If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not that any of this will click with you. You have amply demonstrated your utter lack of comprehension of, or ability to apply, physics.

Really? I'm the one who doesn't understand? Um, no.

This is what you said,

The floor [sic] pans of the WTC towers were not capable of supporting even the static mass of the dozen or so levels that first began moving.

Those are your words. What you're saying is that the lower floors were not capable of supporting the floors above them, even when they were not moving. Really? Then how did the building stand for 30 years?

You then go into pure and utter nonsense about columns and other areas you know absolutely nothing about. It's not even worth commenting on any further.

Seriously, like I said to another poster, your best bet is to watch videos. Posting is also clearly not your thing.
 
.........What you're saying is that the lower floors were not capable of supporting the floors above them, even when they were not moving. Really? Then how did the building stand for 30 years?......

Now you're just being ridiculous. Floors aren't bearing the weight of the floors above them. All they have to support is their own weight, and the weight of internal partitions, plus fixtures and fittings, people and furniture. Jesus christ, the level of ignorance in structural engineering here is beyond a joke.
 
Those are your words. What you're saying is that the lower floors were not capable of supporting the floors above them, even when they were not moving. Really? Then how did the building stand for 30 years?

The building was held up by columns, not floorpans. Each floorpan only had to support its own weight and that of the contents of that floor (they also stiffened the whole system, but that's another matter).
 
Last edited:
Really? I'm the one who doesn't understand? Um, no.

This is what you said,



Those are your words. What you're saying is that the lower floors were not capable of supporting the floors above them, even when they were not moving. Really? Then how did the building stand for 30 years?

You then go into pure and utter nonsense about columns and other areas you know absolutely nothing about. It's not even worth commenting on any further.

Seriously, like I said to another poster, your best bet is to watch videos. Posting is also clearly not your thing.
The video proves Cole can't do physics, and he has no clue how the WTC collapsed, as his experiments fail.

The floors in the WTC did not hold up the upper floors; the shell and the core held up the 110 floors.
Each floor in the WTC could only hold up itself, and a total of 29,000,000 pounds, and it would fail.
You don't comprehend the experiments by Cole are idiotic BS, and do not model the WTC floors.

Do the math; a floor in the WTC can hold up to 29,000,000 pounds; how much does 11 to 12 floors in the WTC weigh? Guess what, Cole failed to do the math when he posted BS experiments based on the lack of knowledge of those falling for the BS.
Cole's experiments are BS; Cole can't comprehend how the WTC was built. Cole failed.
 
Last edited:
Watch the first video you posted. What happens to the bag of rice once it impacts the scale? It bounces up! Does it continue to accelerate downwards at or near freefall? Absolutely not! Your OWN video shows what should have happened. As the rubble, or floors, impacted the lower floors they would have decelerated. This deceleration would have occurred multiple times, and either the collapse would have completely stopped before it reached the ground, or the entire process would have taken much longer.

Your own videos are supporting CD. It's just a shame that you can't understand this.

That's because it is a spring scale, the spring absorbs the energy and rebounds unfortunately the Towers were not giant springs!

The forces were so unbalanced in the towers, that a noticeable deceleration was physicly impossible. instead the energy goes into destroying the columns welds by vibrating the columns from side to side.
Your Wile E coyote and Daffy Duck physics is False!
 
Last edited:
Really? I'm the one who doesn't understand? Um, no.

This is what you said,



Those are your words. What you're saying is that the lower floors were not capable of supporting the floors above them, even when they were not moving. Really? Then how did the building stand for 30 years?

You then go into pure and utter nonsense about columns and other areas you know absolutely nothing about. It's not even worth commenting on any further.

Seriously, like I said to another poster, your best bet is to watch videos. Posting is also clearly not your thing.
What I said is correct.
Floors need support only floor loads.
Floor loads are transfered ti columns whichmust be able to take the addutive load of all structure above any point along their length.

That you utterly confuse how a building works is quite telling.
 
What you're saying is that the lower floors were not capable of supporting the floors above them, even when they were not moving. Really? Then how did the building stand for 30 years?

External support columns.

Seriously, why does your ignorance allow you to have such confidence?
 
What I said is correct.
Floors need support only floor loads.
Floor loads are transfered ti columns whichmust be able to take the addutive load of all structure above any point along their length.

That you utterly confuse how a building works is quite telling.

FF seems to think that real buildings are constructed like Cole's model: put up a floor's height of columns, then sit a floor on top of them, then put up some more columns on top of the floor, and carry on like that, so each floor is carrying the entire weight of the building above. And he seems to think that anybody whose understanding differs from his in any way is an idiot. It's one of the purest cases of Dunning-Kruger syndrome I've ever seen, even here.

Dave
 
FF seems to think that real buildings are constructed like Cole's model: put up a floor's height of columns, then sit a floor on top of them, then put up some more columns on top of the floor, and carry on like that, so each floor is carrying the entire weight of the building above. And he seems to think that anybody whose understanding differs from his in any way is an idiot. It's one of the purest cases of Dunning-Kruger syndrome I've ever seen, even here.

Dave

There was reference to a house of cards as well. That is a structure that has floors taking the weight of upper structure.
Thanks gawds that engineers don't build that way.
 
There was reference to a house of cards as well. That is a structure that has floors taking the weight of upper structure.
Thanks gawds that engineers don't build that way.

I first proposed the house of cards Idea in 2005, as a way to illustrate disassembly of structure, then it took off, should have copyrighted the Idea I have seen it used a billion times, a dollar for each usage and I would be a billionaire.
 
I first proposed the house of cards Idea in 2005, as a way to illustrate disassembly of structure, then it took off, should have copyrighted the Idea I have seen it used a billion times, a dollar for each usage and I would be a billionaire.

As I said, it does demonstrate that a structure need not have its components destroyed to have it fail. The dropped penny simply disrupts the connections between components. All cards are intact afterwards, just not connected in a structural system.
 
I suppose it could be argued that a house of cards is a series of diagonal columns where the 'floors' are only there as a convenient balancing point for the next set of columns and don't actually carry any weight apart from their own.



eta: Yes, I'm bored today ;) (That's not my house of cards btw)
 
Last edited:
What you're saying is that the lower floors were not capable of supporting the floors above them, even when they were not moving. Really? Then how did the building stand for 30 years?
Take a look at the image below.


Please explain how you think that the floor inside the yellow oval helps support any loads placed upon the floor above it in the red oval.

Thanks.
 
I suppose it could be argued that a house of cards is a series of diagonal columns where the 'floors' are only there as a convenient balancing point for the next set of columns and don't actually carry any weight apart from their own.

It could, but the same still wouldn't be true of the WTC buildings, in which the floors were suspended from effectively continuous columns.

Dave
 
I suppose it could be argued that a house of cards is a series of diagonal columns where the 'floors' are only there as a convenient balancing point for the next set of columns and don't actually carry any weight apart from their own.

[qimg]http://i250.photobucket.com/albums/gg274/sap-guy/houseofcards.jpg[/qimg]

eta: Yes, I'm bored today ;) (That's not my house of cards btw)

Yep, diagonally braced pairs of 'columns' supporting platforms that in turn support more diagonally braced pairs of 'columns'.
 
External support columns.

Seriously, why does your ignorance allow you to have such confidence?

Just a suggestion to False Flag:

I suspect that you are, in fact, fairly intelligent. Your problem is not that you cannot understand the relevant physics or engineering concepts, but that instead of actually thinking about these concepts as they are presented to you by the other posters here, you are instead only thinking about these posts so as to figure out how to formulate your next snarky response. "The floors cannot support the weight of the floors above them? Ha, ha- then how did the building stand up for so long?" Well, you clearly weren't listening to the actual point being made in the original post (and throughout the discussions of the WTC)- the FLOORS only supported the loads on each floor- it was the columns that supported the weight of the entire building above them. You didn't really try to understand the actual post or the actual construction, which is quite relevant to understanding the mechanisms of the collapse. Instead you stopped listening as soon as you read enough that allowed you to formulate a negative response- which proved, of course, wrong.

Frankly given your interests and native intelligence I would like you to have an open mind and really think about what the physicists, engineers, and architects are trying to tell you. Study it. Read about some of the basic concepts from other sources not related to 9/11. Only then make your own decision. Don't start with your mind made up and being convinced that any facts to the contrary must somehow be wrong.

I
 
Just a suggestion to False Flag:

I suspect that you are, in fact, fairly intelligent. Your problem is not that you cannot understand the relevant physics or engineering concepts, but that instead of actually thinking about these concepts as they are presented to you by the other posters here, you are instead only thinking about these posts so as to figure out how to formulate your next snarky response. "The floors cannot support the weight of the floors above them? Ha, ha- then how did the building stand up for so long?" Well, you clearly weren't listening to the actual point being made in the original post (and throughout the discussions of the WTC)- the FLOORS only supported the loads on each floor- it was the columns that supported the weight of the entire building above them. You didn't really try to understand the actual post or the actual construction, which is quite relevant to understanding the mechanisms of the collapse. Instead you stopped listening as soon as you read enough that allowed you to formulate a negative response- which proved, of course, wrong.

Frankly given your interests and native intelligence I would like you to have an open mind and really think about what the physicists, engineers, and architects are trying to tell you. Study it. Read about some of the basic concepts from other sources not related to 9/11. Only then make your own decision. Don't start with your mind made up and being convinced that any facts to the contrary must somehow be wrong.
+1
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom