If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I can't believe you called that a hammer, can't be more than 4 pounds.

He didn't even use a rose bud, and heat the steel properly.

Pipe would have been closer to that actual core columns not a steel rod.

This video is like all of Cole's video a laugh riot he is totally clueless.

Take some fine bone China plates, and some carpenters pencils, sand the pencil leads
Until they are 1/8th max thick. Glue the pencils on bottom of the fine China.

Suspend the China, by the pencil leads between wooden boards, drop a four inch concrete
Block from 4 feet, and observe the reaction.

I wonder how many rods he used til he found just the right amount of heat and force of pounding to get that shot?


As you say, a rosebud, a couple of minutes and he wouldn't need a hammer.
 
Not quite. Kinetic energy after falling is equal to potential energy released, which is proportional to height fallen, so in fact it's just over 7 times.

Yep, sorry for the typo; I meant falling 0.3 meters, which is my guess at what Cole has in his falling disk experiment. But that suggests another answer to the OP request for experiments to disprove Cole: He should repeat the experiments with the same equipment but with different heights.
 
Um... Anything can be balanced on a fulcrum if you know the center of gravity or can find it. What does that have anything to do with structural strength or scaling, and how does it in any way debunk his argument(s)?

It's nothing to do with the fact that it will balance. Think rigidity.

Dave
 
I think we may have driven our conspiracy theorists away with a smattering of facts. If only we could somehow convert them and recruit them, so that this idiocy would die a natural death.
They'll be back, at least the die-hards like FalseFlag will. Someone who says things like this
I hope as many of you as possible go on record stating that scale matters in the experiments performed by Mr. Cole. What you are really doing is destroying your credibility. Please continue.
isn't amenable to reason. Someone who thinks that reiteration of a plain fact that destroys his argument is actually ammunition for it is someone for whom the argument is the only reality that matters. It reminds me of JayUtah's dictum that the goal of CTists is not to resolve the question but just to prolong the argument; that, to them, is winning the argument. It isn't even about the Towers anymore, it's about them being right- something they don't have to prove, only feel.
 
What most of these people seem to not understand, or just ignore, that for the collapse to be progressive after the first floor fails, all it needs is for the energy gain from the added debris of that floor, plus that added from gravity accelerating the entire debris down to the next floor, just have to be more than that which was lost by the small amount of debris lost outside the footprint from the upper part of the building and the floor, and the tiny amount that was required to rip the floor from its connectors on impact.

Basically each time a floor fails, that failed floor's mass is added to the mass of the falling debris, and then that along with the rest of the structure is accelerated for a further 3 metres or so by gravity.

Once the first floor fails, the rest must, until enough of the top debris block is lost outside of the building's footprint to start slowing the collapse.

This is exactly what we saw happen.
 
What most of these people seem to not understand, or just ignore, that for the collapse to be progressive after the first floor fails, all it needs is for the energy gain from the added debris of that floor, plus that added from gravity accelerating the entire debris down to the next floor, just have to be more than that which was lost by the small amount of debris lost outside the footprint from the upper part of the building and the floor, and the tiny amount that was required to rip the floor from its connectors on impact..
There seems to be a lot of resistance to understanding the relevant bits of the collapse mechanism.

Two - related - key issues being:
1) how did the progression get started; AND
2) Where did "debris accumulation" become the dominant mechanism.

A common recurring sub issue is the vague idea that somehow it was accumulated debris which started the process. It wasn't - it was "knife edged" loading as the falling perimeter struck the lower floor.

This graphic shows reality for WTC2 and WTC1 was the same process but less extreme angles.
ArrowedROOSD.jpg

The Left side yellow arrow shows how the still at that stage intact perimeter of the Top Block impacted the floors below shown by blue lines.

That imposition of overwhelming load started "ROOSD" for that quadrant of the tower. Invert the logic for the right side arrow which is "rising" (relatively) and shears off the Top Block floors from below.

The other two sides for WTC2 a cross of downwards and upwards destruction.

And that reality also kills another bit of nonsense for WTC Twin Towers. So called "crush down" AND "crush up" occurring at the same time. AND it wasn't "crushing" either.

WTC1 obviously a similar explanation - same parameters involved with no significant differences.

Obviously there would be some debris from the initiation stage BUT lots of it coming from the mutual break up of both Top Block and Lower Tower clearly indicated by that picture.

AND - back to the OP - if anyone thinks they can meaningfully model that real event.....

....be my guest! :boggled:



HOWEVER - since I borrowed the graphic from a truther (Achimspok) we all know it must be wrong.

:runaway

:D
 
Last edited:
See those dark columns in the middle. How come those weren't still standing after the collapse?

Clearly they were destroyed/broke apart during the collapse :boggled: What's so hard for you to grasp? Almost 15 years and you're still struggling.

Once again, you are insinuating that the building had some sort of design flaw.

Never said anything of the sort. Just pointing out the obvious for simple-minded truthers.
 
Last edited:
I know no one here is going to read this, but I will post it anyway. This article discusses the second video I posted at the beginning of the thread.

Here is a link to the article - http://www.ae911truth.org/news/254-...n-towers-civil-engineer-tests-3-theories.html

Here is a quote from the article that addresses scale -

Jonathan Cole said:
So while we may not be able to tell what caused the force, we can tell the direction of the net force by observing the direction of the motion. The direction of the net force applied is independent of scale, which is why a coconut launched from a catapult or a bullet blasted from a gun or a thrown bean bag all have similar motions, and therefore all have similar directions of applied net force — yet none of them scale whatsoever. We can study the trajectory of the coconut, the bullet, and the beanbag and understand that they travel in similar motions or paths, and therefore all have a similar direction of net force that caused the motion.

Coles trivial assertion (i.e., that "gravity acts downward") means NOTHING like what you asserted it means (that "scale is irrelevant in his experimentation.")

The fact that you think that sentence means what you asserted proves, beyond doubt, that you have no background in mechanical engineering or engineering modeling.

Please, please give me some idea of your background/experience, so that I can find words / analogies that fit into your world view. Then perhaps I can help you to see how wrong you are in your interpretations of Cole's statements, how utterly clueless Cole is, and how wrong you are to put your blind faith into someone like Cole.

To give you the slightest glimpse of how real engineers construct scaled models for even SIMPLE testing, here is a reference (posted in the SUNY Structural Engineering class) to Harris' book "Structural Modeling & Experimental Technique" that I referenced above.

http://civil.eng.buffalo.edu/cie616/2-LECTURES/Lecture%202%20-%20Modeling%20and%20Scaling/PDF/Theory%20of%20Structural%20Models%20Chapt.%202.pdf

This chapter shows some of the analysis that is required to perform SIMPLE modeling (elastic deflection, static situations, etc.).

It barely skims the surface of the enormous complexity that would be required to model total failure by dynamic overload ... ACCURATELY.

By the way, I mentioned in an earlier post that Cole's scale factor was 120:1.

To show how absurd that number is, in this book, written by 2 mechanical engineers whose explicit specialty is "construction of valid structural engineering models for experimental testing", the recommendation range scale factor for dynamic loading is 1:3 to 1:10.

The choice of scaling factor is NOT simply a matter of economics. The further one gets from 1:1, the more rigorous one has to be with "dimensional analysis". And even when one is as rigorous as possible, the larger the error in your testing gets.

Cole uses an absurd scaling factor of 120:1, and pays ZERO attention to even rudimentary dimensional analysis. His results are utterly meaningless.

Now, try to appreciate this sentence: Even if, thru some miracle, Cole's testing produced the correct answer, then his testing would STILL be utterly meaningless because his methods are so incompetent.

Cole's been at this sort of experimental idiocy for about 7 years or so. 1000s of engineering students in the US have passed thru classes in experimental methods, during that time. Cole could easily have gone back for some badly-needed re-education in this "experimental methods". He has chosen to not do so, even though he has known all along that he would be producing, and releasing to the public, more of these giant steaming piles of Wrong.

Even if his entire career has been designing sewer systems, as a Professional Engineer, Cole has absolutely NO EXCUSE for producing such vapid, incompetent crap & presenting it to clueless amateurs as valid "engineering experimentation".

Try as I might, I can NOT reconcile Cole's PE license with his production of this nonsense as merely "ignorant or uninformed". Cole KNOWS, he must know, that he is violating these fundamental principles of engineering testing. Every single one of us went thru this training in our engineering labs while getting our degrees.

It is not possible that he is unaware.
He is simply ignoring fundamental principles & lying.

The original rendition of Feynman's quote was gravely lacking.

It should have read, "If your theory doesn't match competent, well thought out, rigorous experiments ..."

Feynman had no patience for, and no use for, incompetence or incompetents.
 
Last edited:
Progressive collapse, demonstrated. It doesn't decelerate, quite the contrary.


Extract each frame of the video using VLC or Virtualdub. You can clearly see that as the first "floor" impacts the second floor it decelerates. The impact is enough to break the toothpicks, which is why the next floor falls. You can clearly see it decelerate as it impacts the third floor. The impact is once again enough to break the toothpick, but Newton's third law is observed. As the floors impact they exert equal and opposite forces on each other. The top floor momentarily decelerates as a result of the impact. This is expected.

The top floors of the WTC did not decelerate as they fell. The entire structure collapsed as if there was nothing there. This behavior is not supported by the official explanation of the collapse, and is not expected.

In the video you can see deceleration as each floor impacts the next. This deceleration is not observed in the WTC collapses.

Nice try, but, no. Try again.

It's also worth noting that not one of you complained about scale in the above video. It's also worth noting that no one said anything about comparing toothpicks to 90,000 tons of structural steel. That is actually OK, because it really doesn't matter. Even at this small scale, Newton's third law was observed.

The fact that the toothpicks broke is irrelevant. What matters is that the upper floor decelerated when it impacted the lower floor. You can see it in the video. It's there. Go ahead and deny it, but it's there. Just remember, each time you deny what can clearly be seen, and is clearly expected by the laws of physics, you destroy your credibility. But still, carry on.
 
.....

The fact that the toothpicks broke is irrelevant. What matters is that the upper floor decelerated when it impacted the lower floor. You can see it in the video. It's there. Go ahead and deny it, but it's there. Just remember, each time you deny what can clearly be seen, and is clearly expected by the laws of physics, you destroy your credibility. But still, carry on.

The WTC impacts were not easily definable units striking other easily definable units. They were messy and a certain amount of tilt was involved, causing the famous 'missing jolt' phenomenon. Nobody in the world of engineering would expect periodic jolts in the case of WTC collapses, as there were not periodic impacts floor by floor - there was a huge series of impacts so closely spaced that the jolts were indistinct and unmeasurable, or 'smeared'.
 
What matters is that the upper floor decelerated when it impacted the lower floor. You can see it in the video. It's there. Go ahead and deny it, but it's there.

So how well do you think a floor structure made up of multiple unconnected truss assemblies suspended between two sets of columns with a thin metal and concrete deck laid on top is modeled by a solid, rigid block of wood?

In any modeling experiment, the first thing that must be proven is that the behavior of the model is predictive of the specific property of the specific system being modeled. Cole hasn't even bothered to try to establish any such thing, because he knows perfectly well that it isn't; the rigidity and the smooth bottom surface of the wooden block mean that it behaves as a single solid mass experiencing discrete impacts, which the relatively much weaker connections (scaling, as usual!) and disordered condition, following the initial failures, of the WTC structure ensure would not happen. What Cole's produced is not a scientific finding but a propaganda video, and it looks like you've swallowed his central Big Lie hook, line and sinker. I'm sure he's very happy to have such a willing dupe.

Dave
 
Last edited:
I'm not going to type all of this again, so I'm going to copy and paste.

Here is the original article: http://www.911blimp.net/prf_FreeFallPhysics.shtml

And here is the relevant text;

Free-falling from WTC heights

The towers were 1350 and 1360 feet tall. So let's start by using our trusty free-fall equation to see how long it should take an object to free-fall from the towers' former height.

Distance = 1/2 x Gravity x Time(squared)

or

2 x Distance = Gravity x Time(squared)

Time(squared) = (2 x Distance) / Gravity

Time(squared) = 2710 / 32 = 84.7

Time = 9.2

So our equation tells us that it will take 9.2 seconds to free-fall to the ground from the towers' former height.

Using our simpler equation, V = GT, we can see that at 9.2 seconds, in order to reach the ground in 9.2 seconds, the free-falling object's velocity must be about 295 ft/sec, which is just over 200 mph.

But that can only occur in a vacuum.

Since the WTC was at sea level, in Earth's atmosphere, you might be able to imagine how much air resistance that represents. (Think about putting your arm out the window of a car moving half that fast!) Most free-falling objects would reach their terminal velocity long before they reached 200 mph. For example, the commonly-accepted terminal velocity of a free-falling human is around 120 mph. The terminal velocity of a free-falling cat is around 60 mph. (source)

Therefore, air resistance alone will make it take longer than 10 seconds for gravity to pull an object to the ground from the towers' former height.


Observations from 9/11

On page 305 of the 9/11 Commission Report, we are told, in the government's "complete and final report" of 9/11, that the South Tower "collapsed" in 10 seconds. Here is the exact quote: "At 9:58:59, the South Tower collapsed [sic] in ten seconds".

The video in post 211, and Newton's third law, tell us that falling objects decelerate as they impact something below. Even if we can't see it because of the dust and debris during the WTC collapses, we know it should be there. We know that the time of collapse should have been much, much longer than 10 seconds. The fact that the entire building collapsed in such a short time is proof that there was nothing in the way of the top floors as they fell. It's undeniable.

You can say that the building was structurally deficient if you want, it's irrelevant. The fact is that the upper floors should have decelerated as they fell. That didn't happen. Mr. Cole's videos prove that the only explanation for this is if the lower floors were removed as the upper floors fell.

The upper floors could have been supported by balsa wood or playing cards; it does not matter. If you had ANY structure that could support the static weight of the upper floors, that lower structure, regardless of its composition, would provide SOME resistance to the upper floors as they fell. If you dropped the upper floors of steel on the lower floors of balsa wood you would still see deceleration, even if it was extremely small. Yes, the balsa wood structure might completely collapse, but it would cause some deceleration of the upper floors. It defies any logic and reason to assume that 90,000 tons of undamaged structural steel would not have offered any resistance to floors that they had always been supporting. Failing to accept this fact has no basis is science or reason. It's pure delusion.

Mr. Cole's videos, and the video in post 211, support the same conclusion. The WTC towers were brought down by CD. Period.
 
Last edited:
Given FalseFlags likes little demonstrations, here are some ideas for him:

1. Build a simple house of cards.

2. Very carefully place a penny on it. The house should remain standing.

3. Now take the same penny but drop it from 5 feet up on top of the house of cards. What happens? Yet the house of cards clearly was able to support the penny in #2. Why do you think it collapsed in #3?

Your example supports CD, you just don't realize it.

If I carefully place a penny on the top of the house of cards it might stay there. Let's assume I could do it, and if I could, that would mean the house of cards could support the static force of the penny. Now, if I raise the penny a few inches and then drop it, the force experienced by the house of cards is now greater than the static force previously exerted. This is because F=ma, and since acceleration is now greater than 0, the kinetic force is greater. Let's now assume the house of cards collapses. What you see with the naked eye is an instantaneous collapse, but Newton's third law says that the house of cards will exert an equal and opposite force on the moving penny. If you had a fast enough camera, you would see the penny decelerate, even if the deceleration was extremely small.

There is no denying this. If you choose to deny it, you are denying one of the most fundamental, indisputable laws of physics.

The lower structure of the WTC towers should have exerted an equal and opposite force on the upper floors as they fell. It does not matter what the composition or strength was of the lower floors. If the lower floors could support the static force of the upper floors, they should have exerted an equal and opposite force as they were impacted. This would cause the upper floors to decelerate, and the time of collapse should have been longer than 10 seconds.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom