If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I wonder what would happen if a group of 1000 elementary school children watched Mr. Cole's experiments with all 9/11 references removed. Then, without adding politics or any external bias, I wonder how they would explain the collapse of the towers. I would be willing to bet that every student who understood the laws of physics, as they pertain to downward motion, would agree that the lower floors had to be removed in order for the collapses to happen the way they did. I'm certain of it.
 
Last edited:
He is not a structural engineer.

He never claims he is a structural engineer. I have not claimed that either. He is a person with at least a basic knowledge of the basic laws of physics as they pertain to downward motion. Once again, you don't need to have any special education to understand Newton's laws of motion and perform experiments based on them.
 
Really? Mr. Cole. That is who you were attacking.
your reading comprehension needs a lot of work.

Try reading this then try answering the question "Against who?" There are two targets and neither of them is Cole - who you have already asserted is a liar. So I'm not the one playing ad-hom against Cole.

I accept the fact that you play dumb when it comes to what really happened on 9/11,
And that is a false claim. What happened on 9/11 was that three tall buildings fell down as a result of preliminary damage and unfought fires. Some persons who currently misuse the word truth claim there was malice in the form of CD involved. None of those persons has ever published an hypothesis worthy of consideration and favouring CD. Those who initially adopted the word "truther" included many persons of honourable intent. Their heritage is shamed by current trolls.
but to play dumb in that last post is a little too much.
Even tho' it seems to have been a bit too subtle for you - many members will understand. ;)
 
He never claims he is a structural engineer. I have not claimed that either. He is a person with at least a basic knowledge of the basic laws of physics as they pertain to downward motion. Once again, you don't need to have any special education to understand Newton's laws of motion and perform experiments based on them.
Correct. And the point I made in the recent post which you appear or pretend to not understand.

He is IMO almost certainly adequately competent in the structural physics as per my comments. Which puts you FF between the rock and the hard place.

Because a person who does understand the physics cannot also not understand so he makes genuine mistakes. YOU cannot have the "bet both ways" IF he understands THEN posting the nonsense he does MUST be deliberate lies intended to deceive.

And you put yourself into the corner - and your own lack of understanding is no excuse. The error is in simple logic - this time at high school level.
 
Last edited:
I wonder what would happen if a group of 1000 elementary school children watched Mr. Cole's experiments with all 9/11 references removed. Then, without adding politics or any external bias, I wonder how they would explain the collapse of the towers. I would be willing to bet that every student who understood the laws of physics, as they pertain to downward motion, would agree that the lower floors had to be removed in order for the collapses to happen the way they did. I'm certain of it.
It is disgusting that you would even consider playing such a deception on children. :mad:

How much of the truth movement has sunk that low?

R Gage at least seems to limit his schemes of deception to adults
 
As of today, 2473 architects and engineers agree there needs to be a new investigation into the collapse of WTC7. No, that does not directly answer your question, but it does show that people with authority to question the official story.

I'd suspect that most people of whatever profession who want a new investigation are motivated by the desire to finally shut up the gibbering idiots who make false claims about the collapse of the buildings.

I'm surprised you showed up again after being torn to pieces over the idea that floors in a multi storey building support the weight of the floors above without at least mentioning that episode. The words you might have chosen were along the lines of "thanks for that. I know a bit more about multi-storey buildings now. I have some more questions."
 
The blacksmith shows that steel can bend without having to melt, which is based on an incorrect interpretation of the meme. No one was disputing that steel loses strength and rigidity when heated, they were disputing jet fuel as the source of molten steel found underneath the towers.
Not really. I can't tell you how many times I have had to clarify that columns don't need to get to their melting point in order for the building to lose its integrity. More than 10 for sure. The truthers I was arguing with didn't believe me; I then had to point out to them that steel elements need fireproofing for a reason.

These are the guys that the blacksmith addresses. If you haven't run into those, lucky you.
 
I'm surprised you showed up again after being torn to pieces over the idea that floors in a multi storey building support the weight of the floors above without at least mentioning that episode.
Torn to pieces?

You kid yourself, and you think way too highly of your logic and reasoning.
 
It is disgusting that you would even consider playing such a deception on children. :mad:

How much of the truth movement has sunk that low?

R Gage at least seems to limit his schemes of deception to adults

I will give you credit for your attempt at turning my argument against me. Well done, but it's BS.

My point was, and everyone knows it, is that elementary physics can be learned and understood by elementary-aged children. If you teach them physics, and then show them the collapses, I'm certain they would tell you that the floors had to be removed in order for the upper portion to fall all the way to the ground in the time it took. Only when they learn the politics involved do they become blind to what really happened.
 
Torn to pieces?

You kid yourself, and you think way too highly of your logic and reasoning.

Did you ever acknowledge the corrections given to your comment about the floors supporting the whole weight of the building above?
 
I'd suspect that most people of whatever profession who want a new investigation are motivated by the desire to finally shut up the gibbering idiots who make false claims about the collapse of the buildings.

If you want us "gibbering idiots who make false claims" to shut up then I assume you support a new, fully-funded, independent investigation. Do you?
 
If anyone were really interested in the progressive collapse of tower blocks, the classic case is Ronan Point. This happened in London in the 1960s. A gas explosion on the 18th floor led to the collapse of 4 floors above. These floors fell onto the 18th, causing it to fail, which fell onto the 17th with the weight and inertia of 5 floors, which collapsed and fell onto the 16th with the weight and inertia of 6 floors, which fell onto the 15th with the weight and intertia of 7 floors, and so on, until the collapse reached the first floor where a cast in situ floor supported by columns broke the fall.

This building was very different from the WTC in that it was made of PCC panels bolted together (ie it wasn't framed), but the principle of progressive collapse was well established with this incident, and entirely (and conveniently) ignored by the ignorami claiming deliberate demolition of the WTC buildings.
 
If you want us "gibbering idiots who make false claims" to shut up then I assume you support a new, fully-funded, independent investigation. Do you?

I don't care. I'm a Brit. I don't have a dog in the fight. I just laugh at the stupidity involved from a distance, knowing that some countries do a better job of educating their kids than others.
 
Did you ever acknowledge the corrections given to your comment about the floors supporting the whole weight of the building above?

First off, the fact that you cling to this so much is a sign you're grasping at anything you can to try to discredit me. Discrediting me is pointless, I am not making any claims of being a person of authority or an expert.

Second, the issue is simply one of semantics, and definition. You assume that I think the cement slab on floor 50 (as an example), supports the weight of every concrete slab above it. This is obviously not true. When I think of a "floor", I take into account the support columns on that floor, the trusses, the steel plates on top of the trusses, and the cement poured on top of the steel plates. So, when I think of floor 50, I know that floor 50 has to support floors 50 through 110. The issue is simply one of semantics and an unclear definition. It was not one of a lack of understanding.
 
I don't care. I'm a Brit. I don't have a dog in the fight. I just laugh at the stupidity involved from a distance, knowing that some countries do a better job of educating their kids than others.

Yes, you do have a dog in the fight. 7/7/05 is your false flag, and there will be more as long as so many people like yourself refuse to wake up.
 
Torn to pieces?

You kid yourself, and you think way too highly of your logic and reasoning.

No, you were torn to pieces. You claimed that each floor supported all the floors above it. You couldn't have been more wrong if you had tried, and this single solitary comment was enough to leave everything else you have claimed as valueless. It is so fundamentally wrong that I thought you really must be joking.
 
If anyone were really interested in the progressive collapse of tower blocks, the classic case is Ronan Point. This happened in London in the 1960s. A gas explosion on the 18th floor led to the collapse of 4 floors above. These floors fell onto the 18th, causing it to fail, which fell onto the 17th with the weight and inertia of 5 floors, which collapsed and fell onto the 16th with the weight and inertia of 6 floors, which fell onto the 15th with the weight and intertia of 7 floors, and so on, until the collapse reached the first floor where a cast in situ floor supported by columns broke the fall.

This building was very different from the WTC in that it was made of PCC panels bolted together (ie it wasn't framed), but the principle of progressive collapse was well established with this incident, and entirely (and conveniently) ignored by the ignorami claiming deliberate demolition of the WTC buildings.


I already discussed Ronan Point, and my posts got banished. I'm not going to make the same mistake here, other than to say the collapse was due to sudden-impact loading, and there is no documentation whatsoever to show that the floors continuously accelerated as they collapsed.

I will say that you don't get to criticize truthers for talking about non-steel framed buildings but then use them to make your own arguments.

This is a double-standard. *Buzzer sound* Try again.
 
Last edited:
.......
Second, the issue is simply one of semantics, and definition. You assume that I think the cement slab on floor 50 (as an example), supports the weight of every concrete slab above it. This is obviously not true. When I think of a "floor", I take into account the support columns on that floor, the trusses, the steel plates on top of the trusses, and the cement poured on top of the steel plates. So, when I think of floor 50, I know that floor 50 has to support floors 50 through 110. The issue is simply one of semantics and an unclear definition. It was not one of a lack of understanding.

You Americans have an expression we don't use, but I believe it is something like "doubling down".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom