If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Extract each frame of the video using VLC or Virtualdub. You can clearly see that as the first "floor" impacts the second floor it decelerates. The impact is enough to break the toothpicks, which is why the next floor falls. You can clearly see it decelerate as it impacts the third floor. The impact is once again enough to break the toothpick, but Newton's third law is observed. As the floors impact they exert equal and opposite forces on each other. The top floor momentarily decelerates as a result of the impact. This is expected.

The top floors of the WTC did not decelerate as they fell. The entire structure collapsed as if there was nothing there. This behavior is not supported by the official explanation of the collapse, and is not expected.

In the video you can see deceleration as each floor impacts the next. This deceleration is not observed in the WTC collapses.

Nice try, but, no. Try again.

It's also worth noting that not one of you complained about scale in the above video. It's also worth noting that no one said anything about comparing toothpicks to 90,000 tons of structural steel. That is actually OK, because it really doesn't matter. Even at this small scale, Newton's third law was observed.

The fact that the toothpicks broke is irrelevant. What matters is that the upper floor decelerated when it impacted the lower floor. You can see it in the video. It's there. Go ahead and deny it, but it's there. Just remember, each time you deny what can clearly be seen, and is clearly expected by the laws of physics, you destroy your credibility. But still, carry on.

Here's a simplified model that does explain why the collapses were longer than freefall - there was resistance, as every floor was hit and incorporated into the growing mass of rubble.


(Reference page with equations and sciency stuff)


(Reference page with equations and sciency stuff)

The 3rd page in the series shows that the "jolt" (deceleration of the upper block) you demand can be predicted in the simple model, and that they simply can't be seen in the coarse resolution used by Chandler and Szamboti.

It also shows that Chandler's measurements of the fall of the North Tower actually verify my simple model.

You wanted experiments? You got 'em.
 
OK so far.
agreed

Pretty ragged, but there's at least an "is" in there. You don't seem to understand the mechanism by which dynamic loadings are exerted too well, but at least you acknowledge their existence.
Indeed. The force the static penny was putting on the static structure was F=ma with m=mass of the penny.
The dynamic load of the dropped penny however, is the amount of momentum of that moving penny, that is transferred to the static structure divided by the time over which that transfer takes place. However, at the moment that the amount of impulse force exceeds the ability of the structure to counter that force, the structure fails and transfer of momentum is no longer taking place and the penny continues until it hits more structure. AT THE SAME TIME as the penny is continuing past its first encounter, the upper structure it first hit has come apart. All cards that are no longer connected as part of the full structural system are no more than falling debris themselves, thus adding to the force on the still lower section of structure.
FF refers to a high speed camera that would show the penny decelerating. That too could be used to determine the force on the structure as the change in acceleration times the mass is the force exerted by the structure. That amount is all that was required to destroy the structure.

Bzzzzzttttt! And there is where you go wrong. You're assuming that the lower part of the structure is able to support the static weight of the upper part after collapse has commenced. That's simply not feasible. When the structure failed, a whole series of elements failed in essentially random ways, with different buckle lengths and locations and, inevitably, sideways displacements of vertical elements. So rather than Cole's idealized plank-on-plank impacts, we have a ragged mess with bits sticking out, landing on a different ragged mess with bits sticking out, and with bits breaking off as they hit. After the initial failure, the lower columns are never able to contact the upper ones all at the same time to give the single solid impact Cole is talking about; in fact, the geometry of the initial failures, as ozeco41 has pointed out ad nauseam to Tony Szamboti, means they can't impact directly at all. What we have instead is bits of the upper section striking bits of the lower section that individually can't support more than a fraction of the load, leading to a sequence of much smaller impacts which average out to a more-or-less constant force.
Further to this, the house of cards does not fail due to destruction of the vertical cards. It is destroyed by overcoming the connections between cards. At the end of collapse the cards are still individually intact, but no longer connected in the system that is a house of cards.
The analogy does fail at this point though:
The structure is very different than the WTC or any other building in that each horizontal level supports the entire mass of structure above it, the "columns" are diagonally braced in pairs, and the "floors" serve to support a next pair of diagonally braced "columns", individual "floors" were loaded very differently than the floors of a building as well, with the uppermost "floor" barely loaded at all.

And by the way, the time of collapse was longer than 10 seconds.

oh gawds yes. It took approximately ten seconds, for debris falling outside of the tower, to hit the ground,(which IS what NIST said) and that hit well before the last of the bits of tower. Closer to 15 and as high as 20 seconds for collapse.
 
Last edited:
So much stupidity in one little video. Note that at 1:29, Cole states, "He's wrong. The steel did melt." And he shows a piece of steel that is quite bent, but which was obviously not melted.

Also, he completely misstates the reason the towers collapsed. It was not that the vertical columns were weakened by the fire and collapsed on their own; it was that the joists were weakened and sagged, pulling in the columns until the connections snapped.
 
So much stupidity in one little video. Note that at 1:29, Cole states, "He's wrong. The steel did melt." And he shows a piece of steel that is quite bent, but which was obviously not melted.

Also, he completely misstates the reason the towers collapsed. It was not that the vertical columns were weakened by the fire and collapsed on their own; it was that the joists were weakened and sagged, pulling in the columns until the connections snapped.

Yeah. I wonder if Cole actually manages to find work these days?
 
The OP's attitude and knowledge, or serious lack of it, is astonishing. I did not take structural engineering classes in college, but by the ripe old age of 6 years, from experimenting with my wood blocks, cardboard scraps, Legos, marbles, and erector sets, I had learned the difference between static and dynamic loads. I find nothing unbelievable about reputable engineers' observations and calculations.

If only Santa had given me gunpowder at 7 -- think how much I could have learned!
 
If I carefully place a penny on the top of the house of cards it might stay there. Let's assume I could do it, and if I could, that would mean the house of cards could support the static force of the penny. Now, if I raise the penny a few inches and then drop it, the force experienced by the house of cards is now greater than the static force previously exerted. This is because F=ma, and since acceleration is now greater than 0, the kinetic force is greater.

Are you suggesting that acceleration on a static object is 0?

This is why I asked you what acceleration figure you would use to calculate the impact force of a bowling ball. You clearly have no idea what you're talking about.
 
Here's a simplified model that does explain why the collapses were longer than freefall - there was resistance, as every floor was hit and incorporated into the growing mass of rubble.


(Reference page with equations and sciency stuff)


(Reference page with equations and sciency stuff)

The 3rd page in the series shows that the "jolt" (deceleration of the upper block) you demand can be predicted in the simple model, and that they simply can't be seen in the coarse resolution used by Chandler and Szamboti.

It also shows that Chandler's measurements of the fall of the North Tower actually verify my simple model.

You wanted experiments? You got 'em.

Watch the first video you posted. What happens to the bag of rice once it impacts the scale? It bounces up! Does it continue to accelerate downwards at or near freefall? Absolutely not! Your OWN video shows what should have happened. As the rubble, or floors, impacted the lower floors they would have decelerated. This deceleration would have occurred multiple times, and either the collapse would have completely stopped before it reached the ground, or the entire process would have taken much longer.

Your own videos are supporting CD. It's just a shame that you can't understand this.
 
Watch the first video you posted. What happens to the bag of rice once it impacts the scale? It bounces up! Does it continue to accelerate downwards at or near freefall? Absolutely not! Your OWN video shows what should have happened. As the rubble, or floors, impacted the lower floors they would have decelerated. This deceleration would have occurred multiple times, and either the collapse would have completely stopped before it reached the ground, or the entire process would have taken much longer.

Your own videos are supporting CD. It's just a shame that you can't understand this.

Wow! You truly don't have a clue what you are talking about. I recommend you take at least a couple of beginning level college physic classes before you post again.
 
Are you suggesting that acceleration on a static object is 0?

Then penny, when resting on the house of cards, is at equilibrium. This means its acceleration is zero, and the force it exerts on the house of cards can be described by the formula F(gravity) = mass of the card x gravity on earth. It is balance by the normal force, which is equal and in the opposite direction.

The penny, when dropped on the house of cards, will exert a greater force than the static force. This is explained in Newton's second law. The falling penny will exert force on the card or cards it is resting on. At the moment of collision, the cards will exert an equal and opposite force on the penny. Since the penny is falling downwards, its downwards fall will either decrease in speed, or momentarily become upwards motion until the force of gravity causes it to continue to fall again. This is explained in Newtons third law.

Here is a video, if you still don't understand the concept.

http://zonalandeducation.com/ezMedia/physics/forces/newton/threeLaws/thirdLaw/forces/thirdLaw1.mp4

The falling floors, or rubble, should have impacted the lower floors and decelerated with each collision. This did not happen.
 
Wow! You truly don't have a clue what you are talking about. I recommend you take at least a couple of beginning level college physic classes before you post again.

Seriously?

Is that the best you can do?

You should watch the video, and spend less time posting.
 
Seriously?

Is that the best you can do?

You should watch the video, and spend less time posting.

Really...and how many years of your life are you going to waste, believing in stupid conspiracy theories.

Let me help you out...Cole and Chandler are idiots. Gage and Griffin are lying con artists.

BTW...I did watch the videos, the bag of rice bounces. So fracking what...it is a spring scale.
 
Really...and how many years of your life are you going to waste, believing in stupid conspiracy theories.

Let me help you out...Cole and Chandler are idiots. Gage and Griffin are lying con artists.

BTW...I did watch the videos, the bag of rice bounces. So fracking what...it is a spring scale.

Sure they are.

Like I said, your best bet is to watch videos. Posting just isn't your thing.
 
Watch the first video you posted. What happens to the bag of rice once it impacts the scale? It bounces up! Does it continue to accelerate downwards at or near freefall? Absolutely not! Your OWN video shows what should have happened. As the rubble, or floors, impacted the lower floors they would have decelerated. This deceleration would have occurred multiple times, and either the collapse would have completely stopped before it reached the ground, or the entire process would have taken much longer.

Your own videos are supporting CD. It's just a shame that you can't understand this.

You might note something. The scale's needle moved about 1/4 of its full allowable travel. That means its capable of measuring force that is 4 times what that rice bag was delivering. Try it with a concrete block and the result will be a destroyed scale. Slowly place a concrete block on the scale and it will be ok even though it exceeds the measurin capability of the scale. Drop the block=scale in pieces. Place the block=scale still ok.

Think about that.

Such a scale uses a spring. A static mass forces the spring down only as far as its mass under g . A falling mass imoarts its momentum to the spring ovet the time it takes to compress the spring. At that point the spring now experiences only the static mass force but has stored the energy of the dynamic loading which it niw uses to oppose the static mass. The very fact that the scale rebounds inducates that the falling mass imparted a greater force than the ststic mass generates.

The floor pans of the WTC towers were not capable of supporting even the static mass of the dozen or so levels that first began moving.. That was ok because the floors were connected to the columns. The FLOOR PANS only needed to support a load that would be expected to be on ONE floor, including the live loads of moving occupants. The FLOOR PAN load was then transferred to the columns via the connections to the columns. Overload the floor pan and it cracks and fails. Overload the connection to the column and the floor fails.

Not that any of this will click with you. You have amply demonstrated your utter lack of comprehension of, or ability to apply, physics.
 
Last edited:
To me it is obvious that FalseFlag has very little real understanding of physics, engineering, or architecture. It is interesting that attempts by much more experienced experts in these areas to correct his misunderstandings are so angily dismissed by FalseFlag. I often wonder in these situations what must go through the mind of the person who decides that they have a better understanding than the experts, with the experts' opinions easily independently confirmable in books, by math, or on the web. The. very idea fascinates me. I don't always agree with what the experts say, but I make certain that I truly understand what they are saying and why, carefully double check the basis for my opinion in light of what the experts are telling me, and make certain that I know why I am right and the experts are wrong, before I tentatively maintain my own view. The ability to be largely clueless, but to be willing to blithely reject what the much more knowledgeable are trying to tell me, is quite amazing. It either involves a great deal of self confidence or a complete willingness to ignore the actual facts to make a political point.
 
Last edited:
Watch the first video you posted. What happens to the bag of rice once it impacts the scale? It bounces up! Does it continue to accelerate downwards at or near freefall? Absolutely not! Your OWN video shows what should have happened. As the rubble, or floors, impacted the lower floors they would have decelerated. This deceleration would have occurred multiple times, and either the collapse would have completely stopped before it reached the ground, or the entire process would have taken much longer.

Your own videos are supporting CD. It's just a shame that you can't understand this.

No, it's a shame that you can't understand the difference between a packet of rice bouncing on a spring scale and the collapses of 110-storey-tall skyscrapers.

It's a shame you can't understand that you can actually learn things about physics by doing experiments on things like packets of rice bouncing off of spring scales, and then applying that knowledge to new situations.

It's a shame that you ignored the part of my post that dealt with the "decelerations" you are demanding be obvious for the Twin Towers.

The 3rd page in the series shows that the "jolt" (deceleration of the upper block) you demand can be predicted in the simple model, and that they simply can't be seen in the coarse resolution used by Chandler and Szamboti. It also shows that Chandler's measurements of the fall of the North Tower actually verify my simple model. You wanted experiments? You got 'em.

It's a shame you missed this graph, showing both the decelerations you were demanding, and the under-resolved data of Chandler/Szamboti, which clearly cannot even begin to resolve the so-called "missing jolt."

chandlervcomp.jpg


A shame, indeed.

(I should note that, as discussed at length in this forum, the "jolts" might be even harder to detect in the real-world case, wherein columns almost certainly didn't land on other columns, the Bazant limiting scenario.)
 
.........The ability to be largely clueless, but to be willing to blithely reject what the much more knowledgeable are trying to tell me, is quite amazing. It .... involves.......a complete willingness to ignore the actual facts to make a political point.

I had no idea as to the extent (or depths) of this phenomenon until I joined this forum, having seldom come across it in real life. When I saw it here I thought the stupid weren't stupid, but just playing a game. I now realise that those kids who bunked-off school, never did their homework, and came bottom in every exam had to end up somewhere, and that "somewhere" seems to be in conspiracy theories and science denial on the internet. I guess it's safer for them than hanging around in shopping centres and on street corners all day.
 
No, it's a shame that you can't understand the difference between a packet of rice bouncing on a spring scale and the collapses of 110-storey-tall skyscrapers.

There is no difference between the two when it comes to Newton's third law.
That is something that you understand, but you refuse to accept it. Or, you refuse to post that you accept it.

Here is another random video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMyw-6bDbTs

Watch what happens to the weight as it impacts the wood block. It bounces up. Why? I know the answer, and I have said it many times. You tell me why it bounces up. Where is the spring?

It's also worth noting that the wood block transfers energy to the ground, and the camera is also affected by the impact. You can see the bounce. Of course you can pretend not to see it, and you can say it's not there, but it's there.

I also know you are going to say there is no deceleration as the weight hits the piece of cardboard. Nonsense. It's there, but it's so subtle that the camera can't pick it up. If you had a high speed camera that could record tens of thousands of frames per second you would see the weight decelerate the instant it impacts the cardboard.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom