I know no one here is going to read this, but I will post it anyway. This article discusses the second video I posted at the beginning of the thread.
Here is a link to the article -
http://www.ae911truth.org/news/254-...n-towers-civil-engineer-tests-3-theories.html
Here is a quote from the article that addresses scale -
Jonathan Cole said:
So while we may not be able to tell what caused the force, we can tell the direction of the net force by observing the direction of the motion. The direction of the net force applied is independent of scale, which is why a coconut launched from a catapult or a bullet blasted from a gun or a thrown bean bag all have similar motions, and therefore all have similar directions of applied net force — yet none of them scale whatsoever. We can study the trajectory of the coconut, the bullet, and the beanbag and understand that they travel in similar motions or paths, and therefore all have a similar direction of net force that caused the motion.
Coles trivial assertion (i.e., that "gravity acts downward") means NOTHING like what you asserted it means (that "scale is irrelevant in his experimentation.")
The fact that you think that sentence means what you asserted proves, beyond doubt, that you have no background in mechanical engineering or engineering modeling.
Please, please give me some idea of your background/experience, so that I can find words / analogies that fit into your world view. Then perhaps I can help you to see how wrong you are in your interpretations of Cole's statements, how utterly clueless Cole is, and how wrong you are to put your blind faith into someone like Cole.
To give you the slightest glimpse of how real engineers construct scaled models for even SIMPLE testing, here is a reference (posted in the SUNY Structural Engineering class) to Harris' book "Structural Modeling & Experimental Technique" that I referenced above.
http://civil.eng.buffalo.edu/cie616/2-LECTURES/Lecture%202%20-%20Modeling%20and%20Scaling/PDF/Theory%20of%20Structural%20Models%20Chapt.%202.pdf
This chapter shows some of the analysis that is required to perform SIMPLE modeling (elastic deflection, static situations, etc.).
It barely skims the surface of the enormous complexity that would be required to model total failure by dynamic overload ... ACCURATELY.
By the way, I mentioned in an earlier post that Cole's scale factor was 120:1.
To show how absurd that number is, in this book, written by 2 mechanical engineers whose explicit specialty is "construction of valid structural engineering models for experimental testing", the recommendation range scale factor for dynamic loading is 1:3 to 1:10.
The choice of scaling factor is NOT simply a matter of economics. The further one gets from 1:1, the more rigorous one has to be with "dimensional analysis". And even when one is as rigorous as possible, the larger the error in your testing gets.
Cole uses an absurd scaling factor of 120:1, and pays ZERO attention to even rudimentary dimensional analysis. His results are utterly meaningless.
Now, try to appreciate this sentence:
Even if, thru some miracle, Cole's testing produced the correct answer, then his testing would STILL be utterly meaningless because his methods are so incompetent.
Cole's been at this sort of experimental idiocy for about 7 years or so. 1000s of engineering students in the US have passed thru classes in experimental methods, during that time. Cole could easily have gone back for some badly-needed re-education in this "experimental methods". He has chosen to not do so, even though he has known all along that he would be producing, and releasing to the public, more of these giant steaming piles of Wrong.
Even if his entire career has been designing sewer systems, as a Professional Engineer, Cole has absolutely NO EXCUSE for producing such vapid, incompetent crap & presenting it to clueless amateurs as valid "engineering experimentation".
Try as I might, I can NOT reconcile Cole's PE license with his production of this nonsense as merely "ignorant or uninformed". Cole KNOWS, he must know, that he is violating these fundamental principles of engineering testing. Every single one of us went thru this training in our engineering labs while getting our degrees.
It is not possible that he is unaware.
He is simply ignoring fundamental principles & lying.
The original rendition of Feynman's quote was gravely lacking.
It should have read,
"If your theory doesn't match competent, well thought out, rigorous experiments ..."
Feynman had no patience for, and no use for, incompetence or incompetents.