If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes. If I knew this was going to be such an issue I would have made a much more concerted effort to clarify what I was saying in my original post.

So if 5 floors, and i am talking about the parts between the outer and inner columns, break from the columns and move downwards, the one floor beneath it(and again with no columns), it would hold?
 
You can attack Cole's conclusions all you want. Personal attacks and attacks on the experiments are unfounded.

The only reason they are personal is because he makes it personal. And why is it not allowed to attack his experiments??? Just because you say so?
 
This has to be a joke. It has to be, unless you're a CIA or MI6 asset. There is no way a licensed, practicing structural engineer would compare Ronan Point to the WTC buildings. It just wouldn't happen. If you really are an engineer, you're paid to be here.

This has to be a joke!

As for Thermite, don't forget Truthers suggested it to account for the lack of noise associated with the explosives used in a demolition.
 
The only reason they are personal is because he makes it personal. And why is it not allowed to attack his experiments??? Just because you say so?

It's obviously allowed because the moderator has not deleted the posts. What I'm arguing is that personal attacks are meaningless and don't further your argument. Attacking the experiments is pointless. All that does is undermine your credibility by suggesting that somehow he is modifying the basic laws of motion. That's not possible.
 
It's my opinion as an untrained layperson. I never claimed I was a psychologist or psychiatrist. If you want to discredit me, then do so. I encourage it, because I am not a professional. That won't stop me from stating my opinion.

Asking you for your relevant qualifications and evidence for your stated conclusions is not in any way 'trying to discredit ' you. In fact, your suggestion that it is speaks volumes.
So, if this is just your opinion, unsupported by evidence or any relevant qualifications, then firstly, why should anyone give it any serious consideration (and why did you post it?), and, secondly, I think this is dangerously close, if not actually, an ad hominem, namely, not "you are wrong because your arguments are invalid", but "you are wrong because you are deluded and stupid".
I welcome your answers and any clarification you may wish to add about your attack on MikeG.
 
It's obviously allowed because the moderator has not deleted the posts. What I'm arguing is that personal attacks are meaningless and don't further your argument. Attacking the experiments is pointless. All that does is undermine your credibility by suggesting that somehow he is modifying the basic laws of motion. That's not possible.

So what was he trying to prove with his experiments according to you? How gravity works, because if that was the case, he did a good job.
 
So if 5 floors, and i am talking about the parts between the outer and inner columns, break from the columns and move downwards, the one floor beneath it(and again with no columns), it would hold?

This question can't be answered based on the information given. What I can say, with 100 percent certainty, is that if the top floor(s) impacted the bottom floor, there would be an equal and opposite reaction during the impact. This would cause the upper floors to decelerate. If the upper floors continued to accelerate continuously, regardless of the rate of acceleration, the ONLY correct conclusion is that there is nothing below the upper floors stopping their fall.
 
So what was he trying to prove with his experiments according to you? How gravity works, because if that was the case, he did a good job.

OK.

If he did a good job, then don't you think it's fair to support his conclusions?
 
Asking you for your relevant qualifications and evidence for your stated conclusions is not in any way 'trying to discredit ' you. In fact, your suggestion that it is speaks volumes.
So, if this is just your opinion, unsupported by evidence or any relevant qualifications, then firstly, why should anyone give it any serious consideration (and why did you post it?), and, secondly, I think this is dangerously close, if not actually, an ad hominem, namely, not "you are wrong because your arguments are invalid", but "you are wrong because you are deluded and stupid".
I welcome your answers and any clarification you may wish to add about your attack on MikeG.

If he can attack me, I will do the same.

You don't have to give any credibility to my attacks, but I'm still going to do it. Is it right? Maybe not. But I'm going to defend myself, and I can play the game as good as any of you. Should it stop? Yes. I'm willing to stop if you, and everyone else, is willing to. If not, game on.
 
This question can't be answered based on the information given. What I can say, with 100 percent certainty, is that if the top floor(s) impacted the bottom floor, there would be an equal and opposite reaction during the impact. This would cause the upper floors to decelerate. If the upper floors continued to accelerate continuously, regardless of the rate of acceleration, the ONLY correct conclusion is that there is nothing below the upper floors stopping their fall.

Can you first clarify what you think deceleration means.
 
I guess the people that write the physics books must be Shills as well along with all the suitibly qualified, accredited and experienced experts who are notable by their lack of support for your side of the argument.
 
It would be nice if everyone who is being paid to be here could identify themselves. I would like to take that into consideration when evaluating criticisms of Cole's experiment.
 
It would be nice if everyone who is being paid to be here could identify themselves. I would like to take that into consideration when evaluating criticisms of Cole's experiment.

You can get paid here? Who knew! Where can I sign up?
 
Can you first clarify what you think deceleration means.

First, let me clarify my original post.

If the upper floors continued to accelerate continuously, regardless of the rate of acceleration, the ONLY correct conclusion is that there is nothing below the upper floors stopping their fall.

To simplify my argument, I have removed some words.

I will use the following as my definition of acceleration: Acceleration is a vector quantity that is defined as the rate at which an object changes its velocity. An object is accelerating if it is changing its velocity.

Source: http://www.physicsclassroom.com/class/1DKin/Lesson-1/Acceleration

I will define deceleration as acceleration in the opposite direction. Acceleration in the opposite direction of travel will cause an object to slow down, or decelerate.

If an object's velocity is 10m/s downwards one second, and then 9m/s downwards the next second, it has decelerated. The cause was an acceleration force in the opposite direction. The deceleration could be continuous, which would cause the object to eventually stop, or it could be instantaneous, which means without air resistance or other force, the object would continue to travel at 9m/s downwards. This example ignores the forces due to gravity, air resistance, and friction, solely for the purpose of giving a definition.
 
Maybe you could tell me what he tried to show his viewers in the video where he hammers on the steel rod.

This is simple. The blacksmith bends the rod sideways with his pinky, which is only a demonstration of the steel's weakness to sideways forces. Cole's hammer exerts a downwards force on the heated steel, much like the force exerted by the upper floors on the lower floors. The steel did not bend.

Summary, the steel bent when a sideways force was applied, but not a downwards force. The conclusion is that the steel, even when heated, was able to resist the downward force applied by the upper floors.
 
Last edited:
£1000, right this minute, if you can quote where I claimed to be an engineer.

I'm an architect.

Equally scary, and I still make my claim you're paid to be here. There is no other logical explanation. No legitimate architect would continue to support the official story, despite all of the evidence against it. It's beyond improbable.

The correct choices, when presented with all the evidence, are to either remain silent or support a new investigation.

You must be getting paid, or someone has something on you and they are making you post here.
 
Last edited:
This is simple. The blacksmith bends the rod sideways with his pinky, which is only a demonstration of the steel's weakness to sideways forces. Gage's hammer exerts a downwards force on the heated steel, much like the force exerted by the upper floors on the lower floors. The steel did not bend.

Summary, the steel bent when a sideways force was applied, but not a downwards force. The conclusion is that the steel, even when heated, was able to resist the downward force applied by the upper floors.

Now you're claiming that heated steel is weak when resisting a horizontal moment, but strong in resisting a vertical one. You're just playing a game, aren't you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom