If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mr. Cole's videos, and the video in post 211, support the same conclusion. The WTC towers were brought down by CD. Period.

The 10 seconds referred to in that report was badly put. That was the time to *first impact* of debris on the ground, and was caused by large lumps of debris free-falling as in the photo below. The main collapse front took longer, in the region of 15 seconds. The less-than-freefall acceleration you deny did actually happen.

 
Last edited:
I'm not going to type all of this again, so I'm going to copy and paste.

Here is the original article: http://www.911blimp.net/prf_FreeFallPhysics.shtml

And here is the relevant text;



The video in post 211, and Newton's third law, tell us that falling objects decelerate as they impact something below. Even if we can't see it because of the dust and debris during the WTC collapses, we know it should be there. We know that the time of collapse should have been much, much longer than 10 seconds. The fact that the entire building collapsed in such a short time is proof that there was nothing in the way of the top floors as they fell. It's undeniable.

You can say that the building was structurally deficient if you want, it's irrelevant. The fact is that the upper floors should have decelerated as they fell. That didn't happen. Mr. Cole's videos prove that the only explanation for this is if the lower floors were removed as the upper floors fell.

The upper floors could have been supported by balsa wood or playing cards; it does not matter. If you had ANY structure that could support the static weight of the upper floors, that lower structure, regardless of its composition, would provide SOME resistance to the upper floors as they fell. If you dropped the upper floors of steel on the lower floors of balsa wood you would still see deceleration, even if it was extremely small. Yes, the balsa wood structure might completely collapse, but it would cause some deceleration of the upper floors. It defies any logic and reason to assume that 90,000 tons of undamaged structural steel would not have offered any resistance to floors that they had always been supporting. Failing to accept this fact has no basis is science or reason. It's pure delusion.

Mr. Cole's videos, and the video in post 211, support the same conclusion. The WTC towers were brought down by CD. Period.

The collapse motion was NOT accelerating! Sure at first something at rest accelerates as it speed increases. In the case of the twon tower collapses the speed more or less leveled off at about 65mph which is about 100' feet per second. In 1wtc the upper section took 3.75 seconds to collapse and drop / disappear until only the intact section from floor 95 or so was left... the collapse from that elevation...At this stage the collapse was moving at 65mph or so and the floors inside the steel cage of the facade took about another 11 seconds or so at. The floors and the air offered resistance to gravity constant pull.

Idiots can take the 14 or so seconds... start and finish... and claim it represents a fraction of G... But this is false... and reductionist and shows nothing... aside from the FACT that not only was there air resistance but there was 95 floor structure to slow the descent.

There was some debris which showed constant acceleration though air... They were falling outside the tower.

This FF thinking is just stupidity.
 
Your example supports CD, you just don't realize it.

If I carefully place a penny on the top of the house of cards it might stay there. Let's assume I could do it, and if I could, that would mean the house of cards could support the static force of the penny. Now, if I raise the penny a few inches and then drop it, the force experienced by the house of cards is now greater than the static force previously exerted. This is because F=ma, and since acceleration is now greater than 0, the kinetic force is greater. Let's now assume the house of cards collapses. What you see with the naked eye is an instantaneous collapse, but Newton's third law says that the house of cards will exert an equal and opposite force on the moving penny. If you had a fast enough camera, you would see the penny decelerate, even if the deceleration was extremely small.

There is no denying this. If you choose to deny it, you are denying one of the most fundamental, indisputable laws of physics.

The lower structure of the WTC towers should have exerted an equal and opposite force on the upper floors as they fell. It does not matter what the composition or strength was of the lower floors. If the lower floors could support the static force of the upper floors, they should have exerted an equal and opposite force as they were impacted. This would cause the upper floors to decelerate, and the time of collapse should have been longer than 10 seconds.

Thank you.

I will be using your conceptual errors, this morning, in my Physical Science classes, as an example of a fundamentally incorrect misapprehension of the meaning of "equal and opposite" force pairs (and a discussion of the differences between "balanced" and "unbalanced" forces) as we review for the Q3 exam tomorrow. You will have helped a number of students do better on their test...
 
Last edited:
Where is this 10 seconds and freefall coming from?

It's obvious in the video that the collapse is less then freefall.

There are large chunks of debris falling outside of the toweres, they are falling faster then the collapse is progressing. They can't be falling any faster than gravity will accelerate them unless you think they are somehow rocket powered.
 
Extract each frame of the video using VLC or Virtualdub. You can clearly see that as the first "floor" impacts the second floor it decelerates. The impact is enough to break the toothpicks, which is why the next floor falls. You can clearly see it decelerate as it impacts the third floor. The impact is once again enough to break the toothpick, but Newton's third law is observed. As the floors impact they exert equal and opposite forces on each other. The top floor momentarily decelerates as a result of the impact. This is expected.
Agreed on the last sentence in particular. The falling set accelerates, though.

I think you're confusing local deceleration with global.


The top floors of the WTC did not decelerate as they fell.
You're either changing horses (switching to global acceleration after proving local acceleration) or just emitting an unprovable statement. Do you have any proof that the falling floors didn't momentarily decelerate at the instant they impacted another one?


The fact that the toothpicks broke is irrelevant. What matters is that the upper floor decelerated when it impacted the lower floor. You can see it in the video. It's there. Go ahead and deny it, but it's there. Just remember, each time you deny what can clearly be seen, and is clearly expected by the laws of physics, you destroy your credibility. But still, carry on.
I'm not denying it. It's obvious. It's pure conservation of momentum. If A goes at speed X when it impacts a static B in a perfect plastic collision, the final speed of the set A+B is necessarily < X, therefore there's deceleration. No one is disputing that.

But you keep missing that when the floor is released (the toothpick broken), the speed of the moving set, which is < X but not zero, increases due to the continued action of gravity, and can indeed exceed X before it reaches the next floor. That's why the acceleration of the set increases.

We've been over this in past.
 
This is what I'm talking about when I say that people treat the building as solid blocks, instead of mass. They try to use mass in their equations, but they are still thinking in solid terms.

As the top tilts, or start to fall, is it logical to assume that all of the floors are still intact, and fall at the same rate from the same starting point?

Or should we assume that when the top sections starts to shift, it suddenly becomes like a cup full of water? The contents start to fall, impacting the floors below, severing connections, before the actual cup starts to descend, therefore the accumulating mass of the falling floors pushes ahead of the collapsing cup....?

It needs some work, obviously.
 
This is what I'm talking about when I say that people treat the building as solid blocks, instead of mass. They try to use mass in their equations, but they are still thinking in solid terms.

As the top tilts, or start to fall, is it logical to assume that all of the floors are still intact, and fall at the same rate from the same starting point?

Or should we assume that when the top sections starts to shift, it suddenly becomes like a cup full of water? The contents start to fall, impacting the floors below, severing connections, before the actual cup starts to descend, therefore the accumulating mass of the falling floors pushes ahead of the collapsing cup....?

It needs some work, obviously.

When the building is tilting the girders and bracing have already failed and a rain of debris has already started floor overloading.
 
A common recurring sub issue is the vague idea that somehow it was accumulated debris which started the process. It wasn't - it was "knife edged" loading as the falling perimeter struck the lower floor.

This graphic shows reality for WTC2 and WTC1 was the same process but less extreme angles.
[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/webpics/ArrowedROOSD.jpg[/qimg]
The Left side yellow arrow shows how the still at that stage intact perimeter of the Top Block impacted the floors below shown by blue lines.

That imposition of overwhelming load started "ROOSD" for that quadrant of the tower. Invert the logic for the right side arrow which is "rising" (relatively) and shears off the Top Block floors from below.

The other two sides for WTC2 a cross of downwards and upwards destruction.

And that reality also kills another bit of nonsense for WTC Twin Towers. So called "crush down" AND "crush up" occurring at the same time. AND it wasn't "crushing" either.


:D
More like "spear up" and "spear down"
 
This is what I'm talking about when I say that people treat the building as solid blocks, instead of mass. They try to use mass in their equations, but they are still thinking in solid terms.

True, sometimes. The other side of the coin, often demonstrated by truthers, is the idea that when a part of the building is destroyed, the mass of that part somehow vanishes. That assumption, though he's very careful never to admit it, is at the heart of Cole's argument from Newton's Third Law; he claims that each floor of the upper section can mutually destroy one floor and no more of the lower section and that Newton's Law demands this symmetry, but neglects the asymmetry between upper and lower sections (or blocks, or clouds of loosely connected debris, or whatever they are a few seconds into the collapse) arising from the fact that all the debris is falling on the lower section and none on the upper.

As the top tilts, or start to fall, is it logical to assume that all of the floors are still intact, and fall at the same rate from the same starting point?

Almost certainly not. The problem with doing any analysis from that point on, though, is that the floors can't be seen, so we have no idea what's going on with them. There is undoubtedly a lot of the detail of the collapse which is not only unknown, but unknowable; it couldn't be observed at the time, and it's too complex to model, not because of limited computing power but because it's a chaotic system.

Or should we assume that when the top sections starts to shift, it suddenly becomes like a cup full of water? The contents start to fall, impacting the floors below, severing connections, before the actual cup starts to descend, therefore the accumulating mass of the falling floors pushes ahead of the collapsing cup....?

It needs some work, obviously.

And some of that work may be impossible; but I think you're on the right lines when it comes to understanding the actual collapse in all its complexity. This is basically what Major Tom calls the ROOSD (Runaway Open Office Space Destruction) scenario, though the concept isn't original to him - even the original Bazant and Zhou paper suggests some aspects of it. It seems to me most likely that this was one of several processes going on at the some time: the floors collapse on to lower floors, in an avalanche of rubble that causes a self-propagating inner collapse; the perimeter columns of the lower section are left unbraced and collapse outwards as the upper section descends; the hat truss has to fall through the space occupied by the cross-bracing of the core, no doubt causing its own series of impacts and breakages along the way; and after everything else has passed by, the severely damaged remnants of the core, also far too slender to stand without bracing, collapse last of all. All these processes take place at different rates and over slightly different, though overlapping, periods of time.

It's quite absurd to draw conclusions on the details of a process like this from a model made of a few planks. The one thing we can determine from simpler models, though, is that there was more than enough energy, many, many times more than enough, stored in the structure to drive this complex process all the way to the ground, and that's the point of Bazant and Zhou's paper.

Dave
 
This is what I'm talking about when I say that people treat the building as solid blocks, instead of mass. They try to use mass in their equations, but they are still thinking in solid terms.

As the top tilts, or start to fall, is it logical to assume that all of the floors are still intact, and fall at the same rate from the same starting point?

Or should we assume that when the top sections starts to shift, it suddenly becomes like a cup full of water? The contents start to fall, impacting the floors below, severing connections, before the actual cup starts to descend, therefore the accumulating mass of the falling floors pushes ahead of the collapsing cup....?

It needs some work, obviously.

It is a first order simplification, however yes, some people take it as a sacrosanct representation of what-actually-happened, and as you point out, it isn't. ozeco's description above also isn't, in that its not the full description. The column sections did spear through floors but CC is correct in that debris was already gathering internally by that point, and of course, much more was about to occur in the next milliseconds through to about 15 seconds from that point.
The cardboard stacks and overbuilt models that TM proponents put forth all miss the mark. Some truly seemed designed not for illumination of the event, but more for self service to a personal belief.
 
Thank you.

I will be using your conceptual errors, this morning, in my Physical Science classes, as an example of a fundamentally incorrect misapprehension of the meaning of "equal and opposite" force pairs (and a discussion of the differences between "balanced" and "unbalanced" forces) as we review for the Q3 exam tomorrow. You will have helped a number of students do better on their test...

Holy Molie, I missed that FF post. Its so bad its worse than wrong. Its Rob Balsamo 11 g wrong.
 
More like "spear up" and "spear down"
:thumbsup: Yes -- BUT...

Try "shear up" and "shear down" - it is even clearer.

...the more important aspect is that "shearing floors" upwards in the Top Block started at the same time as "shearing floors downwards" in the Lower Tower - at the START of "Top Block descending". The destruction of the Top Block did not wait till the lower tower was "crushed down" to near ground level THEN "crush up" of Top Block started.

That is where that crush down crush up model does NOT apply to WTC Twin Towers

- it wasn't the crushing i.e. buckling of columns in any form of one dimensional approximation - it was shearing of joist connections; AND

- Destruction of the top block started at the very beginning of descent - it didn't stay in one piece and only break up when it reached the ground.
.
 
:thumbsup: Yes -- BUT...

Try "shear up" and "shear down" - it is even clearer.

...the more important aspect is that "shearing floors" upwards in the Top Block started at the same time as "shearing floors downwards" in the Lower Tower - at the START of "Top Block descending". The destruction of the Top Block did not wait till the lower tower was "crushed down" to near ground level THEN "crush up" of Top Block started.

That is where that crush down crush up model does NOT apply to WTC Twin Towers

- it wasn't the crushing i.e. buckling of columns in any form of one dimensional approximation - it was shearing of joist connections; AND

- Destruction of the top block started at the very beginning of descent - it didn't stay in one piece and only break up when it reached the ground.
.

The top block was basicly a simplification of the model, it was used to preserve the mass so the computers didn't have to handle too many data points.
The fact the people took it as a literal representation of the events, means they didn't understand the limitations of the model.
The critical factor was always the strength of the connections both up and down to resist being disunified.
That is true of Towers 1-2 and 7.
 
If I carefully place a penny on the top of the house of cards it might stay there. Let's assume I could do it, and if I could, that would mean the house of cards could support the static force of the penny. Now, if I raise the penny a few inches and then drop it, the force experienced by the house of cards is now greater than the static force previously exerted.

OK so far.

This is because F=ma, and since acceleration is now greater than 0, the kinetic force is greater.

Pretty ragged, but there's at least an "is" in there. You don't seem to understand the mechanism by which dynamic loadings are exerted too well, but at least you acknowledge their existence.

Let's now assume the house of cards collapses. What you see with the naked eye is an instantaneous collapse, but Newton's third law says that the house of cards will exert an equal and opposite force on the moving penny. If you had a fast enough camera, you would see the penny decelerate, even if the deceleration was extremely small.

Again, true, but you haven't actually understood why the penny will decelerate rather than just accelerating slightly less for a brief period. Because the house of cards can support the static weight of the penny at the point of impact, the force exerted, however brief, will be greater than mg (where m is the mass of the penny), so there will be a net deceleration.

The lower structure of the WTC towers should have exerted an equal and opposite force on the upper floors as they fell. It does not matter what the composition or strength was of the lower floors. If the lower floors could support the static force of the upper floors, they should have exerted an equal and opposite force as they were impacted.

Bzzzzzttttt! And there is where you go wrong. You're assuming that the lower part of the structure is able to support the static weight of the upper part after collapse has commenced. That's simply not feasible. When the structure failed, a whole series of elements failed in essentially random ways, with different buckle lengths and locations and, inevitably, sideways displacements of vertical elements. So rather than Cole's idealized plank-on-plank impacts, we have a ragged mess with bits sticking out, landing on a different ragged mess with bits sticking out, and with bits breaking off as they hit. After the initial failure, the lower columns are never able to contact the upper ones all at the same time to give the single solid impact Cole is talking about; in fact, the geometry of the initial failures, as ozeco41 has pointed out ad nauseam to Tony Szamboti, means they can't impact directly at all. What we have instead is bits of the upper section striking bits of the lower section that individually can't support more than a fraction of the load, leading to a sequence of much smaller impacts which average out to a more-or-less constant force.

This would cause the upper floors to decelerate, and the time of collapse should have been longer than 10 seconds.

And at this point you can't even read from your own hymn sheet. Even if the upper floors were able to decelerate instantaneously, the overall time of collapse wouldn't be affected; the sum total of energy lost to impacts would be the same, it would just be distributed differently through the collapse. And by the way, the time of collapse was longer than 10 seconds.

By the way, the above isn't actually written for FalseFlag, who either won't read it or won't understand it.

Dave
 
Your example supports CD, you just don't realize it.

If I carefully place a penny on the top of the house of cards it might stay there. Let's assume I could do it, and if I could, that would mean the house of cards could support the static force of the penny. Now, if I raise the penny a few inches and then drop it, the force experienced by the house of cards is now greater than the static force previously exerted. This is because F=ma, and since acceleration is now greater than 0, the kinetic force is greater. Let's now assume the house of cards collapses. What you see with the naked eye is an instantaneous collapse, but Newton's third law says that the house of cards will exert an equal and opposite force on the moving penny. If you had a fast enough camera, you would see the penny decelerate, even if the deceleration was extremely small.

There is no denying this. If you choose to deny it, you are denying one of the most fundamental, indisputable laws of physics.

The lower structure of the WTC towers should have exerted an equal and opposite force on the upper floors as they fell. It does not matter what the composition or strength was of the lower floors. If the lower floors could support the static force of the upper floors, they should have exerted an equal and opposite force as they were impacted. This would cause the upper floors to decelerate, and the time of collapse should have been longer than 10 seconds.

It is a shame that you start off so well, and then go on to get it so wrong. I notice there were excellent explanations right above this post, so I will not need to explain in detail how you made your wrong turn. But you really should consider getting a more detailed knowledge of physics and engineering before you grab on to someone's crap conspiracy theory and attempt to prove trained engineers wrong by using a highly incomplete and distorted concept of physics created by crazed people for their own political agendas. You can then calculate the actual predicted collapse time and determine if that would have been detectably different from that which can be measured from the video. just one question that you might ask yourself- what frame rate would have been necessary to create a "fast enough camera" to detect the difference, and what was the effective frame rate of the cameras used for the WTC videos?
 
Last edited:
A cats terminal velocity is 60mph, so therefore the buildings should have fallen slower. :jaw-dropp
 
A cats terminal velocity is 60mph, so therefore the buildings should have fallen slower. :jaw-dropp

I would like to fund an experiment involving a stack of cats separated by toothpicks. Please make this happen. :)
 
Yes, really. Scale is irrelevant.

I understand your ignorance. You simply haven't the slightest clue what you're talking about, and as a direct result, are reduced to parroting (without understanding) someone (Cole) who is lying to you.

But I do NOT understand the arrogance.

I assume that you're not a bona fide moron. (Literally, with a mental age < 13 years old.) If you are, I apologize for my brusqueness.

You KNOW that you do not understand the engineering approach to scaling in experimental techniques. You've seen some of the tech info that I've posted to you.

In the spirit of "if it isn't on YouTubez, it isn't real", allow me to present a real expert in the field of physics, engineering & especially "experimental methods", to give you a little taste of the fact that "scaling issues are paramount in ALL experiments."

Don't believe me?

How about this entertaining, smart guy from MIT?
Prof Walter Lewin (MIT): "Lec 01: Units, Dimensions, and Scaling Arguments"
youtube.com/watch?v=X9c0MRooBzQ

It's all fun, and the scaling discussion begins around 11 minutes in.

Lest you be confused, the "square-cubed law" that he mentions is one of the most generally applicable ones in all of Statics, including Structural Engineering.

A few more people who know how critical scaling & dimensional analysis are to experiments. Every last one of these people's work asserts forcefully that Cole's ignorance (literal ignorance, as in "paying no attention to") of scaling renders his massively scaled (120:1) experiments meaningless.

http://bfy.tw/4e6q

Try to learn something...
 
I would like to fund an experiment involving a stack of cats separated by toothpicks. Please make this happen. :)

How are you going to get 1300 cats to stand still, let alone balance on top of each other?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom