If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I once was a 'gatekeeper', but I left it open and let out all the sheeple. :blush:

As for being paid, I'll take $50 per month to stay away from ISF.
 
Last edited:
There's something missing from those drawings. He doesn't show the locations where he's going to install the thermite.

:D

-

It's a timber framed building, therefore much less likely to be destroyed in a fire than a steel framed one. Some people never get this.
 
OK, but you have no problem with the blacksmith comparing the steel rod to the twin towers, right? It's OK for the blacksmith to do it, because it supports your ideas, but when Cole does it it's wrong, because it goes against what you believe. Right?

The blacksmith never says he is comparing a steel rod to the towers, and if he did, he is an idiot. The blacksmith just points out that steel weakens when heated. Nothing more or less.
 
OK, but you have no problem with the blacksmith comparing the steel rod to the twin towers, right? It's OK for the blacksmith to do it, because it supports your ideas, but when Cole does it it's wrong, because it goes against what you believe. Right?

Did the blacksmith ever claim that his piece of steel represented the whole tower? If he did (I must have missed it), then he would be completely wrong too. I believe his claim was just that he could show that steel didn't have to melt to deform. Did he or did he not show that?
 
Did the blacksmith ever claim that his piece of steel represented the whole tower? If he did (I must have missed it), then he would be completely wrong too. I believe his claim was just that he could show that steel didn't have to melt to deform. Did he or did he not show that?

great minds, think alike ;)
 
Do you accept that:

1/steel weakens as it gets hot?

2/steel expands as it gets hot?

3/that the weakest point of any steel frame are the fixings?



To test how good your understanding of irony was. You rather proved my point for me. Thanks.


Here is what you're missing.

Let's say the steel melted. It didn't, but let's say it did.

Let's just say that floors 60 through 80 magically disappeared instantaneously, and floors 81 through 110 fell about 210 feet and impacted floor 59. That is 210 feet of freefall acceleration that I will give you. What would happen when floor 81 impacted floor 59? There would be a hell of an impact, but the force exerted by floors 81 through 110 on floor 59 would be exerted by floor 59 on floors 81 through 110. This impact would cause the upper block to decelerate. That's a fact. The expected deceleration of the upper floors was not observed in the actual WTC collapse. There is only one explanation for this.

Talk about melting steel all you want. I have just spotted you 21 floors that magically disappeared. In fact, if you want, add 21 floors to the top. Let's say that there were 131 floors in the WTC buildings. It doesn't matter. There would have been a deceleration as the upper floors impacted the lower floors. This did not happen.

You also refuse to accept the fact that floor 59 was always supporting the upper floors, so the only additional forces would be from the kinetic energy. Some of this energy would be absorbed by floor 59, and when floor 59 failed, there would be less total energy (or forces) exerted on floor 58. I'm not saying that the entire building wouldn't collapse in my example, but I am saying the upper floors would not accelerate at or near freefall all the way to the ground.
 
I believe his claim was just that he could show that steel didn't have to melt to deform. Did he or did he not show that?
And did Cole show that the steel could handle a downward force without deforming (severely)? I think he did. Did Cole show that the rod didn't collapse due to gravity? I think he did.
 
The blacksmith never says he is comparing a steel rod to the towers, and if he did, he is an idiot. The blacksmith just points out that steel weakens when heated. Nothing more or less.

This is nonsense. The whole video is an attempt to debunk truthers. The whole video is about 9/11 and steel. What do you think he's talking about?
 
And did Cole show that the steel could handle a downward force without deforming (severely)? I think he did. Did Cole show that the rod didn't collapse due to gravity? I think he did.

Wow, you really don't get it do you? How the hell can you compare a steel rod, to an entire building? How stupid do you need to be, to not see a problem with that?
 
Wow, you really don't get it do you? How the hell can you compare a steel rod, to an entire building? How stupid do you need to be, to not see a problem with that?

Yet you have no problem with the blacksmith doing it, do you?
 
Yes, but he is not comparing a single steel rod to an entire building!!!!!!:jaw-dropp

He is implying it.

Also, where does Cole compare that rod to an entire building? I am certain he wouldn't, because scale and materials DO matter. Scale does not matter when it comes to the laws of motion, but they most certainly do matter when it comes to the size and composition of large vs. small objects and structures.

The blacksmith also heats the steel to 1800 degrees using a furnace. The conditions were nothing like what happened on 9/11. Skeptics don't seem to have a problem with that.
 
He is implying it.

Also, where does Cole compare that rod to an entire building? I am certain he wouldn't, because scale and materials DO matter. Scale does not matter when it comes to the laws of motion, but they most certainly do matter when it comes to the size and composition of large vs. small objects and structures.

The blacksmith also heats the steel to 1800 degrees using a furnace. The conditions were nothing like what happened on 9/11. Skeptics don't seem to have a problem with that.

FalseFlag, the blacksmith demonstrates something useful in understanding the collapse - that steel weakened by heat can more easily bend when subjected to lateral forces. This is relevant when realising that WTC columns were subject to lateral forces when floor pans sagged as a result of the heat. Once bent by those lateral forces then the vertical forces they were supporting became catastrophic.

In Cole's experiment there were no lateral forces. If there had been then that steel rod might well have bent.

Unfortunately some knowledge of trigonometry, vectors and the like is required to understand this, but examples from daily life are available if you want them.
 
Yet you have no problem with the blacksmith doing it, do you?

Because he wasn't. :jaw-dropp

Lets see what he actually says in the video.

"So I am taking time out of my busy day, to try to put to rest one of the more moronic things I have seen on the internet lately, and that is saying something. Through my Facebook feed, I saw yet again, that old tired argument, or that question, Jetfuel only burns at 1500 degrees, and since steel melts at 2700 degrees, 9/11 was a conspiracy. I am so sick and tired of this argument. Now, I am not going to make any claims to what did or did not happen. If it was a conspiracy, I do not care. What I am upset about, is the retarded metallurgical things that you guys are saying. I am not arguing the facts. Jetfuel does in fact burn at 1500 degrees. Steel will start melting, some carbon steels, at 2300 degrees. But if you hold this up as a reason for conspiracy, you are an idiot. This is a piece of half inch thick steel. A36 structural steel, designed for structures. This is a 250 pound anvil. Ima put this steel in the back of this anvil, and i am going to lift this 250 pound anvil with this bar of steel. Do you see how the structural steel is supporting this anvil. Ok. There. Now, in my furnace, I have an identical half inch bar of steel, Just like this, and its gonna be like 1800 degrees. Just 300 more than jetfuel, when it comes out. And I want you to see something very interesting. Going to the forge. Its very hot, but not melted. Obviously, its not melted. I put this in here, and now watch this. Ima gonna take my pinky finger, my pinkyfinger! Half inch solid steel. Check it out. Its a frigging noodle.Your argument is invalid. Get over it!"

So where does he compare his steel rod to the towers?
 
Last edited:
He is implying it.

Also, where does Cole compare that rod to an entire building? I am certain he wouldn't, because scale and materials DO matter. Scale does not matter when it comes to the laws of motion, but they most certainly do matter when it comes to the size and composition of large vs. small objects and structures.

The blacksmith also heats the steel to 1800 degrees using a furnace. The conditions were nothing like what happened on 9/11. Skeptics don't seem to have a problem with that.

He does it in his video... Did you watch the video? This is what he said.

"Lets conduct a more realistic experiment, by heating a rod at about where the heat really was in the towers". So there is no denying he is actually comparing the rod to a tower. But just to be sure, he then says the following. "And see if the top accelerates down, by gravity alone".

And here is the video.

https://youtu.be/WgCtvTmshZ8?t=3m55s
 
A sphere can be a solid. Your argument needs further clarification. If you are trying to use semantics to insinuate that no currently molten spheres of iron have been found, then I don't get your point. It makes no sense to assume steel would stay molten long after any external heat was applied. In order for a solid sphere to exist, it must have been molten, or able to be shaped, at one time.

A sphere of Iron produced in a chimney effect fire,

P1000572_zps8mhnxv9y.jpg


Sulfidication produced in Chimney effect fire.
P1000493_zpsqdtwr4ug.jpg


Coles experiments are worthless because he miss applies chemistry, and physics, are we supposed to believe that paper can transmit impact energy at 5800 meters per second,
That the bolts and weld will not sheer do to impacts from the Accumulated mass?

I haven't seen one experiment of Cole's that was not completely stupid, not his thermite experiments, his sulfidication experiments, his paper and fire cracker experiments, or his hammered steel rod experiment.
Cole is just an Embarrassment to engineering nothing more and if he believes what he is peddling he shouldn't be an engineer, We need to redo the qualifications to eliminate people like him who could potentially be so incompetent that they could put someone's life at risk.
 
OK, but you have no problem with the blacksmith comparing the steel rod to the twin towers, right? It's OK for the blacksmith to do it, because it supports your ideas, but when Cole does it it's wrong, because it goes against what you believe. Right?
He isn't. All he is showing is that it requires little force to permanently deform steel when heated to a temperature. He is showing that you do not have to melt steel for it to fail thus countering the stupid strawman truther meme "jet fuel can't melt steel beams".

This is why you fail and why you are a truther. You simply do not have the ability to understand the simplest of concepts. Mr Cole makes the same mistake, which is also why he is a truther. His blow torch tomfoolery is laughable.

I remember his silly experiment with the steel beam after which he used his "mark I" eyeball to determine that no eutectic steel was present. He has no concept of what a eutectic is and doesn't understand that the only way to determine its presence is through the use of metallography and microscopy.

You have zero understanding of material properties as applied to the WTC. I doubt you even managed to gain a high school certificate in a science subject let alone go on to study other science related fields at advanced or degree level.

You're simply akin to a toddler having a tantrum because he doesn't understand and can't get his way.

P.S. Can my CIA/MI6/NWO/Lizard handler make it clear whether I'm being paid a flat fee or by the number of words written. Thanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom