If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
To become a "Sewage Engineer" he probably had to undergo a selective lobotomy so that he could apply physics to sewers but be incompetent in the physics of structures.

We need check - why don't we ask a "Sewage Engineer" if such selective surgical intervention was needed by him/her to reduce his/her reasoning skills, scope of understanding and basic intelligence from the heights of "structural engineer" down to the pits as a "sewerage engineer".

Until then I'll remain unconvinced that what field an engineer works in would guarantee a lack of competence in another field of engineering.

Presumably a person intelligent enough to be a structural engineer could move into the field of sewer (or water??) engineering BUT no mere water/sewer engineer could deign to offer comment on crassly wrong claims in the field of structures.

Maybe I'm wrong but I have the crazy idea that Cole is wrong because the idiotic claims he makes are wrong. Wrong in engineering. Wrong in structural engineering. And NOT wrong because he is a "Sewage" engineer.

And my second crazy idea is that his claims would be wrong if those same claims were made by a structural engineer. Or an aeronautical engineer or....
...someone who drives school buses or
...etc...etc...

They would still be wrong if they were claimed by an architect...

...or a journalist...

or.....

They would be wrong if they were claimed by a talking Kangaroo, a talking cow, or Christ himself.
My point was Cole specific work experience is in sewers and pumping systems not in structures.
I have a feeling since that is his specialty, he may have a bone or two to pick with the government, over past work he has done, and may be on a vendeta, that is blinding him as to
How foolish his Ideas are.
He is working in Florida, and it is easy to run a foul of the EPA doing his type of engineering work in Florida.
 
He doesn't care about evidence or physics or even proving a point.
He is motivated by political ideology, a sense of persecution and the knowledge that he is one of the superior thinkers that knows the truth unlike you brainwashed sheep. It's the same with all Conspiracy Brlievers and Truthers.
Look st Moon Hoax, JFK, Sandy Hook, and in the past things like TWA 800. They are all the same.

As long as he keeps the thread going he is winning.
 
The thermal properties which led to the failures at the WTC were both loss of strength and expansion when heated. The later caused the frame to distorted locally, joints to fail and local failures leading to floor sections dropping on overloading local areas where the material dropped. This sort of process progressed passed the point of no return and the sections above these local failures were inadequately support AND misaligned with the axial system below. This was the moment of naked eye visible release.
 
Fair enough. What you say in one thread on one day has nothing to do with what you say on others at different times.

It would help if you start out with a score card so we can keep track of your ever changing moods. OK?

People keep telling me to try and focus and stay on topic, so that's what I'm trying to do in each thread, so yes, what I say will be different in each one based on who I'm talking to and what we are talking about.

Yourself and others are the ones trying to lump everything together into a fantastical CT so that you can pigeon-hole me according to your preconceptions.
 
Second, the issue is simply one of semantics, and definition.

You assume that I think the cement slab on floor 50 (as an example), supports the weight of every concrete slab above it. This is obviously not true. When I think of a "floor", I take into account the support columns on that floor, the trusses, the steel plates on top of the trusses, and the cement poured on top of the steel plates. So, when I think of floor 50, I know that floor 50 has to support floors 50 through 110. The issue is simply one of semantics and an unclear definition. It was not one of a lack of understanding.

The issue is this:

While you explain your understanding of what you mean by floor - and in that context, are correct - it misses the point entirely.

It misses the point cuz in your view, the falling stuff has its momentum directed onto the columns ONLY, bypassing any inherent weakness/inability of the floor pans to stop the stuff from falling.

But that's not how things work in the real world.

In the real world, stuff falls onto the floor pans first, which have to be able to absorb that momentum and THEN direct that momentum onto the columns. You now realize/admit that couldn't happen.

Therefore, your earlier assertion that the "floors" should survive falling stuff, or however you phrased it, to be wrong.

You should thank those that corrected you. It doesn't hurt your position to do so....
 
A sphere can be a solid. Your argument needs further clarification. If you are trying to use semantics to insinuate that no currently molten spheres of iron have been found, then I don't get your point. It makes no sense to assume steel would stay molten long after any external heat was applied. In order for a solid sphere to exist, it must have been molten, or able to be shaped, at one time.


(Wow, I post late on a Saturday night, get up very early Sunday morning and there are three new pages on this thread. Do all Truthers keep Russian time now?)

Further clarification? Cole says, on the video (starting 20 seconds in), "There's plenty of evidence of temperatures high enough to melt steel, including molten spheres of iron..."

Yet no molten spheres have been found, only solid ones.

Molten spheres are evidence that temperatures high enough to melt steel are present. Solid ones are not.

The actual evidence is not molten spheres as Cole claims, it's solid spheres that one might assume (and might be mistaken in so assuming) were molten at the time of the collapse.

Why does that matter? Because it takes an assumption (that temperatures were high enough at the time of collapse that the solid spheres that were found afterward were molten at that time) and pretends that that's evidence for the assumption itself. It's circular reasoning.

It's as though you were accused of embezzling and in court, the prosecutor holds up 67 dollars in cash that was seized from your wallet at your arrest, and tells the jury, "This embezzled money in the accused's possession proves that he is guilty of embezzling." By calling it "embezzled money" he's assuming what he's claiming to show as evidence, that you embezzled the money rather than rightfully owned it.

How does he know it's embezzled money? Because it was in your possession and you're an embezzler. How does he know you're an embezzler? Because you were in possession of embezzled money. That's how circular reasoning works.

Off to prison with you! (Well, maybe in Russia. In the U.S. any competent defense lawyer could object to that statement in court as unsupported, assuming the conclusion, or prejudicial, and the judge would disallow the testimony.)

How does Cole know the spheres were molten at the time of the collapse? Because temperatures were high enough to melt steel! How does he know there were temperatures high enough to melt steel? Because there were molten spheres of iron! That's how circular reasoning works.

His other "evidence" for the "temperatures high enough to melt steel" all works the same way. Assuming the conclusion, again and again: "melted steel full of holes," "melted handguns in the museum" and so forth.

This is not a matter of particular engineering or other expertise; it's a basic error in reasoning. Cole didn't get some engineering wrong, he got elementary logic wrong. He got thinking wrong.

And that's his very first claim in the video. No need to watch any farther to find what he got wrong.
 
Do I have definitive proof of this (other than the existence of gatekeepers)? No. My evidence is thousands upon thousands of posts by skeptics denying the most fundamental laws of physics, .



Let's use the hypothetical situation that you are wrong about the thousands of posts by skeptics that deny the most fundamental laws of physics because YOUR understanding is too rudimentary, and the posts by skeptics ACTUALLY refer to laws of physics that are far more complex than the fundamental laws can be applied to.

How would your stance about 9/11 change?
 
So stop playing silly games and someone like me WILL walk you through the issue. Step by step - as long as you are prepared to join in reasoned discussion.

BUT drop the lies by half truth crap.

"An incendiary couldn't do it..." was NOT the claim - the claim was that thermite is "totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition" That assertion is true for the Twin Towers AND even more to the point is the fact that thermite was not used. More pedantically the burden of proof is on anyone claiming thermite usage to prove that it was used. No one has. And there i an even more fundamental issue - thermite is only of relevance if it was used in some form of MHI (AKA "CD"). So prove CD and maybe you can THEN explain why and how thermite was used. BUT drop the arse about truther style of false argument.

"...what random normal heat did almost by accident..." is also deliberate dishonesty in your response. The "heat" was neither "normal" nor "random".

So stop with the debating tricks - such as those two lies by goal post shifting.

The ball as always in your court. I will join in honest reasoned discussion and explain those aspects you clearly do not understand or are pretending to not understand.

I am prepared to "walk you though" the reasoning of the issue. If you don't want to join in honest debate - no problem to me - I will not persist in responding to trolling.

You misunderstand, this is not a game or trolling.

To me ineffective means no (or insufficient) damage, couldn't do it. I think you are working on inefficient, not ineffective.

It could simply be a conflict of definition, again I offer the benefit of the doubt.

Step two, you are stumbling over "random normal heat". It's not dishonesty. I had, in a section you chose to ignore, said normal office fires. Office fires are normal, they can be modelled, they can be predicted, and their are measures in place to combat them. A normal fire in an office is "normal heat" when an office is on fire.

So, we are interpreting the quote I was replying to, and my response, in different ways, using different definitions. Is there any wonder you can't grasp where I am coming from?

MHM claims a high incendiary would be ineffective in a CD scenario. I read this to mean that an HI cannot bring down a building, even though office fires did. I do not understand this logic.

When we boil down various collapse scenarios, it is all down to the application of heat to steel (before buckling and everything else), correct? So to claim that an HI cannot apply heat to steel is counter intuitive, when your opposing argument is that a normal office fire applied the heat to the steel.

There is much more on the subject that baffles me, and we may get to at other times, but it was this, and only this that I was responding to.
 
People keep telling me to try and focus and stay on topic, so that's what I'm trying to do in each thread, so yes, what I say will be different in each one based on who I'm talking to and what we are talking about.

Yourself and others are the ones trying to lump everything together into a fantastical CT so that you can pigeon-hole me according to your preconceptions.

This is the natural result of you asking for something, getting it, and then ignoring it. Like when you asked for proof that WTC 7 was more than superficially damaged by the North Tower.
I proved it to you in seconds. Yet you ignore it.

That behavior gives us all the evidence we need to draw conclusions on your motives.
 
This question can't be answered based on the information given. What I can say, with 100 percent certainty, is that if the top floor(s) impacted the bottom floor, there would be an equal and opposite reaction during the impact. This would cause the upper floors to decelerate. If the upper floors continued to accelerate continuously, regardless of the rate of acceleration, the ONLY correct conclusion is that there is nothing below the upper floors stopping their fall.
Can you please address my question, that I have asked several times, of what proof do you have that the upper floors did not decelerate every time they crashed on another floor?

Otherwise you are making a bare unsupported assertion.

You are dodging that question. It looks more and more like you're making it up to support your conclusion.

It's your very premise whey you say this:
If the upper floors continued to accelerate continuously, regardless of the rate of acceleration, the ONLY correct conclusion is that there is nothing below the upper floors stopping their fall.
I am denying your premise. The floors did not accelerate continuously and you have no proof that they did. They accelerated discontinuously: each impact decelerated a floor, then the detached floor plus the already accumulated mass of floors accelerated again due to gravity until they hit the next floor.
 
MHM claims a high incendiary would be ineffective in a CD scenario. I read this to mean that an HI cannot bring down a building, even though office fires did. I do not understand this logic.

I gave the bones of an answer to this yesterday, but perhaps you missed it. It boils down to how much heat plausible incendiary packages can deliver to the steel during the duration of their activity, and it isn't enough. Some are impressed by the high temperatures of thermitic reactions, but they're short-lived reactions.

Pass your finger through a candle flame and you'll come to no harm. Pour a pint of (much cooler) boiling water on your finger and you'll get a serious burn.
 
When we boil down various collapse scenarios, it is all down to the application of heat to steel (before buckling and everything else), correct? So to claim that an HI cannot apply heat to steel is counter intuitive, when your opposing argument is that a normal office fire applied the heat to the steel.

I think you are reading it wrong. Truthers always claim that office fires are not hot enough to weaken the structure for it to collapse, so it can only be done by HI. So they skip the part that says, that fires can weaken a building enough for it to collapse. You start out with the wrong premise. So why would NIST look at explosives, when fires were enough to weaken the structure for it to collapse? Whats next? Does NIST also has to test the laser beam theories?
 
Step two, you are stumbling over "random normal heat". It's not dishonesty. I had, in a section you chose to ignore, said normal office fires. Office fires are normal, they can be modelled, they can be predicted, and their are measures in place to combat them. A normal fire in an office is "normal heat" when an office is on fire.

MHM claims a high incendiary would be ineffective in a CD scenario. I read this to mean that an HI cannot bring down a building, even though office fires did. I do not understand this logic.

There was nothing normal about any aspect of 9/11. Normal office fires aren't started over 20 floors, simultaneously, by a 757 striking a building at 500 mph or whatever it was.

Normal office fires don't have a massive hole in the side of the building, feeding an endless supply of oxygen. They are also suppressed by the building's internal system, which wasn't functioning.

You need to stop with the crap you got from Truther University, using descriptors designed to minimize observations. You need to apply common sense.

Nothing about 9/11 was "normal".
 
NIST worked for years on their reports, to come up with the most plausible theory, as to what happened on 9/11 to the buildings based on numerous evidence. If the truth movement is not happy with that theory, they should bring forth their own theory based on factual evidence and support by that evidence. They have not even started on that yet, so why should we take the truth movement serious?

Its easy to try to discredit an organisation like NIST, just because they are part of the conspiracy, or are government sponsored, so they must be in on it, or whatever. Its a lot harder to come up with own theories, that stand on their own, and prove that the buildings were blown up, or taken down by super thermite, that for some reason is so secret, that only the government can get its hands on. So truthers can say, we cant come up with our own theory, because we don't know what kind of superthermite was used.

Thats what I call an easy cop out tbh. Its just a stupid excuse, because they have no clue as to what has happened, and are to stupid to come up with their own theory, no matter how much cash Gage forks in every year with AE911truth.
 
This question can't be answered based on the information given. What I can say, with 100 percent certainty, is that if the top floor(s) impacted the bottom floor, there would be an equal and opposite reaction during the impact.

While true, it doesn't mean that both parts have equal amounts of energy to impart/absorb.

Think about this simple example:

You have a 50 lb weight tied off to a string that has a breaking strength of 25 lbs, giving you an overload factor of 2/1.

Now raise the weight a sufficient distance that will break the string when you drop it. We'll assume 5 ft. We agree that at some as of yet unknown distance, the string will break, right?

When the dropped weight falls (at free fall acceleration) that 5 ft, the string goes tight and breaks.

There was an equal and opposite reaction when the string broke, but the weight continues to fall cuz it had more potential energy to impart to the string than the string could absorb. Right?

This would cause the upper floors to decelerate.

Not necessarily, and here's where an oversimplified understanding of physics gets you in trouble/confused.

2 things can happen:

1- if the string is vastly overloaded by the dropping weight, it won't decelerate the weight. Remember when the weight was first dropped and it accelerated a free fall acceleration? In this case, the string will merely check up the weight's fall a little and cause the weight to briefly experience a period of less than free fall acceleration.

2- With a stronger string, there can indeed be true deceleration.

There's a subtle distinction between the 2 scenarios that is difficult to grasp at times, but it's the difference between having a rudimentary understanding of physics and a more evolved one.

If the upper floors continued to accelerate continuously, regardless of the rate of acceleration, the ONLY correct conclusion is that there is nothing below the upper floors stopping their fall.

No.

Take the weight to a height of 100', with a series of strings that are progressively 5' longer - the first will be 5', the second 10', and so on. Every 5' there will still be an equal and opposite reaction between the weight and the strings, just as you state, so there is no violation in the laws of physics there.

So, and think this through a bit before you reply, if at 100' the starting velocity is 0 fps and the weight has reached sufficient velocity after being accelerated by gravity at free fall acceleration (which gives it sufficient momentum) the break the string at the 95' level, it will without a doubt have a higher velocity (and hence even MORE momentum) when it reaches the 90' level since it passed through the 95' level with a velocity of > 0 fps.

Please understand that the string does NOT represent the column strength, but rather the floor strength, because stuff falls on the floors first as explained in an earlier post.
 
NIST worked for years on their reports, to come up with the most plausible theory, as to what happened on 9/11 to the buildings based on numerous evidence. If the truth movement is not happy with that theory, they should bring forth their own theory based on factual evidence and support by that evidence. They have not even started on that yet, so why should we take the truth movement serious?
Yeah, that. ^

Looks like even Husley is only trying to "prove NIST wrong version the umpteenth", rather than come up with a plausible alternative hypothesis.
 
He could be mistaken, but not about his experiments. His experiments simply show that the fundamental laws of physics, as they pertain to downward motion, are true.

If you want to question his conclusions, then go ahead; but don't question his experiments. There is nothing wrong with them.

Scaling
...
 
If anyone were really interested in the progressive collapse of tower blocks, the classic case is Ronan Point. This happened in London in the 1960s. A gas explosion on the 18th floor led to the collapse of 4 floors above. These floors fell onto the 18th, causing it to fail, which fell onto the 17th with the weight and inertia of 5 floors, which collapsed and fell onto the 16th with the weight and inertia of 6 floors, which fell onto the 15th with the weight and intertia of 7 floors, and so on, until the collapse reached the first floor where a cast in situ floor supported by columns broke the fall.

This building was very different from the WTC in that it was made of PCC panels bolted together (ie it wasn't framed), but the principle of progressive collapse was well established with this incident, and entirely (and conveniently) ignored by the ignorami claiming deliberate demolition of the WTC buildings.


This proves global structural collapse? One corner = whole building?
 
Scale does not matter when it comes to the laws of motion, but they most certainly do matter when it comes to the size and composition of large vs. small objects and structures.

While the former isn't exactly true - scale, for example, is crucial to things like air resistance - the latter is of course spot on. Now, try applying this new-found understanding of yours to the question of whether a collision between two planks a foot or so across with smooth surfaces will behave exactly the same as one between 208 foot wide assemblies of columns, floor trusses and concrete floor pans, all of which have already been broken, twisted and misaligned by random amounts.

Your model, in which part of the structure magically vanishes leaving perfectly undamaged sections above and below in perfect alignment, is a vastly over-simplified one that was generated as one that was unrealistically biased in favour of collapse arrest. Your continued failure to understand the difference between this model and the almost infinitely more complex features of a real collapse is what Cole is relying on to sell you his snake oil, and you continue to be a most enthusiastic customer.

Dave
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom