DaveThomasNMSR
Muse
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2010
- Messages
- 877
Extract each frame of the video using VLC or Virtualdub. You can clearly see that as the first "floor" impacts the second floor it decelerates. The impact is enough to break the toothpicks, which is why the next floor falls. You can clearly see it decelerate as it impacts the third floor. The impact is once again enough to break the toothpick, but Newton's third law is observed. As the floors impact they exert equal and opposite forces on each other. The top floor momentarily decelerates as a result of the impact. This is expected.
The top floors of the WTC did not decelerate as they fell. The entire structure collapsed as if there was nothing there. This behavior is not supported by the official explanation of the collapse, and is not expected.
In the video you can see deceleration as each floor impacts the next. This deceleration is not observed in the WTC collapses.
Nice try, but, no. Try again.
It's also worth noting that not one of you complained about scale in the above video. It's also worth noting that no one said anything about comparing toothpicks to 90,000 tons of structural steel. That is actually OK, because it really doesn't matter. Even at this small scale, Newton's third law was observed.
The fact that the toothpicks broke is irrelevant. What matters is that the upper floor decelerated when it impacted the lower floor. You can see it in the video. It's there. Go ahead and deny it, but it's there. Just remember, each time you deny what can clearly be seen, and is clearly expected by the laws of physics, you destroy your credibility. But still, carry on.
Here's a simplified model that does explain why the collapses were longer than freefall - there was resistance, as every floor was hit and incorporated into the growing mass of rubble.
(Reference page with equations and sciency stuff)
(Reference page with equations and sciency stuff)
The 3rd page in the series shows that the "jolt" (deceleration of the upper block) you demand can be predicted in the simple model, and that they simply can't be seen in the coarse resolution used by Chandler and Szamboti.
It also shows that Chandler's measurements of the fall of the North Tower actually verify my simple model.
You wanted experiments? You got 'em.