If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
He makes false claims, which make him either mistaken or a liar.

Re-read my post. What I said is that it is laughable to assume a licensed, practicing engineer lacks a basic understanding of basic physics.

People do make mistakes. Engineers make mistakes. You are taking my statement to absurd levels to try to prove your point.

What false claim(s) has Mr. Cole made? Is this your opinion, the opinion of the members of this forum, or the expert opinion of his peers?
 
See, this sort of argument doesn't really make sense to me, so perhaps you could walk me through your thinking and logic.

An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?

Even though I called you by your true colors after the first post of yours I read, this...puzzles me. In what way is what happened to the WTC buildings "random Normal heat"?
 
I can, because the blacksmith video was based on false assumptions also.

I'll have to go watch the cole video again to remind myself what he is saying.

The meme was jet fuel can't melt steel beams.

The blacksmith shows that steel can bend without having to melt, which is based on an incorrect interpretation of the meme. No one was disputing that steel loses strength and rigidity when heated, they were disputing jet fuel as the source of molten steel found underneath the towers.

The blacksmith was actually agreeing with the meme, but he didn't know it because he misinterpreted it, which I understand is quite common as it is not very clear.

Oh, I am just certain you have simply mounds of delicious evidence for this assertion...

Care to share it?
 
Re-read my post. What I said is that it is laughable to assume a licensed, practicing engineer lacks a basic understanding of basic physics.

People do make mistakes. Engineers make mistakes. You are taking my statement to absurd levels to try to prove your point.


Then you do acknowledge that Cole, despite his credentials, might be mistaken.

Why, then, did you bring them up at all?
 
What false claim(s) has Mr. Cole made? Is this your opinion, the opinion of the members of this forum, or the expert opinion of his peers?


The time to first false claim in the first video posted in the OP is 20 seconds. "There's plenty of evidence... including molten spheres of iron."

No molten spheres of iron have been found. Only quite solid ones.
 
Last edited:
Your ad hominem attacks on Mr. Cole do nothing. He is a licensed engineer, currently employed, and practicing his profession. Any claims that he lacks a basic understanding of basic physics are unfounded and laughable.
Cole is an idiot if he thinks his experiments are models of the WTC. I think he is making fun of 911 truth followers, and gets entertainment from idiots who believe his experiments are valid, those who post in his videos.

If Cole believes his claims on 911, and his experiments, then it is amazing he can keep a job and do rational work... but not impossible to be a 911 truth nut, if Cole is, and do your normal work. But it does mean his expertise at being a sewer engineer has not helped his 911 truth idiotic claims.
 
Your ad hominem attacks on Mr. Cole do nothing. He is a licensed engineer, currently employed, and practicing his profession. Any claims that he lacks a basic understanding of basic physics are unfounded and laughable.

Sewage is his professional specialty, the lines need to be laid, with one inch per ten foot drop.
He is not a structural engineer.
 
Re-read my post. What I said is that it is laughable to assume a licensed, practicing engineer lacks a basic understanding of basic physics.

People do make mistakes. Engineers make mistakes. You are taking my statement to absurd levels to try to prove your point.

What false claim(s) has Mr. Cole made? Is this your opinion, the opinion of the members of this forum, or the expert opinion of his peers?

That's why I sincerely believe Cole is a fraud, a licensed engineer can't be that dumb to embarrass his profession with those dumb fraudulent experiments.
 
Who are these people?

I don't know of anyone who claims that steel keeps its strength until it melts. From what I have seen, it's common knowledge that steel loses its integrity when heated, and regains it when cooled.

Yes steel loses strength when heated. Office contents and large fires ARE in evidence in the WTC. Thermite is not.

Steel also deforms when heated, more so if loaded, and even more idf loaded beyond its normally expected condition.

It does NOT return to its predeformation strength. It cannot reform to its original shape, therefore it cannot supply the same strength it had before.

WRT the blacksmith video, sorry AClark, the first instance of the mention of thermite was that it was used to melt columns and the meme was that jet fuel cannot melt steel. In point of fact NO OFFICIAL investigation at all ever said that jet fuel did melt any steel. The meme is a fantasy invention of the 911TM. Jet fuel was a relatively small contributor in the fuel supply for the WTC fires. It WAS the accelerant that produced large area multifloor fires in mere seconds rather than the more normal and random hours long time frame of common office fires that reach that level of involvement.

Now if thermite only supplied enough heat to weaken columns to failure, how was it timed to supposedly produce a collapse that can only happen by coordinated column failures? If it then later produced scads of molten steel in the rubble, how much was used, how did it get loaded and iow, show some evidence of the operation or the thermite itself?
 
Last edited:
... steel loses its integrity when heated, and regains it when cooled.
lol, I missed this...
onemeridiansag.jpg
Oh, look, cooled, the steel did not regain shape.
So we can move back in. What do we do, reheat the steel and push it back up to level the floor above...
 
Last edited:
Sewage is his professional specialty, the lines need to be laid, with one inch per ten foot drop.
He is not a structural engineer.

To become a "Sewage Engineer" he probably had to undergo a selective lobotomy so that he could apply physics to sewers but be incompetent in the physics of structures.

We need check - why don't we ask a "Sewage Engineer" if such selective surgical intervention was needed by him/her to reduce his/her reasoning skills, scope of understanding and basic intelligence from the heights of "structural engineer" down to the pits as a "sewerage engineer".

Until then I'll remain unconvinced that what field an engineer works in would guarantee a lack of competence in another field of engineering.

Presumably a person intelligent enough to be a structural engineer could move into the field of sewer (or water??) engineering BUT no mere water/sewer engineer could deign to offer comment on crassly wrong claims in the field of structures.

Maybe I'm wrong but I have the crazy idea that Cole is wrong because the idiotic claims he makes are wrong. Wrong in engineering. Wrong in structural engineering. And NOT wrong because he is a "Sewage" engineer.

And my second crazy idea is that his claims would be wrong if those same claims were made by a structural engineer. Or an aeronautical engineer or....
...someone who drives school buses or
...etc...etc...

They would still be wrong if they were claimed by an architect...

...or a journalist...

or.....
 
Last edited:
He makes false claims, which make him either mistaken or a liar.
Those are the two available options:
(1) Incompetent and doesn't understand what he is talking about OR
(2) liar.
Re-read my post. What I said is that it is laughable to assume a licensed, practicing engineer lacks a basic understanding of basic physics.
Thanks for supporting the assertion that he is lying. I would still accept a small possibility that he is incompetent.

What false claim(s) has Mr. Cole made? Is this your opinion, the opinion of the members of this forum, or the expert opinion of his peers?

Why do members on all three sides - debunkers - truthers AND trolls (including Poes) - make that error. The question about a claim is always "is the claim true or false" NOT "Do people with qualifications agree/make the same error/disagree......" :o
 
Last edited:
Then you do acknowledge that Cole, despite his credentials, might be mistaken.

Why, then, did you bring them up at all?

He could be mistaken, but not about his experiments. His experiments simply show that the fundamental laws of physics, as they pertain to downward motion, are true.

If you want to question his conclusions, then go ahead; but don't question his experiments. There is nothing wrong with them.
 
Last edited:
The time to first false claim in the first video posted in the OP is 20 seconds. "There's plenty of evidence... including molten spheres of iron."

No molten spheres of iron have been found. Only quite solid ones.

A sphere can be a solid. Your argument needs further clarification. If you are trying to use semantics to insinuate that no currently molten spheres of iron have been found, then I don't get your point. It makes no sense to assume steel would stay molten long after any external heat was applied. In order for a solid sphere to exist, it must have been molten, or able to be shaped, at one time.
 
To become a "Sewage Engineer" he probably had to undergo a selective lobotomy so that he could apply physics to sewers but be incompetent in the physics of structures.

We need check - why don't we ask a "Sewage Engineer" if such selective surgical intervention was needed by him/her to reduce his/her reasoning skills, scope of understanding and basic intelligence from the heights of "structural engineer" down to the pits as a "sewerage engineer".

Until then I'll remain unconvinced that what field an engineer works in would guarantee a lack of competence in another field of engineering.

Presumably a person intelligent enough to be a structural engineer could move into the field of sewer (or water??) engineering BUT no mere water/sewer engineer could deign to offer comment on crassly wrong claims in the field of structures.

Maybe I'm wrong but I have the crazy idea that Cole is wrong because the idiotic claims he makes are wrong. Wrong in engineering. Wrong in structural engineering. And NOT wrong because he is a "Sewage" engineer.

And my second crazy idea is that his claims would be wrong if those same claims were made by a structural engineer. Or an aeronautical engineer or....
...someone who drives school buses or
...etc...etc...

They would still be wrong if they were claimed by an architect...

...or a journalist...

or.....

Here's a summary of your post: blah blah blah, ad hominem attack.

Elementary school children have the capacity to understand the basic laws physics and perform experiments based on them. One does not need to be an engineer in order to understand, demonstrate, and make sound conclusions based on Newton's laws of motion.
 
Last edited:
"Do people with qualifications agree/make the same error/disagree......" :o

As of today, 2473 architects and engineers agree there needs to be a new investigation into the collapse of WTC7. No, that does not directly answer your question, but it does show that people with authority to question the official story.
 
Here's a summary of your post: blah blah blah, ad hominem attack.
On who?

Elementary school children have the capacity to understand the basic laws physics and perform experiments based on them. One does not need to be an engineer in order to understand, demonstrate, and make sound conclusions based Newton's laws of motion.
I'm glad you agree with me even though you most probably cannot see why. :thumbsup:
 
http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/appeal-to-authority.html

ETA- Has Mr. Cole published any peer reviewed papers related to 9/11 in a professional journal? Is yes, can you link me to them.

Thanks!

Once again, one does not need to be an engineer to understand Newton's laws of motion. Anyone can duplicate his experiments, given the resources. The issue is what conclusions should be made based on Newton's laws of motion and what was observed during the collapse of the WTC buildings.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom