If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's possible I missed it, there was a lot of activity overnight :)

If I read you correctly, you are now discussing how much heat an HI can apply to steel and for how long.

This to me is progress, we are looking at the possibilities, rather than just flat out denials and insults.

To my mind, that means that one would have to look at the placement and configuration of the HI, to see if it could be effective.

Here, it is assumed by some truthers that a shaped charge is placed to sever vertical columns. This is denied by debunkers, who seem to consider little piles of powder all over the place, not doing enough precise damage, or derails about evidence, blah, blah, blah.

Neither side wants to really discuss the possibilities, which unfortunately leaves me in a mire, because I can't come to a conclusion unless I can walk through the process.
Fire did it. Darn, you are late to the BS of thermite. 911 truth failed with thermite since 2005.

There is no evidence for any thermite, or shaped charges. No damage to WTC from thermite or shape charges. Thus if you love fantasy, go to a 911 truth web site of woo, and make up lies.

Cole used fire crackers, not thermite, and cole implied just setting off explosives. No explosives on 911. Thus we have three experiments which don't model any aspect of 911, except gravity.

Cole made the three dumbest experiments and fooled a fringe few to believe without thinking.
 
It's possible I missed it, there was a lot of activity overnight :)

If I read you correctly, you are now discussing how much heat an HI can apply to steel and for how long.

This to me is progress, we are looking at the possibilities, rather than just flat out denials and insults.

To my mind, that means that one would have to look at the placement and configuration of the HI, to see if it could be effective.

Here, it is assumed by some truthers that a shaped charge is placed to sever vertical columns. This is denied by debunkers, who seem to consider little piles of powder all over the place, not doing enough precise damage, or derails about evidence, blah, blah, blah.

Neither side wants to really discuss the possibilities, which unfortunately leaves me in a mire, because I can't come to a conclusion unless I can walk through the process.

As CC mentions, there is no 'shaped charge' delivery system for thermite. There is a patent for a small device that directs the flame, but it's more metal than thermite. What's more, to contain enough thermite to theoretically damage the kind of massive steel members in question it would be so big that we bump into that scaling business again; a large volume of thermite would tend to destroy the container before it had done its work. Also installing it and concealing it would, dare I say, be impossible. Not to mention synchronising the many such devices required.

The number of objections to thermite as a serious demolition agent would take many paragraphs to analyse, but one question might settle it - why don't the pros use it?
 
Where would the evidence of Monrue's effect be for a shaped charge?
Do you understanding that thermite can not produce a metal plasma, and be used as a shaped charge?

Thermite either has to a melt the material while in physical contact, or be used in conjunction with Oxygen to heat then oxygenize the material.

But thermite can not produce a metal plasma or a detonation wave.

That's what I'm saying!

(I assume you mean Munroe effect, although if she was there with Elvis, we have more to worry about.)

Preconceptions result in heated arguments and name calling, when I would rather talk about the possibilities.

So you say, that a conventional shaped charge wouldn't work, and I agree that trying to apply a compound to a vertical column and keep enough HI material in contact with the area to be cut (or weakened) would be a challenge.

However, lets assume that if an HI were to be used, that the operators would be far more aware of its limitations and usage than you or I, and would know how to use it without encountering the problems you suggest.

<more to follow, life calls>
 
Fire did it. Darn, you are late to the BS of thermite. 911 truth failed with thermite since 2005.

There is no evidence for any thermite, or shaped charges. No damage to WTC from thermite or shape charges. Thus if you love fantasy, go to a 911 truth web site of woo, and make up lies.

Cole used fire crackers, not thermite, and cole implied just setting off explosives. No explosives on 911. Thus we have three experiments which don't model any aspect of 911, except gravity.

Cole made the three dumbest experiments and fooled a fringe few to believe without thinking.

If I were asked to describe truthers in as few words as possible, those would be the three.
 
Once aga,in Thermite was put forward by Truthers to get round the lack of sound and shock waves associated with demolition charges.
I don't think they even thought about how it could be used, installed or even how it would work.
 
That's what I'm saying!

(I assume you mean Munroe effect, although if she was there with Elvis, we have more to worry about.)

Preconceptions result in heated arguments and name calling, when I would rather talk about the possibilities.

So you say, that a conventional shaped charge wouldn't work, and I agree that trying to apply a compound to a vertical column and keep enough HI material in contact with the area to be cut (or weakened) would be a challenge.

However, lets assume that if an HI were to be used, that the operators would be far more aware of its limitations and usage than you or I, and would know how to use it without encountering the problems you suggest.
<more to follow, life calls>

Impossible.
 
However, lets assume that if an HI were to be used, that the operators would be far more aware of its limitations and usage than you or I, and would know how to use it without encountering the problems you suggest.

No, let's not assume that unless we have some evidence. It's the "Appeal to the mysterious knowledge of nefarious conspirators" logical fallacy (though I'm sure there is a snappier name).
 
As CC mentions, there is no 'shaped charge' delivery system for thermite. There is a patent for a small device that directs the flame, but it's more metal than thermite. What's more, to contain enough thermite to theoretically damage the kind of massive steel members in question it would be so big that we bump into that scaling business again; a large volume of thermite would tend to destroy the container before it had done its work. Also installing it and concealing it would, dare I say, be impossible. Not to mention synchronising the many such devices required.

The number of objections to thermite as a serious demolition agent would take many paragraphs to analyse, but one question might settle it - why don't the pros use it?

You forgot to mention the patent spacificly states that the device can be used in conjunction with compressed O2, to cut though the steel.
As an illustration of a previous experiment of Cole's he uses a gas filled Jack to put pressure on a thermite charge to force the heated Iron produced towards the metal to be melted.
The jack uses cheap neoprene o rings for seals so it would never work in fires, the O rings would melt.
If you can confine the thermite with a thermally dirived oxydant the combination of the hot,
Aluminum oxide, the hot Iron, the pressure, and the oxidizing steel makes a very effective cutting device the only problem though it also makes a very messy dangerous fuel air blast when exposed to fires with an exstreamly blight almost blinding white flash!:D
 
You forgot to mention the patent spacificly states that the device can be used in conjunction with compressed O2, to cut though the steel.
As an illustration of a previous experiment of Cole's he uses a gas filled Jack to put pressure on a thermite charge to force the heated Iron produced towards the metal to be melted.
The jack uses cheap neoprene o rings for seals so it would never work in fires, the O rings would melt.
If you can confine the thermite with a thermally dirived oxydant the combination of the hot,
Aluminum oxide, the hot Iron, the pressure, and the oxidizing steel makes a very effective cutting device the only problem though it also makes a very messy dangerous fuel air blast when exposed to fires with an exstreamly blight almost blinding white flash!:D

I'm thinking of patent 2006/0266204, which got Truthers in a tizzy back then because it was directional. Long time since I read the application, but it appears to be a sealed unit. Maybe I missed the O2 part.
 
That's what I'm saying!

(I assume you mean Munroe effect, although if she was there with Elvis, we have more to worry about.)

Preconceptions result in heated arguments and name calling, when I would rather talk about the possibilities.

So you say, that a conventional shaped charge wouldn't work, and I agree that trying to apply a compound to a vertical column and keep enough HI material in contact with the area to be cut (or weakened) would be a challenge.

However, lets assume that if an HI were to be used, that the operators would be far more aware of its limitations and usage than you or I, and would know how to use it without encountering the problems you suggest.

<more to follow, life calls>

A shaped charge uses Monrue's effect and leaves a visible metal residue on the material it acts upon, usually a green copper oxide.
A shaped charge is an explosive charge that causes formation of a metal plasma, the metal plasma is forced away from the explosive and concentrated by the detonation wave.
It is the metal plasma not the explosive that cuts though the steel and leaves a metal residue behind, usually copper green and easy to spot with the naked eye.
 
No, let's not assume that unless we have some evidence. It's the "Appeal to the mysterious knowledge of nefarious conspirators" logical fallacy (though I'm sure there is a snappier name).

And therein lies the problem. Refusal to work through a thought experiment to come to some sort of conclusion.
 
And therein lies the problem. Refusal to work through a thought experiment to come to some sort of conclusion.
Fire did it, conclusion finished. Are you a fire denier.

Fire caused the collapse. You can make up BS, but fire remains the only culprit. Why are you trying to back in CD. 19 terrorists did 911; the alive BS you showed up with was BS, like CD.
 
Last edited:
I'm thinking of patent 2006/0266204, which got Truthers in a tizzy back then because it was directional. Long time since I read the application, but it appears to be a sealed unit. Maybe I missed the O2 part.

Yes as did Steven E. Jones, he even managed to post a picture of the bridge demolition device with an O2 tank in the back ground, on line years ago without realizing his mistake.

If you read the patent description it is in there, patent drawings are vague for a reason, to prevent copy of the actual device.
 
A shaped charge uses Monrue's effect and leaves a visible metal residue on the material it acts upon, usually a green copper oxide.
A shaped charge is an explosive charge that causes formation of a metal plasma, the metal plasma is forced away from the explosive and concentrated by the detonation wave.
It is the metal plasma not the explosive that cuts though the steel and leaves a metal residue behind, usually copper green and easy to spot with the naked eye.

I think that's where my vocabulary fails. I know that shaped charge is the wrong terminology to use, as it implies an explosion, when what I am referring to is a device or mechanism to direct or control the HI so that it moves in the desired direction, not a detonation wave.

I don't know enough about these materials, but what I do know is that it would be extremely difficult if not impossible to rig it in a way that most people assume that it must be done. A shaped device placed vertically or diagonally on a column, with the intention of severing that column.

I don't know what the correct fallacy is, but saying it couldn't do THIS and therefore wasn't used at all is a bit dismissive and inaccurate.

So we are back to possibilities. If the objective was to ensure that a building that was going to be damaged and subjected to fire collapsed, rather than remain standing, then detonation and explosion and severing of vertical columns is not required. What you require is to ensure that any weakening is sufficient to cause collapse.

Therefore it is theoretically plausible, that devices placed in key areas could cause enough heat to ensure sufficient weakening.

One doesn't need to know the exact make-up of the device and/or the HI to know that if you exclude what is impossible, you can examine what is left.

Given the nature of thermate and its ilk, a shaped device could be fabricated to contain it while it "eats" downward through a horizontal member, enough to weaken it.
 
...
Therefore it is theoretically plausible, that devices placed in key areas could cause enough heat to ensure sufficient weakening....
Which Cole experiment had this BS in it?

Not plausible, no evidence. Only plausible in the minds of 911 truth CD fantasy believers.
 
So we are back to possibilities. If the objective was to ensure that a building that was going to be damaged and subjected to fire collapsed, rather than remain standing, then detonation and explosion and severing of vertical columns is not required. What you require is to ensure that any weakening is sufficient to cause collapse.

Why should you consider that was an objective and not just a consequence of the fires?

You can dream up all sorts of ways to make things happen but first you need to show reason that the objective was what was seen in the end.

No one has really ever explained why building 7 had to fail.
 
Who's making asterisks up?




Did you not question why an incendiary couldn't do it? Yes you did.
Did we answer?
Yes we did.

Can we move on now?


Moving on is not the object, how many skeptics can be gotten to dance around a point, is.
 
Why should you consider that was an objective and not just a consequence of the fires?

You can dream up all sorts of ways to make things happen but first you need to show reason that the objective was what was seen in the end.

No one has really ever explained why building 7 had to fail.

Why do you assume that we have to have complete theories on everything?

I don't know what was in building 7, I don't know what was in the twin towers. I don't know if or why they were brought down, or by whom.

You seem to assume that because I disagree with what I have been told, that I have to have a complete theory down to every last detail. I don't.

I'm trying to work through possibilities, rule out what's impossible and evaluate what's left. Most other people don't want to do that.

The most complete "official narrative" is NIST, and whether you personally admit it or not, it has been agreed by persons on both sides of the debate that it is not 100% correct. The reasons for this are either benign or malicious, and the significance is also hotly debated.

Collaborating, agreeing and discussing on parts that are in dispute, and coming to some sort of rational outcome would in an ideal world put the whole thing to bed, but not if the arguers get so carried away in the fight, that they get distracted from the issues.
 
I think you will run into trouble when it is scaled up, but then I don't know how large you are going, or what materials and connections you will be using.

I'll let you know. Funnily enough, structural engineers know how to make buildings structurally sound, and one of the biggest fanciest international firms of structural engineers in London is on board with this one, and they have no qualms whatsoever about saying this building will work. Unlike internet woo-meisters, structural engineers tend to be pretty good at understanding building's structure.
 
And therein lies the problem. Refusal to work through a thought experiment to come to some sort of conclusion.

I like my thought experiments the way I like my real experiments: with no more assumptions than necessary.

Otherwise, what's the point of the experiment?

Could a secret space laser have been used to bring down the buildings? Of course it could! All we have to do is set up a thought experiment where we assume that such a thing exists.

No, let's not assume anything unless we have to. Can you explain the need for the assumptions you're asking for? It seems like the only reason to make these assumptions is to ensure that our thought experiment reaches not "some sort of conclusion", but rather a predetermined conclusion. That's a terrible way to run an experiment, real or otherwise.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom