If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, you were torn to pieces. You claimed that each floor supported all the floors above it. You couldn't have been more wrong if you had tried, and this single solitary comment was enough to leave everything else you have claimed as valueless. It is so fundamentally wrong that I thought you really must be joking.

Your conclusion on the subject differs from mine. I also took the time to explain what I meant, and you ignored it. Typical.
 
......I will say that you don't get to criticize truthers for talking about non-steel framed buildings..........

£1000 for you, right now, if you can quote me doing anything of the sort.
 
Your conclusion on the subject differs from mine. I also took the time to explain what I meant, and you ignored it. Typical.

No, you disappeared immediately, with no explanations, and stayed away for days. You've only arrived back overnight (our time), and are whistling along pretending it never happened. You were demolished, which is ironic really.
 
£1000 for you, right now, if you can quote me doing anything of the sort.

I will clarify my statement. Skeptics don't get to cite the collapse of non-steel framed buildings and then criticize truthers for doing the same. I should have used the word "skeptics" instead of "you".
 
No, you disappeared immediately, with no explanations, and stayed away for days. You've only arrived back overnight (our time), and are whistling along pretending it never happened. You were demolished, which is ironic really.

Some posters have lives, which take precedence over this forum.

Once again, you are examining the evidence and coming to the wrong conclusion. At least you are consistent.
 
You'll be able to quote your "explanation", then. Obviously. I presume you aren't talking about #415, which I answered within 5 minutes.
 
You'll be able to quote your "explanation", then. Obviously. I presume you aren't talking about #415, which I answered within 5 minutes.

I stand by what I said in post #415. Everything in that post is correct.
 
No, it isn't. It is all completely wrong. Fundamentally wrong. I've designed many a multi-storey building, and if even the most junior Cad technician on my teams had said anything as wrong as the stuff you've just said, they would have been sent off for a bit of re-education.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I have a building to work on......
 
First off, the fact that you cling to this so much is a sign you're grasping at anything you can to try to discredit me. Discrediting me is pointless, I am not making any claims of being a person of authority or an expert.

Second, the issue is simply one of semantics, and definition. You assume that I think the cement slab on floor 50 (as an example), supports the weight of every concrete slab above it. This is obviously not true. When I think of a "floor", I take into account the support columns on that floor, the trusses, the steel plates on top of the trusses, and the cement poured on top of the steel plates. So, when I think of floor 50, I know that floor 50 has to support floors 50 through 110. The issue is simply one of semantics and an unclear definition. It was not one of a lack of understanding.

So if we take the first floor, you are saying, that if we carefully place all other floors on top of that first floor, it would hold up? Just want to clarify your statement.
 
OK. You might not suffer from paranoia, but your posts are clear evidence you suffer from delusions, and some sort of other cognitive impairment.

I think I missed the obviousness of the evidence.
Could you please elaborate? Oh, and please begin by listing your psychological/ psychiatric qualifications and experience. As you rightly maintain, engineers must be qualified to give valid judgements on engineering matters, and so only qualified psychologists or psychiatrists should be making judgements such as those you have just expressed.
 
No, it isn't. It is all completely wrong. Fundamentally wrong. I've designed many a multi-storey building, and if even the most junior Cad technician on my teams had said anything as wrong as the stuff you've just said, they would have been sent off for a bit of re-education.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I have a building to work on......


This has to be a joke. It has to be, unless you're a CIA or MI6 asset. There is no way a licensed, practicing structural engineer would compare Ronan Point to the WTC buildings. It just wouldn't happen. If you really are an engineer, you're paid to be here.
 
So if we take the first floor, you are saying, that if we carefully place all other floors on top of that first floor, it would hold up? Just want to clarify your statement.

My definition of "floor" is stated in post #415. I stand by it. If there is another term for it then we can use that. I do not claim that the actual cement you are standing on on the first floor supports anything but what is on that floor.
 
I think I missed the obviousness of the evidence.
Could you please elaborate? Oh, and please begin by listing your psychological/ psychiatric qualifications and experience. As you rightly maintain, engineers must be qualified to give valid judgements on engineering matters, and so only qualified psychologists or psychiatrists should be making judgements such as those you have just expressed.

It's my opinion as an untrained layperson. I never claimed I was a psychologist or psychiatrist. If you want to discredit me, then do so. I encourage it, because I am not a professional. That won't stop me from stating my opinion.
 
My definition of "floor" is stated in post #415. I stand by it. If there is another term for it then we can use that. I do not claim that the actual cement you are standing on on the first floor supports anything but what is on that floor.

Ok, so you are actually saying that the columns hold up the other floors. Thanks for the clarification.
 
Ok, so you are actually saying that the columns hold up the other floors. Thanks for the clarification.

Yes. If I knew this was going to be such an issue I would have made a much more concerted effort to clarify what I was saying in my original post.
 
Last edited:
This has to be a joke. It has to be, unless you're a CIA or MI6 asset. There is no way a licensed, practicing structural engineer would compare Ronan Point to the WTC buildings. It just wouldn't happen. If you really are an engineer, you're paid to be here.

This is your third accusation of shilling. Now you're back, and so we don't derail this thread, perhaps you'd like to answer my questions here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11160161#post11160161
 
Here's a summary of your post: blah blah blah, ad hominem attack.

Elementary school children have the capacity to understand the basic laws physics and perform experiments based on them. One does not need to be an engineer in order to understand, demonstrate, and make sound conclusions based on Newton's laws of motion.

Wow, this is priceless. So you do have a problem if we attack Cole, but you don't have a problem that Cole and his band of truther friends at AE911 attack the people at NIST. Double standards much?
 
This is your third accusation of shilling. Now you're back, and so we don't derail this thread, perhaps you'd like to answer my questions here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11160161#post11160161

I can't find my original post, so I will summarize it here.

Gatekeepers exist. The NSA, and similar agencies employ people to spread misinformation. That's a fact.

The skeptics here fall into three categories. The first category consists of those with cognitive impairments. They truly do not have the ability to correctly process the information they are presented with, and so they believe the official story. They continue to post here because they seek like-minded people, and they want to belong to something. The second category consists of those who believe there are issues with the official story, but they won't question it. They go along with it because they also want to belong to a group of like-minded people. The third category consists of people who are paid to be here. They monitor forums like this to see what is being posted, and they engage in misinformation tactics to suppress it.

Do I have definitive proof of this (other than the existence of gatekeepers)? No. My evidence is thousands upon thousands of posts by skeptics denying the most fundamental laws of physics, and thousands upon thousands of posts by skeptics who refuse to accept anything that goes against the official story. I have also noticed that truthers usually get banned. I have no idea why I have lasted so long.
 
Last edited:
Wow, this is priceless. So you do have a problem if we attack Cole, but you don't have a problem that Cole and his band of truther friends at AE911 attack the people at NIST. Double standards much?

You can attack Cole's conclusions all you want. Personal attacks and attacks on the experiments are unfounded.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom