If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I will give you credit for your attempt at turning my argument against me. Well done, but it's BS.

My point was, and everyone knows it, is that elementary physics can be learned and understood by elementary-aged children. If you teach them physics, and then show them the collapses, I'm certain they would tell you that the floors had to be removed in order for the upper portion to fall all the way to the ground in the time it took. Only when they learn the politics involved do they become blind to what really happened.

Only if you were negligent in teaching them about scaling...
 
This has to be a joke. It has to be, unless you're a CIA or MI6 asset. There is no way a licensed, practicing structural engineer would compare Ronan Point to the WTC buildings. It just wouldn't happen. If you really are an engineer, you're paid to be here.

Wait. Aren't you the one claiming the destruction of a model, with a construction completely unlike the construction of the WTC towers, "proves" something about the collapse of the towers? Rowan point was mentioned only to help you see your fundamental error about sequential loading.

And you are still ignoring scaling...
 
You can attack Cole's conclusions all you want. Personal attacks and attacks on the experiments are unfounded.

Cole's conclusions are derived from a completely inaccurate model, custom-crafted to produce the effect he needed to support his pre-determined "conclusions".

ETA: Perhaps I am being unfair--Cole did, at least, get the direction in which things fall correct.
 
Last edited:
This question can't be answered based on the information given. What I can say, with 100 percent certainty, is that if the top floor(s) impacted the bottom floor, there would be an equal and opposite reaction during the impact. This would cause the upper floors to decelerate. If the upper floors continued to accelerate continuously, regardless of the rate of acceleration , the ONLY correct conclusion is that there is nothing below the upper floors stopping their fall.

It is here that you do err.
 
Last edited:
You misunderstand, this is not a game or trolling.

To me ineffective means no (or insufficient) damage, couldn't do it. I think you are working on inefficient, not ineffective.

It could simply be a conflict of definition, again I offer the benefit of the doubt.

Step two, you are stumbling over "random normal heat". It's not dishonesty. I had, in a section you chose to ignore, said normal office fires. Office fires are normal, they can be modelled, they can be predicted, and their are measures in place to combat them. A normal fire in an office is "normal heat" when an office is on fire.

So, we are interpreting the quote I was replying to, and my response, in different ways, using different definitions. Is there any wonder you can't grasp where I am coming from?

MHM claims a high incendiary would be ineffective in a CD scenario. I read this to mean that an HI cannot bring down a building, even though office fires did. I do not understand this logic.

When we boil down various collapse scenarios, it is all down to the application of heat to steel (before buckling and everything else), correct? So to claim that an HI cannot apply heat to steel is counter intuitive, when your opposing argument is that a normal office fire applied the heat to the steel.

There is much more on the subject that baffles me, and we may get to at other times, but it was this, and only this that I was responding to.

It is because(A) thermite is hard too time.
(B) electric matches and batteries are undependable in fires.
(C)the Aluminum in thermite can melt at 600C and the iron oxide float to the surface rendering the thermite inert.
(D) Thermite, works best when utilized with a high pressure oxygen jet from either bottled oxygen, or a thermally derived oxygen source.
(E) 99% of the steel that was photography captured or examined, showed evidence of sheer, not Monrue's effect, or ductile deformation with embedded shrapnel, or melting or Oxygen cutting.
(F ). The protection of the buildings from chimney effect fires, was compromised on 9/11/2001, and an massive fire of up to 1400C is quite possible in the critical core of the towers and in the elevator shafts of building 7 with little or no flame.
(G) if you had read and understood RJ. Lee's letter, on the micro spheres, you would have understood that, that is also where Cole fails in his sulfidication experiment,
Structure and structural integrity of systems in a building plays a major role in fires and the chemical reactions induced in and by those fires.
(H) Jones, & Harrit, and Gage as well as Cole, conveniently ignore that simple fact always have one of the reasons I didn't believe Jones, in 2005 when I called him after talking to someone at NBC, while preparing for my appearance on the tonight show.
 
It would be nice if everyone who is being paid to be here could identify themselves. I would like to take that into consideration when evaluating criticisms of Cole's experiment.

I am not being paid to be here.

I'm a high school physics teacher, who understands how critical scaling is, and am here of my own volition.
 
First, let me clarify my original post.

To simplify my argument, I have removed some words.

I will use the following as my definition of acceleration: Acceleration is a vector quantity that is defined as the rate at which an object changes its velocity. An object is accelerating if it is changing its velocity.

Source: http://www.physicsclassroom.com/class/1DKin/Lesson-1/Acceleration

I will define deceleration as acceleration in the opposite direction. Acceleration in the opposite direction of travel will cause an object to slow down, or decelerate.

If an object's velocity is 10m/s downwards one second, and then 9m/s downwards the next second, it has decelerated. The cause was an acceleration force in the opposite direction. The deceleration could be continuous, which would cause the object to eventually stop, or it could be instantaneous, which means without air resistance or other force, the object would continue to travel at 9m/s downwards. This example ignores the forces due to gravity, air resistance, and friction, solely for the purpose of giving a definition.

...what happens when you drive a small nail with a big hammer?
 
This is simple. The blacksmith bends the rod sideways with his pinky, which is only a demonstration of the steel's weakness to sideways forces. Cole's hammer exerts a downwards force on the heated steel, much like the force exerted by the upper floors on the lower floors . The steel did not bend.

Summary, the steel bent when a sideways force was applied, but not a downwards force. The conclusion is that the steel, even when heated, was able to resist the downward force applied by the upper floors.

It is here that you do err.
 
This is the fairest post I have seen on this forum. You admitted the experiment was good, but you reject his conclusions. That's fair.

The question then is, why do you reject his conclusions? If his experiments are good, why are his conclusions wrong?

...because he ignored scaling...

(And because he depended upon an incorrect model of the construction of the towers.)

About the only thing he got right is the direction things fall in this gravity well.
 
OK, but you have no problem with the blacksmith comparing the steel rod to the twin towers, right? It's OK for the blacksmith to do it, because it supports your ideas, but when Cole does it it's wrong, because it goes against what you believe. Right?

Ummm...no.

(Gently) The blacksmith compared the heated steel rod to...


...a heated steel rod.
 
This proves global structural collapse? One corner = whole building?

Any Time a structure's connections have insufficient strength to absorb the energy acted upon the structure, the connections will fail, it is simply that simple.

The rate of failure will be determined by the discrepancy between the strength of the connections vs the energy acting upon them too produce the sheering force. Said force acting upon the structure to cause disunification.

Interestingly if the towers structure had been heated more the collapse would have been slower slightly by about 1/10 to 1/8 of a second, as more ductile deformation would have taken place absorbing more energy from the accumulating and descending mass.
 
I think you will run into trouble when it is scaled up, but then I don't know how large you are going, or what materials and connections you will be using.

It is actually quite a strong structure, as the propeller like wings act as buttressed structures and should be good at dissipation of wind loading, as long as it is not sucked up by a water spout.

I am working on a similar design for a theoretical tall building using an overlapping truss structure of 3d printed steel, a building where connection failures like those seen on 9/11/2001 would be impossible.
 
I gave the bones of an answer to this yesterday, but perhaps you missed it. It boils down to how much heat plausible incendiary packages can deliver to the steel during the duration of their activity, and it isn't enough. Some are impressed by the high temperatures of thermitic reactions, but they're short-lived reactions.

Pass your finger through a candle flame and you'll come to no harm. Pour a pint of (much cooler) boiling water on your finger and you'll get a serious burn.

It's possible I missed it, there was a lot of activity overnight :)

If I read you correctly, you are now discussing how much heat an HI can apply to steel and for how long.

This to me is progress, we are looking at the possibilities, rather than just flat out denials and insults.

To my mind, that means that one would have to look at the placement and configuration of the HI, to see if it could be effective.

Here, it is assumed by some truthers that a shaped charge is placed to sever vertical columns. This is denied by debunkers, who seem to consider little piles of powder all over the place, not doing enough precise damage, or derails about evidence, blah, blah, blah.

Neither side wants to really discuss the possibilities, which unfortunately leaves me in a mire, because I can't come to a conclusion unless I can walk through the process.
 
It's possible I missed it, there was a lot of activity overnight :)

If I read you correctly, you are now discussing how much heat an HI can apply to steel and for how long.

This to me is progress, we are looking at the possibilities, rather than just flat out denials and insults.

To my mind, that means that one would have to look at the placement and configuration of the HI, to see if it could be effective.

Here, it is assumed by some truthers that a shaped charge is placed to sever vertical columns. This is denied by debunkers, who seem to consider little piles of powder all over the place, not doing enough precise damage, or derails about evidence, blah, blah, blah.

Neither side wants to really discuss the possibilities, which unfortunately leaves me in a mire, because I can't come to a conclusion unless I can walk through the process.

Where would the evidence of Monrue's effect be for a shaped charge?
Do you understanding that thermite can not produce a metal plasma, and be used as a shaped charge?

Thermite either has to a melt the material while in physical contact, or be used in conjunction with Oxygen to heat then oxygenize the material.

But thermite can not produce a metal plasma or a detonation wave.
 
Last edited:
It's possible I missed it, there was a lot of activity overnight :)

If I read you correctly, you are now discussing how much heat an HI can apply to steel and for how long.

This to me is progress, we are looking at the possibilities, rather than just flat out denials and insults.

To my mind, that means that one would have to look at the placement and configuration of the HI, to see if it could be effective.

Here, it is assumed by some truthers that a shaped charge is placed to sever vertical columns. This is denied by debunkers, who seem to consider little piles of powder all over the place, not doing enough precise damage, or derails about evidence, blah, blah, blah.

Your flat-out denials are what causes the insults.

Protip - don't ask questions if you don't want the answers.

Neither side wants to really discuss the possibilities, which unfortunately leaves me in a mire, because I can't come to a conclusion unless I can walk through the process.

Debunkers as you call us, have discussed the possibilities. The percentage that a high incendiary was responsible for anything on 9/11 is zero.
 
It is actually quite a strong structure, as the propeller like wings act as buttressed structures and should be good at dissipation of wind loading, as long as it is not sucked up by a water spout.

I am working on a similar design for a theoretical tall building using an overlapping truss structure of 3d printed steel, a building where connection failures like those seen on 9/11/2001 would be impossible.

I replied before I got to the bit about the internal walls being load bearing. My biggest concern was the ring that supports the dome, and the connections from the .. glalums? I understand that his model is not a perfect depiction, so I was concerned about the connection of the glalums to the ring, and the connections of the butresses to the glalums. In both cases it is vertical faces that connect, presenting shear concerns with gravity loads without further support.

The model was incomplete at the point I was viewing it, and there is a few pages on the thread which I haven't had time to go through.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom