If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Perhaps he is not aiming for scientific exactness, maybe he is just going for a simplified visual representation for the majority of his audience, who will be laymen.

We all know that schools tell lies, and over simplify things to introduce topics, and then offer deeper and deeper levels of understanding at later dates. We know that pie charts and line graphs are used in marketing or management to try and visually represent, in an easily understood way the numbers behind things.

What we also know is that the oversimplification of issues is a classic propaganda technique. Simplify things beyond the point where the simplification is valid any more and they can be re-spun to justify any lie you like. So why is it that truthers, who are supposed to be on the lookout for just this sort of distortion and manipulation of the truth, take what that likes of Cole say on faith? Why are you only ever sceptical about one side of the argument?

Dave
 
How can they be edutainment, if its clear that his assumptions are false? What is the edu part in edutainment mean according to you?

I don't know the man, or why he did it, other than it was allegedly in response to the blacksmith.

I'm assuming that the blacksmith was trying to educate whoever his intended audience was, and therefore Cole would be trying to present his rebuttal. I don't think either video was intended for scientific analysis.

As I said, I was making an assumption, you'd have to ask the man himself if you want more detail.
 
What we also know is that the oversimplification of issues is a classic propaganda technique. Simplify things beyond the point where the simplification is valid any more and they can be re-spun to justify any lie you like. So why is it that truthers, who are supposed to be on the lookout for just this sort of distortion and manipulation of the truth, take what that likes of Cole say on faith? Why are you only ever sceptical about one side of the argument?

Dave

I can't answer for anyone else, I'm not part of any organisation, however if you care to look you will note that I was dismissive of Cole, not taking his assertions on any sort of faith. We were discussing his motives, not his assumptions, and I simply presented a less sinister option.
 
I don't know the man, or why he did it, other than it was allegedly in response to the blacksmith.

I'm assuming that the blacksmith was trying to educate whoever his intended audience was, and therefore Cole would be trying to present his rebuttal. I don't think either video was intended for scientific analysis.

As I said, I was making an assumption, you'd have to ask the man himself if you want more detail.

Well at least the video from the blacksmith was based on actual science, and the video from Cole was based on nothing but false assumptions. I don't understand why you can't see the difference.
 
I don't know the man, or why he did it, other than it was allegedly in response to the blacksmith.

I'm assuming that the blacksmith was trying to educate whoever his intended audience was, and therefore Cole would be trying to present his rebuttal. I don't think either video was intended for scientific analysis.

As I said, I was making an assumption, you'd have to ask the man himself if you want more detail.

Heating up an inch thick rod, and hitting it with a hammer, has to be the most stupid comparison to a 1300 feet high building collapsing due to gravity. Of course his rod won't collapse to the ground due to gravity. So how can this guy not understand that you can't scale this down? Does he think the towers were one big steel block, where no one could work in? Is he really this stupid? Or is he being dishonest?
 
I don't know the man, or why he did it, other than it was allegedly in response to the blacksmith.

I'm assuming that the blacksmith was trying to educate whoever his intended audience was, and therefore Cole would be trying to present his rebuttal. I don't think either video was intended for scientific analysis.

As I said, I was making an assumption, you'd have to ask the man himself if you want more detail.
Do you think Coles video was a valid rebuttal to blacksmiths video?

If so explain how it is, remember actually watching the blacksmiths video would be helpful.
 
Well at least the video from the blacksmith was based on actual science, and the video from Cole was based on nothing but false assumptions. I don't understand why you can't see the difference.

I can, because the blacksmith video was based on false assumptions also.

I'll have to go watch the cole video again to remind myself what he is saying.

The meme was jet fuel can't melt steel beams.

The blacksmith shows that steel can bend without having to melt, which is based on an incorrect interpretation of the meme. No one was disputing that steel loses strength and rigidity when heated, they were disputing jet fuel as the source of molten steel found underneath the towers.

The blacksmith was actually agreeing with the meme, but he didn't know it because he misinterpreted it, which I understand is quite common as it is not very clear.
 
I can, because the blacksmith video was based on false assumptions also.

I'll have to go watch the cole video again to remind myself what he is saying.

The meme was jet fuel can't melt steel beams.

The blacksmith shows that steel can bend without having to melt, which is based on an incorrect interpretation of the meme. No one was disputing that steel loses strength and rigidity when heated, they were disputing jet fuel as the source of molten steel found underneath the towers.

The blacksmith was actually agreeing with the meme, but he didn't know it because he misinterpreted it, which I understand is quite common as it is not very clear.
911 truth says there was melted steel; and repeat the jet fuel BS so they can back in CD, thermite and other BS. The blacksmith video shows those in 911 truth steel fails in fire. Thus the video is valid, but exposed the idea, don't know the ideas, or what they mean. Like the alive terrorists, or no clue UBL was wanted.


? lol, the tag line is, "jet fuel can't melt steel", used by 911 truth when they wonder what melted the steel... they finally had a nut, Jones make up thermite four years after 911... 911 truth was happy, no clue steel fails in fire, not melted. nice try, but more like alive terrorists. - better watch the blacksmith video too
 
Last edited:
See, this sort of argument doesn't really make sense to me, so perhaps you could walk me through your thinking and logic.

An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?

There was evidence of fire. No evidence of thermite / thermate.. blah blah.

I could list what's missing as far as evidence is concerned regarding thermite/mate but you'll ignore it.
 
There was evidence of fire. No evidence of thermite / thermate.. blah blah.

I could list what's missing as far as evidence is concerned regarding thermite/mate but you'll ignore it.


That has nothing to do with what I said. I asked for the logic that any high incendiary cannot do what a normal fire can.

It's you lot who are insisting that thermate can't cut steel columns, not me.
 
That has nothing to do with what I said. I asked for the logic that any high incendiary cannot do what a normal fire can.

It's you lot who are insisting that thermate can't cut steel columns, not me.
Why consider a "high incendiary" when there is no evidence it was used and no reason to believe unchecked fires could not lead to the observed result?
 
That has nothing to do with what I said. I asked for the logic that any high incendiary cannot do what a normal fire can.

It's you lot who are insisting that thermate can't cut steel columns, not me.

You were curious how an incendiary couldn't do "it'

"It" is the destruction of the WTC.

Of course thermite / thermate can cut steel. They do it all the time with it.

Heck, it may be why it exists in the first place. I dunno.

What I do know is that it couldn't have been used to do controlled demo on 9/11.
 
That has nothing to do with what I said. I asked for the logic that any high incendiary cannot do what a normal fire can.

It's you lot who are insisting that thermate can't cut steel columns, not me.

Well Thermate can cut steel, but you need specialized equipment to do it vertically(Column), because its just a chemical reaction, so you have to device something to redirect the reaction. And believe me, if they had to cut every column with thermate, you could watch it from the moon, because of its brightness.
 
Heating up an inch thick rod, and hitting it with a hammer, has to be the most stupid comparison to a 1300 feet high building collapsing due to gravity. Of course his rod won't collapse to the ground due to gravity. So how can this guy not understand that you can't scale this down? Does he think the towers were one big steel block, where no one could work in? Is he really this stupid? Or is he being dishonest?

I honestly don't know, his example is moronic, but then so was the blacksmiths.

Cole states that the lower section of the building was cold and hard, with heat near the top, and then tries to show that with his steel rod. The heated section does not bend or buckle under gravity, or when hit by a hammer, but as far as being a representation of a tower, it fails miserably.

As I said, I don't know what he was thinking, and I don't think his video helps anyone.
 
I honestly don't know, his example is moronic, but then so was the blacksmiths.

Cole states that the lower section of the building was cold and hard, with heat near the top, and then tries to show that with his steel rod. The heated section does not bend or buckle under gravity, or when hit by a hammer, but as far as being a representation of a tower, it fails miserably.

As I said, I don't know what he was thinking, and I don't think his video helps anyone.

The only thing the blacksmith had to do was prove that steel loses its strength far before it's melting point, with temps not all that special.

He did that.
 
That has nothing to do with what I said. I asked for the logic that any high incendiary cannot do what a normal fire can.

It's you lot who are insisting that thermate can't cut steel columns, not me.
It is like you don't read you posts.

No steel was cut on 911 with thermite. Thus it does not matter what you make up, or google from 911 truth.

An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?
What is precise about what was not used on 911? It is BS.

Cole used simulated high explosives, not thermite. What are you talking about? BS. This is the stupid Cole experiments thread, not the what Cole did not do in his BS experiments.

Start a new thread on AClark's claims about thermite, and why zero evidence was found for thermite.
 
Why consider a "high incendiary" when there is no evidence it was used and no reason to believe unchecked fires could not lead to the observed result?

See this is where everything falls apart on these forums, and why the gang up approach is so counter productive.

X says something
I respond to X
A, B, and C respond making assumptions about what I'm saying and derail everything.

Originally Posted by MileHighMadness View Post
Again, the concept that the WTC buildings were bought down by controlled demolition, is one of the dumbest ideas in the history of mankind. The idea isn't just stupid, it's beyond stupid. Cole doesn't offer one single of piece of evidence to back up any of these crazy 9/11 theories. Thermite? It's not a high explosive, it's an incendiary, and totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings.
See, this sort of argument doesn't really make sense to me, so perhaps you could walk me through your thinking and logic.

An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?

I wasn't suggesting termites were used, I was asking MHM to clarify his position. You lot then jump on me, assuming all sorts of things on my behalf, meanwhile MHM doesn't answer, so you lot think I'm suggesting Marmite was used to bring down the towers. I'm not Mr Jones, I don't know anything about nanotermites.

If I was to consider that any known or unknown high incendiary was to be used, I would be thinking why go to all the hard work of trying to sever columns, when a much easier time could be had severing beams and girders, working in the vertical rather than the horizontal.
 
See, this sort of argument doesn't really make sense to me, so perhaps you could walk me through your thinking and logic.

An incendiary couldn't do it, but an office fire can. I can't follow that at all. How can precise, high heat not accomplish what random normal heat did almost by accident?

Oh wow, you don't understand the difference between localized thermite and a raging fire?

Maybe instead of trolling here everyday you'd be better served attending an eighth grade science class.

Since it's obvious science isn't your strong suit, how about math?

Why don't you calculate how much thermite would be needed to bring down the 3 massive buildings and get back to us. Be sure to show your work!

TIA!
 
The only thing the blacksmith had to do was prove that steel loses its strength far before it's melting point, with temps not all that special.

He did that.

Here comes off topic BS, quibble about posters; why stay on topic when complaining is easier. Wish ignore button was found, and stop posting BS about people, get on topic.
Failure to realize, does not have to post anything.
Still, it was a long time since someone repeated the BS of alive terrorists, or no clue which planes were used. Not new, but after 14 years, it appears the only reason here is due to WoT... Like Jones made up Thermite due to war, AClark remains knowledge free of 911 as and event, and is upset 911 truth is so darn full of BS and no one cares as much as he does about war.

AClark did doubt 19 terrorists are the only ones responsible for the act... no clue UBL was wanted before 911.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom