If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here's a simplified model that does explain why the collapses were longer than freefall - there was resistance, as every floor was hit and incorporated into the growing mass of rubble.

.


As far as I can tell, troofers don't have the ability to understand vertical impacts.

They take what many people might think of when talking about impacts - a ball rolling into a series of walls - and use this life experience to help them understand what should happen in a vertical impact. The ball decelerates as each impact with each wall until there's not enough momentum to break through one of them, and that's where it stops. This is so simplistic that even the dummies on Jackass understood it in one of their movies when they were making predictions on how many drywall barriers that Bam Margera was going to break through while running into them on his skateboard.

But that doesn't work/translate into understanding vertical impacts.

The closest analogy that I can think of when comparing vertical impact to a horizontal impact with a series of walls would be if Bam's skateboard was powered with some sort of cruise control/feedback device. He would impact a wall and decelerate, but the cruise control would re-accelerate the board - as gravity would do to the falling debris of the towers - and it just keeps going cuz all that matters is if the first impact doesn't slow him down, none will until he hits the far side of the warehouse - analogous to the ground at the WTC site.....

It's either that, or they KNOW that they're wrong and don't care....
 
That's what I don't get in this conversation. Just because the upper part of the towers decelerate briefly, shouldn't gravity remain working on them? And, since it's still a moving mass (decelerating doesn't mean stop), the laws of momentum and energy still apply to the lower floors.
 
As far as I can tell, troofers don't have the ability to understand vertical impacts.

They take what many people might think of when talking about impacts - a ball rolling into a series of walls - and use this life experience to help them understand what should happen in a vertical impact. The ball decelerates as each impact with each wall until there's not enough momentum to break through one of them, and that's where it stops. This is so simplistic that even the dummies on Jackass understood it in one of their movies when they were making predictions on how many drywall barriers that Bam Margera was going to break through while running into them on his skateboard.

But that doesn't work/translate into understanding vertical impacts.

The closest analogy that I can think of when comparing vertical impact to a horizontal impact with a series of walls would be if Bam's skateboard was powered with some sort of cruise control/feedback device. He would impact a wall and decelerate, but the cruise control would re-accelerate the board - as gravity would do to the falling debris of the towers - and it just keeps going cuz all that matters is if the first impact doesn't slow him down, none will until he hits the far side of the warehouse - analogous to the ground at the WTC site.....

It's either that, or they KNOW that they're wrong and don't care....

I think it has something to do with their automobile square tires, and stone shock absorbers same physics apply to cars as to the three buildings in question.
:D
 
That's what I don't get in this conversation. Just because the upper part of the towers decelerate briefly, shouldn't gravity remain working on them? And, since it's still a moving mass (decelerating doesn't mean stop), the laws of momentum and energy still apply to the lower floors.


All that's true.

But to make it even more bizarre, truthers want to SEE the "decelerations" ( but they're NOT truly decelerations, but merely a decrease in acceleration rate ) at every "floor" cuz they don't have the mental capacity to move beyond a simple 1D model and into the realm of the real world where it was chaotic, and therefore no obvious "deceleration" can be seen.

Rather it must be deduced by averaging the acceleration rate. Even Chandler the Clown has done decent work by announcing the troofers that it accelerates at about 2/3g.

THAT is proof of resistance, given by the intact structure, to the falling chaotic mass of junk.

Troofers are just too dumb to understand
 
That's what I don't get in this conversation. Just because the upper part of the towers decelerate briefly, shouldn't gravity remain working on them? And, since it's still a moving mass (decelerating doesn't mean stop), the laws of momentum and energy still apply to the lower floors.

Yes, and what's more it's an ever-increasing moving mass. As long as the next floor below breaks then things can only get worse. It halts at the first impact or it doesn't halt at all, and even that's a Bazantian simplification.

"Newton's Third Law" Truthers seem to think that one falling floor is "cancelled out" by the one impacted and forget to add new floors (among about a hundred other misconceptions, that is).
 
All that's true.

But to make it even more bizarre, truthers want to SEE the "decelerations" ( but they're NOT truly decelerations, but merely a decrease in acceleration rate ) at every "floor" cuz they don't have the mental capacity to move beyond a simple 1D model and into the realm of the real world where it was chaotic, and therefore no obvious "deceleration" can be seen.

Rather it must be deduced by averaging the acceleration rate. Even Chandler the Clown has done decent work by announcing the troofers that it accelerates at about 2/3g.

THAT is proof of resistance, given by the intact structure, to the falling chaotic mass of junk.
A thought came to me today... (it happens...)

When a skydiver jumps out his aircraft he immediately experiences an acceleration of g. However since he is in a fluid (the atmosphere), a countering force of air resistance builds up. At some point the force of gravity and the force of air resistance equal in opposite directions and the Skydiver reaches terminal velocity.

So although he begins AT an acceleration of g he reaches an acceleration of zero, all the while in between those two points in time, his velocity is increasing. Some call that deceleration but is it noticeable? Not in any video of a skydiver I have seen.

Velocity is the change in distance over time. Acceleration is the change in velocity over time. "Deceleration" isn't really a scientific term. Its just "acceleration" with an opposite direction to the conventional positive direction.

But here we are speaking of the change in acceleration over time. I don't know that there is actually a specific term for that. Its simply a decreasing acceleration. A change in acceleration could also in some cases, be increasing. That's an increasing acceleration. If "de-celeration=less acceleration" as the term is often used for this, then what do you call "increasing acceleration" ........ Accel-aceleration?

After all it could get even more complicated with a change, in the rate of change, of acceleration.
This actually does occur in the skydiver example since at t=0 the upwards force equals zero and increases proportional to the square of the velocity. It also occurs in your car when you step on the gas then step on it harder, acceleration increases at the second step..
 
Last edited:
But here we are speaking of the change in acceleration over time. I don't know that there is actually a specific term for that. Its simply a decreasing acceleration. A change in acceleration could also in some cases, be increasing. That's an increasing acceleration. If "de-celeration=less acceleration" as the term is often used for this, then what do you call "increasing acceleration" ........ Accel-aceleration?

Jerk! :p
 
I also know you are going to say there is no deceleration as the weight hits the piece of cardboard. Nonsense. It's there, but it's so subtle that the camera can't pick it up. If you had a high speed camera that could record tens of thousands of frames per second you would see the weight decelerate the instant it impacts the cardboard.

No, in fact there is no deceleration of the weight when the weight hits the cardboard box.

You are making the same mistake that many others (notablt Tony Szamboti) have made.
You're confusing "decreased acceleration" with "deceleration".

"Accelerating" means its acceleration is some positive value (i.e., a > 0).
"Decelerating" means its acceleration is negative (i.e., a < 0).
__

If something is accelerating downward at a constant 9.8 m/sec^2, and then its downward acceleration drops to, say, 9.5 m/sec^2, there has been NO deceleration. Both 9.8 & 9.5 are both >0. Ergo both are accelerations.

The object is simply accelerating at a smaller magnitude.

Something accelerating at a smaller magnitude is still speeding up. If you plot the velocity vs. time graph for the numbers above, there will be no downward slope on the curve.

In order for something to be decelerating, its acceleration has to go negative. For example, it starts out accelerating at 9.8 m/sec^2, and then its acceleration drops to -2.2 m/sec^2. Since -2.2 is <0, then this object will be decelerating.

Think of it like this: you're in a spaceship, flying in space. If you throw on the "forward thrusters" (ones throwing propellant backwards that accelerates the ship forward), then you are accelerating.

If the magnitude of that acceleration is 9.8 m/sec^2, then you're accelerating at 1G. If you reduce power to those thrusters to produce an acceleration of 4.9 m/sec^2. then you've reduced your acceleration to .5G, but you are still accelerating.

The giveaway is that you're still being pushed backwards into your seat. At 1G you're pushed into your sear harder than at .5G.

If you cut off the thrusters, then your acceleration drops to zero.

It's only by turning on the "reverse thrusters" (ones shooting propellant forward & pushing the ship backward) that you decelerate.

The dead giveaway that you are decelerating is that you're no longer being thrown backwards into your seat, but rather forwards against your seat belt / harness.
__

If that dumbbell was your ship, and you were being thrust forward at 9.8 m/sec^2, and you ran into some diaphanous substance (the cardboard box) that reduced your acceleration to 9.5 m/sec, you would NOT be "decelerating" when you hit it. You would be accelerating at a lower rate.

You would not be thrown forward against your harness. You would be thrown backwards in your seat at a slightly reduced force.
 
Last edited:
If you throw on the "forward thrusters" (ones throwing propellant backwards that accelerates the ship forward), then you are accelerating.

If you cut off the thrusters, then your acceleration drops to zero, but your velocity does not, you are still moving forward..

It's only by turning on the "reverse thrusters" (ones shooting propellant forward & pushing the ship backward) that you decelerate. Until your velocity hits zero, then you start going backwards, if you keep the thrusters on.

Excellent post, I just had one tiny addition to make, because it was probably so obvious to you that you failed to consider it.

That's why docking in space is difficult, and why we don't have the technology to do those fancy space battles we see in so many movies.
 
Has False Flag realised the magnitude of the ignorance s/he displayed with regards the structure of the building, and gone off to do a bit of studying of building structures, perhaps? One can only hope.
 
Has False Flag realised the magnitude of the ignorance s/he displayed with regards the structure of the building, and gone off to do a bit of studying of building structures, perhaps? One can only hope.

It would take an ability for reflection and self-examination not the slightest bit in evidence so far. But you never know ...
 
That's why docking in space is difficult

It's not that difficult at all. The hard part is getting the orbits matching, but the docking is pretty easy.

[and why we don't have the technology to do those fancy space battles we see in so many movies.

Well most of the fancy space battles in movies totally ignore physics and that space is really big so they'd be spread out. Also there aren't a lot of reasons to fight in space when we can fight far more effectively on the surface of the planet.
 
Well most of the fancy space battles in movies totally ignore physics and that space is really big so they'd be spread out. Also there aren't a lot of reasons to fight in space when we can fight far more effectively on the surface of the planet.

I read recently that the Russians actually brought a huge cannon into space, and set it up on one of their early space stations. Anticipating battles in orbit between their stations & ours.

Cooler heads prevailed & they never attempted to fire it. Considering recoil, probably a REALLY good thing for their own station...
 
Last edited:
Cad!

oh,,,, I see,,, humm, learn something new every day.

"accelerate, jerk and jounce", sounds like a 1960s sock hop song.

I learned about jerk when my kids took high school math, but I didn't know about jounce, although it makes sense. Turtles all the way down...
 
Last edited:
The hilarity of the Cole videos is the detonations in his model (which ignores the square cube law) are far more prevalent that anything truthers imagine were detonations in any of the actual collapses.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom