If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
See this is where everything falls apart on these forums, and why the gang up approach is so counter productive.

There would be no "gang up" if you would actually state what you are getting at in your posts.

Stop playing the misunderstood truth seeker, that ship sailed and thinking people don't see through your games is insulting.

We can all look back and read your posting history.
 
See this is where everything falls apart on these forums, and why the gang up approach is so counter productive.

This is a critical thinking forum with many intelligent members ranging from scientists, doctors, structural engineers, lawyers, arson investigators, college professors, etc.

If you're ignorant about science and can't form a coherent argument it's not our problem.
 
Yes he did. Why did he feel the need to?
It is something about people having problem with the concept that an office fire can heat structural steel to the point where it collapses.

You would not be one of those, would you?
 
There would be no "gang up" if you would actually state what you are getting at in your posts.
.

I did, I responded to an individual, quoting him, and asking him to explain.

You, and others seem to have a very hard time with that concept and went nuts down all sorts of tangents.

If you can't understand me asking someone to clarify their opinion, something relatively simple, why reply at all with your invalid assumptions? Again and again.

Stop making **** up on my behalf, read what I actually put, and check and see if I'm actually replying to someone or something specific, rather than trying to derail threads bringing in all sorts of unrelated off-topic stuff.
 
It is something about people having problem with the concept that an office fire can heat structural steel to the point where it collapses.

You would not be one of those, would you?

Who are these people?

I don't know of anyone who claims that steel keeps its strength until it melts. From what I have seen, it's common knowledge that steel loses its integrity when heated, and regains it when cooled.
 
I did, I responded to an individual, quoting him, and asking him to explain.

You, and others seem to have a very hard time with that concept and went nuts down all sorts of tangents...........................

Yeah.. it's us, it's always someone else fault you are misunderstood.

Good luck.
 
I did, I responded to an individual, quoting him, and asking him to explain.

You, and others seem to have a very hard time with that concept and went nuts down all sorts of tangents.

If you can't understand me asking someone to clarify their opinion, something relatively simple, why reply at all with your invalid assumptions? Again and again.

Stop making **** up on my behalf, read what I actually put, and check and see if I'm actually replying to someone or something specific, rather than trying to derail threads bringing in all sorts of unrelated off-topic stuff.


Who's making asterisks up?


Originally Posted by AClark View Post
See, this sort of argument doesn't really make sense to me, so perhaps you could walk me through your thinking and logic.

An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?

Did you not question why an incendiary couldn't do it? Yes you did.
Did we answer?
Yes we did.

Can we move on now?
 
Yeah.. it's us, it's always someone else fault you are misunderstood.

Good luck.

You can't see it, can you?

I'll try again.

MHM said
a high incendiary is totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings

I asked him to explain his thinking.

DGM then goes to ask me for a complete CD hypothesis, which is irrelevant to what we were talking about.

Noah then starts banging on about evidence of thermite, which is irrelevant to what we were talking about.

You both then refuse to admit that you are going off on a tangent, and what you are saying has nothing to do with what I was asking MHM to clarify.

I realise that asking you to own up that you were talking at cross purposes is futile, but I want my position on this clear. I was responding to someone, and you guys shoved your noses in and went off in the wrong direction, which you seem to do with amazing regularity. God only knows what beachnut and the some of the others were on about, I notice they put a few posts in too. I'm sure you think you are clever, and you can smugly pat yourself on the back, but really your just getting in the way, and it's bloody annoying.
 
Yes he did. Why did he feel the need to?

Because twoofers kept posting that the buildings could not have collapsed do too fires because Jet Fuel can't melt steel beams.
The meme he was debunking was jet fuel can't melt steel beams to cause the buildings collapse, which is an attempt to debunk Banzant.
 
Because twoofers kept posting that the buildings could not have collapsed do too fires because Jet Fuel can't melt steel beams.
The meme he was debunking was jet fuel can't melt steel beams to cause the buildings collapse, which is an attempt to debunk Banzant.

Wrong
 
I realise that asking you to own up that you were talking at cross purposes is futile, but I want my position on this clear. I was responding to someone, and you guys shoved your noses in and went off in the wrong direction, which you seem to do with amazing regularity.

Fair enough. What you say in one thread on one day has nothing to do with what you say on others at diferant times.

It would help if you start out with a score card so we can keep track of your ever changing moods. OK?
 
See, this sort of argument doesn't really make sense to me, so perhaps you could walk me through your thinking and logic.

An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?
So stop playing silly games and someone like me WILL walk you through the issue. Step by step - as long as you are prepared to join in reasoned discussion.

BUT drop the lies by half truth crap.

"An incendiary couldn't do it..." was NOT the claim - the claim was that thermite is "totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition" That assertion is true for the Twin Towers AND even more to the point is the fact that thermite was not used. More pedantically the burden of proof is on anyone claiming thermite usage to prove that it was used. No one has. And there i an even more fundamental issue - thermite is only of relevance if it was used in some form of MHI (AKA "CD"). So prove CD and maybe you can THEN explain why and how thermite was used. BUT drop the arse about truther style of false argument.

"...what random normal heat did almost by accident..." is also deliberate dishonesty in your response. The "heat" was neither "normal" nor "random".

So stop with the debating tricks - such as those two lies by goal post shifting.

The ball as always in your court. I will join in honest reasoned discussion and explain those aspects you clearly do not understand or are pretending to not understand.

I am prepared to "walk you though" the reasoning of the issue. If you don't want to join in honest debate - no problem to me - I will not persist in responding to trolling.
 
An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?
Yes, a fire not only can, but fire Did.

Fire did it. Random normal heat? What is Random Normal Heat?

"normal heat did almost" - fire did it, not almost.

Your posts add too much BS, and you keep being off topic, and failing to be clear in your posts.

Why not figure out how to follow "that", before complaining about your posts being confusing, except for you.
 
“Jet Fuel Can’t Melt Steel Beams” is an assertion made by September 11th, 2001 attack conspiracy theorists that the burning fuel from crashed planes would not have been able to melt the supporting beams of the World Trade Center. The claim is widely mocked online for being based on flawed evidence.
Origin
On April 13th, 2005, the first installment of the Loose Change film series was released, which argued that the September 11th, 2001 attacks were orchestrated by the United States government. The film claims that the burning fires within the World Trade Center towers would not have been hot enough to compromise its structural integrity, alleging that a controlled demolition actually brought down the two buildings.

And the blacksmith shows steel fails in fire, thus debunking the BS idea...

911 truth can't do research - which is why we suffer BS of alive terrorists for the nth+1 TIME
 
Last edited:
I don't know of anyone who claims that steel keeps its strength until it melts. From what I have seen, it's common knowledge that steel loses its integrity when heated......

Congratulations. Perhaps without even realizing it, you have put your finger on the reason why the Truthers have failed. :clap:
 
Originally Posted by MileHighMadness
Again, the concept that the WTC buildings were bought down by controlled demolition, is one of the dumbest ideas in the history of mankind. The idea isn't just stupid, it's beyond stupid. Cole doesn't offer one single of piece of evidence to back up any of these crazy 9/11 theories. Thermite? It's not a high explosive, it's an incendiary, and totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings.

See, this sort of argument doesn't really make sense to me, so perhaps you could walk me through your thinking and logic.

An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?

I'm quite sure that one could collapse the BOK Tower with thermite, if owners would be so generous as to donate the building. ;) Just how "controlled" it would be is anyone's guess. Just pack big loads of thermite in cupolas around all the floor-support columns at around the 30th floor and ignite it all at once with each cupola having a heating wire and have all of them connected to a single high voltage source. There'll be no problem with needing to conceal the apparatus from everyone and no worries of it having to survive an airliner impact and fires. I'm sure that it will be a literally dazzling show. Folks in Texas will probably see the glow on the horizon. :D

Once the collapse begins, nothing will stop it. There'll be a big supply of souvenirs afterwards from the tons of thermitic iron lumps that will probably look like iron-nickel meteorites.
 
Your ad hominem attacks on Mr. Cole do nothing. He is a licensed engineer, currently employed, and practicing his profession. Any claims that he lacks a basic understanding of basic physics are unfounded and laughable.
 
Your ad hominem attacks on Mr. Cole do nothing. He is a licensed engineer, currently employed, and practicing his profession. Any claims that he lacks a basic understanding of basic physics are unfounded and laughable.


He makes false claims, which make him either mistaken or a liar.

You say his credentials preclude his being mistaken.

Fair enough.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom