If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, because he wasn't trying to only show how gravity works.


This is the fairest post I have seen on this forum. You admitted the experiment was good, but you reject his conclusions. That's fair.

The question then is, why do you reject his conclusions? If his experiments are good, why are his conclusions wrong?
 
This is simple. The blacksmith bends the rod sideways with his pinky, which is only a demonstration of the steel's weakness to sideways forces. Gage's hammer exerts a downwards force on the heated steel, much like the force exerted by the upper floors on the lower floors. The steel did not bend.

Summary, the steel bent when a sideways force was applied, but not a downwards force. The conclusion is that the steel, even when heated, was able to resist the downward force applied by the upper floors.

Well, i watched the video, and he is comparing his steel rod, with the towers. He even states the following. "Lets conduct a more realistic experiment, by heating a rod at about where the heat really was in the towers". So there is no denying he is actually comparing the rod to a tower. But just to be sure, he then says the following. "And see if the top accelerates down, by gravity alone".

So are you still saying he was trying to show anything else?
 
Now you're claiming that heated steel is weak when resisting a horizontal moment, but strong in resisting a vertical one. You're just playing a game, aren't you.

What game? The steel does what it does. You can't change the laws of physics. The blacksmith obviously bent the steel with his finger. That happened. Cole obviously struck the rod with a hammer, and the rod did not deform. That also happened. There were two different forces applied, and the steel behaved differently with each force. How is that a game?
 
Last edited:
Equally scary, and I still make my claim you're paid to be here. There is no other logical explanation. No legitimate architect would continue to support the official story, despite all of the evidence against it. It's beyond improbable.

The correct choices, when presented with all the evidence, are to either remain silent, or support a new investigation.

You must be getting paid, or someone has something on you and they are making you post here.

Is there no end to the depths of delusion your side is capable of?

I am not paid by anyone to post here, and have been on the site for some 4 years and over 11,000 posts without ever having posted in WTC conspiracy threads before. I was only motivated to post when I saw people making absolutely stupid and unsupportable claims about how buildings work.

Please, tell me that this building won't stand up. I'd love your expert input.
 
Last edited:
What game? The steel does what it does. You can't change the laws of physics. The blacksmith obviously bent the steel with his finger. That happened. Gage obviously struck the rod with a hammer, and the rod did not deform. That also happened. There were two different forces applied, and the steel behaved differently with each force. How is that a game?

Because he was actually comparing a steel rod to a tower. Thats whats wrong with Cole.
 
Last edited:
What game? The steel does what it does. You can't change the laws of physics. The blacksmith obviously bent the steel with his finger..........

So far so good.

Now, if the blacksmith had applied the same pressure with his finger to the steel in any other direction (other than along the long axis of the rod) would he have been able to bend it?
 
Last edited:
Well, i watched the video, and he is comparing his steel rod, with the towers. He even states the following. "Lets conduct a more realistic experiment, by heating a rod at about where the heat really was in the towers". So there is no denying he is actually comparing the rod to a tower. But just to be sure, he then says the following. "And see if the top accelerates down, by gravity alone".

So are you still saying he was trying to show anything else?

It's actually Cole's hammer. I need to correct that in my posts.

I think the rod does bend a little after he hammers it a few times, so there might be some movement there.

I think he is trying to show that the steel doesn't collapse. It doesn't disintegrate. In fact, it doesn't really weaken when it comes to supporting vertical loads. I don't know how that could be wrong.
 
Last edited:
I can't find my original post, so I will summarize it here.

Gatekeepers exist. The NSA, and similar agencies employ people to spread misinformation. That's a fact.

The skeptics here fall into three categories. The first category consists of those with cognitive impairments. They truly do not have the ability to correctly process the information they are presented with, and so they believe the official story. They continue to post here because they seek like-minded people, and they want to belong to something. The second category consists of those who believe there are issues with the official story, but they won't question it. They go along with it because they also want to belong to a group of like-minded people. The third category consists of people who are paid to be here. They monitor forums like this to see what is being posted, and they engage in misinformation tactics to suppress it.

Do I have definitive proof of this (other than the existence of gatekeepers)? No. My evidence is thousands upon thousands of posts by skeptics denying the most fundamental laws of physics, and thousands upon thousands of posts by skeptics who refuse to accept anything that goes against the official story. I have also noticed that truthers usually get banned. I have no idea why I have lasted so long.

And those who call BS when and where they see it and their conclusion about the events of 9/11 largely matches the "official narrative" despite disagreements about the details.
 
Is there no end to the depths of delusion your side is capable of?

I am not paid by anyone to post here, and have been on the site for some 4 years and over 11,000 posts without ever having posted in WTC conspiracy threads before. I was only motivated to post when I saw people making absolutely stupid and unsupportable claims about how buildings work.

Please, tell me that this building won't stand up. I'd love your expert input.

Thats a beautifully designed building Mike!
 
So far so good.

Now, if the blacksmith had applied the same pressure with his finger to the steel in any other direction (other than along the long axis of the rod) would he have been able to bend it?

As long as the steel was the same temperature I think he could have bent it in the opposite direction. I don't know this as a fact, it's just what I suspect. I do know that he (the blacksmith) doesn't apply any downwards pressure to the top of the rod. There are two entirely different forces being applied.
 
Last edited:
Yes, because gravity had no effect on the rod. Thats when he started to hit it with a hammer.

OK, and hitting it with a hammer didn't appear to substantially weaken the rod. I don't get your point. I'm not trying to be difficult. I really don't understand your point.
 
OK, and hitting it with a hammer didn't appear to substantially weaken the rod. I don't get your point. I'm not trying to be difficult. I really don't understand your point.

Ok no worries. I am trying to make the point that Cole is actually trying to compare a solid steel rod, to the twin towers. If you don't see a problem with that, you sure need to read up on scaling in structural engineering.
 
As long as the steel was the same temperature I think he could have bent it in the opposite direction. I don't know this as a fact, it's just what I suspect. I do know that he doesn't apply any downwards pressure to the top of the rod. There are two entirely different forces being applied.

Do you accept that:

1/steel weakens as it gets hot?

2/steel expands as it gets hot?

3/that the weakest point of any steel frame are the fixings?

Then why ask for my expert opinion on your work?

To test how good your understanding of irony was. You rather proved my point for me. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Ok no worries. I am trying to make the point that Cole is actually trying to compare a solid steel rod, to the twin towers. If you don't see a problem with that, you sure need to read up on scaling in structural engineering.

OK, but you have no problem with the blacksmith comparing the steel rod to the twin towers, right? It's OK for the blacksmith to do it, because it supports your ideas, but when Cole does it it's wrong, because it goes against what you believe. Right?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom