
Last edited:
... I don't know what was in building 7, I don't know what was in the twin towers. I don't know if or why they were brought down, or by whom. ...

19 terrorists are the ones who did 911. You know who did it, but you can't grasp reality.

Fire caused the collapse, caused by the attacks of terrorists; why is because the terrorists wanted to murder people; more reality you deny.

In fact, your fantasy version of 911 based on BS google 911 truth junk, some terrorists are still alive.

14 years and you don't know.

100 percent, it was fire, no matter how much you make up BS about people not agreeing, you fail to realize it does not mean they support the idiotic dumbed down CD lies. You can't figure out it was fire.
 
Last edited:
19 terrorists are the ones who did 911. You know who did it, but you can't grasp reality.

Fire caused the collapse, caused by the attacks of terrorists; why is because the terrorists wanted to murder people; more reality you deny.

In fact, your fantasy version of 911 based on BS google 911 truth junk, some terrorists are still alive.

14 years and you don't know.

100 percent, it was fire, no matter how much you make up BS about people not agreeing, you fail to realize it does not mean they support the idiotic dumbed down CD lies. You can't figure out it was fire.

But that doesn't play in to his hatred of the USA snd what he perceives as the crimes of tbe 'War on Terror' as expounded in his thread of that name.
9/11 needs to be a vast criminal plot to underpin and support his worldview. Just like the other Truthers.
It must be obvious to everyone taking part in his discussions .
 
I think that's where my vocabulary fails. I know that shaped charge is the wrong terminology to use, as it implies an explosion, when what I am referring to is a device or mechanism to direct or control the HI so that it moves in the desired direction, not a detonation wave.

I don't know enough about these materials, but what I do know is that it would be extremely difficult if not impossible to rig it in a way that most people assume that it must be done. A shaped device placed vertically or diagonally on a column, with the intention of severing that column.

I don't know what the correct fallacy is, but saying it couldn't do THIS and therefore wasn't used at all is a bit dismissive and inaccurate.

So we are back to possibilities. If the objective was to ensure that a building that was going to be damaged and subjected to fire collapsed, rather than remain standing, then detonation and explosion and severing of vertical columns is not required. What you require is to ensure that any weakening is sufficient to cause collapse.

Therefore it is theoretically plausible, that devices placed in key areas could cause enough heat to ensure sufficient weakening.

One doesn't need to know the exact make-up of the device and/or the HI to know that if you exclude what is impossible, you can examine what is left.

Given the nature of thermate and its ilk, a shaped device could be fabricated to contain it while it "eats" downward through a horizontal member, enough to weaken it.

Since I have actually built the device your talking about, I might know a little something about how such devices work.
I built a device long ago and sent a design drawing into NIST with a description of how they work, and why they wouldn't work in fires.
Cole's devices are quite primative, and laughable a thermal or Oxygen lance works on similar principles Thermitic Lances were used in the clean up at ground zero.
Thermitic was a brand name of a perticular lance, until they changed it because of truthers.
I also posted the drawing on this forum years ago, and explained why it wouldn't work.
 
That's what I'm saying!

(I assume you mean Munroe effect, although if she was there with Elvis, we have more to worry about.)

Preconceptions result in heated arguments and name calling, when I would rather talk about the possibilities.

So you say, that a conventional shaped charge wouldn't work, and I agree that trying to apply a compound to a vertical column and keep enough HI material in contact with the area to be cut (or weakened) would be a challenge.

However, lets assume that if an HI were to be used, that the operators would be far more aware of its limitations and usage than you or I, and would know how to use it without encountering the problems you suggest.

<more to follow, life calls>

IOW it wuz magic.
 
And therein lies the problem. Refusal to work through a thought experiment to come to some sort of conclusion.

No. A refusal to engage in a thought experiment based on junk premises avoids coming to deceptive conclusions, ones that need constant reference back to the junk premises. It's worse than pointless, it's damaging; it leads into dark alleys where the unwary don't realise the whole caboodle was unreal all along when they're presented with the conclusions.
 
Why do you assume that we have to have complete theories on everything?

I don't know what was in building 7, I don't know what was in the twin towers. I don't know if or why they were brought down, or by whom.
You seem to assume that because I disagree with what I have been told, that I have to have a complete theory down to every last detail. I don't.

I'm trying to work through possibilities, rule out what's impossible and evaluate what's left. Most other people don't want to do that.

The most complete "official narrative" is NIST, and whether you personally admit it or not, it has been agreed by persons on both sides of the debate that it is not 100% correct. The reasons for this are either benign or malicious, and the significance is also hotly debated.

Collaborating, agreeing and discussing on parts that are in dispute, and coming to some sort of rational outcome would in an ideal world put the whole thing to bed, but not if the arguers get so carried away in the fight, that they get distracted from the issues.

Hijackers in planes.

Glad I could help.
 
I don't know enough about these materials, but what I do know is that it would be extremely difficult if not impossible to rig it in a way that most people assume that it must be done. A shaped device placed vertically or diagonally on a column, with the intention of severing that column.

I don't know what the correct fallacy is, but saying it couldn't do THIS and therefore wasn't used at all is a bit dismissive and inaccurate.

It's the argument from ignorance. However, it's a fallacy too far; the actual fallacy most seriously in operation is the fallacy of shifting the burden of proof. The initial provisional conclusion to be drawn from the fact that three buildings suffered differing degrees of fire and impact damage and subsequently collapsed is that the collapse was caused by the fire and impact damage, because it is known that structures can suffer sufficient damage from fire and impact to collapse. In the absence of any evidence to the contrary, and following the establishment by engineering studies that the degree of damage suffered was sufficient to cause collapse, this becomes the default conclusion, that requires positive evidence to be overruled. Truthers dislike this conclusion because it doesn't fit in with the way they want the world to work, so they make up alternative hypotheses and then demand disproof, when there is technically speaking nothing to disprove.

In fact, the most notable thing about evidence for the alternative theories is its absence. The absence of evidence for demolition explosives extends as far as the complete absence from the audible record of the collapses of the highly characteristic sound of the type of high brisance explosives that are required to sever steel; if they were there, they would be unmistakable. Their absence is notable enough to be evidence of the absence of any such devices. It was this that led some frustrated truthers to fabricate the thermite hypothesis, led by Steven Jones's insistence in the face of all evidence that thermite was commonly used in building demolitions. Subsequent research has only found one example of the use of thermite in a structural demolition, and this was not to sever a compressive but a tensile element - specifically, a bracing wire - which of course requires a completely different approach to that needed for a relatively massive support column. There has never been a plausible suggestion or example given of a thermite-based device that could do what truthers choose to claim it did.

Given that a perfectly reasonable collapse hypothesis exists, which has been studied in detail and found to be physically not just possible but more or less inevitable, vague suggestions that something else might have happened are simply not worth considering. If truthers could suggest a specific mechanism by which thermite could sever a structural column, then they would at least have the beginning of an argument; though they would then have to come up with a plausible explanation of how such a device could be installed unseen, and how the bright light emitted by the thermite reaction could not be seen outside the towers, and how the devices could survive the fires, and a whole load of other objections I haven't thought of yet. And even then, that wouldn't get the truther hypothesis across the finish line in the race to understand the collapses; it would place it at the start line, because we would then at least have an alternative hypothesis to test against the available evidence. At the moment we don't even have that.

It's a bit like, to extend the race analogy, someone debating who won a race because there wasn't a photo-finish, and claiming that, because we don't have photo-finish evidence, it's possible someone else won instead, even though everyone in the stadium saw the winner cross the line well ahead of the competition. But at the moment, the truthers are claiming that someone might have won who wasn't even in the race.

Dave
 
Although the thread has moved on many pages since this happened, please note that accusations of posters being 'shills' / being paid to post are breaches of rule 12.

As well as sticking to the topic, please ensure that you are all civil and polite, and that you address the arguments rather than attacking the arguers.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha
 
This proves global structural collapse? One corner = whole building?

It proves that there is such a thing as progressive collapse. If Cole's bastardisation of Newton's Third Law were correct, then the initial failure of one floor in Ronan Point could at most have caused the collapse of one additional floor below it, after which the destructive force of the first collapsing floor would have been fully absorbed. The fact that the collapse continued to progress is a simple demonstration that Cole's argument is nonsense.

Dave
 
AClarke

There are several points why the whole Thermite discussion is a mute discussion tbh.

1) The devices needed to cut the exterior and interior beams, take up space, and there sure as hell was none at the exterior columns. because you have to remove the outer cladding to get to the columns(They are columns, so you have to cut from 4 sides).

2) If thermite was used on all columns, it would have been such a bright sight, that people on the moon could see it.

3) Many exterior column sections were still connected together after the buildings had collapsed. Hell, even some of those sections hit WFC3.

4) Large sections of the interior columns were still standing after the outer columns and floors were already lying in pieces on the ground.

5) More then a dozen people survived the collapse of one of the towers, while they were in the stairwells. None of them noticed large bright flashes of thermite going off. And none of them was burned because of the thermic reaction.

So what can we conclude from this? No thermite was used.
 
Reichstag demolition. Looks like thermite to me.



Notice the size of the containing devices. It also surely looks like they take quite a while.
 
FalseFlag, the blacksmith demonstrates something useful in understanding the collapse - that steel weakened by heat can more easily bend when subjected to lateral forces. This is relevant when realising that WTC columns were subject to lateral forces when floor pans sagged as a result of the heat. Once bent by those lateral forces then the vertical forces they were supporting became catastrophic.

In Cole's experiment there were no lateral forces. If there had been then that steel rod might well have bent.

Unfortunately some knowledge of trigonometry, vectors and the like is required to understand this, but examples from daily life are available if you want them.

OK.

Let's simplify this. The steel in the towers does exactly what the skeptics want it to, at all times. It weakens, melts, or whatever you want. None of this matters, though. It doesn't matter one single bit.

As I said before, you can magically remove 20 or 30 floors by whatever means you wish, and then drop the remaining floors on the rest of the building. At the moment of impact, there will be a deceleration. The deceleration will continue until the movement stops, or the top reaches the ground. The only way the top will continue to accelerate is if the lower floors are removed prior to the impact of the upper floors. Go ahead and deny this, but you are denying the most fundamental laws of motion.

In summary, go ahead, pretend the steel can do whatever you want it to. It changes nothing. Newton's third law applies, is valid, and doesn't change with scale.
 
Because he wasn't. :jaw-dropp

Lets see what he actually says in the video.

"So I am taking time out of my busy day, to try to put to rest one of the more moronic things I have seen on the internet lately, and that is saying something. Through my Facebook feed, I saw yet again, that old tired argument, or that question, Jetfuel only burns at 1500 degrees, and since steel melts at 2700 degrees, 9/11 was a conspiracy. I am so sick and tired of this argument. Now, I am not going to make any claims to what did or did not happen. If it was a conspiracy, I do not care. What I am upset about, is the retarded metallurgical things that you guys are saying. I am not arguing the facts. Jetfuel does in fact burn at 1500 degrees. Steel will start melting, some carbon steels, at 2300 degrees. But if you hold this up as a reason for conspiracy, you are an idiot. This is a piece of half inch thick steel. A36 structural steel, designed for structures. This is a 250 pound anvil. Ima put this steel in the back of this anvil, and i am going to lift this 250 pound anvil with this bar of steel. Do you see how the structural steel is supporting this anvil. Ok. There. Now, in my furnace, I have an identical half inch bar of steel, Just like this, and its gonna be like 1800 degrees. Just 300 more than jetfuel, when it comes out. And I want you to see something very interesting. Going to the forge. Its very hot, but not melted. Obviously, its not melted. I put this in here, and now watch this. Ima gonna take my pinky finger, my pinkyfinger! Half inch solid steel. Check it out. Its a frigging noodle.Your argument is invalid. Get over it!"

So where does he compare his steel rod to the towers?

As I said before, the entire video is in the context of 9/11. His experiment supports your theories, even though it's not what actually happened during 9/11. Since you agree with his conclusion, you have no problem with what he is doing.

None of this matters, though. You can claim the steel can do whatever you want, other than defy Newton's laws of motion.

See post #575.
 
OK.

Let's simplify this. The steel in the towers does exactly what the skeptics want it to, at all times. It weakens, melts, or whatever you want. None of this matters, though. It doesn't matter one single bit.

As I said before, you can magically remove 20 or 30 floors by whatever means you wish, and then drop the remaining floors on the rest of the building. At the moment of impact, there will be a deceleration. The deceleration will continue until the movement stops, or the top reaches the ground. The only way the top will continue to accelerate is if the lower floors are removed prior to the impact of the upper floors. Go ahead and deny this, but you are denying the most fundamental laws of motion.

In summary, go ahead, pretend the steel can do whatever you want it to. It changes nothing. Newton's third law applies, is valid, and doesn't change with scale.

This post proves a complete ignorance of gravity and physics; self-debunking.
 
He does it in his video... Did you watch the video? This is what he said.



And here is the video.

https://youtu.be/WgCtvTmshZ8?t=3m55s

And how is this different from the blacksmith heating the rod to 1800 degrees? He clearly says jet fuel burns at 1500 degrees, yet he heats the rod to 1800 degrees. He also claims the rod is structural steel. This implies he is talking about structures. He is talking about 9/11. The WTC towers were made of structural steel. What more do you want? You know he was talking about the WTC buildings. It is implied.

What is your point by your argument? Your argument is absolutely pointless, and it's no longer worth discussing. Continue all you want, but you will do so without me.

This is just another game of semantics. You can continue playing on your own.
 
A sphere of Iron produced in a chimney effect fire,

[qimg]http://i271.photobucket.com/albums/jj132/chainsawprof/P1000572_zps8mhnxv9y.jpg[/qimg]

Sulfidication produced in Chimney effect fire.
[qimg]http://http://i271.photobucket.com/albums/jj132/chainsawprof/P1000493_zpsqdtwr4ug.jpg[/qimg]

Coles experiments are worthless because he miss applies chemistry, and physics, are we supposed to believe that paper can transmit impact energy at 5800 meters per second,
That the bolts and weld will not sheer do to impacts from the Accumulated mass?

I haven't seen one experiment of Cole's that was not completely stupid, not his thermite experiments, his sulfidication experiments, his paper and fire cracker experiments, or his hammered steel rod experiment.
Cole is just an Embarrassment to engineering nothing more and if he believes what he is peddling he shouldn't be an engineer, We need to redo the qualifications to eliminate people like him who could potentially be so incompetent that they could put someone's life at risk.

This is nothing more than a personal attack.

Again, see post #575.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom